Open Minutes is an early work in progress.Learn what that means

(unnamed)

Meetings

View meeting →
3:24:55

Good evening, members of the assembly, for the record, I'm Dr. Jarrett Bryant, the superintendent of the Anchorage School District, and I'm joined by the Chief Financial Officer of the School District, Mr. Andy Ratlift, and I'm also joined by our school board president, Carl Jacobs, and we're available to answer questions tonight. My comments will focus first on the budget. As members of the public and the assembly are well aware, ASD is facing a $90 million structural deficit for next school year. In practical terms, that means that if we don't make reductions to what we're spending on right now, we would be $9 million short. So we've had an unenviable task over the past six plus months of figuring out ways to move forward as a district, to still ensure that we fulfill our mission of educating all students for success in life, but with 90 million fewer dollars. How did this structural deficit come to be? There are a number of very complicated factors, but I'll boil them down to one, lower enrollment and the reasons why students student enrollment is lower, a number of reasons. One are changes in modality in learning. Many more students are opting for correspondent schools, for example. Many of them attend ASD correspondent schools, but because they're not in a brick or brick and mortar building, what we're beginning to see is that more and more school buildings are underutilized. In fact, over the past 15 years, ASD has lost more than 6,000 students. And to put that in perspective, a full elementary school serves about 350 to 450 students. So when you put that in the context of 6,000 students, that's the equivalent of about 14 to 16 full elementary schools. That's one of the challenges that we face. But the other challenge that the districts faces is that oftentimes revenue has been flat or unpredictable. And as we know, the cost of doing business for a school district, for a municipality, for an everyday household is going up and up and up. What I can assure the assembly is that 95 cents on the dollar of ASD's budget goes towards classroom instruction, student support services, and the cost to maintain and support our buildings. And it's frankly the latter that's probably growing at the most exponential rate compared to the others. I can control not hiring administrators, and certainly there have been freezes over the past several years, but what I can't control is the cost of fuel. Think about the price of gasoline as we pass by a gas station here in Anchorage, and you'll see that the cost of fuel is up by about a dollar from where it was a month ago. Why does it impact the school district? Think about the hundreds of school buses that traverse the municipality of Anchorage that spans about 2,000 square miles. Think about the costs that that means when it comes to next year. Think about the cost of fuel energy. Think about the costs of deferred maintenance, as I shared with the assembly at several previous joint assembly meetings, ASD's deferred maintenance is approaching $1.5 billion. And to put that in perspective, the average municipal bond from ASD specifically has averaged around 65 to 75 million over the past few years to chip away at that $1.5 billion. That would take decades. And that's time that our students don't have to spare when it comes to ensuring that their schools are safe places to be. So with all that context said as to where are we at, let's talk about how we approached balancing this structural deficit for next school year. One of the first things that we looked at was administration. So typically in ASD, we average about 5% of our budget goes towards district administrators like myself, our finance experts, our human resources department and what have you. And I will say that we've made the largest administrative reductions that we've seen in many years within the Anchorage School District. Just one example, our largest department is the Office of Academic Services. That department providical supports to all of our school buildings, whether it's through special education services, whether it's through supporting specific containeries and curriculum, supporting teachers, sometimes instructional coaching directly to schools, that department was reduced by 22%. And within the department of academic services, some departments were slashed by as much as 40, 50%. And in addition to academic services, we saw reductions across a number of areas administratively, including in communications, our development and grants division, our fine arts department, dozens of IT staff have been reduced from our workforce effective July 1, human resources, and a number of other areas. So that was step one. And as I mentioned, 95 cents on the dollars goes to everything but district administrators. So but that said, our commitment is to ensuring that as many resources as possible can directly go toward the classroom. We also wanted to be proactive, which is why the district implemented a hiring freeze in late November, early December to try to make sure that as vacancies came up, specifically outside the classroom, that we could hold those so we can prioritize every dollar for our classrooms. Even so, we had to go a step further. Again, we can't completely solve this deficit through administration. You could fire myself, take away every stipend from every school board member, fire everybody in the administration building, and we still would have had over $60 million to reduce from our deficit, but we did continue to pursue efficiencies. What does that look like? So we have over 90 school buildings in the Anchorage School District, and we've sought ways to do more with less, and we put forward in our budget proposal to the school board a number of things that in previous years we would have never recommended, but frankly, it was one of the only ways that we can ensure that as many critical dollars go as possible to our classroom educators. So one of the things that we had to look at was support and supplemental programs, some that have been funded for many, many years, including the popular Ignite program for our promising students, including consolidating the ways that we implement art and music in schools. These weren't things that we aspire to do. These were things that we had to look at critically. So again, we could protect as many classroom teachers as possible. We looked at ways to trim around the edges. So, for example, in middle school, for many years, if not decades, we've had a structure call the middle school model, which essentially gave our middle school educators valuable time to troubleshoot about their cohorts of students to help support their academic progress. We're unable to accommodate offering that extra class period, and we had to reduce the number of educators in our middle school. That was a very painful reduction that had been considered a number of times over the past five years. But when you're facing a $90 million deficit and there's no evidence that a structural revenue reform is coming from Juno, these are the types of structural decisions that we're faced with. And I could go on for hours and hours about all the different things that are not included in this budget, but I'll fast forward to the fact that even after going through