Open Minutes is an early work in progress.Learn what that means

Assembly Regular - March 24, 2026

Is it just me for Shine Don't let them steal your mind you said if they owed you money I won me for you Oh you're stuck with anything Don't let these woman sing upon soon Good four five six sometimes two go in your cavity and nobody else fall Think I did something bad I did something bad Never question Say if they owe me money If they owe me something Let's go out and spend it I'm not very lucky if they owe me something Let's go back

Sometimes the world

moves too quickly and I know It's not like the earth is slow we both know I can see at least a more and nobody stays mad me all

get started in just a couple minutes Okay, everybody ready? Good evening, everybody. Welcome. I now call to order this regular meeting of the Anchorage Assembly. Tonight is March 24, 2026. It's 5:03 p.m. Madam Clerk, would you please call the roll.

Member Myers?

Unknown

Here.

Member McCormick.

Unknown

Here.

Member Martinez. Member Baldwin Dane.

Unknown

Present.

Member Johnson.

Unknown

Here.

Chair Constant. Vice Chair Brawley.

Unknown

Here.

Member Voland. Happy to be here. Member Silvers?

Unknown

Here.

Member Rivera?

Unknown

Present.

Member Gurker.

Unknown

Here.

Member Presford?

Unknown

Here.

Chair, you have a quorum.

Thank you. And I would note we are all here, and we're all here in person tonight. I'm glad to see it. Next we'll have the pledge of allegiance. Mr. McCormick, would you please lead us in the pledge?

I pledge allegiance to the

flag of the United States of America.

Mr. Martinez, would you please read the land acknowledgement?

Yes, Chair. A land acknowledgement is a formal statement recognizing the indigenous people of a place. It is a public gesture of appreciation for the past and present indigenous stewardship of the lands that we now occupy. It is an actionable statement that marks our collective movement toward decolonization and equity. The Anchorage Assembly would like to acknowledge that we gather today on the traditional lands of the Denina Athabascans. For thousands of years, the Denina have been and continue to be the stewards of this land. It is with gratitude and respect that we recognize the contributions, innovations, and contemporary perspectives of the upper cook inlet denina. Thank you, Chair.

Thank you, Mr. Martinez. Next we have Minutes of previous meetings. Tonight we have it for a regular meeting, February 17, 2026. Is there a motion to approve?

Unknown

Second.

Motion to approve by Mr. Myers. Seconded by Ms. Baldwin Day. Any discussion. Oh, I would also note for the record that we are also joined by the youth member Kenny Bowser. Also I would ask for I have a motion to approve by Mr. Myers, seconded by Ms. Baldwin Day. Any discussion? Seeing hearing no discussion, I'd like to ask unanimous consent. Is there any objection to the adoption of the motion? Seeing hearing no objection, the motion is adopted. I am 4.A. Next we have the mayor's report. Madam Mayor

Thank you, Mr. Chair, and good evening, everyone. Last week we kicked off construction to rebuild cargo terminal one at the Don Young port of Alaska. This represents Did I hear a woo-hoo? Yeah. I know. I know we're not supposed to clap, but can we clap? Thank you, Mr. Chair. This represents a huge milestone in the entire Port of Alaska modernization. It also represents a lot of work that has spanned assemblies and mayoral administrations. The port is a lifeline, not just for Anchorage, but for our entire state. Roughly 90% of Alaskans rely on the inbound cargo that crosses these docks and rebuilding this critical piece of infrastructure will secure our port for years to come. Speaking of our future, I firmly believe that local schools are the bedrock of our community and our economy. And there is no investment more worthy than investing in our kids. We're facing a very difficult time for public education in Alaska. Tonight's agenda includes the school district budget. I want to acknowledge the incredibly difficult decisions that the school board and district administration have had to make. The impacts will be felt deeply across our community by students, families, educators, and staff. My administration is fully committed to doing everything within our power to support our students, our educators, and our classrooms, and to stand up for the families who rely on the Anchorage School District to prepare their children for the future. Anchorage residents' ballots are now in your hands. If approved, Proposition 9, the one-time education levy, will provide almost $12 million to the Anchorage School District. This funding will help stabilize our schools by limiting class size increases and show our children that their education is our priority. The education levy is one of several opportunities for voters to invest in our shared future this April. There are seven municipal bonds on the ballot, from essential road and drainage maintenance to life safety upgrades at public facilities. These bonds represent a commitment to keeping our municipality functional, safe, and vibrant. Investing in our future also means investing in our people. And tonight I want to recognize the incredible professionalism of our municipal workforce. Recently at the Central Transfer Station, a member of the public suffer a critical medical emergency while unloading their trash. Two of our Solid Waste Services crew members jumped into action, administering life-saving CPR. They were coached by a 911 dispatcher who provided steady expert guidance over the phone. Because our AFD teams had recently spent time on site reviewing navigation to improve response times, EMS arrived quickly to stabilize the resident and transport them to the hospital. This response was a team effort. I want to thank all our municipal employees who helped save a life that day, from the SWS staff to the APD dispatcher and the EMS staff at the fire department. Lastly, as we move into spring and temperatures warm up, we'll see a lot more people gathering outside and recreating in our parks and trails. I know I'm excited to get out there. With more people outdoors, I want to remind members of the public, if you see a neighbor in crisis, please call for help. If you witness a crime or dangerous behavior, please report it. If you see trash in a park or public area that needs cleaning, please report it. Our municipal teams are here to respond. That's all for now. Back to you, Mr. Chair. Thank you.

Thank you, Madam Mayor. Next we have the chair's report. Good evening, everybody, and welcome tonight to our regular meeting. And the first thing I'll start out with is like the mayor, we have an election happening. In fact, it closes in 14 days and approximately two and a half hours. On April 7, that'll be your last day to vote. And once you filled out your ballot and sign the declaration, you can return your ballot envelope in one of three ways. One, you can drop it at one of 18 secure drop boxes within the municipality. You can mail it using first class postage, or you can bring it to one of three. Anchorage accessible voting centers. If you haven't received your ballot, have questions or need to look up the secure drop box or accessible voting center at locations, go to Muni.org slash elections or call the voter hotline at 907-243-VOTE. Earlier is better. If you haven't had your ballot or if some issue comes up, get to the voting staff as soon as you can so you can get that resolved. I know that I received my ballot tracks notification today that not only was my ballot received, but it will be counted. So you can sign up at Anchorage Votes.com if you want to get notifications of where your ballot is in the process. Next, tonight or today, we open applications for our 2026, 2027 Anchorage Assembly youth representative positions. The assembly created the youth representative position in 2017 to ensure that young people have a voice in municipal decision making and to encourage engagement among the next generation of community leaders. Students interested in applying can learn more about the position eligibility requirements and application process on the assembly website, Muni.org slash youth applications will be collected until May 8, 2026. And this year's youth members, Jacob Lavarius West High School, Gwyneth Egelson of Betty Davis East High, and Kennedy Bowser of Chug High School sponsored a resolution encouraging ASD youth to hold a voter or ASD to hold youth voter registration drives, which ASD did in partnership with the League of Women Voters. And I am so glad to report that the effort resulted in 321 eligible students registering to vote. So by the municipal election, we'll have 300 and 21 new high school age voters on the roll. Next, I want to talk about the Board of Equalization. I want to highlight a few examples of what's great about our community. As you may have heard, we had a high number of property appraisal appeals this year. Appeals are heard by the Board of Equalization, which is comprised of private citizens and local professionals. It's not a municipal staff person who decides on your appeal, but a panel of your neighbors. The board reached out a few weeks ago to ask for help, so the assembly put out a call to recruit members. And I'm pleased to announce with the passage of our budget, excuse me, with the passage of our agenda tonight, that we had a record number of applicants, and if you approve them all, we will have a full board as of tonight. I want to thank Anchorage Daily News for amplify our request to the board members, and I want to thank everyone who stepped up to serve. This is a great example of how our community comes together to solve problems and how people will step up to serve their community when asked. I anticipate we'll get a report sometime in early April if the department needs additional resources to tackle the number of appeals that we have. But we're on the right track and assembly members at this time are not required to sit on the board of equalization. Also I want to mention that if we have items that need to be continued tonight, we will unless there are very specifically a reason to continue them to the meeting of April 14, we may continue them to the meeting of April 22, which is a special meeting with the intent to funnel all final business to that meeting before the April 28th meeting, so that the April 28th meeting can conclude with certification at a reasonable hour for the new elected assembly members. So with that I will conclude my report and we will go down the diocese for committee and liaison reports. We'll start with you, Mr. Myers. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Nothing to report. Thank you, Mr. McCormick.

Nothing to report. Thank you.

Thank you, Mr. Martinez.

Thank you, Chair. The next meeting of the community and economic development committee will be held Thursday, April 2, 9 a.m. At the last meeting, we discussed some of the Title 23 changes that the body will be be coming before us soon. And just encourage people to look at the reports that we often publish. They come from different departments, and we have really good departmental reviews about what's happening, particularly around street maintenance and other things. So a lot of reliable information and I just encourage people to tap into that website. Thank you, Chair.

Mr. Martinez, Ms. Baldwin Day.

Thank you, Chair. The Minnesota Municipal Audit Committee meets tomorrow, which is not typical. We normally meet on Thursdays. We are meeting tomorrow from two to 3 p.m. at City Hall in the usual conference room. I also wanted to add that several of us traveled to Washington, DC for National League of Citi conference last week and also met with our congressional delegation. A lot of conversation happening not only in our municipality and with our congressional delegation, but around the country about infrastructure funding specifically for our roads and our streets, funding for housing to meet the housing demand that is rising everywhere as our shrinking supply makes itself plain. And also a lot of conversations about how municipal governments or how local governments continue to operate wisely in very fiscally constrained environments. It was a great opportunity to connect with other local legislators from around the country and also meet with our federal delegation and let them know what is important to us here in Anchorage and urge them to support federal legislation that helps us have a more robust and stable local economy. So was really grateful to be a part of that along with a couple of my colleagues. Thank

you. Thank you, Ms. Baldwin Day. Mr. Johnson.

Yeah, thank you, Chair. I'll note that the March meeting in the infrastructure enterprise and utility oversight committee was canceled. We'll be back in April. And for the Assembly Legislative Committee, our next meeting will be tomorrow at City Hall at 10:50 a.m. In addition to our usual items of business, we'll also have a discussion on the 21st century Road to Housing Act. And also House Bill 258, establishing statewide spay and neuter assistance fund. And House Bill 348 regarding feral cats. That's all, Chair.

Thank you, Mr. Johnson. Vice Chair Murder.

Thank you. Just a brief report this evening for the budget and finance committee. The committee met last week on Thursday, March 19. And then our next meeting will be Thursday, April 16, 10 to 11.A. City Hall room 155. And then I'll also remind members and the public that the first quarter budget revision process or one Q starts next month for the assembly and is already underway for departments and the administration. We anticipate the revised budget will be introduced at the April 14th meeting, our next regular meeting. We have two work sessions on the books for Friday, the 17th of April and Friday the 24th of April. So please if you have thoughts or questions about that, please follow up with the Office of Management and Budget or the relevant departments. Thank you.

Thank you, Vice Chair William. Mr. Fallon.

Thank you, Mr. Chair. I will piggyback off of Member Baldwin Day. I too was able to attend the National League of Cities Conference and learned a great deal. In addition to attending the conference, myself and member Baldwin Day and Chair Constant were also we're also able to meet with the members of our federal delegation and to discuss with them issues around the port. Some of our needs, but also exciting announcements there, as the mayor mentioned in in her remarks tonight. We discussed with them the Road to Housing Act that member Johnson just mentioned. I might also flag for the legislative committee that we discussed the basics act, which has to do with giving localities more control over some of the federal infrastructure spending to push our priorities forward. We also discussed funding for homelessness response and potentially some legislative fixes to give the U.S. Army Corps of Engineer authority to build housing within the municipality. So those meetings with Senators Markowski and Sullivan and Bagic, I think were very good meetings. I did want to on the record extend my appreciation for them for hosting us for their time in meeting with us and discussing these very important issues to Anchorage. Thank you, Mr.

Chair. Ms. Over. Nothing to report. Thank you. Thank you Ms. Vera.

Thank you, Mr. Chair. Nothing to report.

Thank you, Mr. Travera. Mr. Kirker.

Thank you, Mr. Chair. Nothing to report.

Thank you, Mr. Kirker. Mr. Martin. Presridia. Thank you, Chair.

Two quick updates. Upcoming in April. The public health and safety committee will meet on April 1 at 11.A. And on April 15, the 15th, the housing and homeless committee will meet on April 15 at 11.A. Please join us. Thanks.

