HYBRID Community and Economic Development Committee Meeting
Good morning, everyone. We'll call this meeting of the community and economic development committee of the Anchorage Assembly to order Thursday, March 5, 9 a.m. We'll begin with member introductions. I'm George Martinez.
Scott Myers.
Johnson.
Online we have member Brawley.
Yeah, and I'll be there.
Excellent. Thank you, Paul. And I don't see any other members online or in person at this time. Just one note for every person who is online with us today. You'll be mic muted as you come online. Stay muted unless you're being unless you're spoken to. We know that the audio for everyone is better when the online mics are all muted, and the only microphone that is live is the one from the room. So we'll try to do that today, and keep everybody muted unless you're being spoken to, and then we'll unmute you. Thank you. We'll begin with our regular reports and I'll turn it over to community development.
Bob Doehl, director for community and economic development. Please be with you at this point. We're doing something we haven't done in six years. I'm not gonna take away from Greg's thunder, and that's updated the building codes. I was the building official for last time on that. And it was shortly after the 2018 earthquake, and I think we think we've had the benefit of learning since then. This is a I'm gonna just emphasize two things. Greg will take away the detail when he gets to that part of the agenda. First one extend our appreciation to the community who helped out. This document was not written by staff. There's a 100 members of the industry who assisted by their expertise their time in making sure we did something that served the needs of Anchorage. And second, when we talk about Title 23 and building codes, we got built 10,000 houses and 10 homes. We know that. Important part there, though. Only a well built safe house is an affordable house. We proved that after the 2018 earthquake. The buildings that fell apart led the way in foreclosures. Those were some real painful, difficult discussions I had to have as building official back then. We also saw a conos where each unit was assessed 120, 180,000 special assessment because of those damages. So as we go forward in talking about building codes, it's a safe house is affordable house, I think is the takeaway. And also the community really felt that stepped up to assist with these. And I'll be followed by Greg for his regular update.
I think I appreciate the comments. I'll keep my updates pretty short today since we do have our presentation in business. And actually I'll be handing the reins off to Daniel King for that presentation, as I'm sure you guys know Daniel really added up the saw the 10 committees when it came to updating the code. So he'll be presenting on that this morning. My brief update that I have for today is that as you know, the assembly did approve the sole source contract for our implementation consultant. I thank you all very much for that. We signed that contract. Yeah, hopefully this week schedule our kick off meeting with the vendor and get the software update underway. So we're all excited for that. That's gonna be our you know primary focus going forward to really make sure that we have successful location.
So I'll end it there. Questions no questions. Feel free to just popcorn into the next person on the list.
Morning, planning director. I want to start out by saying that we do have some positions open in the department that we're currently hiring for three decisions, one of which is our zoning and land use review manager. So people are away if you know of anyone. I also wanted to give a little bit of a brief update on some projects headed to the assembly in the next month or so, and then I'll hand it over to Boster to finish off the list. The first and foremost project that is on my mind these days is the tenure targeted comprehensive plan review. That is a targeted review of the comprehensive plan that we started last year. We've been working with PCC on it for almost a year now. And we have posted some materials on our website. We're looking for comments from the public. We are also circulating the materials amongst the departments and among staff to for review and comment. So if you would like a link to that, let me know. It's on the planning website under the long range planning division website. And then in addition to that, we are sending the parks rezoned project to the assembly. I'm thinking it might be up for introduction 8 March 24. That's an exciting project because that is something that we'll be implementing the comprehensive plan. It's been asking for a long time. So that is has been on the department to do list for decades at this point, and I am excited to bring it up to the assembly.
Well that just to acknowledge our member Brawley is in a person with us and member McCormick has joined us on the phone as well. Just one question. follow up with the planning director if there are any other questions. Positions not filled and impact of work. Is there is there a relationship between those particular positions? The work that we expect impacted and can you describe that for us?
Sure, of course. There is a little bit of an impact, especially in zoning and land use review, because we not only had empty positions, but people hit by the bug that's going around to the department has been devastated over the last month or so with a lot of outages due to that. However, staff in last year stepping up, and a little bit of over time, but they have been able to cover the rate within the expected time frame pretty well despite the lack of vision. So yes, and pack on staff, but maybe not as much of an impact on actually times.
Yeah, I have a couple of questions. Thanks for the update on the plan review, targeted review. I'd love to talk more about that, but offline probably. And then I guess just a couple notes as well relevant to this. So I know the urban design commission ordinance that I've put forward is moving forward, just wondering, I know there's work sessions scheduled, when might that come back to the assembly, assuming that there isn't kind of a follow-up action.
As soon as the work sessions have been completed, then we'll be taken that you know based on place on assembly agenda. That usually takes a few weeks to get from that point to actually appearing on an agenda it is your organization have a faster way of doing that after the work sessions maybe we can the actual process
yeah just an update because I know that was introduced and is going for there. And then question
we'll come back to it if the problem
we do have a few more things to talk about we're
thank you Mr. Chair yeah Dave we're kind of foster long I'll go through these very quickly but we do have a lot going on on Monday night the planning zoning commission discussed planning zoning case 2025-138 which looked at updating the future land use plan for across the poll a couple of our institutions sort of for long range plans one of the aspect of that was part of track J government bill so you may see that but basically by changing the future land use designation on the map it allows that to become our plan as soon as the subdivision process goes through and it's in plan we're because of the success of that project, we're looking at bringing forward another phase of those types of changes to land use plan up later this year, probably at West Anchorage. It's some other stuff ship creek. The legacy results project is underway going to planning zoning next week. That's getting the TR, D2, E4 zones that were supposed to be phased out in 2014. So we're moving through the process of getting those properties updated to modern zoning. Right now, it's sort of like if you're in D2, it basically says you go to R-2M anyway. So fixing that. Omnibus number one, which is really just technical fixes going to the assembly later this month for introduction. Mentioned parks rezone. We've got some B-3 changes coming up. One of those was an ordinance from AO 2025-63 that membership there and Raleigh worked on last year. And we added on to that with some next use V3 updates. So those are PZC cases 2026-35 and 2026-34. Food production AO is ordinance 2026-32. That I think is moving through the process. A lot of good feedback on that. We're updating the wetlands plan that's going to the planning zone and commission on April 20. So there's an ear from the state to start building on that, but really the intent of that is to update the basics of it. And soon we're gonna start updating wetlands mapping. So we're trying to establish certainty for mapping. So there's year E River RFP will be coming out soon. And other than that, we're also looking at AMC or 2190 into the DCM chapter 2107. So we'll work with traffic involved services on that. And then finally we've been tracking the rezonance to implement the comprehensive plan, which I believe was AO 2025-40(S). Which create the process so far we've tracked 11 of them. Just looking back before the that tool in place, I think. probably three or four times what we used to see. So 11 isn't that many, but in past years I think 24, we have maybe two or three. So it's pretty good to see that we heard some good feedback about that. Commission pointing so that tool is being used and is delivered results. So that's pretty hard. So that answer any questions
I didn't think of my other question and it was actually sound like a project already underway the old getting rid of the old zones essentially. So basically does that mean when those properties are rezoned that that the old title 21 officially goes away because I know it's in our codes and it's still referred to even though it doesn't apply to most things anymore. Just wondering like at what point does it actually go away.