everything that I've just described and much more, we still had to increase the pupil to teacher ratio by four students in the Anchorage School District. Again, that was essentially our last resort. And we were still forced to consider that painful decision in order to balance our budget. So what I can say is that this budget did not come with a good decision versus a bad decision. It was a matter of a terrible decision versus another terrible decision. And collectively, as a school board and myself, we had to figure out the best way to move forward as a district. Let me tell you a little bit about where I stand as the chief administrator for the district, is that one of the things that we can do for our community is to brought provide a sense of clarity. As many educators tell me, clarity is kindness. And for too many years, we've been holding on to programs and offerings and buildings because we want to hold on to hope that one day the legislature will come through, will figure out a fiscal plan, and we'll be able to offer the same things that we were able to offer in a very different time in Anchorage's history. I think that time is running out. And I will say, as terrible as this budget is, it does implement a number of structural changes that are going to help us manage much smaller deficits in future years to come. I don't want my district to go through this experience of a $90 million reduction ever again. But even though all of these reductions before you that that you're reviewing tonight. We still are having to face a $40-plus million deficit for next year. So it may be tempting for a school board member or a member of the public to wonder if more funding were to come in, can we add back X or Y program. Frankly, my direction to the school board will be to consider preserving as many dollars as we can just to maintain the levels of service that we'll have in next school year for the school year after that. So again, our challenge is not trying to figure out ways to save all of the programs that are currently in place right now. Wonderful programs, I might add, but it's a matter of how do we lessen the impact and reduce harm for our students two years from now, when again, we're facing a $40 million deficit and a projected $30-plus million deficit after that. So the district is in urgent need of making structural changes, and we do our very best to bring the community along with us. And I will say I'm sure that there'll be some extended conversation around the school consolidation portion of this budget. And I certainly have immense compassion for everyone who testified on the impact that that's had emotionally on the lives of our impacted communities again, that was not a difficult that was not an easy decision to make either, and to be completely transparent with the body. I did not propose school consolidations in the initial budget because in November the school board had actually rejected a proposal for school consolidations and I respected the will of the board, but I was asked to put forward a school consolidation proposal for them. Early in March, and I complied with that directive. But with that said, even though my school my budget did not include school consolidations, it did include other terrible choices that the school board had to grapple with. For example, one of the proposals in the budget was to dramatically reduce the number of health care professionals in our schools. So the original budget proposal would have reduced our nursing rings by over a dozen nurses, which would have had its own set of consequences for our students. And it also included large reductions to athletics and activities for our students, which again were very upsetting to the community at the time and provided a sense of relief when the school board had to make a very difficult trade-off between managing a school consolidation proposal, albeit on a very compressed timeline, and the prospect of offering as many activities and health care professionals in our schools as possible. It's an agonizing trade off, I can only imagine as someone who didn't have to vote on it, but had to be there to watch that process. It was not easy for anyone involved. And I'm happy to speak more towards the process, but I think as we zoom out here, what I'd like for the body to understand is that there are no easy choices forward. We can certainly make reverses in one area, and we'd have to make additional reductions in other areas. And again, we could rest we could contemplate hypotheticals about how to restore services. This for this upcoming school year that look like this school year. But my focus is on that $40 million deficit for FY28. And I hope that as you consider the things that you'd like more information on, I hope that you'll empathize with the agonizing tasks of the school board, not just this year, but in the years to come. And my ask to our community is to come along with me in this conversation because there's no easy path forward, but collectively, we can figure out a way to chart a path that is going to be sustainable within the realities that I know are true. And as of today, again, there are bills being put forward, but one of the complicating factors of school finance at the state level is that we oftentimes don't know what our revenue reality is until well into the summer, well after teachers have made their commitments or have perhaps left the municipality to teach in other places. There are a number of things that happen. In fact, you'll probably remember right along with me that the historic BSA increase that took place this summer was just that historic, but it also happened just a couple of weeks before school. You can imagine how destabilizing that is, not just for ASD, but for districts across the state. And with that said, we're looking ahead to next school year, and we see the same revenue picture. While that BSA increase was historic, it represented a $20 increase from the year before. And ASD is equip is operating under the equivalent of about a $1,400 BSA, because we've invested $700 of BSA worth of fund balance. Why did that happen? Because this time last year, parents, community members, maybe even some people in this room were pleading with the district to please preserve these programs, give the legislature time, give our community time. I'm afraid that time is running out and at this time. My ask of our community is to please come along in this conversation. It is not too late to enter it. But I owe it's my duty to ensure that the public is aware of how grave the situation is and the fact that there aren't any easy fixes or easy answers. Anything that comes back will result in something that would have to be taken away from students. And I hate that we're in this reality, but it would not be fair to the community to provide hope as the strategy. The strategy here is to get ASD's expenditures more in line with the revenue. And right now, for reasons outside of our control that large largely that rest largely in Juno, they're not matching. So I'm trying to get ASD much closer to fiscal sustainability than we've ever been. And that is where we're at today, this incredibly painful, agonizing process for all involved. So I thank you for listening to my initial comments and my team and I look forward to answering the questions you have about the ASD budget.