Thank you. And youth member Bowser. No report. Thank you, Chair. All right. Thank you. That then takes us to our addendum to the agenda. The addendum includes items to be added as prepared Friday before the meeting. We also have some late on the table items tonight to address. We have a number of new items and some supplemental items. I'll go ahead and read the supplemental items in first. So that's 10.F 10 information memorandum. AIM unnumbered 2026 answers to assembly questions. Then we have 10.G.8 AO 2026 unnumbered in ordinance to the Anchorage Municipal Assembly amending Anchorage Municipal Code Section 27.20.135 pertaining to Chuggyak, Birchwood, Eagle River Rural Road Service Area Sversa Board of Supervisors to add the criteria of community council representation on the Sespursa Board of Supervisors. Oh, I'm sorry, this is an item for introduction, so it's new. Hold on. Yeah, so we'll go ahead and take care of that. Is there a motion to introduce

move to introduce on the table?

Unknown

Second.

Move by Mr. Myers, second amendment, Mr. Volnis or third. Ms. Baldwin Day. It's kind of a tie between Mr. Ms. Baldwin Day, I think. So that one is taken care of. So we have a resolution 10.F nine information memorandum. Unnumbered 2026, Taco Campbell community council resolution regarding the closure of Campbell STEM Elementary. So this one, I think the member who drafted it asked if it should be associated with the budget, and the decision was no. If it is part of the budget, then it doesn't need a motion, but if we keep it separately, we do. So I think we'll leave it, we'll leave it for new. So we'll go ahead and work our way now through the new items that need action. So the first item is 10.A.4 resolution error 2026, unnumbered resolution of the Anchorage Assembly. Recognizing March 29, 2026 as education and sharing day. I have introduced laid this item on the table, Ms. Brawley, would you move

it? Move to introduce.

Unknown

Second.

Move by Mr. Brawley, second by Mr. Bowland, and I can speak to the time sensitivity. Mr. Constant. Thank you. This day is tomorrow, and I've been traveling. So if or not tomorrow, Sunday, and if we don't do this tonight, then it's after the fact. So I would ask members' indulgence to get it on the agenda for tonight. Any further discussion? Like to ask if there's unanimous consent. Is there any objection to the motion? I'm seeing hearing no objections, that item will be laid on the table. Next is another new item, item 10.B nine resolution error 2026 unnumbered resolution at the Anchorage Assembly amending and supplementing the 2026 state legislative program to advance a strategic housing initiative investment redundant initiative. Ms. Brawley, would you take care of that. Move to introduce Second. Move by Mr. Second by Mr. Wall and I would also like to speak to that. Mr. Constantine. Thank you. I had heard from members of the administration and from the legislature that if we don't ask, we don't get in the context of if there is a windfall that comes from oil, that we should have another request come in, and what the intent was was to put forward a housing infrastructure investment fund. And if and when we get to this item, if you look at it, there it's a it's a list of projects and a request to the legislature to fund infrastructure like sewer and water, the expensive parts to these projects. There are properties within every district of the municipality, so it was intended to be a broad opportunity for the legislature to do that. So the reason why it's time sensitive is because the CAPS system will close between now and the next time that we move a meeting, and so we can't just put it on. We have three weeks between now and then. And so if we don't do this tonight, then it won't get in. So I would like to ask for your support. I'd like also to ask you now's consent. Is there any objection to the Mr.

Myers? I want to ask you or disclose potentially conflict of interest. Several of these parcels in district two I've worked on in like a professional capacity. Obviously, this will not happen while I'm still on the body, but if it does, then I will get paid on some of these.

So I would offer that I don't believe it's conflict. You could probably rule because I'm moving this. I defer to the vice chair. Well, I think now would be the time.

Okay, given that this is a speculative funding request, but that it sounds like you do have existing business interest with these properties. I guess I would find that you do have a substantial interest in this at this time.

Okay, that's fine. I can leave.

Okay, and I'll ask if any members disagree with that ruling or would like to override.

I am gonna suggest that A it is very speculative, and B, there is no money because this is an infrastructure project. It's not to create a parcel that will be sold. It's to put in the infrastructure so developers can do that. So it's two steps removed from the possibility, in my opinion. So I think we should be careful in excusing members from participating in votes because the code commands that you will participate.

That's fair. I guess then procedural question, if this was considered a ruling, and then should we just move to override the

ruling? It's a diminished issue in a way. So probably you can just let it go, but

Okay. Well in that case then I will I see the logic of saying that it is speculative that this is not specific to a single project. So in this case then, Mr. Myers, I would rule that you do not have a conflict at this time. Okay, thank you. Thank you.

Thank you, Mr. Myers, for making the disclosure. That's the important part is that you get it on the record. So Yeah, so we have the vote on this. The question is I'd like to ask unanimous consent to an objection to the adoption of the motion to lay on the table. So the question before this item on the table, is there objection to laying it on the table? I'm not seeing or hearing any objections. That item will be laid on the table, and it's item 10.B.9. So next we have item 10.D 45, which assembly member memorandum and a numbered 2026 recommendation of award of a sole source contract with Traffic Logics Corporation for the procurement of relocatable speed feedback signs and associated equipment is our motion. Move to introduce it. Move by Ms. Riley is there.

Unknown

Second.

Second by Ms. Baldon Day. To the manager, do you want to explain to us the time sensitivity?

Thank you, Mr. Chari. Yes. These are this is in order to order 15 additional speed feedback signs from the same contractor that we have been using for purchases, speed feedback signs. The time urgency is driven by the desire to have them arrive in May, right as the ground thaws, so we can install them in time to be present for the entirety of the summer. The goal these have been proven effective in decreasing bad traffic driving behavior, and the goal is to disperse them around town to enhance safety on some of our high crash roadways. Thank

you. Right. Any members want to discuss that. I'd also like to ask unanimous consent. Is there any objection to the documenting point of information

checked? I think what I heard was a motion introduced, but that's what I meant. But it but well I think the mover said it was a motion introduced, but if we put this on the agenda, it would be for action tonight, correct? Yes. Okay, just want to clarify that.

Yeah, so if it's introduced, then it is on our consent agenda tonight. As item 10.D 45. Is there any objection? Any you can pull it if you want to further discuss it. So okay, I'm not hearing any objections. We'll consider that item laid on the table. So then that takes us to 10.F.9 information memorandum. AIM unnumbered Tucker Campbell community council resolution regarding the closure of Campbell STEM Elementary. Is there a motion? Move to introduce.

Unknown

Second.

So it's moved to lay on the table. Ms. Baldon Day, seconded by Mr. Rivera. You want to speak to the time sensitivity?

Yes, this was a resolution that was passed at the last Tacu Campbell community council meeting, which was just over one week ago. And clearly this pertains to another item before us tonight, but I think should stand alone since it is a community council resolution that is not specifically germ to the contents of the budget, but it is about the closure of Campbell's stem, which is a part of our conversation this evening. Thank you.

Okay, thank you. Any further discussion? Any objection? Seeing hearing none, go ahead and lay that item on the table as well. I think that takes care of everything that I have so far. Okay, so now I'd like to ask for a motion to incorporate the addendum as printed and distributed and the laid on the table items so moved. Second moved by Ms. Baldwin Day, seconded by Mr. Warland. Is there any objection? Seeing hearing no objection, the Addendum and the laid on the table items have been incorporated. Next we have appearance requests. So we do have an appearance request tonight. We have Conrad James 9.B. Mr. James, please come forward. Microphone is off, plus the green button. Please come forward. There's a green button, you press that. And then please state your name, what part of town you're from. You'll have three minutes. There you go.

Name is Conrad James. Born and raised in Raleigh, North Carolina, but I'm currently unhoused here in Angridge. So I guess I I'm living everywhere. Members of the Assembly Mayor. I'm here tonight. And of friction. And of motion. I'm here to dictate the economic resurrection of the unhoused our differently abled in our elders. We have treated these bodies as static liabilities. Tonight I offered you three tangible blueprints to transform them into kinetic engines of Anchorage's economy. First, the Anchorage Jetney. We propose localized transit programs of human powered sleds and carts. Picture the raw, beautiful kinetic heat of the human body becoming a sovereign currency in our winter streets. By employing our people to push and peddle these two seeded vessels, we transform idle bodies of vital conduits to transit. We give them the dignity of motion, the cardiovascular flesh of purpose, and the direct localized stream of compensation. They are no longer waiting for salvation. They are actively moving our city forward. Secondly, the street paper. They will step onto the street corners not with empty hands asking for charity, but as vocal embodied merchants offering art and local news. The energetic exchange of currency, the profit above costs, will be split between the vendors' own pockets and the nonprofits' collective fund. We're teaching them to use their voices, make eye contact, and actively participate in the semantic rhythm of the marketplace. Third and most profoundly is the alchemy of rehabilitation. Anchorage is scarred of dilapidated abandoned properties, the decaying bones of our city. We propose acquiring these hollow structures and teaching the unhoused, disabled, and elder neighbors to breathe life back into them. We will teach. Tactile wisdom of drywall conductive flow of electrical wiring and the liquid circulation of plumbing. These classic irreplaceable trades, once we habilitate it, these properties will become short term daily daily rentals woven into the modern ab economy. But the profound shift is that the architects of the rebirth, property managers and maintenance managers will be pooled from the vulnerable communities in permanently house in the very walls that they healed alongside their renting guests. We will build equity, teach mastery of the physical world, and create self self-sustaining organisms of self shelter. Motion exchange rehabilitation. We do not need to hide our vulnerable populations. We need to hand them the tools to rebuild themselves. And in doing so, rebuild the very foundation of Anchorage. Thank you for your breath, your time, and your vision.

Thank you. Next we have the addendum to the agenda. Excuse me. Flip the page. Next we have the consent agenda. Thank you, Mel Clerk. Consent agenda items are number 10.A through 10.G, and are typically routine or non controversial items, such as biddle words, new business, information reports, and ordinances and resolutions for introduction. The consent agenda may be approved by the assembly by a single vote on a motion to items on the consent agenda may be approved by the assembly by a single vote on a motion to approve the consent agenda. Prior to approval, items may be polled by assembly members for discussion, separate votes on any of these items. Under the rules, all ordinances and some resolution will have an opportunity for public hearing at a future date. Starting with you, Mr. President, do you have any items? No items tonight. Thank you, Pierre. Thank you, Mr. President. Mr. Girker.

Ten off and two, Chair.

Ten A two Mr. Girker. Thank you. Mr. Thank you. No items. Thank you. Ms. Silvers. No items. Thank you. Thank you,

Mr. Mr. Walland. Thank you, Mr. Chair. 10 Delta 20.

10.D 20, Mr. Walland. Thank you, Ms. Bowley.

Thank you. I have several apologies in advance. First 10.A.3, 10 alpha three. Second, 10.B.2, Bravo 2. Third, 10.B five, bravo five. And then 10 Bravo 9 and then 10.D 24, 25, and 26. And on 25 and 26, the intention is not to move those. And then lastly, on behalf of the chair, 10.F three. I think that's Fox Drop.

So I have 10.B 2, 5, and 9, 10.D 8, 24, 25, 26, and for me, 10.F three. Oh, and 10.A three.

Yeah, and I think you said 10.B eight. I did not pull that.

I said 10.B.9.

Yes, thank you.

And 10.D eight, but that one you didn't pull. Okay, 10.D eight you didn't pull, just to be clear. Okay, thank you, Mr. Johnson. No items, Mr. Chair. Thank you. Ms. Baldon

Day. Thank you, Chair. I have 10 alpha 1. 10 delta 45 and I believe that is all. Thank you.

All right, so I have you with 10 alpha one and 10.D 45. No, Mr. Martinez. No additional items. Thank you. Mr. McCormick. No additional items. Thank you. Mr. Myers.

Yes, Chair 10.A four, I believe, but I seem to have misplaced it in among all my papers.

Yeah. I have the actual printed version, but you probably have the reading version somewhere. I'll find it before. Thank you. So I'm going to go ahead and read through the list to make sure we got everything. I have 10.A one, Ms. Baldwin Day, 10.A two, Ms. Gurker, 10.A three, Ms. Brawley, 10.A four, Mr. Myers, 10.B two five and nine, Miss Brawley. Ten D 24, 25, and 26, Ms. Brawley, 10.F three, Ms. Brawley. Did I miss anything? Anything missing? Any any last question? Did you say 10.D 45. There you go. Thank you. It's off my list. I did miss that one. I'm going to do this once more. There's so many on the list. And they exceed the numbers on my page, so there's so many under the 10 D's. 10.A one, Miss Baldwin Day. 10.A two, Ms. Skirker, 10.A three, Miss Brawley, 10.A four. Mr. Myers, 10.B. Two, five, and nine, Ms. Brawley. Ten D 20, Mr. Volant. Ten D 24, 25, 26, Ms. Brawley. Ten D 45, Miss Baldwin Day, and then 10.F three, Miss Brawley. Get 'em all. Okay. Minus all of those items we just pulled. I'd like to ask for a motion to approve the consent agenda.

Unknown

So moved. Second.