Just before you answer just to put a record member is joined as about five minutes ago as well six after
the chair. So yeah for one thing you know for nonconformities we always have a copy of the old code so we can always refer back to it if something applies. And there are actually even still a few more TR TR is the transition zone. So there are a few more that so that might take a little bit longer but in general it will mean that almost no properties are referring to the old code. So it might still be there but you won't be directing any from the pope you have to go back to this other code that isn't really close to anywhere else. So for like 90% of the people it everybody will be using title 21. It is getting it I don't think you can take it out of mini code just yet but it's a step
no and to clarify that I don't foresee us being able to take it out of maybe code for a long while just due to the PCs PUDs and the SLs that exist in our zoning code and still refer to old code. So it's how we can all of that up as well I don't expect old code to go away at it.
So the rewrite was the generation project really. Thanks.
Any questions. Thank you. Move forward to real things.
Good morning, Tiffany Briggs, real estate director. We have an ordinance that should be getting introduced at the March 24 meeting. This is to dispose of two parcels at less than per market value to habitat. We previously had received authorization to competitively dispose of these parcels. We did that. We didn't receive any bids. They've kind of been passively listed for sale. So we'd be looking to transfer those to habitat. They plan to have construction completed on both parcels within five years. So we would be putting a reversionary clause. that if that didn't happen it would come back to the meeting on the HLB side we had our monthly meeting with Connie yesterday regarding Fulton Hills Survey work is 75% complete. Northern Geotechnical is going to be drilling some test holes, eight test holes. And that is going to start on March 10. And they are working on their lot reservation form. But they're working on the language and whatnot. The Tosh track parcel HLB staff are working with Stantec to conduct hazardous materials testing on those two structures that are still over there. And to complete a market demand study of the area to determine the best and highest use of the parcel. And that work is being funded through the Brownfields grant. And then our two plating actions that we have in Girdwood. The survey crews have set the property corners and working through the final steps to get those plots recorded within the next couple months.
questions thank you right on
you and that are being
oh sure yes one is at the corner of Fourth and Pine and then the other is at the corner of Fourth and Klondike
we'll move forward to public works
thank you mr chair Kent Kohlhase, public works director it's a more operational than perhaps the planning development services department but in the in the world of maintenance and operations I did send an email I think to all members in the past week or so explaining widening efforts that are going on across town we typically have between five and six crews working during the day three crews working at night lighting mostly residential streets now but a few of the main since they're still working on so that's a significant effort for them street maintenance supported as did right away and other departments support it for Rondy and it was a very successful effort for street maintenance provides the snow for the snow sculptures as well as the snow for the races and they'll be moving in probably this afternoon start setting up for the Iditarod so they really enjoy that work and take a lot of pride in it still in maintenance and operations in the fleet world we are outfitting a number of the police shop but radio shop are outfitting it a number of new police cars there's control cars this time there's I think 12 goes for detectives there's a number of outrage that are gonna be used by the service officers and there's some other vehicles coordinating pretty heavily between fleet and APD to work to meet their needs as moving along. I guess the last thing in the maintenance and operations world we have received four new sanders that came in that we purchased with the $3.5 million levy that the voters approved last year those are on property I think one or two is more operational and the others are being undergoing the final fitting with radios now they're all the other equipment will be on the road soon and in addition we have the last tranche of our Trackless the Trackless is a brand name is the sidewalk tractors we purchased I believe 14 of those with me's funding the last five have just arrived so a benefit that you're in certainly next year in the traffic world some metrics they use with respect to I think to document traffic speed traffic mods things like that I could provide more information if folks want to that we'll get that that that is something that they work on every year and then they use the bond funding to implement those programs and then they are also working on getting their projects out to bid which aligns with the my next update which is PM and E working on getting about 15 construction projects. So you'll start seeing a number of Yeah coming through the assembly some before the election. Many of them will be after the election because they're funded with bonds that are on the election, presuming the law's passed. The mayor, I think folks may know the mayor is is working on an open house for March 19. With respect to the upcoming law proposition and departments will be staffing that to provide information to voters. The last thing I'd mention in the PME world is The department worked with the administration and provided information on possible designated spending grant for the district city's on third Avenue and 15th. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I guess one other thing I've mentioned is that in the downtown arena, there is a lot of work happening this summer up right. Town square the MD has some work to replant some trees in a number of locations downtown, replace some sidewalks. I'm certainly not missing a number of projects. There are there are 10 or 15 large projects that are happening there. So the municipal managers can be in the working group to align the project managers on all those groups so that we make sure that if we close the road, we're not closing all the roads in the area and adversely affecting businesses to the degree we can. So that's an effort that started last week, and we'll be having some regular meetings with that group and assembling a project management calendar so that all the project managers can be aware of those impacts, and then of course we'll have a outreach each project manager always has public outreach to affect the businesses in the area. That's a comprehensive effort to try to minimize the impact while implementing a number of large projects too. That answer any questions folks may have.
yeah, two different questions. One I I'm guessing it's in the stack of things moving forward, but update on the work for 100th and Victor.
I believe probably I believe that is coming to the assembly next approval for work.
Okay, that's great. Yeah, because I know that area obviously being that four-way intersection is. I know it's gonna take a while to actually fix, but folks have been asking about that. Other question is just in general with snow or widening the roads. I really appreciate the update you gave. I think it was helpful. And I know we've probably all heard frustration about narrow roads and the so the explanation about the snow and just as a math problem, right? That we only have so many trucks. But I was curious if you have a sense roughly what percentage of our city roads have been, you know, have had that address, the road widening, or like where are we in that kind of stack?
I don't have I don't have a percentage. I did hear from the department yesterday that they think that in the next two to three weeks it should the bulk of the road. I'll verify that and get back to you member Brawley and other members who may be interested in.
Okay, and I know that's pending, of course, another snowstorm or we know. But yeah, it seems like anecdotally have to see more roads that have gotten taken care of. So thanks for that.
Okay, I'll follow up as well. With a remark and a question. Do a good job this year. I would say year over year, we we're improving. And I feel like the investments that the assembly has authorized are hitting the streets, and it's good to see it in work. I also think that the reclassification project that's around the sidewalk machinery operators to give a kind of a different level of opportunity for employment. Yes. And the way what that's meant to us in terms of staffing has been significant. Do you have a sense of I can only deal with anecdotal and then some of the anecdotal comes from constituent feedback. The sheer number of constituent complaints has decreased one hundredfold from my vantage point from the year of what we call snow McGee. Only the amount of snow. They say this is a historic snow load year as well. So we're into snow load years, different between the amount, the speed, but equipment we're also very different. So there are meaningful differences. What I kind of want to get a sense is are we doing more plowing? Is there is there more happening this year? It felt like within five days after a major snowstorm, we had we saw things happening in a way that was markedly different. Have there been more plowing this year than in the past, and is that because of equipment, or why are we seeing what I think is more of an effective operation happen?