3:40:45

I would say I think it would depend on the context. A couple of scenarios have been put forth. One would be more of a symbolic adjustment to the total cap, and others would be more substantive. So for example, if the assembly did reduce the ASD budget. That's not what I'm talking

3:41:50

Thank you for that clarification, Mr. Chair. Again, it really depends on what we're talking about, what the whereas is, the whereas may involve an expenditure that's millions of dollars, in which case the the things that the school board would have to consider to make up that difference would be very difficult, very challenging, and ultimately their decision, so I can only

3:54:12

Yes. In fact, the school board in the resolution that I referenced earlier tonight had three directives. One or the two we've already spoken about, but the third was actually to work with the community on a long range process to engage the community and ensure that moving forward that school consolidation proposals are thoughtful and grounded in community input and some of the realities that perhaps the community doesn't know, and we should inform them of them. Thank

4:06:40

Sure. So that process goes through our accreditor cognia, and there's a process specifically for STEM credentialing, and that's a process that could be implemented again. In fact, it's something that I'm excited to do once we move forward with consolidating our footprint so that it's smaller, but can sustain incredible STEM programs for the foreseeable future. So if Campbell STEM were closed and there weren't some sort of reversal that were to happen in the future, that would be something that I would utilize to recertify a school. With that said, it is not an easy or simple process. It requires the buy-in of teachers, school leader to champion it, and a lot of commitment to the principles espoused by Cognia, but it is a process that can and will be done when the situation is appropriate.

4:07:37

In terms of the cost, I believe it's several thousand dollars, just a few thousand, several thousand. Not an extraordinarily large cost. I will say having gone through the district accreditation process, so now every single anchorage school is accredited through Cognia. It does take a couple of years and then continuous monitoring and oversight from Cognia, the accreditation board, but again, having just gone through a district wide accreditation for all schools, we certainly have the infrastructure to pursue additional STEM accreditations for one or more schools in the future.

4:13:13

Sure, Member Gerker, great question. So this process of consolidating schools or right sizing schools has been taking place not just this year, but frankly for the past four years, and it's taken place in different modalities each time. Sometimes there were improvements, and I would say in this most recent iteration, a lot of setbacks due to the crisis that we face. But with that said, back in, I believe 2023, we actually took an entire year off from closing schools, but we didn't take a year off from discussing consolidation because we spent about six months working with the board and collecting input from the community on some sort of framework for how one would pursue a very agonizing task of selecting from You know, over 94 schools, a list to move forward to a school board to select for consolidation. And through that process, we received some good feedback, and some of the metrics that the school board adopted that particular year that have set a framework for subsequent conversations are a number of things, one of which would be utilization within an area. So one of the things that we see within Anchorage is we have a number of schools. Again, we've lost 6,000 students, the equivalent to let's say 14 plus full elementary schools, but oftentimes what you see is that they're clustered within a five mile, sometimes fewer radius. There are some situations where one elementary school is just a couple of streets away from another elementary school. And one of the reasons is actually very positive. It's because back when we were developing these schools many decades ago, the idea was to create neighborhood schools. And I think that's a very valuable, very aspirational idea that worked for many, many years. But fast forward to the popularity of correspondence education, lower birth rates, and a number of other factors beyond the scope of this conversation, we see a number of schools within a small geographic region that are underenrolled. And at a high level, that is not a good thing for students because when a school is underutilized or within an underutilized area of town, you're more likely to share services, you're more likely to have combination classrooms, you're more likely to share a PE teacher or a music teacher, or what have you. These combinations manifest in different ways. So that's one piece. And of course, When you have schools that are very close to one another that are all underutilized, the next thing is is it feasible? Is it financially sustainable to institute transportation services? So that's another factor. Mr. Bryant.