Motion to approve by Mr. Myers, seconded by Miss Brawley. Any discussion? Seeing hearing none I'd like to ask unanimous consent on the approval of the consent agenda minus the poll items. Is there any objection? Seeing hearing no objection, the consent agenda has been adopted. So if you're here to see action on any of the items on 10.A through 10.F items polled, your business has now been approved, which brings us now to item 10.A.1. 10.A.1 is resolution AR 2026-62. Resolution of the Anchorage Municipal Assembly designating March 27, 2026 as Good Frida Earthquake Remembrance Day. This item was polled by Miss Waldin Day. Thank you, Chair. Move to approve. Second? Move to approve by Miss Faldon Day, seconded by Miss Silvers. I'd like to ask unanimous consent. Is there any objection? Seeing hearing no objection, the item has been adopted. We'll have Ms. Maldon Day reading. Ms. Silvers presenting. Please come forward. A

resolution of the Anchorage Municipal Assembly designating March 27, 2026 as Good Frida Earthquake Remembran Day. Whereas at 5:36 p.m. on March 27, 1964, a magnitude 9.2 earthquake, the most powerful earthquake recorded in North America, and the second largest earthquake ever recorded, hit Prince William Sound and rocked South Central Alaska for over four minutes, with aftershoc lasting for more than a year following the earthquake. And whereas the event known as the Good Friday earthquake cost an estimated 131 lives and left thousands without food, water, and shelter, and caused over 300 million in property and structure damage in 1964 US dollars, amounting to over 3.2 billion in today's money. And whereas thousands of Alaskans became first responders, including firefighters police officers, Alaska State Troopers, members of the United States Army Corps of Engineers, the Alaska Army National Guard, and the Alaska Air National Guard, medics, doctors, nurses, municipal workers, ham radio operators, and many others who selflessly served the state and their fellow Alaskans during this time of great need. And whereas Alaskans immediately began the process of rebuilding their devastated communities and lives through resilience, determination, and selfness selflessness, as they used this disaster as a pivotal moment to grow as a state. And whereas the loss of life and property of the Good Friday earthquake was tragic, yet also provided a wealth of data about subduction zone earthquakes and the hazards they pose. And whereas memorials have been set up all over Alaska to remind Alaskans about their past so that they are better prepared for future emergencies. Be it resolved that the municipality of Anchorage remembers, recognizes, and honors the hard work and exemplary sacrifice of the thousands of military members, including the National Guard first responders, and all those who came to the aid of their fellow Alaskans in the aftermath of the Good Friday Earthquake. Now, therefore, the Anchorage Assembly Assembly designates March 27, 2026 as Good Friday Earthquake Remembrance Day, passed and approved by the Anchorage Assembly this 24th day of March, 2026.

Hello, welcome, please do your name. You just turned it off. One more time. There you go. You're

good. Yes, my name's Helen Valanti. I am here to accept this year's Good Friday Remembrance Day resolution on behalf of my father in law Charles Valante, who originated the request for this annual legislation. Charles Valente now lives in Olympia, Washington, and is not able to be here due to health issues. This Friday marks the 62nd anniversary of the Good Friday earthquake, March 27, 1964. Tonight, we honor the memories of all those who perished, suffered great loss, and those who became the resilient Alaskans who helped to rebuild villages, towns, cities, and ultimately the state. In accepting this resolution, I am honored to speak and keep memories living on. Looking at archives, newspapers, and photographs has helped me visualize what went on so long ago without the technology we have today. During the 1964 earthquake, Alaska earthquake, radio became the primary and often the only lifeline for communication in a severed Anchorage. One instrumental person I discovered was a reporter for KENI Radio, Jeannie Chance, who became a central figure broadcasting for days without break to help coordinate relief, deliver official information, and share personal messages, providing vital comfort and logistical support in the isolated community. The broadcast provided a sense of connection and calm for citizens who were initially unaware of the disaster, if the disaster was a nuclear attack. As Jeannie provided updates on the situation, she was also experiencing the aftershocks her effort earned her numerous numerous awards and led to a political career, and her broadcasts are often cited as a crucial example of the human centric response to disaster management. My father in law Charles Valanti spent many years remembering the nearly five minutes that changed his and many lives forever. His job at the time was also crucial. He was working as an Air National Guard dispatcher at Coolis Air National Guard Base in Anchorage. This job was to provide relief, rescue, and sadly, any necessary recovery. Tragically, on April 25, 1964, he lost his crew, his flight crew, during a humanitarian relief mission for the city of Valdez. The plane crashed into Valdez Harbor and was never recovered. He has carried the memory of those patriotic men for 62 years, and today salutes them once again. Today he remains forever humble the legislation passed by the municipality of Anchorage Council in 2014. And to those council members seated here today who have supported this resolution. Never forgetting all those who work behind the scenes and names we will never know who helped make this resolution possible. In closing tonight, my humble respect, honor, and thanks go to this year's sponsor, Council, Mayor, City Clerk, and my father in law, Charles Relanti, for making every March 27 Good Friday Earthquake Rememberance Day. Thanks for your time. Thank you.

Next we have item 10.A.2. 10.A two is AR 2026-71, a resolution of the Anchorage Municipal Assembly, recognizing Vietnam Veterans, Vietnam War Veterans Day in Anchorage, and honoring Vietnam War Veterans and their families, and publicly expressing gratitude for their service to our nation and our community. This item was polled by Mr. Gurker. Move to approved chair. Second to approved by Mr. Kirker, seconded by Mr. Johnson, I my brain is not functioning tonight. I would like to ask to be added as a sponsor, please. Thank you. So this item was moved by Mr. Gurker, seconded by Mr. Johnson. I'd like to ask unanimous consent. Is there any objection? I have Mr. Gurkha reading, Mr. Johnson presenting. Mr.

Kirker. Thank you Mr. Chair. And I do want to invite folks to come on down. If you are if you're able to stand. If not, feel free to go ahead and stay where you're at, and they'll get a they'll get a photo at the end. A resolution of the Anchorage Municipal Assembly recognizing Vietnam War Veterans Day in Anchorage and honoring Vietnam War Veterans and their families and publicly expressing gratitude for their service to our nation and our community. Whereas the Vietnam War is one of the longest conflicts in United States history with active United States military involvement from 1955 to 1975, where more than 2.7 million American men and women served in Vietnam and over 58,000 members of the United States Armed Services gave their life in service to our nation and whereas Alaska has the highest rate of veterans per capita of any state, with more than 16,000 Vietnam War veterans calling Alaska home, and South Central Alaska boasting the highest rate of veterans per capita of any region in Alaska. And whereas many Vietnam War veterans returned home without the recognition and gratitude they deserved for their service and faced indifference and hardship. In fact, many Vietnam War veterans did not receive adequate care and support for conditions arising from their service in Vietnam. And whereas Vietnam War veterans have remained steadfast in advocating for veterans of subsequent conflicts to receive the care, recognition, and support they deserve. Whereas March 29 is observed nationally as Vietnam War Veterans Day, commemorating the day the day the last United States combat troops departed Vietnam and honoring all who served during that conflict. Whereas Vietnam War Veterans demonstrated courage, dedication, and resilience under extraordinarily difficult. conditions and their service reflects the highest traditions of the United States Armed Forces. And now therefore the Anchorage Assembly recognizes March 29, 2026 as Vietnam War Veterans Day in Anchorage and honors the courage and recognizes the sacrifices made by Vietnam War veterans and their families and publicly expresses the gratitude for their service to our nation and community. Passed and approved by the Anchorage Assembly this 24th day of March 2026.

First of all I'd like to thank my wife, my family, and all other veterans because without our family we couldn't have made it if the people in the in the audience in the in the in the family if you would raise your hand if you have a military veteran within your family somewhere anywhere, just raise your hands that's Anchorage in general because we're the best state there is and we honor our veterans. I know I have been in 48 states and some of the states don't even recognize this. So on this day, I think all veterans will appreciate it. And I want to ask Bob Sherrill of the Anchorage Veterans Military Museum if I to post this certificate we all appreciate it. Thank you.

Thank you. Next we have item 10.A three. Ten A three is resolution AR 2026-72. Resolution of the Anchorage Municipal Assembly recognizing Rick David for his military service and lifelong dedication to improving the lives of veterans in Anchorage and across Alaska. This item was polled by Ms. Brawley. Second. Move by Miss Brawley, second by Mr. Myers. I'd like to ask unanimous consent. Is there any objection? Seeing hearing no objection, I have Mr. Johnson reading and Miss Brawley presenting. Mr. Johnson

A resolution of the Anchorage Municipal Assembly recognizing Rick Davage for his military service and lifelong dedication to improving the lives of veterans in Anchorage and across Alaska. Whereas Rick David is a proud Vietnam War veteran who served his country honorably during the Vietnam War. And where's Mr. Davage voluntarily enlisted in the United States Army at 17 years of age and served as a combat medic in a pathfinder unit, an elite, highly specialized unit tasked with infiltrating enemy held areas ahead of main forces to establish and operate helicopter refueling points and landing zones. And whereas Mr. Davage was wounded during combat operations and is a recipient of the Purple Heart. After his injury, he continued his service by working to provide care to service members in the Burn Therapy Unit at Brook Army Medical Center. And whereas, after his military service as chair of Vietnam Veterans of America chapter 904, and founder of the Alaska Veterans Foundation, Mr. Davage worked tirelessly to advocate for veterans' rights and expand access to services, including seeking support for veterans struggling with the effects of agent orange exposure, post traumatic stress injury, and other conditions related to military service. And Whereas Mr. Davich has been an advocate for recognition of the unique challenges faced by veterans experiencing homelessness, as well as played an influential lol role in changing federal law to reopen the period of for application for na Alaska native land allotments for many individuals who were unable to apply due to their military service. And whereas Mr. David was a driving force in effort to update the veterans memorial on the Alaska Park Strip. He provided leadership for veterans issues at the as the president of the Alaska State Vietnam Veterans Council and as a member of the Anchorage Military and Veterans Commission. Now, therefore, the Anchorage Assembly recognizes and honors Rick David for his courageous military service and lifelong dedication to improving the lives of veterans in Anchorage, Alaska, and across the state of Alaska. Passed and approved by the Anchorage Assembly this 24th day of March, 2026.

Spend six years in the army. We put out a number of books. Companies. And a lot of these books have a lot to do with Alaska. There's a lot of people here that I know and I've known for a long time. Some been a pain in the ass, some of them have been pretty good. Yeah. Never afraid to ask. Don't be afraid to ask. You'd be surprised what I know. Work for Von Reagan, work for Senator my old friend. governors a lot of the mayors here so I really appreciate the the knowledge of my service. I'm now 80 years old. Don't tell my wife that and I'm planning to stick around a little bit longer. Don't tell my wife that and if you have some idea of something that you think I can ask contribute to, don't be afraid to ask. Some of you are Democrats, some of you are republicans, but we work together as Alaskans and we solve problems. And it works. It works. The book I wrote a long time ago on solving the problem of homelessness in Alaska has now been updated again and has now been re relief all over the United States by organizations that have requested copies. It started right here. And you'd be surprised. So Thank you very much for this evening. My wife is back east someplace. So I'll see you tomorrow. And I have a lot of number a lot of friends here. Many of them veterans. Thank you

again. So I want to note he's so gracious. I've known him for many, many years, and he never once corrected me until tonight. It's David. So Thank you, Rick. And we have some folks in the queue. Mr. Rebera.

Yeah, thank you, Mr. Chair. First I'd like to request to be added as a co sponsor to this resolution.

I think the same for all of us. Yeah. Thank you, Mr. Bare.

Great. Thank you. And then second, to Rick. You've never just been a pain in the ass, Rick. You've been a helpful pain in the ass sometimes. We go back years and years and and I still have some of your books, and I as I've read them over the years, debated with them over the years. I've always appreciated your willingness to do that, to engage in thoughtful debate about ideas and never really focus on party lines, but on what's best for Anchorage, what's best for Alaska, what's best for the country. So I really appreciate everything that you've done, and you still got more to do, Rick. Thank

you. Miss Purley. Yeah, thank you. Just very briefly wanna also extend good wishes to Rick, and I know Connie couldn't be here, your wife in person, but she's watching online, so hello Connie as well. And also wanting to pass good wish on behalf of my partner, James, who couldn't be here tonight either, but has actually known you longer than I'm known. I've known him. So he says hello as well. Thank you.

I think finally have Mr. Johnson in the queue.

Yeah, thank you. I just want to personally apologize to Mr. David for mispronouncing your name during the resolution.

Yep. And thank you, Rick, for all of the hard work over all the years bringing sanity to the question of veteran homelessness in the state, which was a boundary breaker in the conversation, helped us to get where we are today, which is not in a perfect place, but better than where we were, which is all we can ask is let's be better today than we were yesterday. So thank you. Thank you. Okay, finally we have on the resolution for reading 10.A.4 resolutionaire 2026-79 resolution of the Anchorage Municipal Assembly recognizing March 29, 2026 as education and sharing day Anchorage. This item was polled by Mr. Myers. Move to approve. Move to approve by Mr. Myers. Seconded by Ms. Brawley. Like to ask unanimous consent. Is there any objection? Seeing and hearing no objection, the item is adopted. I have Mr. Myers reading and I'll be presenting.