I think there's a few things, Mr. Chair. I think we have received in addition to having more staff on board in this winter than we had the luxury of it previous winters. All those folks have done a great job in attracting and hiring folks. The conversion of the talk about the seasonal positions we converted the street maintenance assistance, which allowed us to bring in entry level people who may not have CDL. That is held. We have new equipment. We're just receiving graders that are purchased with the levy, but even prior to that, we had made some investments in equipment. So our graders were well beyond their useful life and breakdowns, so we're seeing fewer breakdowns. I think those certainly help. I think that the snowing year. snow came so fast and so heavy in such a compressed period of time that it was just it was just infeasible to plow the city in our target of 72, 84, 96 hours given the concentration of snow that came at one time. Well we saw in January this year were with snowfall after snowfall after snowfall that generally they were far enough apart that we had time for our crews to meet that better. So I'd say it's a mix of things is more equipment more staffing and the timing of the snow I think plays into the snow events plays in how how how easily we can meet the metrics in our snow
this helps me understand is the level of sustained investment and commitment to being able to maintain a certain level of operation let alone if we want to improve more equipment hitting the streets more force doing work things we can control we don't control the weather as much as people may probably imagine
if I may Mr. Chair, some other things that that Paul VanLandingham and his crew are working on and we have bought equipment towards that end you're going to have sand trucks that are equipped with both nose plows and belly plows so they can they can assist in the plowing up we used to have belly plows years and years ago when they went away for some reason that nobody recalls this was years or so ago but they are they're useful and they can team up with a greater on certain streets and certain subdivisions which freeze up a greater than work. So see much benefit this year because those sanders are just coming online but next year we'll have a fleet of them equipped and ready to go.
That is good news and one other question around berms if there's one complaint aside from one and And I think you're done a remarkable job. It's just even getting around. When a complaint is coming around widening, it's still within the time period of the work your kind of timetable. And the work is got completed in a way their constituents have responsiveness. So I really appreciate that. Is there a new equipment? I think somebody mentioned this. Wow. Is there a new equipment that somehow making berms worse. I thought it was. Just the sheer amount of snow. I would imagine it's going to be in stagger. It's the sheer amount of snow.
I used to do that job. and the gate on the end of the grader that is supposed to contain snow as you pass it the right way. Can only contain so much snow if you have more than six or so inches of snow in a snowfall. It spills over. And if you have 10 or 12 inches, it spills over significantly.
So it's not a joystick. Problem with some new mechanical thing that we just don't know how to use.
Well, it's the volume stuff.
Right, I appreciate that. And I thought that that I did see it. Somebody does their hand cool and yes, member Baldwin.
Sorry about that. I want to add some. I did want to mention that when I think it's not remembered is a partners on the team. And it seems to me that as some And maybe has suffered significant many of the negative I have received has been about DOT maintain roads specifically in the sidewalk. So I'm curious is there a way to be something respondent to the kind of raise. I've gotten that the run around around me operation. And it's trying to that that's really unacceptable. So I'm not perhaps offering about how we might relate to relationships. Because what's happening now, at least in my district is unacceptable. So wanted to point it on the record that hot shelf shelf, Alaska maintenance maintenance. Pretty pretty pretty miserable. Thank you. Thank you.
Yeah, if I may actually I saw the note there with having challenges in this room, we're working to get them resolved. When somebody on Y unmute and they're speaking if we can remember to mute in here. It stops that feedback if we don't mute it here. It's very challenging. Speak if train of thought.
So what you all heard was the person behind the curtain giving us the what's happening with the real time broadcast problem. But if you are online when you're speaking, we here have to mute so that this way there's one microphone live on both spaces online or in the room at a time. And Mr. Clay's is the voice behind the production. Do you want to respond?
Certainly. Through the chair to Member Baldwin Day and to everyone. We work at both an operational level and a coordination level of the DOT on a very regular basis. I don't know that that's field level constant contact, certainly during snow events with KC Eliason and his team. In addition, the administration is in discussions, and I've been involved in something with the management level that DOT it's a regular topic of discussion. We know that they are challenged with respect to resources and resources both in I presume in equipment and perhaps some personnel. And we know that they've explained to us that their highest priorities are the high speed roads, the high traffic roads. But we have convey to them and I know they received complaints directly from Chris Tit that well the concerns about challenges with sidewalk maintenance. And matter of fact, I spoke with Kurt Warren, who's the head of maintenance just last week about that. And we're gonna we're gonna continue to coordinate at the operational level that that's about all we can do is continue to talk with them, but I guess I would I would offer that there are discussions at the between the administration and the management regarding the system.
Member Baldwin follow up comment and we're gonna try to get the audio right here. So we'll mute here and you'll go live.
I appreciate that. Thank you so much. Oh, that's much better. Wow. Yeah, I really I appreciate that. And I absolutely recognize that that call is doing yeoman's work to coordinate with DOT. And I do I do understand that there are both staffing and equipment challenges at the range and everything.
All right, you're back online. We didn't hear you from the beginning. So if you want to click the microphone at the top there, which is M I see higher.
Sorry. Can you hear me now.
Yes.
Okay. Thanks up. Yeah, I appreciate that there's that that coordination is happening. And I know that Mr. VanLandingham is is in communication with DOT. And I'm sympathetic to the fact that they have staffing and equipment challenges here in Anchorage, particularly. I think what's what's difficult about that is that it's been It's been reported and I'm tracking down the verification for this as well. That the staffing in Anchorage is fairly similar in terms of maintenance and operations to the staffing in Juneau and Fairbanks, which to me is a policy choice. And that's a staffing decision that's been made. When you know, obviously DOT maintained significantly more road miles in sensitive areas here in Anchorage than elsewhere in this state. And so again, I'm empathetic to the shortage of equipment and personnel to do the work here. What I'm less empathetic about is the fact that that decision appears to have been made knowingly. And that that starts that starts to grate, you know, as a policymaker who is hearing in real time the issues and the challenges that my constituents are having moving around the city safely. It becomes I become less empathetic, I guess is what I'm getting at. Particularly when this appears to be a perennial challenge. And so, you know, when when a partner at the state level says we are working on it, but then nothing changes year over year. I struggled to believe that anything is actually being done in a different manner to achieve a different outcome. I appreciate your coordination, Mr. Kohlhase. And I absolutely believe that you and everyone else in the Muni is doing their dead level best. I just I just question the responsiveness of our partner. And you know, ultimately at some far future date would love to see the municipality assume responsibility for all of our winter maintenance in Anchorage, because quite frankly, we do it better. So there's perhaps a long range conversation to be had about that. But thank you. Thank you for the work that you do and for your efforts to coordinate with our partners at the state level.