4:16:04

you. So transportation service is is another thing that that's considered. Another thing that was on our criteria that we developed that particular year was on community growth because we did receive feedback that there are certain neighborhoods where perhaps there are developments that are going to be put in place that would result in not necessarily new residents to Alaska, but perhaps the migration of residents from one area of Anchorage to another. That's another common thing that comes up that would preclude an area from being considered development is something that's factored. A big piece is facility condition. And I think that's the one that played a prominent role in this situation because we're trying to manage a number of very difficult things at once. One, we have a $.5 billion tally in deferred maintenance, and it would take us 20 years in school bonds alone to reduce that number. And that's assuming that there's no growth in additional deferred maintenance. So one of the most significant ways that you can reduce that deferred maintenance number is to reduce the number of schools that you maintain in your portfolio. So one of the things that's being considered, for example, with Avot Loop Elementary would be to declare that facility as excess, and just for clarity to the public, that's a term that that's a legal term meaning that the school declares the building as being additional to its needs, providing it to the municipality. It does not mean that a school is excess to remission. And in fact, oftentimes the schools that are selected for closure are incredible. And Campbell STEM is no exception. It's an incredible school that adds a lot of value to hundreds of people in this community. But with that said, a common thread across all these schools is that there's a large amount of deferred maintenance. And we can talk about, you know, this school is on this bond or this school is going to be on this future bond, but when you look at the big picture, I think our path to ensuring that our schools can endure for future generations is frankly to have either fewer schools or many, many more children to fill those schools. And one thing that does make Campbell stand out are a couple of things. It was mentioned that there are fungible dollars that are through the school bond debt reimbursement program that are affixed to Campbell STEM. That is something that was taken into consideration as the directive from the school board was to find efficiencies that could generate short term dollars. And that's the second thing that the school board has to grapple with. The first one was around large deferred maintenance needs. The second one would be around how do we in this crisis moment try to Bring back as many fungible dollars to the district as possible so that we can move services forward for an additional school year. And I will say to the school board, they were making a very difficult decision between adopting budget that dramatically reduced the number of healthcare service providers in the school, specifically nurses, and then also athletics, and to consider that with a building that's in need of many repairs, with Campbell specifically, again, a wonderful program, but I think we have to separate the program from the facility. So Campbell is the, I believe, the only school that I can recall this year that was closed more than one time due to severe winter conditions. There was a sewer line that was frozen and something that doesn't get often talked about in these technical conversations is that specific issue with the facility was not a common that was not incorporated in the bond that we're talking about for Campbell STEM. And then there's additional work that needs to be done in the school. So even though there was a recent roof project in my most recent visit to Campbell, you know, well before the school consolidation conversation happened, I did notice that there was a bucket to collect water droplets at the very front of the school. So when I look at Campbell STEM, I see a school that perhaps deserves millions of dollars in investment, but when you zoom out and you look at the financial crisis that the district and city and state is in, we have to have the difficult conversation of figuring out how do we sink our footprint so that we can make every dollar that we may or may not get from the taxpayer through bonds to make sure that our schools can endure for generations. So myself, I had to make the very difficult I had to decomp decomparementalize in some ways the incredible program which we can rebuild and put in other locations from the facility that, yes. Could we tactically repair this building? Yes. But are there other needs that have also resulted in that $1.5 billion in deferred maintenance, I would also say yes. So it was and then in addition to facility condition, there are a number of other different metrics like alternative use. So there are a number of different things you can do with the a consolidated school. One way that's slightly less drastic, but is also more cost effective is to repurpose a building for another use, such as being filled by a let's say a charter school that has a much larger enrollment. A good example of that would be when we move the Alaska Native Cultural Charter School to the Lake Hood facility. Lakehood, the year that it was closed was approaching about 50% utilized, meaning that it was more susceptible to combination classes and a number of other things, sharing specialists, et cetera, et cetera. But fast forward to today, the Alaska Native Cultural Charter School is housed there. And as a charter school, they're able to use their dollars to maintain the minor maintenance on that facility. But I would say in the bigger picture, I'm also seeing a school that's at its highest enrollment that it's ever been. So now we have nearly 400 students that are in that building, whereas before it was approaching under 200 within the next couple of years. So that specific community, that specific building was transformed by alternative use. And that's another thing that was considered. And that's why in this proposal you'll see a number of different combinations. In the case of Campbell STEM, the proposals to declare it as excess because of the very intense needs that it would need to repair it for generations to come. But the alternative would be to repurpose a vacant facility for a charter school, one, so that you can have an independently funded charter school to pay for the minor maintenance and utilities costs, but two, ensure that that building has a greater utilization than it has before. And I would say in all the situations where that where that's happened, it's been better for students. It was better for students when we were able to fill the Lake Hood facility with one of our highest performing Title I charter schools. And it also was a huge win for the Baxter community when a school was closed on the east side, but those students were rezoned to Baxter, so now it's at the highest enrollment that it's been in for about 10 years. And as a result, it was less likely to have combination classrooms. It was less likely to have a number of these different vulnerabilities that happen when you have the same number of buildings that you had 30 years ago when you had almost 10,000 more students. So it's extremely complicated. And I don't blame the public for desiring some sort of strier that spits out the school that's the number one best candidate for consolidation. That's never the case. And there was never a school that was easy to close. There was never a school where there were arms racing, please close my school. We haven't heard from a single family from the Fire Lake and Lake Otis communities tonight, and those are fantastic schools as well. And I had the honor of hearing from hundreds of families that told me very compelling compelling reasons why those schools should be open as well. This is not easy work. But at the end of the day, I have to offer some lens of objectivity to the board that when I say that there are 6,000 fewer students in the same number of buildings that we had 20 years ago, that it's ultimately a disservice to those students when they're more vulnerable to the impacts of underutilization, such as everything that I previously described. So at a high level, those are just some of the criteria that we looked at for about a year and have largely guided our decisions in the subsequent years.