Thank you, Mr. Chair. A resolution of the Anchorage municipality municipal assembly recognizing March 29, 2026 as education and sharing day Anchorage. Whereas education, the cornerstone of the strong and free society shapes the individual opportunity in the collective future of our community. And in the municipality of Anchorage, the education and well being of youth remains a priority. And whereas the education whereas education is more than a transmission of knowledge and skills, it also plays a role in preparing individuals for lives of responsibility, service, engagement in their communities, and whereas Rabbi Menichum and I apologize if I butcher these. Mendel Schneerson, known as Labudovich. Rebby experienced significant historical upheaval in the 20th century and emphasized the importance of educational, ethnic or ethical responsibility and acts of service as a foundation for stronger communities. And whereas his legacy contributed to the global movement that has supported educational initiatives, community institutions, and opportunities for individuals to engage in service and mutual support. And whereas inspired these values of education, service, and respect for the dignity of every individual, the Alaska Jewish Campus and Museum, which served Anchorage and Alaska for over 35 years, is it advancing a new initiative to collaboration in local nonprofit organizations serving children with special needs. The Alaska Friendship Circle, an inclusive play and community space designed to support children of all abilities and their families, and whereas the education should equip individuals not only of economic participation, but also for constructive engagement in civic life, including a commitment to community, respect for others, shared responsibility, and justice. Whereas education and sharing day has been recognized since 1978, following the joint congressional resolution, and is observed annually across the United States to promote the importance of education, service, and community engagement. And whereas the observation provides the opportunity to reflect on our shared responsibilities to ensure that all young people have access to education and supportive environments that enable them to lead lives of purpose, contribution, connection to their communities. Now, therefore, the Anchorage Assembly recognizes March 29, 2026 as education and sharing day in the municipality of Anchorage and encourages the residents to support education, engage in acts of service, contribute, and well-being of the community, passed and approved by the Anchorage Assembly on the 24th day of March 2026.

Rabbi Greenberg. Thank you. On the behalf of the Alaska Jewish Campus and Alaska Jewish Museum, I would like to thank Assembly, Chair Chris Constant and the Mayor Mayor Zan LaFriends and the entire Ankish Assembly for proclaiming education sharing day for Anchorage. Today the assembly is joining the American tradition started by US Presidents Carter and Reagan, US Congressmen, the Congress, as well as Alaska's past and present governors, Alaska State Senator, the Alaska State Senate House, and the State Senate and House of Representative and past Anchorage Assembly members in proclaiming education and sharing day on the birth anniversary of the global spiritual giant and leader the Lababich Rebe Rabbi Menachem Schneerson in tribute to his commitment to promoting the importance of moral and ethical education as the foundation of a brighter and better future for all. From his early childhood, the Rebbe envisioned a world filled with love and harmony and emphasised how one single good deed, kind word and a positive or a positive thought has the power to teep the scales and usher our society into a state of true unity and peace. This resolution is also timely as Jews Jewish people worldwide prepare to celebrate the holiday of Passover, the festival of liberty, commemorating the Israelites' excellence from Egypt led by Moses. The Rebbe is teaching that Egypt represents not only a physical location at the northern tip of Africa. The Igun name for Egypt is Mitsraim, which means also constraints and limitations. The Israelite redemption, which occurred over 3,000 years ago, empowers all of us to free ourselves from all all of our internal and external pressures that keep us from realizing our true potential. Moses and his generation, the Rebbe in our generation continues to guide millions to his teachings to utilize the inherent goodness and light to change the world for the for the better. Thanks to the Rebbe's inclusive vision and unconditional love for humanity, leadership and dedication, countless lives have been touched and inspired through the establishment of the Lobaba Jewish Center of Alaska and the Alaska Jewish Museum and Alaska Jewish Campus. In that way, with the support of the City of Anchorage Child Care and Early Education Fund, Tred Alaska, the State of Alaska Childcare Program Office, and the Gastin Foundation, we embarked on a historic milestone project which will change the future of our town and state, the Alaska Friendship, the first inclusive early childhood play center in Alaska and maybe in the entire US, for children with disabilities and special needs founded on the belief that within each person there is a soul, and that soul is equal worthy of boundless love and connection. Immediately Egypt, when Moses gathered the Israelites, he did not speak to them about the promised land or about the long walk ahead, but rather he spoke of the responsibility of parents to educate their children. Why the obsession with education? Because to defend the country, we need a strong army, but to defend a civilization, we need great schools. The Rebbe taught that education is not just about accumulating knowledge in areas like math, science, and history, but our educational system must pay attention, indeed, the main attention to the building of character with an emphasis on moral and ethical values. Today's declaration of education and sharing day serves as a call to all the citizens of our great city to reflect on the vital role in education and preparing. are you to be the leaders of tomorrow but then emphasize on inspiring them to their obligation to serve a cause greater than self with courage and compassion. I would like to make an official invitation to all the entire assembly, the mayor, to come to our outdoor new outdoor beautiful state of the art play center for children's special needs and also to have a discussion about the future building of the indoor play center to make sure the winter does not take a weight from the phone and the children could play in the winter as well. May our city serve as a beacon of light for all people of all walks of life. May we all see the fulfillment of humanity's great future as proclaimed by Hazai nation should not leave the third against nation, neither should they learn war anymore. Amen. Thank you so much

thank you next in the consent agenda we approved the confirmation of Lance Wober as the chief financial officer or fiscal officer, so we will now do his swearing in taking the oath

The Constitution of the State of Alaska.

Constitution of the State of Alaska.

And the charter of the municipality of Anchorage.

And the charter of the municipality of Anchorage.

And that I will faithfully perform the duties. And

I will faithfully perform the duties. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, members of the assembly. I just want to thank you for this opportunity to again serve the municipality in a different role, and I really appreciate the support of Mayor LaFrance and her team to give me this opportunity. I will do the best job I possibly can. Thank

you. And you are the champion of the game of musical chairs. Next up we have item 10.B two. Ten B two is AR 2026-63 resolution of the Anchorage Municipal Assembly in support of Alaska House Bill 78 and Act relating to a defined benefit retirement plan for public employees and teachers. This item was poll by you, Ms. Brewley. Move to approved. Second to approved, seconded by Mr. Johnson. Ms. Bley.

Yeah, I'll be very brief. And I want to also recognize and acknowledge a number of public safety professionals there in the back standing in support of this. There is not public testimony. And then also I would say well. So this is in support of Alaska House Bill 78 regarding defined benefits. As noted in the resolution for many years, or several years anyway, the municipality has been in support of a of a policy such as this to create a defined benefit pension for our public employees. So I would urge support and then I would also invite if any member would like to be added as a sponsor, please indicate as well. Thanks. Thank

you, Mr. Chair. Well, I would like to be added as a sponsor. And then I feel bad because I didn't warn him I was gonna do this ahead of time, but I wonder if I might ask Mr. Evans to come down and if any of his colleagues want to join him. Sort of in solidarity, feel free to come up front. But Mr. Evans, my question for you is when it comes to recruitment and retention. For our police department, if you could just speak a little bit to what a defined benefit retirement plan might mean. For recruitment and retention.

Through the Chair. Member Boland. As a Tier Two pension employee myself, I can tell you that next month, a 30 year employee here in the municipality, I can say that my pension has been everything for me. And I want to see the same for future recruits and our current employees to have the option. The beauty of H B 78 is folks have an option if they if they are comfortable with their defined contribution and they're at a point in their career where they want to stay where they are at, they can, but they have the option of entering into the defined benefit system. So I just look forward to our current employees and new employees having that option so that they can choose the security of a pension if they wish to. So I think it will do wonders for recruiting and retention to answer your question in a long way.

No, I appreciate that. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Right. Pile people in the queue. Mr. Vare.

Yes. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I would like to be added as a co-sponsor to this resolution. And just Yeah very briefly. I've been seeing over the last several months and really year or so, a growing bipartisan support among my constituents regarding this particular bill. And the my constituents always talk to me about the public safety component, about how we should congratulate ourselves for getting back to a ful staffed department comparatively to what we were some years ago. The looming crisis of retirements, I think is an is an issue that we need to find a way to resolve. And I think this bill does a way is helpful in that way.

And I would note the mayor asked be added on the previous item. The education sharing day. So just so you know the mayor is also added a sponsor to that. Mr. Martinez.

Chair just briefly I just wanted to be added as a sponsor to

this item. Mr. Martinez, Mr. Johnson?

Yeah, thank you, Chair. Just very briefly speaking to the officers in the room as well as the municipal and state employees who work so hard to take care of this community and the state. I think with everything that you give to take care of us and the sacrifices you make that that we carry a heavy obligation to take care of you as well. So I'm proud to be the sponsor of this.

Thank you, Mr. Berker.

Thank you, Mr. Chair. I'll be very briefly, very brief. Look, we have somewhere between like, I don't know, six or $7 billion in unfunded liability from the last time we had a defined benefits pension plan. Proponents have said that they think they fixed the overwhelming financial challenges of this kind of retirement plan. The sponsor of this of this legislation in the house described this plan as nearly bulletproof. Anyone knows what happens if you're shot while we're in a nearly bulletproof S. You die. I'll be a no vote. Thank

you.

Can you please add me as a sponsor as well?

Thank you. Mr. Presbirdia.

Yeah, just ask me a sponsor. Thank you. Mr. McCormick.

Yeah. I would love for Alaska to be able to provide the defined benefits program, helping the recruitment retention, absolutely. But as member Gerger said, I remember the $8 billion in unsecured funding from the last pension program that closed 20 years ago. And I have hesitations there. This is something the state legislature would own. They're the ones that would be responsible for it. I will leave the decision to them. I'm not voting against defined benefits program. I'm just willing to stay in my lane and focus on what we got going on here in the assembly and getting our budget under control. I hope the state is able to fund that for the rest of the state as well.

Thank you. Mr. Johnson back in the queue.

Yeah, thank you. I think just in response to some of the comments, I want to just say that simply because a previous defined benefits plan didn't work out the way intended, does not mean that a defined benefits plan cannot be successful. And there's some major substanti changes between previous plans and the one we see here today, including when people become eligible, a sliding scale for the contributions to make sure the funds still stay solvent, how the benefits are calculated for the individuals and more. I think there is a very strong intent to make sure that this is on a sound financial footing. And I just want to add to the record that the state actuary modeled this bill over a 25 year horizon and found that it would take three years at 0% trust fund returns for the plan to drop below 90% funding. And I will also note that these three years of no returns is an event the actuary pointed out is almost impossible to occur and has never happened in the 30 70 70 plus years of pensions in Alaska. So I think we're getting it right this

time. Thank you, Chair. Yeah, just for the sake of clarification. A previous version that didn't work doesn't seem to me to be the burden of the workforce today. And Mr. Havan, just respectfully when you def when you describe the impact of your tier and your defined benefit. Are you Are you aware of the way a system didn't work or whether it worked well or not? Or are you aware of how you can take care of your family?

Through the chair, Member Martinez, I am well aware of

the

And I do believe that the H B 78 and what would be tier five of the defined benefit system has corrected the errors of the past that were done by state actuarials. So and while I have the mic, I would just like to say, too, that not only am I the president of APDEA, but I'm also the chair of the coalition of municipal unions. And on behalf of COMU, I just want to say that the other municipal unions are are also in support of H B 78 and wanted me to echo that for them. AFL CIO happens to be in Juno right now for a fly in. Otherwise they would have members here, but they're actually in JUNO for the last two days, lobbying with boots on the ground down there. So they also are in support. So thank you.

Thank you, Mr. Evans, for your diligence on being able to do a contrast with what happened in the past and for the ability to know take care of your family today. Just to remind colleagues, this is a resolution in support of a legislative item at the state level. And so from my vantage point, I think it's a pretty clear Let's stand in solidarity with our workforce and anything we can do to make it better. Thank you. I think

there's no one else. Thank you. I'll just add I have a very large frustration this year is the first year I was not one of the primary sponsors. So my peers have worked around me, which is a sign of things to come. And it is a sign that y'all are ready for this job and ready to do it in my absence. So I appreciate that. Glad to be at it as a sponsor. And I think everyone's been at it. But so the work continues. Thank you. So next we have members may proceed to vote. A vote of nine to three in the youth member votes.

Unknown

Yes.

Yes. AR 2026-63 has passed the body. Next we have item 10.B 510 B 5 resolution resolution Air 2026-73, a resolution of the Anchorage Municipal Assembly requesting a comprehensive review of fully of fully tax exempt real property to ensure compliance with the municipal code, verify public benefit, and explore tax relief options for residents to recapture vino eligible exemptions. This item was pulled by you, Ms. Brawley. Move to approve.