And I have just two final comments of questions for Mr. Kohlhase and then we'll move on. Just more bluntly. It's terrible. When our sidewalks looking real good, and I'm driving through the community film like, yeah, we're on top of it. And then the next night. The DOT trunk jack it all up. And our sidewalks are like, What the heck trash is this? So We are doing a really good job. It's getting jacked up and it's costing us more because of the lack of coordination. So we want a year-round city, the coordination plays an actual role, but it's just jacked up and it's shooting on. I'm sorry, it is pooping on our work. It looked really good. And the good news is you just you got back to it. And so you didn't leave the streets there. And I'm thinking of the bar, because you've had a lot of presence on the bar this year, and all across the entire corridor. And there are pockets that I just don't recall being able to walk for years. And DOT tries their best to restore that lack of walkability, but we're seem to be on top of it. So great job, we're on top of it, but it's costing us absolutely additional work because of that coordination question. The other question I have is when you're doing your data data analysis around lowering speed limits downtown. Do you use are we using in something that I've asked for, at least in terms of in my world, the relationship between speeds and economic development. Because presumably the speeds create more walkability or commercial activity in the downtown corridor that people are looking for. But I think of the corridors like Muldoon, which is strode a 45 mile per hour road on an economic corridor that's identified specifically for economic development, and it's also a corridor with a high incident and pedestrian traffic incident corridor. So we have a high traffic corridor and with economic development designated to be town center. But the municipal road goes through it. So I just want us to have the learning the lessons learned and the data that supports why lowering speeds might be both safe, but also economic, because for Muldoon businesses, we prefer businesses or cars to stop. Then to just fly right through our neighborhood. We don't mind getting through our neighborhood, so we don't have people who don't want to be there stuck in traffic. But we know that high speeds keeps people out of businesses. And they just cut right through. So we know there's a relationship. We'd love to have just that being part of the conversation moving forward. No additional things for now. Let's continue to move on for the agenda. We'll come around to public or we'll before we get into the new business items. We'll give an opportunity for the audience participation and come back around to that at the end. I see ACDA is here. Do you want to give an update, Mr. Robbins?
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Yes, just a couple of quick things. I know we have a lot of the agenda. Just want to remind the members that AO 2026-24 is coming up on the March 24 agenda, and that's the transfer of the lots underneath the old Northwest building to ACDA for development. Just want to encourage your support of that. AO. Beyond the beach is kicking off tomorrow. It's the downtown grant program. It's partnership between the mayor's office and ACDA. Encourage you to notify or go for your constituents to go to our website and participate in that. We've closed the RFI on the Fireweed Flats housing project on Fireweed Boulevard, and we'll be issuing the RP next week. Also closed the RFI on the 30 Ingra R B resort, and we're meeting with our single respondent on that RFI week after next to discuss next steps. Proud to announce that the weekend market is returning downtown, which is a huge economic impact on our downtown during the summer. We have a new contractor that we're very excited about. Actually, a partnership between two contractors, absolutely, and Ericsson Unlimited, which is Krista George and Brad Erickson will be taking over the market. We're very excited about the results of that. So join us labor day for the downtown market. Thank you.
Yeah, thanks. Thanks for all the updates. Question and we could continue conversation offline. I was talking with somebody about for example, utilizing vacant storefronts or you know, sometimes temporary uses, things like that to bring some life back. I don't know if there's an existing program to do that with ACDA, or if you guys have talked about it. Obviously, it requires the private, you know, property owner to agree to it. But it seems like there's some possibilities to make space for arts activities or other kind of pop up uses. So anyway, just wondered if that was something that's in the works or an existing program. But otherwise maybe something we could talk about it.
To the chair, Brawley. That's a great idea, actually. And it's not I have to have that, but I'm gonna program no. We don't have a program like that, but it would be a it's a it would be a great idea to work with property owners and say, look, can we come up with an activity that's gonna focus attention on your vacant place for three or six months while you're trying to rent it? That's an excellent idea. We'll talk
into that. It's a really good idea. I'm gonna jump in on that and say Municipality vanquish is a wonderful place for great ideas that go sit on the shelf and then back. And it's not member Brawley's recycling a great idea, but institutionally, ACDA has had a history of a conversation with the Live Workplay Committee that had a grant a few years ago from when and John Bittner's over there now at the AEDC. A D C yes. One of those letter organizations around economic development, but there was a grant. We actually did some of this work a decade ago. In the so there's probably some groundwork already laid to get going aggressively, rather than kind of really deliberate a lot about that. So great idea for activation. There's work that we could probably tap into to get moving a little faster than that. Thank you for that. Absolutely. I love your go get them out of to as a as a development authority.
So I'm calling calling the channel starts on the 16th when he's out here
at the ADC. Hey, right on. Thank you.
And we don't have any you're done, Mr. Robbins?
Yes, sir. I am thank you.
We look forward to the conversation later on with the order.
Absolutely.
Thank you. We don't have any unfinished business. We have two agenda items for some substantial discussion, but at this time just to check the room. Are any members of the public here that will be test of speaking later on some comment time. I don't see any. I have one person there, another person that wants to say something comments. We're gonna hold space for you, Mr. Baxter. Thank you. And I wanted just to exemplate check on that. So I have you there, Mr. Baxter. Thank you. And we'll turn into first new business discussion and I'll turn it over to who's Mr. King is gonna leave discussion. And we'll have a 10 minute presentation and then open it, or is it that's too much time. And then we'll have any conversations from members and we'll try to carry this out. Oh thank you, Mr. King.