4:24:29

Sure. So utilization, you can define it in a couple of different ways. The state actually has an index for defining utilization. They look at it in terms of square footage. It's a very sterile process. In ASD, we've created a somewhat more school friendly way of calculating capacity. So that's incorporating factors such as, you know, perhaps we must house a special education program that requires just a handful of students being in a large room. So in which case having a small number of students in a large space is actually utilizing the building to its full extent because some of our high need special education programs actually do need a lot of space. So it's very nuanced. I wish I could just tell you if it's 50 and below, you're on the list. If it's 50 or more, you're not. But it's more complicated than that because, again, to my previous point, sometimes you'll have as many to as four to five schools within a five mile radius. So even if one school may be utilized, if that school were to be consolidated into the others, they'll be much better utilized. So when I'm what we're

4:25:38

So utilization, it student enrollment is a large driver of it, but I think it's important to keep the nuance of special programs like special education.

4:26:35

It depends on the context, and that actually reminds me of the last point that I wanted to make, but I think when we developed that initial criteria several years ago, each one was a fixed a point system. I would need I'm happy to give that to the assembly and others. It's on our website, but just for clarity, I'm happy to provide that, but I don't want to misspeak on what got what number of points. But the other piece that I'll leave you with on the topic of school consolidations is that oftentimes people assume that there's some sort of short list and my ex school wasn't on the previous list that I saw last year or this year, so why is it on the list now? And I will offer some nuance to that because this would be the third proposal that's gone before this set of school board members. And each time there have been amendments or adjustments made to the original proposal. And when those changes are made, it causes a cascade, a domino effect. So, for example, Baxter was one that I mentioned earlier. It was actually initially slated for closure. Why was it not on the list again? Because the school board did close another school on the east side that same year. We rebounded that school into Baxter. So it now is at a very high level of utilization. There are other examples too, like Tudor Elementary was previously on a list, but after it was not consolidated by the school board, program changes were made, and preschool classrooms were moved into that particular building. And there are countless other nuances of when a school is removed from a list or not consolidated or the list is adjusted, there's a series of other changes that happened that could impact utilization. Most recently, the school board was faced with a proposal on consolidation, right sizing rather, in November. And while they did decline to consolidate schools at that time, they did approve the administration to move forward with commercial child care in underutilized buildings. So, for example, Fairview Elementary, which was which is historically a school with low utilization, will now house the headquarters for one of the childcare providers as a spinning kind service or a some sort of joint collaboration. We've also been able to utilize funds from municipal grants to put that work forward. But again, not to get too in the weeds, but again, every time that there are changes made to a consolidation proposal, it creates a ripple effect that changes the nature of the criteria by which these schools were initially assessed.