Unknown

Second.

Yeah, I have one technical amendment, but I'm not the primary sponsor, so I wanted to also seed the floor first to see if the sponsors wanted to add any additional

commentary.

We would love to hear the technical amendment.

Ms. Brawley.

Okay, then I will move Brawley Amendment one that was distributed. Second

motion to amend by Ms. Brawley. Seconded by Mr. Volan, Ms. Brawley.

Yeah, thank you. This does two things in in amends three places. The first is it really recognized that the folks who would conduct this analysis, which is the assessor's office and others involved in that process are very busy in this spring. And so just ask them to indicate what the staff time and resources that would be needed to complete the full analysis, specifically in section three talks about having an initial report in 120 days from from passage of this. So ask for that. And then the second is it's important to remember that we can be looking forward as far as correcting misclassified exemptions. And then we can also look backwards. But the question should be separated whether we move forward with that or if we are able to collect taxes from prior years. So this wording it again it's minor, but it really clarifies and also I think helps set public expectations that we may or may not be able to really collect a lot of back taxes versus being able to correct it going forward. So really just making sure that that's clear. But I really appreciate the sponsors bringing this forward. I think it is a great idea and it is something that we should be regularly auditing. Thank

you. Anyone else? On the amendment?

Is there any objection to the amendment? Seeing you hearing no objection, we'll consider the amendment as adopted. Back on the main motion. Any wish to speak? Seeing hearing none, members may proceed to vote.

Mr. Chair, I was in the queue.

Oh, I'm sorry, Mr. Kirker. Go

ahead. Yeah, just a question to the sponsors. Did you guys talk to the administration of that timeline established in there realistic and feasible?

Yes. Yeah, and essentially that's why the timeline was they're very, very busy. The we just asked them to do a systemic review of property valuations as well. So kind of thinking of the timeline, we call for an initial report within 120 days, and that could be similar to what member Broadly described, a roadmap. Okay, thank you. Thank you.

Anyone else? Sure, none members may proceed to vote. Only vote of 12 to zero, and the youth member votes.

Unknown

Yes.

Yes. AR 2026-73 is amended as passed the body. Next we have item 10.B nine. Resolutionary 2026 unnumbered resolution of the Anchorage Assembly amending and supplementing the 2026 state legislative program to advance a strategic housing infrastructure investment initiative. This item was pulled by you, Ms. Brawley. Second.

Yeah, so I polled this briefly because I think there was some question or just wanting to understand what this is and what the list of properties is, so I would turn it to the sponsor, Mr. Constant.

Thank you. So I had heard requests from folks in the legislature and in the administration that the municipality needs to care be careful not to miss a potential opportunity if there is an oil Price spike windfall at the legislature that we had some additional projects in. And so one thing that we know we have is a policy set for housing as a priority for the municipality, and we also know we have a ton of stranded land that doesn't have infrastructure relating to it, that is a high cost element. And so if you look at the item it's in your packet, there are a number of properties listed, and each one is a potential location. The resolution as stated says that we would pick from this if the legislature funds at any level. I would like to ask Mr. Dole to come forward and can I just talk about the properties that got on there and kind of the logic behind it. I had started with just the top five properties. We talked about the totem property in East Anchorage, we talked about Powder Ridge, we talked about the Third Avenue and Ingra site. We talked about the archive site, which are large properties that have multi-million dollar costs associated with public infrastructure going in. But the administration when asked to slightly a different direction, Mr. Dole.

So the chair Bob Dole, Director of Community Economic Development. We looked at properties where the probably the biggest impediment to their development is the cost of putting in the inf off site infrastructure that goes with it. The water, the sewer, the roads, the utilities. And the to develop those properties, it is a big step, and it's frankly it's a step too far for many of them to economically develop. We identified those as examples. I'm sure there's more out there, but these are the sorts of properties that the this we would be able to go forward in accomplishing them our goal of 10,000 homes in 10 years with this funding. It does it's not a subsidy to actually building the house, but everything to get that lot ready so that's ready for a builder to build on

it. Thank you, Mr. Vaughn.

Thank you, Mr. Chair. Actually, Bob, since you're here if I could ask you a question as well. These properties, I mean, and this is this all These are all properties that could be catalyzed by putting in the infrastructure or needed utilities. This is all buildable

lands. These are all buildable lots, but for the cost of development, which is prohibit.

Great. Thank you. I appreciate Chair Constant bringing this forward and I think if I can I would request to be added as a sponsor to this one as well. Because I think it gets at the sort of the intent with where we were headed when you and I, Mr. Chair brought forward our short term rental tax proposal. I think this is is great to ask, you know I'm happy to take money from the state. I'm happy to take more state investment, yes. But I also think you know we've had sort of a talking point here in the municipality that gets more and more repeated that nobody is coming to save us. And so I really think we need to continue as a body to explore solutions for how we can invest as a locality in housing. And here's a great list of properties. Then Mr. Chair, you also pointed out to me that the last whereas does include these sort of key properties that we've talked a lot about. The Negra, downtown, the archive site in Midtown, Totem and East, others. So those go are also included along with the exhibit A for consideration is what I'm understanding by this so yeah, I hope we can make this ask, but I also hope that we can continue as a body to think carefully about how we can Consider raising our own revenues as a municipality because housing is much needed. Thank you. Ms. Baldon Day.

Yes. Thank you, Chair. I'm curious if what we're proposing here is an infrastructure bank in in which we are proposing to make to use this funding to actually make sub market loans to developers, or are we suggesting that we would be doing direct investment in developing the infrastructure that's needed and then the parcel being ready for

the So I can speak to that. When I initially started, I had those five major projects, Third and Ingro Archives, totem 100 that C Cars Gamble and Powder Edge. And the public infrastructure is the key here. We're talking about the roads, all of that stuff. And so we did not get to the level of talking about how we would implement would it be a bank repayable, would it be an investment fund. I think that if we're looking at resources kind of the one time dollars coming in, the question will be before the body and the appropriation when it's finalized, how that would be implemented. But all of those other projects were added because I think it does make sense to demonstrate broadly across the municipality the need. And then how it is implemented in its final would be between the assembly of the administration and the state.

Excellent. So we would we would see the sort of nuts and bolts come back before us in the event that we did, in fact, secure this funding from the state.

So I think that that would depend very much on how it is funded by the state, right? They are the ones ultimately who would have the ability to put structures and frames on it. We want it to be as general as possible. It may not be that number, it may be one fraction of that number. They may pick a project and say this is the one we like. They may say you get this much, and you can pick. So it really ultimately depends on what happens in the legislature, and then it comes to us in whatever form they send it as approved in the law. So we don't really control what they do. Thank you. That's helpful. Yeah. But anything that is appropriate to the assembly would or to the municipality would come to the assembly ultimately. So you will be involved in that part of the process. And again, we picked projects across every district. We are attempting to appeal very broadly to as many people as we can. And the number one thing we're trying to face in Anchorage other than the port, which is underway, is housing. So it just seemed like low hanging fruit. Ms. Briley.

Yeah, things. I would just briefly add, too. This is really going if it moves forward at all, it would be one line in the capital budget with some very broad intent language. And so I think that's what we're trying to square that. But more more would be to come to figure out how that money is prioritized, and then could also be added as a sponsor or co-sponsor. Thank

you. Thank you. You know, in the capital budget, when we have started kind of moving out the column that says state funded, which is money from heaven that's never coming. This is like that. So it it's not It's not all that likely, but it could happen. So and that it could happen is worth putting it out there. This is the year, if any. Okay. If there's no further discussion, then members may proceed to vote. On a vote of 12 to zero in the youth member votes.

Unknown

Yes.

Yes. Air 26-80, which is item 10.B.9 on this agenda has passed the body. That then takes us to item 10.D 24. I'm sorry, 10.D 20. It's at the bottom of the page. Don't see it. 10.D 20 is AM 210-2026, Chicacu River Advisory Board reappointment. This item was polled by you, Mr. Voland.

Thank you, Mr. Chair. I'm wondering, can I ask a question of the administration before I make my motion? Sure. This individual is currently running for Anchorage Assembly to represent Eagle River. So just on the timing piece, my thought is that it might be good to postpone this until the meeting of May 12. So we know what happens with that election. And we're not scrambling to find somebody else, or maybe we hold this one until after the election if this individual still wants to serve in that capacity. So thoughts on that from the

administration. Hello, Czan Fleet Green, office of Mayor LaFrants. My understanding is that if this individual gets elected to the assembly, then they would no longer be able to serve on this commission. So I would just say it's up to you as a body how you want to proceed. My understanding is that this reappointment is not needed, but I would have to call someone to confirm that, but it's not needed for quorum.

So it doesn't it's not a difficulty, then should we confirm this person tonight, and they have to step down to find somebody else. We can do that in a timely manner.

If this person has to step down after the election, then yes, we would quickly try and fill the vacancy.

Okay, so I think with that I would then I will move to approve.

Unknown

Second.

There's a motion to approve by Mr. Vaughan. Second by Mr. Girker. Anyone wish to speak to the item? None members may proceed to vote. a vote of 12 to zero and the youth member votes yes yes AM 210-2026 is passed the body okay now we have 10.D.24 10.D.24 is AM 192-2026 recommendation of award an indefinite of an indefinite delivery indefinite quantity contract to Alaska land clearing to provide hazard fuel mitigation services for the municipality of Anchorage. This item was pulled by you Ms. Brawley move to approved second move by Ms. Briley second by Mr. Bol and Ms.

Riley this is just making a correction that was flagged by our budget analysts so I'm gonna move a verbal amendment and that is on page one line eight in the memo to change the number 2 million to the number 3.5 million to match the actual body of the item

so there's a motion to amend it by Miss Bley is there a second second second by Mr. Bolin you want to speak to that Ms. Brawley

I think it speaks for itself

any further discussion on the amendment seeing hearing none I'd like to ask unanimous consent any objection to the amendment seeing hearing no objection the amendment is passed we're now back on the main motion as amended any further discussion seeing hearing none members may proceed to vote on a vote of 12 to zero and the youth member votes yes. AM 192-2026 is amended has passed the body then there's gonna be no motion on 10.D 25 or 26 those items will come back before you later there's item 10.F three is 10.D 45 off the bottom of the page again. Item 10.D 45 is assembly memorandum number AM 232-2026 recommendation of award of a sole source contract with Traffic Logic Corporation for the procurement of relocatable speed feedback signs and associated equipment from the municipality of Anchorage. This item was polled by you, Ms. Baldwin Day. Thank you, Chair. Move to approve.

Unknown

Second.

Move by Ms. Baldwin Day. Second by Mr. Johnson. Ms. Baldwin Day.

Yes, thank you. I skimmed but did not have a chance to do a deep read. I just want to confirm that the placement of these speed feedback signs is not limited to only municipal roads. If someone on the administration could speak to that, that would be

great. I can speak to that to the chair member Baldwin Day. Of the reasons that we're exploring this as an option is because as I think we've all discussed, you know, we have limited levers to pull in the architecture of some of our more dangerous roads because they're not controlled by the municipality. And so we do have other things we can control, including enforcement. And so this was part of that effort. We have offered to the state that we would be willing and interested in placing them on state roads. They've indicated that they're actually planning to order their own array of speed feedback signs as well. So we'll continue to collaborate with them to see if they're able to address areas that we're concerned about with resources that they've supported that will free up more resources for use elsewhere in the municipality, but our intent is to work with the state to place these where APD and traffic gauge would gauge them to be most effective in dealing with areas where we have problem driving, and some of those areas include state roads.

Thank you. Will the will the AMATs high speed crash network be factored into those decisions as well?

You do chair absolutely that. And also we have an assessment from APD of areas where they would specifically recommend this where they're seeing bad driver behavior. So we'll take the various those various inputs into account in considering where we place these.

Great. Thank you very much. Any further discussion? On a vote of 12 to zero in the youth member votes.

Unknown

Yes.

Yes, AM 232-2026 has passed the body, which now brings us to item 10.F three. Move to approve.

Unknown

Second.

Move by Ms. Move to accept. Yeah. Move by Ms. Riley, second by Ms. Ballon Day.

And I pulled this one on the chair's behalf. So Mr. Constant.