Sure. All right. Hello everybody. Welcome to Assembly Ordinance 2026-33. Update to title 23. That's the short title for it. I'm gonna stand back here next to the computer. Now it's pretty That was the short title. Here is our longer title. Okay this ordinance is actually going to repeal 10.75, which is fire inspection fees, those get rolled into the fire chapter of the building code. That was a request from licensing. And then it also will repeal and reenact I think 11 chapters of the building code. These are all of the building codes that get updated every three years. So it's a lot of sections that we went through in this process. The code committee meetings were set up. We had met representatives from the building board on every one of our code committees. We had over a 100 professionals in the community. That includes reviewers and inspectors from within the department, but also professional engineers, architects, contractors developers were all involved with this process. So first I want to just say thank you to the building board for your participation and all of the representatives from the community to help. This is a big big process. It was started in January of 2025 and it continued through the summer. And then in the fall, we met met with the building board twice to go over and approve all of the recommendations. We also met with the on-site tech board for some updates to the well and septic fees that we were proposing. And we're still in communication with the Alaska State fire marshal for one of the updates, which will be part of our significant changes that I will talk to you about. A little bit of background on what the committee's goals were. First and foremost, we had to be able to educate the group in these committees on what those changes are at the national level every three years. These codes and they update, they make changes with rep recommendations at the national level. We as a municipality did not adopt the interim 2021 code. So we had to be able to educate not just on changes from 2018 to 2021, but then 2021 to 2024. An example of that would be in 2018, that blue text at the top. 2018, they adopted a section on occupied roofs because a lot of people are interested in having rooftop parties. We thought we should tell people How to do that, how to handle that, because that's an added occupant load. So that became occupied roofs in the code. the national level. In 2021, they refined some of the requirements for the number of stories and the height of the buildings that could be applicable for these. And so that was an interim change that happened in 2021. And then in 2024, they changed the term from occupied roofs to occupyable roofs to try and define the difference whether your intent is that it could be occupied, that's an occupyable roof. So if you were trying to say, oh, we'll only do it in the summer, that's occupyable. Oh, we're only going to do it one month out of the year or one time out of the year, that is occupyable. And so we need to be able to capture that. This is one of those things that was really difficult to capture for the committees is to say, okay, well, this happened in 2021. We want you to know that this was an important change. And then now this other change happened in 2024. So these kind of things take a while. That is to help advise on substantial changes that can affect Anchorage, right? We need to be able to tell them all of this stuff. What we then did is discuss local issues to construction and propose and adopt local amendments for our local conditions and constraints. Things that affect Anchorage specifically what is our capabilities to regulate what is our capabilities as a very cold climate trying to deal with those issues. An example would be the code has for a long time had a section on unvented room heaters and we have historically amended out that section completely because it's not a safe condition in an area where you likely need to use this room heater six months out of the year. So we want to make sure that if you do have a room heater in the fuel gas room heater that is going to be vented to the exterior so this is an example of a local amendment that we think is important to Anchorage because of the conditions that we deal with. Other note on this update from 2018 to 2024 is we went through our insurance rating. And currently we are at a five. We were previously at a three. One would be the best you can get. And we were at a three. We are now at a five because we had not adopted the 2021 code. Once we adopt the 2024, we will be able to go back and go back to a three with ISO to work with us for this change as coming. So a note on the building safety service area for those that are or are not familiar, the building safety service area, all of Anchorage is supposed to abide by the Title 23 building codes. But we have a building safety service area that requires that you get a building permit, building plan review, and building inspection everywhere outside of this building safety service area, the blue area on the map is optional. Eagle River, Chugiak, Girdwood, all those areas don't require a building permit. They still require land use permits, but they do not require a building permit. Which was perfect fodder for a research project out of the University of Colorado Boulder and the University of Notre Dame, where they found it fascinating that we have this strong line of regulation versus non regulation, and they wanted to do research on it. What they found, they looked at the hillside on residential buildings built between 2018 and 2023 on either side of the nice straight arbitrary line line that we have for the building safety area. And they found that there was not a difference in the sale value of any of the houses in the cost per square foot. Case, but they did find that stuff within the building safety service area, the BSSA, was more complex. Usually was a larger house, more complex designs where you potentially have living over garages, more re-entering corners, which is instead of having a box, you have odd shapes sizes on your building. They posit that there is higher confidence within the building safety service area to do more interesting designs. Whereas outside of that, if you're not gonna have building review, they think that maybe you'll feel safer. Yeah, risk aversion, and you'll just build a simpler box. All right, so now we can go over some of the significant changes. I'm gonna try and just go over the highlights and if someone wants to tell me if I have got a lot of time or a little bit of time. There are more significant changes that you can see in exhibit B. But these were some of the bigger ones that I thought would be good to touch on. A significant change in the admin code is when a building permit is required. Well, one of the big changes we made was for non-structural modifications to homes. We went from a $5,000 limit to a $10,000 limit. It's been $5,000 since at least 2003. And controlling for inflation that would go up to at least $1,000 now. This is for things like repairing your roof when there's roof damage. If it's if it's under $10,000 to do it, you don't need to get a building permit. Replacing drywall, as long as it's not a firewall, you can do that without a building permit, when it's smaller areas. Yes.
How do we use a dollar value for this? I mean, again, kind of understand sort of to say like if it's a smaller project, then we'll keep the cost down, but I mean if it's if we require these building permits for safety reasons, shouldn't it be designed defined by something other than the project cost.
And part of the challenge with that, I think is that when you remove drywall within a building, the more work you're doing, it's going to trigger the enforcement of us coming in to make sure that you're not doing something that you shouldn't, right? Under $1,000 if you're replacing a piece of drywall. We don't want you to replace firewalls without a permit. That is a life safety risk. But the smaller cost for that replacement, it allows us to try and capture when that happens. We can come in and go, okay, that actually is a section of firewall, and we do need to do something. So if it looks like a small amount of work, it's easier for enforcement. Kind of a way for us to get a handle on the scope project scope essentially.
5,000 is an outdated number. So
sure. Yeah. I mean I can understand why we increase that. I just seems like an interesting metric. And I guess is that fairly common practice?
I don't know if it's fairly common practice. We've had it since 2003. I think it was actually before when we had the uniform building code as well. Yeah, it's been in place for a long time. It allows us to capture some of this work. I'd say for like a roof, that $10,000 limit if you're replacing roof shingles a piece of the section because there was some damage. Obviously we're less concerned about that, but when you're doing a full re route, we'd have more concerns about making sure that everything gets put back correctly. We do know that replacing a section of roofing for under $5,000 doesn't always happen, right? You're not usually not gonna have to get into all of the underlayments, but just replacing the shingles alone could be $6,000 a piece of the roof. So we're trying to capture that, say, Well, we want to let you do some repairs on your house without a permit, without inspections. But not all of it. Another change in the admin code is for mobile food units and shelter units. These are two sections that that modify the requirements for the building permit. The previous version of this language was that no building permit is required. But further into the section, it says electrical permit is required, which is a building permit. So it is a little confusing, and people wanting to put in a mobile food unit get confused in the process. This also does not exempt you from a land use permit. So if you were required to, if you wanted to put in mobile food unit and you tried to just go put it in because you thought you didn't need a building permit, you it's not true. You still need an electrical permit, which is a building permit, and you still need to get land use permit, which inside the BSSA is handled as a building permit. So our proposed update to the language was that you will obtain a building permit, but you will be exempt from the building review and the building inspections, except for as listed in this language in this section, right? That clarifies that you will get a building permit. So that you do know that you have to come in here. It does not confuse people in the public when they want to put in a new mobile food unit. But it also helps them know that there is a process still that you have to go through. We saw this was a problem for one of the central Lutheran church when they were doing the first shelter units project, they came in with just electrical drawings and they were confused why they had to go through zoning because they heard that there was no building permit required, but you still have to meet zoning code requirements to put this in. So we wanted to make sure that we capture that. You will get a building permit, go through the regular process. And then the fee tables. Yes. Fee tables was another big adjustment that we made. We're proposing adding a limit to the number of inspections that can be included on commercial permits. We already have a limit on the number of inspections included with a residential permit. You get 23 inspections at a base level on a residential permit. And if you go over that amount, then you pay for those on a inspection by inspection basis. Commercial, though, if you if you spend $5,000 on your construction valuation or $1 million on your construction valuation, you get the same number of permit inspections, which is infinite. We thought that that was little much. And so what we've done is put a limit on that. We based it on the inspections that were completed on fully completed projects between 2020 and 2024. And we came up with a limit based on that. In this case, the inspection limits that we put in, 1% of permits under $1 million will go over, meaning that after $1 million of construction valuation, 1% of those permits will have inspections over the amount that they're allotted, and they'll just pay for those on an inspection by inspection basis. Between $1 million and $5 million will go over. One of the big benefits that we tried to see in this is this has allowed us to increase the number of residential inspections that we can offer. We were originally saying 23 inspections were going to be given, and then over 500,000, you would get two more for every 100,000 debt you paid. We are now just moving that to 23 inspections, and every 100,000, you are gonna get two more inspections. You'll see in the middle. Okay, you'll see in the middle. This section right here between the green and orange, those are all the inspections that will be paid for when you pay for your permit. What happens is people will come in to close out their permit and find out that they have a ton of inspections that they didn't realize that they were gonna have to pay for. All of that's now captured. So you have 15 percentage points reduction in the number of residential permits that are gonna go over when they close out their permit. So you don't have to pay a big fee at the end.
Yeah, thank you, Chair. Twenty is a really interesting number. Where where does that come from
great question. No idea. It's been in place for a while. Bob Director of Community Economic Development. Previous building official. When we looked at that six years ago, it basically was developed as an average of what was necessary for the different trades to get through a residential structure going forward by the time you factor in structural mechanical, plumbing, electrical we found that number would predominantly cover most places going forward. It was a statistical analysis permits prior to years but been in place before that, but we revalidated it that way.
Thank you, that's a standard.
Greg Soule, development services. One of the other benefits we see to limiting the commercial inspections as opposed to just unlimited is this will really incentivize the subcontractors and kind of generals from just basically scheduling partial inspections here and there, which should actually speed up construction times and you know limit the amount of times that are trips out there, you know. Basically they'll have to do it right and they'll be more incentivized to do it right the first time and do it complete.
Yes. We also will be doubling the number of inspections included on retro permits. Typically it's a inspection by inspection for a retro. A retro would be replacing your water heater, extending some electrical outlet or small projects like that for a trade. And so you usually pay for every single inspection. But for a water heater, sometimes you'll get everything installed and you pay 175 for your permit fee, and then we have to come back out a second time because there's a correction. Then that just is an additional charge to the public that we don't think is necessary. So we want to make that a $350 benefit to them at $175. So you'll pay a $175 fee and you get two inspections with that. So if there is corrections, you're not gonna get charged a second time at the end of your project. We think that's a really big benefit to the homeowners, but also the contractors where it gets confusing what's paid, what's not paid. Most stuff is gonna get done in two inspections. And that's only possible by us making these other adjustments to limit other things. We can try and make it easier for more residential projects to move forward. But stop worrying. Okay, I can all right. Now to the fun stuff. Okay, our big change in the international building code is gonna be for single exit buildings. This was a proposal from the public and was considered by our architects and engineers on not only the international building code, but also the international fire code. And the discussion was to allow up to four dwelling units per floor. Current code allows you to go up to three stories tall. We are now proposing that you can go up to six stories tall and only have one exit in the building. This is the big conversation nationally, and other jurisdictions like New York and Seattle and Hawaii all have local amendments to allow similar things. And so we've been working really hard to come up with a way to do this safely, and this should really incentivise more residential construction on smaller lots to try and get more more residential units installed in town. We are seeking approval through the state since we are deferred jurisdiction, so we have a request for modification in. And we just actually had a meeting yesterday on this with the state fire marshal trying to hammer out less details. So you should expect that we will probably propose a an S version of this that's gonna include their requests. They won't approve the deferred jurisdiction request without their modification. So we're hammering that out with that to try and make it possible. And it's all to do with safety to make sure that all the right safety precautions are taken.
Can I ask a question?
I can run through the rest of these. We'll have a second chance tomorrow.
I have a quick question for you, but I'm gonna ask Ms. Ms. Ross to ask it.
Oh I have heard in some places where they have this, they've had to add like Seattle where it's high earthquake, they've had to add on so many other safety measures that it becomes cost neutral with having two staircases. Are there a lot of extra things that you had to add to make this safe?
Not a ton. Structurally, not a ton. What we're what we're requiring is clarifications on things like the fire alarm or smoke alarm integration. So typically on a lot of these you'll have smoke alarms in your unit, right? If you take one out, no one's gonna know until the fire inspector comes through and goes, hey, you took that out, put that back in. Now these are gonna be integrated to a fire what is the term fire alarm system. Thank you to the fire alarm system and it's monitored, it's a monitored fire alarm system. So if one gets taken out, everyone's notified that it's been taken out, right? That's not a big change. It's not a big cost increase, but it is a monitoring system. So that's a big change that we've done for that. Restrictions on the staircase itself to make sure that this is a safe space for those residents to get out, right? In the case of a fire. So there's big increases on safety for the staircase itself, but we are not proposing at this time big modifications structurally to that's gonna increase the cost. These will probably not pencil out for large lots, right? Because you have a large lot, you have plenty of space. You want to put in more than four units per floor. That's a limitation that's that's been in the base code for a long time, up to three stories. We're just saying that you can go up to six stories now. So this is for postage stamp lots that wouldn't be able to do this construction otherwise. Okay. I will run through some of these. We have horizontal wet venting and circuit venting. These are two things that we have restricted in the past for the uniform plumbing code. We are now opening the floodgates to allow this sort of stuff. Intended. Please enjoy. So that's a big good change. It allows more more autonomy to the contractors and engineers to make choices that make sense for their building. Modifation and parking space requirements. We require unit heater plugs basically at the exterior of buildings. And we have a small modification to say that up to 50% for nine plus and larger, up to 50% of the required number of outlets on the exterior can be reduced up to the number of parking spots actually provided since we no longer have parking minimums. Change in the international energy code. This is probably a big one. But it's mostly just a visual change. We are in climate zone seven, but we have historically reduced our requirements to climate zone four's standards. That would be like Seattle. We are much colder than that. And the energy code committee felt very strongly that we should be pushing for higher energy conservation on our buildings, especially our new buildings. This would be in our current construction, the R value minimum is R-21 that we put in our walls. That's a two by six wall construction with that insulation. What the code wants you to do for energy conservation is do that and then put two inches of continuous insulation on the exterior. So the code committee felt very strongly that we should be pushing for the enhanced, but it did not feel strongly enough that we should be stopping construction from happening for what you can actually build right now. So what we've done is put two columns that there is the minimum, which is the same as what we've always had, and then there's the enhanced. And this is to educate the public on if you want an energy conserving building, you should do the enhanced design, but we will approve your minimum design. So it still puts all the control into the owners of the buildings and the developers to do what they think is right, but at least tries to educate them on what is best for the community and energy. This is another significant change for the existing building code. Before 2018, we had a policy in place that required that if you had a low insulation roof and you wanted to increase the insulation, there's you're gonna be holding a lot more snow on your roof now because it's not gonna melt and drain away. So we wanted you to verify that the roof could structurally support that load. When it was adopted into the code, a subsequent AO actually modified that to say it was only applicable to buildings built before 1970. However, buildings built after 1970 often have really thin insulation, and then they come back and retrofit with thick insulation to for energy conservation. We could not enforce that you needed to get that checked. And so what we've had is people call in and say, hey, my roof is sacking after I've had this retrofit. What's the problem? And it's likely that their building was never designed to hold 40 pounds per square foot, which is our minimum design snow load. So that's holding more snow, it's deflecting more, and you can have issues. The code committee felt very strongly that we should not have this limitation at 1970. It makes sense to put that limit at the