Thank you. So for members benefit to understand what this is. There have been some challenges in relationship to the 1991 fish and wildlife program. That are subject to current development of litigation and other matters. Because the municipality has been stripped of its authority to operate the hydropower utility, but it hasn't been stripped of its liability and responsibility to fund. And so we are in a very unique and precarious position where separate entities are kind of Given the authority to appropriate out of our budget, which is not good. And so the previous member that I worked with on the occlutin hydropower project put a hold on any appropriation from the Anchorage Hydropow to any part of the Fish and Wildlife program until such a time as a detailed capital improvement budget was presented to the assembly, not just a single line item in the budget that said we're going to spend this much, and we're not going to tell you on what. And so currently they have done that. And so the hold is in a position to be released by the acceptance of this AIM. But what I'm speaking to you about as members who are going to be here into the future is that you have a due diligence requirement to look closely at the Anchorage Hydropower budget as detail, because you are not in the control to no one in the municipality is in the control to set what those expenditures are at this time, and until litigation is concluded, or until 35 years have passed and we sell the utility and it's no longer on our books. And so you are now the stewards of the question of fiscal stewardship of the trust of the people on these projects. And so when you see an Anchorage Hydropower budget, I ask you to please look closely and make sure that the expenses proposed, the amounts being requested makes sense because you are the only check on third party entities having a hold on our budget. So I'm just offering you my caution and be careful. But they have complied for this year. And going forward, it's up to you to hold them to their compliance. That's why I pulled this one. So if there's nothing else, then members may proceed to vote. On a vote of 12 to zero in the youth member votes.

Unknown

Yes.

Yes, AIM 35-2026 has been accepted. So that concludes the business on our consent agenda, Mr. Gurker.

Mr. Chair, I move to change the order of the day. Take up items 13.A and 13.B after 14.E. That allows us to take up item 14.A sooner, right after the dinner break. So all the folks here to testify an AST's budget can get home in a decent hour and put the kids to bed. Second.

So that was a motion to change the order to day was 14 13.A and B after 14 what? Okay. 14.E. So there's a motion to change the order of the day to take up items 13.A and B after 14.E, which functionally means we would take up the AST budget just after our break. So and the motion was made by Mr. Gurker, seconded by Ms. Brawley. Is there any discussion on the motion? I'd like to ask unanimous consent. Is there any objection to the motion? I'm seeing here no objection. So what that means to the public the order of the day has been changed. The next item we'll take up is the school district budget. So we'll be back in just a little bit of time as we take our regularly scheduled break.

Is it just me? Don't let them take the shine, don't let them steal your mind. Oh me. Say if they owe you money. I want me to be so then. Don't let these homes sing. Nobody else fall Think I did something bad I did something bad Never question Say if they owe me money If they owe me something Let's go bad and say I'm not very lucky If they owe me something Let's go back in the own scares But it's all a rose I always go I wake up and begin to choose a door Don't let them take a shine Don't let them steal your mind Way Say if they owe you money I won't need a man Oh yeah Just a little in a thing Don't let these woman stay for my six nobody else

Sometimes the world

moves too quickly, and I know It's not like the earth is turning slowly gone, but we both know I can sleep alone or at least a while It doesn't hope Even though I know Where I'm gonna go That you take me I nobody Stays mad me Oh Which way in your eyes But don't calm down the wood Sometimes the world moves too quickly, and no it's not like this mad meet you take me seriously Too good, it'll do good, and all do good, too good, it'll do good, and all do good, too good, it'll do good, all do good Such a leg through the shade for co us what do I care what this work What do I care Tell you to just simply w What you can do somehow you can have a cry. Turning fast With no sign of slowing down And the birds like now get the town The skies are clear and blue With the coas in the year You are the love all night So with something that's wrong to wear And the midnight sun is gone away with the falls to show to sing ones of the time I Snow is quiet with no one but your voice is singing loud So sing away so all can you So the last can all be found And the midnight sun is gone away with the fall colours to show to think on never time Lightning strikes and diamonds A bloody stone a door mind A morning wasted on trivial An evening wasted on primitive things around here Everybody knows everybody The past lives document it to the closest topic And what song does the conversation starting out save us a good life Think God that you can Always got Uncles Thank God you came Thank God you came Thank God you can We won We won't think I'm now we working for the past But the whole damn house on you miss the praise God spell 15 work on your miss A place of chasing what you want When you want if you want till it's up and does Beans burning in the clubs of fire Please no chase in peace I must scream But honestly I feel the breach We are And the life you change the face you've made is this the life you made for me. Think God that you can always got on seem ready to save us. Think God you came, think God came, think God you came. Always a good guest, come and save us. Always got on some ready to save us. Think God came, think God you came, think God used to feel the love. Highway the fill of some space the moon's only pretty far away she only wants me so keep his boys so the same Maybe I can find me here Just you know, I'm gonna be up peaches with a little bit of chart. Scoop and make it quite fun. Just my elbow and kisses the glass. Just like it took you out too much to say. Why don't you go visit the summer time because it's you took all those freckles in the water Why don't you still sit down sea Go get yourself some love why don't you follow the game peaches, square peaches, are you taser Sweetness, sweetness You've been like Square Peachy, Square Peaches, are you Sweetness, sweetness, I'm suspicious when you misses I'm a miss You will never find a bitch until you go change your mind Go things for fun and know that the boats I let You say some love and you follow the kids are you beasts in your life on the beaches are you suspicious when you say so fresh from Palm trees ready made good fine Cause you was on your own time coming Don't stop running Burning the leaves in the back yard summers Flowers and a breeze keep wanted me Tired of the breeze get wanted me Seconds from the least hard tree Too scared to breeze freedom Me Too scared to see Too scared to Alright,

everybody, sorry that took so

long. We'll come back to order now. And since nobody

now and take up item 14.A. 14.A is AO 2026-21. An ordinance determining and approving the total amount of the annual operating budget of the Anchorage School District for its fiscal year, 2026-27, and determining and appropriating the portion of the assembly approved budget amount to be made available from local sources. There's also a substitute version. Public hearing on this item is now open. Welcome, please come forward and line up if you're gonna testify. Members of the public will have three minutes. So welcome, please state your name and what part of town you're from. The microphone is off, so if you hit the green button, it'll go on. There's a green button. There you go, you're on. So welcome, please take your name, what part of town you're from, you'll have three minutes.

Thank you, members of the board. Members of the assembly, excuse me. Mayor La France. Twenty-eight years in Alaska. 24 here in Anchorage. My family lives next to the Campbell STE campus, and I'm the luckiest father of two amazing kids that I'm proud are as part of ASD. I'm proud they walked to school in a safe neighborhood. I'm testifying tonight because I believe that we want the same things, that we're allies, actually, in raising strong future Alaskans, and that we actually really, really care about people staying here in Anchorage and in Alaska. All of us community members are here tonight with a big ask. We ask you to do what you must to save Campbell. I'm here to ask something, a second big ask. Ask why. Ask why this school. Tonight is the night that the Anchorage School Board has to answer to the public on the record. The members of the public have asked multiple times why and how they chose to close Campbell. The school board has dodged this question. Then their numbers haven't added on up. I believe that our kids in our community have a right to this answer. And this question is vital to my children and to my community. Campbell is a neighborhood of homes for first-time home builders. It's economically and socially all mixed up together. Campbell struggled for many years. It was titled by the federal definition, and the school reflected that. In 2016, the school's kids, teachers, and leadership started to work together, building up the school through STEM. This is the Alaska experience. We pull ourselves up. And it required a ton of work. They did that by gr renovating a local park. And today the neighborhood is a safe walking neighborhood with a school in its center and its heart. I'd love to tell you a lot more about what the school is like. Where they integrate special education kids, where it's a desirable lottery in school where people really want to be there. And so people moved into this neighborhood. I can tell you the home next to me, the family is moving, and their daughter is now working for her masters with working in medicine with CRISPR. The house across the street has was closed, sorry, was moving, and the family backed out during the 24 hour probationary period. All of this is because of the uncertainty and unlike other schools, Campbell stems to be dispersed. It's supposed to be ripped up into three separate schools and scattered about. The teachers are supposed to go to other schools. And that's destroying 10 years and the safe community that we've all worked together built together. Please tonight please tonight ask the hard questions. Get the answers. This will restore trust in ASD. Thank you.

Thank you. Welcome please take your name on part of Tony from you'll have three minutes.

Thank you. Thank you so much. My name is Melly Roche and I live in District Three. Thank you to the assembly members who have spoken with me. I know I've emailed and talked to a few of you. I'm here to advocate for Campbell STEM. I moved here three years ago. I've got three kiddos two of whom are in Campbell STEM and one hopefully will also be going to there in a couple of years. I moved here with my husband and I like to think we're kind of what you guys are looking to recruit. So congratulations you got us two people who can work and three kids who are ready to engage. My oldest son has high functioning autism he is included in his classroom he is supported in ways that are amazing. He wanted me to tell you because I told him I'd be speaking and he said please let them know that all of my friends are going to a different school and I will never have any friends again. A little hyperbole but for him it's a big deal because it took him two years to make those friends. I mean even for adults anyways we moved here and I have been so grateful to be here and to be part of the community I wanted to just pack my bags on the day that the vote went through I went from thinking, I voted for this school in a bond, they're gonna improve it, they've already fixed the front, they're gonna do some more things. This is a STEM school, they got their accreditation. Dr. Witt is amazing. All signs point to this being something that Anchorage should be so proud to have. I see the kids walking to school, it's amazing. I feel safe, I feel welcome. All these things that I know you guys are putting so much effort into building, and I'm so grateful for that. Warning. My co-worker texted me. I'm so sorry about your school. I was like, What do you mean? Why oh, oh, you're gonna close my school with no warning. 11 days later, they voted. And what I heard from the school board and the assembly, not the assembly, you guys, the other people, the school board people. What I heard from that administration was, well we had to pick something, and all schools are a special, you'll get over it. I didn't sleep very well that night because that didn't sit well with me. I work with budgets, I understand deficits. I could explain that to my kiddos, hey, flat funding, prices. Like it's very basic. We'll get into the deta later. I understand that this is a state funding issue. I get that, and I am advocating and I am calling. The timeline though doesn't add up. We want the state to fix this. I agree. I'm sorry, but you can't make government move that fast. This school cannot be reopened. You can add sports, you can add other programs, but you can't save this school once it closes. So whatever you can do, whatever clarity you can get for us, I would appreciate it. Thank you so much for your work.

Thank you. Welcome, please state your name. What part of town you're from? You'll have three minutes.

Good evening. My name's Mike Nealed. A few of you were at Friday's meeting and listened to me before. I'm sorry you have to see my face again. We're getting tired of it. But a couple of things I wanted to talk about for Campbell's stamp is in comparison with the other three schools that we're going into our third grade English language arts proficiency scores are leaps and bounds higher. We're 46% higher than one of the schools, 113% higher than another, and 158% higher than one more in addition to that one, our academic growth over the last year is on the same metric, 600 and 9% higher than one of these schools, 600 and 41% higher than another, and 800 and 32% higher than the third. It's not acceptable to a parent that they have to send their kids to lower schools for what reason. We haven't been given a reason. Every reason that that's been brought up could easily be refuted. Of the concerns are you know, we're asking for another bond, another levy from the people. At the same time, Campbell's already on last year's levy. If we're not doing what we said we would do, or if the school board is not doing what they said they would do, no, how are people going to fund them again further? You know, we have a chance to back this up and we have a chance to save save face. I mean, I think it gives them an easy out. My suggestion is in in doing your job, where we're looking at section six point oh five of the budget. Part one of that demonstrates how they come about their budget. This the superintendent's going to give a budget to the district, they're gonna have public hearing. Our public hearing was combined with other cuts with nursing with activities. Then it gets a vote, it comes up to you. You can raise as a whole, lower as a whole, except or deny. Anything is gonna help us buy us more time. I mean, try and hear what we're saying and represent us. You can lower by one penny. And that sends it back to the drawing board and buys us additional time to have these conversations. Earlier today, the state finance committee said that they're planning on including another hundred and $58 million for a one time BSA increase in the event that a permanent BSA increase does not pass. That that would be half of the budget shortfall Anchor School District has. So do what you can, please buy us some time and just send it back to the drawing board. It doesn't take much. A penny, a dollar, $10, it doesn't actually even change the budget. The next portion of that, section C, if you don't come back, that's when it shall be passed and will become law if you do nothing. So you do have a chance now, and I implore you to do what you can for us. Thank

you. Thank you. Welcome. Please state your name what part of town you're from, you'll have three minutes.

I made this for the school board members. But I'm leading it to you because I really wanted to testify. And I just wanna share it with you. Hello, my name is Hannah Winger. I'm seven and second grade at Campbell STEM. I love all my classmates and teachers and can't wait for another year of Campbell STEM. But if you close my school, it will not happen. And I will and it will change my life. I will not have the teachers I hope for, and many and many and may not have the friends that would be helpful in my learning. It in my school I like that my music teacher teaches us music and different dances every music class. I like that they give different grades pots of stem and make it fun. I like my gym and the many games that like Ninja Course and that when we get to go outside my gym teacher coaching that teaches us how to cross country ski kick sled and also ice skate. I like the people in the school that come and tell us about the Alaska native culture and their knowledge. I'm my favorite subject. Ignite is my favorite subject in school. I was first told I could be part of Ignite on the very same day you voted to closing night in Campbell. My backyard is part of the school grounds and I can go there all by myself by walking. I play there on the playground during the breaks. It is a safe and fun place for me and other kids. This is in the heart of the neighborhood and very important to it. I like the Campbell made its very own different puck and opened it to public. It's called Louine Puck and has a little free library. Please help me save Campbell stem.

Thank you. Welcome. Please state your name. Well, part of Please We ask folks not to clap when there's public testimony going on. Please say your name will part of Turn from you'll have three minutes. My

name is Carmen Wenger, and I live in the Taco Campbell neighborhood. I was born in Anchorage in the 80s, and I'm here today with concerns about the closure of Campbell's STEM. Today will focus on process, as I understand there is a limited amount that can be done by the assembly on budget, but I do believe you are in a position to get answers the school board will not give families. I will be sharing these from four perspectives. As a parent, I am concerned about the lack of notice or participation and the amount of information about our school that has appeared to be new to school board members even after the rush decision to close. All of this could have been available if community engagement had taken place, or even if we had reasonable amount of time and available an ability to address the board before a vote. As a community member, I am concerned about an uncertain future of a highly utilized public resource. Our house backs into the playground at Campbell STEM, and something we immediately noticed and have been so thankful for over the past 10 years is how constantly utilized the school grounds and building are. They are a hub for our community and create a safe, connected neighborhood that people move to raise their kids for. The lack of information about process, timeline, or future of the school building and grounds has created anxiety and rumors, and we already have neighbors telling us they are moving. As a property owner and taxpayer, I'm concerned about the use of school bonds that were voted on by the people of Anchorage with a specific intent and the appearance of a high performing neighborhood school with a specialized program serving a diverse community, being targeted so bond funds can be reappropriated. Additionally, as an advocate, I'm concerned that this undercuts our ability to successfully advocate the state for the additional funding that we truly need. It is not in dispute that our schools are being starved by the state. Legislators are concerned about not having the workforce to support the current or future industries for Alaska. We are a STEM state and we need a strong STEM workforce to thrive. To honestly advocate for more funding, we need to show the numbers of what has been lost to inflation, yes. But we also need to show the innovation that will solve our state's problems, such as building a war horse for tomorrow. Programs like Campbell STEM. When I introduced myself, I said I was born in Anchorage. Unfortunately, I didn't get the chance to be raised in Anchorage. When the economy tanked in the 80s, my geologist parents were laid off from their jobs and couldn't find work. I was raised on the stories of the childhood I could have had. I moved back to Anchorage to start the life I missed out on as a child. And I now fear for my children having the same experience of professional parents who had to make the hard choice to leave because they can't make a future they want for their kids' work. I want to raise my kids here, but every day is feeling harder to envision that future. We are asking, we are looking to you to help be part of that solution. Please request the information we are not getting from the school board about prioritization of schools for consolidation. Help us understand how to reassure our citizens that a school getting a bond is not targeted for closure. Stand up for the future needs of our city, and please allow the he not allow the PC closures

centers. Thank you. Welcome. Please take your name a part of Telling you from You'll have three minutes.

My name is Sylinda Brooks. I urge each assembly member to vote no on this ordinance. It may only be symbolic, but symbolism matters. What kind of community do we want to live in? How highly do we value adequate public notice and open civic engagement? For those unfamiliar, Campbell STEM is the only nationally certified science, technology, engineering and math elementary school in Alaska. As test scores are improving notably, the building is utilized. Daily school attendance is at 90%. The school is slated to receive a 1.5 million grant. Campbell's Dem was not one of the 10 schools identified in 2024 for possible closure after systemic review of all schools using a cross-the-board criteria. Campbell is an older school, but voters approved 2025 bomb package with 11.5 million to address Campbell's maintenance needs. Also, the school roof was replaced in 2024. Yes, just two years ago. Campbell has maintenance issues, but its situation is similar to many other schools. Putting the puzzle pieces together, it appears that Campbell STERT rose to the top of the closure list because of some old state school bond debt reimbursement monies tied to Campbell that could be moved to support staff salaries in sports, but only if ASD Premier closed the school, despite the school's success. The Campbell community learned about possible closure on Friday, February 13 at 4:21 p.m. when ASD sent an email. Yes, the email arrived after school had closed for the day. It also arrived a day after the Taku Campbell Community Council meeting. Following the Frida email was a three-day weekend with president's day on Monday. Tuesday was the sole opportunity for public testimony. Scant time to learn about the closure, let alone to organized and prepare testimony on such an important issue. After ASD voted to close, volunteers started knocking on doors to inform neighbors. Residents without school age children had never gotten the email, nor did parents expecting their five year old kids to start kindergarten. Campbell at the Pat Tacu Campbell community council meeting on March 12, the council passed a unanimous resolution opposing closure. The community continues organizing, connecting, and advocating against closure at every opportunity. We ask you to vote no on the ordinance to let us know that you're committed to adequate public notice, transparency, and processes that allow for meaningful public participation to provide decision makers with more knowledge and understanding before voting on such a complex and important decision to close the school. It's a school that is the nucleus of the neighborhood, central to the social fabric of the neighborhood.

Welcome, please state your name. What part of town you're from? You'll have three

minutes. By Julake. I work at Campbell STEM. Can you pull that microphone down? Our community was blindsided. We were never on the short list of schools brought before the board for a closure vote. It was made very clear by Jim Anderson in the early discussions about right sizing that the Anchorage community was not in favor of closing special schools like charter and alternative programs. They still aren't. So then why was Campbell STEM chosen for closure? $2.2 million of fungible money. However, as stated by Jim Anderson in the February 24th meeting, that money is fungible. It's always been fungible and still is. So then use the $2.2 million for what you need it for. Don't replace it in your budget. Would that decrease the amount of money in the Campbell budget capital budget to repair Campbell STEM? Yes. But I guarantee you that these students are much more interested in a STEM education than than the Anchorage community is interested in another shiny, fully remodeled building like Inlet View. Our kids don't care about new furniture or an updated parking lot plan. They want STEM education. If the school board continues to use the $2.2 million how it's currently out allotted in the budget, then they don't have to find it somewhere else. That leaves $80,000 to be found in the budget to keep Campbell STEM open. $260,000 of that is found by not having to add two new bus routes to transport our students to other locations. So we're down to $540,000, which could be found by temporarily reducing the middle school or nursing FTE that was added back by five positions until further funding is received. Why dismantle an amazing program that aligns perfectly with district goals and desired educational growth that took an entire school almost a decade to build for a gain of five FTE they know will be later funded. You have said that the municipality has funded the district at max capability. I now ask that this body would reduce the amount of the Anchorage School District's budget by the minimum amount that would warrant it being sent back to the Anchorage School Board and adding that amount back at a later date, if appropriate, give the school board the time to learn more and do what's right. In her 2021 campaign, Dora Wilson said there's more work to be done in providing pathways to the many opportunities in the vast number of career options like skilled trades, vocational technology, and apprenticeship. It is important to educate students about these pathways at an earlier age. The earlier students are exposed to a variety of career fields, the more relevant subjects become. We do this at Campbell STEM. Kelly Lessons authored an article in the Anchorage Daily News published March 29, 2024, on the topic of lottery and school choice, stating one of the most important services an elected official can render is to ask questions that respond to community interest and whose answers can potentially improve a policy or practice. To that end, I must ask, while closing schools and using capacity as a factor, is the school board aware that neighborhood schools, no matter how you're

be

gonna

able to do that. I am gonna pause the public hearing right now and I'm gonna read our rules of order. This is a business meeting, and we're here to do the work of the municipality. Please help to create a climate of respect in the chambers. Refrain from personal attacks, speaking out of turn, shouting, clapping, snapping, pacing, etcetera. Please keep your signs eight and a half by 11 inches or smaller. Please keep the aisles clear, except when lined up to testify. Please do not approach the diocese. If you have information to share, please hand it to the clerk. Please stop speaking if a point of order is called. So I may rule on the point of order. If rules are not followed, I may interrupt speakers to call for compliance. If compliance with the rules does not occur, then I may pause the meeting. If there's an actual disruption, I'll give a warning. If the disruption persists or happens again, the person will be asked to leave. I didn't read it earlier today. Three years. And I just say that because it's distracting for us to hear stuff when we're here. We're trying to hear the speaker, not all of the stuff on the side. So please respect the speaker by providing a venue where the speaker can be heard. So please come forward. Please state your name, what part of town you're from. You'll have three minutes. If you're making a presentation, it's a little less disruptive than if you're in the audience waving signs and yeah. So please state your name and what part of town you're from. You'll have three minutes. It's on. It's off now. Go ahead. Good evening. Good evening,

and Rob just one second. Mr. Cherry let her time add to his time.

We don't do that. No, but we could probably let her go if she wants to. We could even sit for three minutes waiting for her. I could go any number of different ways, but we don't

add time. Is there is there any way we could make an exception? I mean, this is obviously a very intimidating environment.

Yeah, I think she can get it. Okay. Welcome.

Good evening, Anchor D assembly members. My name is Ila. I live in Spinard. I just did a science project at Campbell's stem. That's why I don't want you to close it. Help me learn so much. We wondered what were dissolved skills the fastest. Apple show vinegar and oil. We timed them all to see which dissolves the skills the fastest. I predicted the apple side vinegar. Which one do you think would solve the fastest? If you think water. My hypothesis was applesed or vinegar. So we test it. We discover flora dissolved scales the fastest. We learned something new. These are the kind of things I learned. Why I don't want Campbellstone to close. I will never be able to make friends with anyone in my class again. And I will never be able to see my friend teachers again. I can tell that all the other students just down that Campbell stem is closed. And you can even hear their sadness in my voice. Thank

you. Welcome, please state your name on part of Town or from you'll have three

minutes. I'm ready if you are. Campbell STEM is an incredible place. So a few people in power. Have come to experience what Campbell STEM is. Instead, we have brought Campbell STEM to you. This particular exhibit makes me smile. It answers a question we have often wondered in our house. Which is bath bombs. Which bath bomb fizzes the fastest? The procedure was to fill up the container with water and drop bath bomb in the container and start stopwatch as soon as it drops in. So we have used the scientific method to determine which one goes to fizzes the fastest, and also tested our hypotheses and assumptions. And this we will probably be using these results at home. I understand the strain we as are under as a city and as a state, the process is challenging. It is done with incomplete information and must be done by a time that predates when June will have completed their decision. Nevertheless, closing Campbell's STEM is the wrong school to close. Mechanisms exist to provide more time. Increasing the budget is not an option. However, there is no cap on transportation, bonds, or extracurriculars. The Muni often uses bonds to provide additional funding. I would ask that you allocate additional funds for transportation or extracurriculars. That will allow the ASD administration to allocate additional monies to fund Campbell's STEM. Alternately, since you can't increase the budget, I ask that you decrease the budget by $100. So that ASD has to go back to the drawing board and provide more time for alternatives to closure to be explored. I have more, but everyone has already said it or said it better. I think I'm going to finish. There's a pivotal scene at the end of Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix, where the kids are in the hall of mysteries and they get trapped by the death eaters. And it looks like everything is without hope. And then the grown-ups show up and they save the kids. Y'all are the grown-ups in Anchorage. We need you all to show up and save our kids at Gamble Sdem. Thank you very

much. Thank you. Welcome. Please state your name. What part of town you're from? You'll have three minutes. Thank you. Good evening.

Put this mic down a little bit. Assembly members and Madame Mir and community members. My name's Amanda Thompson. I'm in the Turnigan Community Council. I'm an ASD art teacher, and I'm speaking tonight on my own behalf. So I'm a third generation Anchorage citizen, and I just thank everyone for their service, really, and paying attention to these education matters tonight. And thank you also for what a joy it was to hear the rabbi speak about education tonight. I couldn't have timed it better. That soul string encouragement and really what our highest priorities should be in education. So I ask you, even if it's just a symbolic vote, to vote down this school district budget just to give a strong message to what our city priorities really are, because they are not reflected in this budget. I had a totally different testimony prepared, but I just thought that commenterative speech just moves me so much. I really started thinking about education as generative, education is moral, education is spiritual, education is compassionate. We really can unite against those. And even if the only thing that unites us in Anchorage, right? Maybe our zip codes. Maybe it's just our property tax burden. If the even if that's the bare minimum, how we need to be united around these education principles, you're hearing teachers and parents talk about and students talk about tonight. This budget is really short sighted. Closing Campbell is not going to solve long term fiscal, fiscal realities. These parents have really gardened this amazing school for their young children, just for me as a educator looking in. It's really rare for me to see such a high standing neighborhood program. And I'm just so encouraged by that. How are they doing this? They're doing this by doing hands-on, measuring hands-on things, things that right Chromebook time can't buy, things that consultants can't sell you. These are all amazing skills are really making a difference for art and design education. All the things that create a problem solvers know. You guys are tackling the city's problems every week. Thank you so much for your time in doing that. These kids are learning those creative problem solvers that can help you, that can be your right, be those youth representatives here to be your staffers who can help solve those problems. I'm speaking up as an art and design teacher just because I see that these programmatic cuts that not just because of budget was, right? These are really seem to be targeted. Why is art being cut? Why is ignite being cut? Why is STEM being cut? Why are these things that create good problem solvers being cut? I need we need to on the assembly. We need the mayor to speak up, ask the district these, so we can get answers about why those things are happening. I'm really testifying here. Just I want to be home with my children. They're doing creative projects right now. Just ask for your help in this as we move forward as a community. Thank you.