actual thickness of the insulation that you have on your roof. So we went back to what was previously there, and we added the exception for cold vented roofs, which is where there's already cold air running through your attic. If you increase insulation in that space, it helps with energy conservation, but will not drastically increase the snow load on your roof. This is an elevator one. I'm gonna just skip it for now because we can have a long conversation about it tomorrow. But there's control space issues that we feel we have a good answer for. Elevator manufacturers feel less confident that that we have an issue that they want to resolve at all, but they have not given us a cost associated with making this change. And we are supported in this change by the international union of elevator constructors, our local elevator union. So for safety reasons. And our last two items are going to be residential dwellings. There's a dwell unit separation requirement. Every unit is supposed to be fulated from the other unit with a fire separation wall. So if you have a duplex, you're going to have a one hour wall separation. This has been harder to achieve on existing buildings where you want to turn a single family home into a single family with an ADU or a duplex. And now you have to go in and retrofit in this one hour wall. There is an appendix proposed that's included in the residential code that addresses this for ADUs. And after it was recommended for adoption, what we did was subsequently turn it into an actual section in the code. We don't want to confuse what an ADU is with zoning definition of an ADU. And so we don't use the term ADU what we say is the limitations are going to be based on the dwelling size. So the proposal is if you are under 1200 square feet, if your addition is under 1200 square feet, you do not have to provide the fire separation between the two units as long as all of the smoke detectors are interconnected between the two sides. That means if there's a fire on this side the smoke detectors will go off over here. The smoke will go off over there and everyone can get out safely. If you are over that size or you don't want to interconnect them because you're you don't want to like be bothered by your neighbors cooking, then you will have to put in the fire separation because it's a risk to the lives of the people in the building. And finally, the AHBA is very happy with this option require pressure treated glulam beams or pressure treated lumber four decks We now allow them if they can protect the beam, it will not have to be pressure treated. This is supposed to be a cost savings and a timeline saver where they may not order the right lumber. And so it shows up and it's not preserved and treated. They can just put in now a regular non preservative treated lumber and paint it and cap it and ice and water shield it. Previous versions of the code have allowed just paint or stain, and then it's assume it's a maintenance item, but what we found is that you usually do not maintain it. And so you end up with these beams failing, crushing and rotting slowly over time, and it ends up being a big cost later. So this is our middle ground of protecting the tops of them and still requiring the features and hoping that they will maintain. So that was what they've cited. And that's it.
All right, great. Wonderful presentation. Chuck full of information. We'll go back and to it. Questions and member Brawley.
Yeah, I think this is probably more just a request for tomorrow's work session because I know we're short on time, but you brought up the I guess two separate things. One is the mobile food units. I'm curious why just food units. I was just imagining, let's say I bought a Conex and I'm selling hats or something like that, right? So would those is there a scenario where there's something where it's not a food vendor, but it's the same building. And I don't know if like the you know our wastewater and those kinds of sanitary issues are are the difference, but just curious about that. And then more generally mentioned those shelter units. It made me think of the ordinances that we passed in the last few years around three and fourplexes, relocatables, you know, all of those kind of building code changes. So just making sure that those are reflected in here, whether they're incorporated, or maybe there was an update that needed to be made anyway, and so it's changing that underlying code, but just making sure because we have made all these changes outside of the normal. The six year cycle of the building code so just maybe you could speak to that at the work session tomorrow.
Yeah, definitely. I imagine the intent was not to undo any of that. And we got the version of the code that we started from was with from the recorders up from the from the clerk's office. Is the most up to date since we got it. We haven't had any changes to the building code specifically. There have been modifications to zoning code with relocatables, but nothing's changed in the building code with reflect to that.
I don't see any additional questions, just for the record. Glulam beams. I think I feel like that's a we came onto this body, and that was a burning question. And middle ground resolution. Good work. Thank you for presentation. Look forward to the work session tomorrow. And a lot of good work in there for folks to process all the staff time and the community members' efforts to that. Now we'll go into the next item is a discussion I've sent around. So online there is a one sheet document with some essential questions around this concept of discussion. I shared it with members so that we all have some basis of the conversation. And for me, the conversation is we'll just talk about it here. Shopping cart containment and municipal disposal policy as we all know. Especially during breakup season, we see lots of Trash and those unsightly things and right of ways all over the place. And in addition to trash and other things, we see shopping carts everywhere. And especially, I'd say close to where shopping carts are originating from big major retailers. So it's been some time that I've had people kind of ask me, what do we do about these shopping carts? What could be done about them? And I've had some conversations with code enforcement just to kind of get a sense of what have other people done about shopping carts in other jurisdictions? And is there, you know, what are these types of questions? So I have a framing of the questions, and I'd love to just read a couple of highlighting questions that that are my top level questions, and then see if there are any at least initial discussions from members to kind of get the temperature check. And then I wanted to get a sense from the person that I talk to often about this, Scott Campbell, to see kind of what code enforcement's thoughts are after our discussion. I hope to walk away with at least some sense of for the public, what could be done, what isn't being done, and how they can participate. So this item is intended for discussion around abandoned shopping carts in Anchorage. There's no ordinance introduced at this time. Goal is to gather initial feedback from committee members for drafting legislation. The question Are abandoned shopping carts sufficiently widespread enough concern to warrant municipal legislation in which areas of Anchorage is the issue most pronounced? Are current enforcement tools adequate, or is there a regulatory gap? And then I guess the top lane question from beyond that is to what extent should retailers be responsible for preventing shopping carts from leaving their property. I think those are the kind of the largest questions that all the other questions will feed into is there a responsibility whose responsibility is it? And are there things we can do as a body or as a municipality to help communicate the differences of those types of questions. So I wanna see if any members have any initial reactions, any initial thoughts to those questions that are and I'll start off with stack from Mr. Johnson Brawley, and then if any any member online tap soon will get you as well. Member Johnson.
Yeah, I mean I I'd be curious to dig into this more. I thought be helpful my perspective that there's some way we could sort of get a sense of what's the scale of the problem. And even better, and maybe this is too much to ask for. Are we seeing certain trends? I mean, I just feel yes, advantage shopping carts aren't nuisance, but just this is purely my experience and anecdotal to feel like it's becoming less prevalent. I feel like the wheel locks are becoming more common. So I guess I would kind of wonder if it's already sort of taking care of itself in a sense that more retailers are are putting in measures to prevent shopping cart the foreseeing effect. So you know, again, I I'd be happy to dig into this, but it'd be nice to kind of get a sense of like what is the scale of the problem, right? Because if we're going to weigh that against what are the impacts, potential costs of the money or retailers, you know, I think it'd be good to sort of define what we're trying to fix.
Yeah, no, I think this is a good question. And I guess my first reaction was basically these are private private property by a private business and so it seems like it should be their problem right but I think where where you're pointing out is where they do become or you know I mean it's not that the retailers want to be taking these cards throwing them in the trash or whatever happens with them. So I think that's my main thing and then I think the question really would be what is the business responsibility. And I think digging into that and what other places have done is important. I've also I mean I've dealt with industry in various capacities and I know often there is a push for good reason to say it is the individual's problem it is the user's problem it is somebody else's problem right and then that is a deflection of from responsibility. And not to say that that everything should be the retailer's responsibility, but I that that is a trend. It happens in every industry because they are limiting viability, right? Responsibility so I think really asking you know what what other places have done but also being cautious before we say and then the city's gonna spend resources on it, which I think is built into your question already. But yeah I think it is definitely worth asking about and I think I've definitely I think John said we've seen less of that, but I s I imagine it's still happening. So I think it's a still relevant question
anyone any members online I didn't see if anyone flagged but they're a question. I'll put you to the stack I would love to at least hear from code enforcement and give us a sense of at least to the one question that may be able to be addressed to me is the scale or what is the issue is to is one at all and identify yourself for the record
Scott Campbell chief inspections supervisor the codevate group to the chair You know, I we receive quite often complaints regarding shopping carts around town various areas seems to pop up more like you said in the springtime when the snow melts and those carts are able to get pushed around on the sidewalks a little easier. From our standpoint as code enforcement, it's something that is probably one of the lowest tier items that we deal with since most of our problems we deal with on a daily basis are regarding life safety. So it's kind of a lower priority for us, and probably something that is gonna be very difficult for us to enforce on as we have limited staff to do that. I did a little bit of research regarding this, and what I found is other municipalities have a tendency to go one way or another. They beef up their code enforcement numbers and they and the municipality pays for the enforcement side of things. There's ways that you know there's cities that collect carts and put them in a compound and charge the retailer to get those out of out of you know lock up, so to speak. There's other municipalities that do the wheel locks. I've seen, you know, most of us seen that when we go to Fred Meyer. And then there's other municipalities who if they you know find them off site, they find the property owner for finding that cart off site. So it really boils down to what level of enforcement we can afford to provide.
Well, let me follow up on that question. What are the retailers' response now when there's a call from us about the shopping carts in the right-of-way. How responsive are they for that property today? I don't know the answer. But let's hear what you got to say.
Not very responsive.
Not very responsive. So on the one hand seasonally I think you made a point around winter and then the summer the warmer months and the ability to move a car off property through snow or through kind of regular ground might increase and I think that that's probably true so as my colleagues think of the decrease that you may see maybe seasonally for sure but I I'd also note that regionally is the other question that you identified there are certain areas where it's highly prevalent and it's probably where the carts are yes that's correct so it isn't it is interesting and I think in the research that Mr. Campbell provided for me just to kind of add this to the mix the this the fundamental relationship between the responsibility of the retailers not only in their property but in their operation are they good businesses are they doing the right thing by the community and I've I raised that question because the two sides of the retailer question with respect to public safety are both I think this car question and then I think the shoplifting question that is happened kind of in tandem for some time and I wonder why retailers are now adding shoplifting prevention more robustly than I've noticed when I don't know of any jurisdiction investing in that as a regular modus operandi a business. So it's like we waited for APDs and investigatory teams to get really robust on shoplifting for the retailers to do something about it. But as shoppers are going into the store It's the store's responsibility from my mind to make sure that environment feels safe for us to go spend our money in. And so the full stop is there when people leave the street, when they leave that business, and they're committing a crime from within that business outside, then obviously the will engage. But the first line of prevention seems like it's the responsibility of the business. And similarly, is there a difference between Red Apple and Walmart with respect to the sheer amount of carts and how they care about the carts as they leave the community. I think Red Apple probably has a higher degree of caring about their carts walking off the property than a Walmart mega corporation. And I could just see anecdotal what I think are the businesses with the most carts in the streets. And I'll leave that off so that they can just identify themselves. But it certainly is an interesting question. And I would flag one creative solution that I saw from another jurisdiction was to compel the businesses to work with the locks. And I think some responsible businesses are doing that now, and you don't see their shopping carts on the streets as often today. So that's happening. But working with the working with the populations of community that essentially are really low barrier, really entry level, and they're figuring out a way to kind of activating some degree of a work plan around community cleanup and these carts. And so the dollar value associated with supporting the cleanup goes to the value of the carts and to the business. And so there's some there's there are ways that. Creative jurisdictions are thinking how to support the public interaction. But let me say it like this. Mr. Campbell, what happens when a cart is not picked up today from a vendor? What happens to that cart when it's on the municipal right away, or it's on in our parkland, for example.
It's gonna be tough for us to find somebody's enough time to send somebody out to get that car picked up.
We're picking them up though. Yeah. And we're and we're covering the cost today of the removal of some of these cars that businesses write off, essentially. Don't even really come out and look for them. I have never seen a Walmart fan driving around my neighborhood picking up the carts. Right. And I see lots of Walmart carts across my community. So it's an interesting question. There are many more questions on this, but I hope that colleagues will consider the questions we have today. Staff will think about some of these things as well. And I'm interested in the follow up. So if anyone wants to follow up on the conversation with Mr. Campbell, I think that that's the right place in terms of both what would it take to have more robust educational awareness and let alone enforcement campaign, and then the resources that may otherwise be out there on the table that we already footing the bill for that we are not capturing to some extent. Shout out to Parks and Rec because they take all the carts that wind up in a park or a trail lab, and they're not there anymore. I don't know what we do with those carts, particularly. But I don't I don't think Walmart really looking for them either. So and I'm trying to pick on that one vendor, but they seem to have a lot of cars on the street. So So for the opportunity for this conversation to bring it. I think it is a timely one and I don't know what the particular space is, but if we can get a sense of scale to Mr. Johnson's point, maybe there's a project here. And maybe we can help on that note, we do have one person that I identified earlier, Mr. Baxter. Do you have a few moments? Would you like to have your comments now?
Yeah, you know
please identify yourself with the
I'm William Baxter and I live in Fairview. And you know, I wrote rode bicycles and in the wintertime since 1990. And my thing about bicycles is sometimes I feel more safer on my bicycle than I'm doing a car. And a lot of times people got the perception that bicycles are dangerous. It's not probably being a walking as a pedestrian is probably the safest thing you can do. And a lot of times I see like like they didn't back back in the olden days, back when I started doing it, one of the things that started, you got numbers on on pedestrian lights. Yeah, that started after I you know after I think and I think a lot of times is if it wasn't for my trucks with stickers on it, I'd be writing my bicycle more, but I like driving my trucks around and showing off agriculture. And a lot of times I think a lot of times, and I've been to Denmark, and I I'm my family, my relatives are from Denmark, they're big on bicycles. I mean they there was a railway station and there was a station railway station there, and there were 3,000 bicycles around it. And I just have to think that. There's a lot of I've been riding by a lot of times people they just how about a bicycle inverse why there's things you need to know about riding bicycles in our city. But that's all I have to say.
Well I appreciate that. And on that note, I would say our city does a really remarkable job in the fire department in the summertime. They provide helmets with the grant with our state partners. And right now it's smoke detector season. And so making sure that all of our community partners are also aware of check your smoke detector batteries. We've just had a couple of fires even in my district. And there was a fire department gave away fire smoke detectors this week, actually, in the trailer court in my district. That work is important. Thank you for raising the safety awareness, Mr. Baxter, and we'll call this meeting adjourned. Thank you.