Thank you. Welcome. Please tell your name up where the town you're from. You'll have three minutes.

Thank you. Good evening. I'm Cal Williams. I live in Airport Heights. I have watched children go past my house to the left, Airport Heights Elementary. And I've watched children go. In the opposite direction to Benny Davis East Anchorage High School for some long time since 1980 when I first moved into that house. Our children, you've heard a million times our future. First time I testified before this group mostly men were there and they were not listening. I was appealing for a stop sign at the corner of ninth and carlock for children who were playing in the street. A lady who I grew up to dearly love. Lia Silcraig said Mr. Chairman, look at the children. These were pictures of children playing in the street. And I ask you tonight to open your hearts and open your minds and look at the children. Give them what they need, and they in turn will give us what we need. As we grow old, they will use their wisdom to take care of us. So each one teach one, each one reach for one, and I ask you again to give the school district what our children need.

Thank you. Welcome. Please state your name. What part of town you're from? You'll have three minutes.

Hello, my name is Juliana Ballou. I'm here because I live in in I live on Levina Street, which is about two blocks away from Camelstem Elementary. I walk there every single morning. First of all, I love this school. It is my favorite school in the entire world. I have been at Campbellstone five years. And I've loved every second of each day. is one of the only gym teachers in ASD that has an arcade doing gym. It is super fun. He brings in video games from home and lets us play as an incentive for being good. And almost every single person at Campbell STE has been good all year. So if our school closes then that we will not have the opportunity to have fun events like this. Also our school is the only stem certified school in the state of Alaska. So please don't school please don't sc please don't close it, because if you close it then there won't be a s certified STEM school in Alaska and to me that is very important. Also our teachers are very interactive and funny. They make us laugh and we play games at Wees and if our school closes we'll have to go to different schools far away from all our friends. I have a lot of neighborhood friends, but a lot of them have moved here from other places just so they can come to the school. I know people that that came here came to our neighborhood just because there was a good school here and if you close it people won't want to move into our neighborhood I'll probably lose friends and other people that I love. So please don't close our school. Please help it stay alive. Thank you.

Thank you. Welcome. Please state your name and what part of town you're from that's fine. You'll have three minutes.

Hello, my name is Gina Winger, and I my background back into Campbellstem Elementary is grand. I love Hello School because of all the special programs I go to, like Ignite and the gym program, as my best friend Julian just stated. As she said, it is the only stem certified school in the entire state, and we love all the stem activity we do. Right now, currently in our class, we are working on a roller coaster and see if to see if the mob and the cardboard can go 10 feet. I love all the more of other activities we have done, like Ignite, where we're making another paper roller coaster. It's extremely fun. We take we take the paper, we fold it, and we concentrate on every second of it. All of our students have learned extremely a lot from everything they do in Campbellstem. Some families I've heard of a family that was moving to this neighborhood just to do Campbellstem when they heard that it was voted for closure, and then in 24 hours they cancel the move. Please please move to keep Campbellstem Elementary open. Thank you.

Thank you. Welcome. Please state your name, what part of town you're from. Maybe lift that mic up. We all have three minutes.

Great. Thank you. My name is Jackie Bellew. I live on Rovina Street, just two blocks down from Campbell Elementary. Coming tonight because we're asking for your help to save our school or at least slow it down so we can understand more. I feel the school district made a hasty decision with the budget. Umly 11 days from you know pulling our name up and putting it on the list and deciding it was time to close us down. I can't imagine making a huge decision like that in 11 days. We still haven't gotten the information as to why. So I know at the joint assembly and school board meeting last week, members asked for this information. It still wasn't given to you. So we're asking for your help with that. Just thinking about 11 days, we bought our house in 2011. And my son went to kindergarten at Campbell in 2018. So we made that decision seven years before he was even ready for school. That's how much we thought about the school. We wanted a good school that was nearby that had before and after school care that felt science, technology, and math were important. And it was nearby, so we could build a community. And we've built a huge community. In 2020, we wanted to expand our house. So we bought the one across the street. We didn't move it anywhere else, even though there's beautiful homes in so many parts of the town. We stayed right here on our block because of our community and our school. So I'm asking for your help. Help us stand up, help us ask questions, and really get answers so that we can make a decision that doesn't just last four years when this money runs out, but let's make a decision that will last for decades. Thank you.

Thank you. Welcome, please state your name. What part of town you're from? You'll have three minutes.

My name is Katrina Wolkoff. I am a resident in Campbellstem neighborhood area, as well as the preschool special needs education teacher. One of seven preschool classrooms at Campbell STEM, six of which are SPED classrooms. As a teacher, of course, wherever I am placed, because SPED is not always guaranteed at a school, I'm going to do my job, which is create an inclusive classroom where my students get the best experience. And Campbell STEM has given my students the best experience. For our kids, they all have their little nerd moments. They have something that draws them to learning. Maybe they love comic books. You know, we got Cat the Kid. If you're old, Captain Underpants. We have things that draw us. For four and five year olds, dinosaurs are still all the rage. And what we do in preschool is we get to take those interests and we get to expand upon those. So we became paleontologists in preschool. My students got to learn about what paleontologists do. They got to work hard digging up and creating their own fossils. They gotta learn the names of different dinosaurs, and half my students aren't even verbal. But if you ask them which picture was a pachyocephalosaurus, they'll point it out real fast. Campbell STEM helped my students have that inclusive moment where they're welcome in all areas of the school. My students are four and five. They have a wide variety of special needs from autism. We have some students that are wheelchair bound. We walk to the cafeteria. My students get to eat with all of the kindergarten through third graders in the cafeteria. My students are given the opportunity to go to science fair events, participate with the support of the fourth and fifth graders who help them build their dinosaur model for an outhouse race. Our goal in life is always to support our future, whether we're teachers, whether we're supporting our community in other ways. And by supporting our students, we need to be making sure that we are providing them the opportunity to learn in an environment that welcomes them and drives them to learn more. Alaska, we need our sciences. We need more engineers. We need more people who are out there looking in the field, learning about our earth, learning about the oil, because that's where our funds come from. If we're not supporting STEM schools and we are closing schools that support that type of learning, we're not supporting the future the way we should be.

Thank you. Welcome. Please state your name and what part of town you're from. You'll have three minutes. It's on. Oh you just turned it off. There you go.

Hi, my name is Rondell Venner. I live in the Taco Campbell community area. And I'm here to ask you to vote no on this ordinance. My child attends Campbell STEM. I've worked very hard to move into this neighborhood because I didn't want her to struggle to be lotteried in to the school and learning more about the lottery process. It's not a promise process. So I worked hard to find residency in this neighborhood, so she can be a permanent student at the school. My child excels when she studies STEM curriculum. I understand that there's a deficit. I understand that things have to. There has to be cuts somewhere. Understand that your job is very hard. But I ask that you take a breath and you slow down your process. 11 days is not an acceptable time frame for anything, for any news, for anybody, let alone a whole school community that has come together. I've been in the outskirts of this community through parents and friends. And to be in the school now for a year and a half, and my child was below grade level in academics and has now excelled and is performing at grade level because of the teachers at the school cared for her and didn't allow her to fall through the cracks and gave me the support that I needed as a parent to ensure that she exceled. I'm not saying that not all teachers care. And I'm not saying that all schools are not good, but this school took the priority and made sure that my kid came up and gave me the resources to ensure that she could. I don't want to see that go away because of an 11 day process. I don't want that to go away. And I don't want that to be eliminated because there are ordinances that say this must be done in this time frame. Yes, there's a budget. But I ask you, can you please do something as the assembly to slow down the process and give us transparency as a community. Give us options as a community. We've come together. And I've involved myself when I found out how to get advocacy and how to involve myself in the civics process. And so I ask that you vote no on this ordinance today to give us time and transparency for this community that has been built and is solid. Thank you for your time.

Thank you. Welcome, please state your name. You'll have three minutes.

Hi there, my name is Jordan Wood. I live in South Anchorage. That means that we were lotteried into Campbell's Dem. We were fortunate enough to be one of the very, very few families that were lotteried in in the fall of last year of this school year. On that note, March 29, 2024, Kelly Lessons authored an article in the Anchorage Daily News on the topic of lottery and school choice, stating one of the most important services an elected official can render is to ask questions that respond to community interest and who answer questions, who answers can potentially improve a policy or practice. To that end, I must ask, while closing schools and using capacity as a factor, is the school board aware that neighborhood schools, no matter how underutilized, can only add students in the fall, not in spring, when charter schools and optional programs can. Are they aware that as an alternative program, Campbell STEM has never been allowed to open our lottery in the spring like other alternative programs do? And that even when we add students in the fall, it isn't to a certain certain percentage of building capacity, but to a teacher count assigned to us by district and administration. Would the district use Northern Lights, Bowman, Denali, or Rilka's programs as a pawn to play chicken with the state? Or did they just think our 65% economically disadvantaged population consisting of 68% ethnically diverse students, 38% of whom are indigenous wouldn't fight for their education for our parents, staff, And students to have shown up to advocate for students' education only to have been met with disdain, contempt, and eye rolling by many members of the school board has been quite sad to see and utterly disappointing. Isn't advocating for student educational opportunities supposed to be what they do? Thank you.

Thank you. If you're gonna testify, please let him come forward. Welcome, please take your name a part of time from you'll have three minutes. My

name is Brian Burke, and I am a counselor with the school district. I've been with the district for many, many years. I could retire, but I haven't. My wife is also a teacher, and both of our kids that are are products of the Yanch school district are very successful as young adults. And we appreciate the education that they have gotten. This is a great district, except when it comes to funding. Extremely important for schools, and especially in this case of Campbell STEM. As far as I'm concerned, it's a crit Campbell's STEM is a critical growth stepping stone for our continued science education in the community. And the state of Alaska. The problem is over, I think lack of money. It's time to look for also other sources of funding to keep our STEM school. And to fund more schools, test scores will continue to rise. I propose that our commun community seek out grants. Donors, foundations, corporations, government entities that can invest in the future of our children's education, especially in the sciences. Writing letters of inquiry for funding to organizations and people such as Elon Musk, Senator Sullivan, Mikowski, Governor Dunlevey, Hill Corp, and other corporations that are, you know Alaska could be very, very beneficial to assisting with the lack of funding. We are the only STEM school in Alaska. And I think it's really important to save our STEM school. We're still in an expert experimental stage, especially at the level of elementary, but it's really, really a great experience, and the kids are really doing well. Thank you.

Thank you. Anyone else wish to be heard of the question? Welcome, please say your name what part of town you're from. You'll have three minutes.

All right. So it's moved pretty much by all the testimony today from the speakers young gold. Well not be as good as order, Mr. Cal Williams, but you know, save our schools. STEM is the future, whether it's AI or engineering, or any of the other professions that are going to be around for a very long time. And if you cut that, you're cutting the future from this community from other communities. Get into China and how they've properly funded their schools. But you have a tough decision. And so the question is, do you want to Have a motion maybe to have a continuation of the public hearing. Well somebody revisits potential funding opportunities and streams or cutting other programs to sort of save this one. Leadership is doing the difficult thing in the face of adversity, whether it's politically unpopular or you know you just don't have the money, but you find a way, and then you hopefully fix it for the next time. So that's sort of all I have to say today. Maybe you want to continue the public hearing and revisit and see what's available. Thank

you. Anyone else wish to be heard tonight? Anyone at all You can't, sorry. Good try. Seeing and hearing none. Public hearing on this item is now closed. What's the will of the body

move to approve?

Unknown

Second.

Yes, thank you. Move to approve the S version.

So there is a motion to approve the S version. Moved by Ms. Brawley. Second by Mr. Presardia. Ms. Brown.

Yeah, I'll be brief. I imagine there's more discussion. First, just to clarify, in order for us to begin discussion, we need to have a motion to approve. So that is what happened. Second is this S version specifically does two things. First that it allows for a defined upward adjustment of the total budget, the operating budget for the school district, depending on the outcome of Proposition 9, which is the one-time special tax levy. So if that was approved, it would allow that the budget could be increased by that exact amount of $11.8 million. And that would mean that the assembly does not have to take a second series of actions simply to adopt that after the outcome of the election. It adds or clarifies some language that was already in there regarding school and bond debt reimbursement. I will point the members to the fact that it is pre-2015, and the reason that it is underfunded at the state level was because it was not fully funded in the 2026 2025, 2026 fiscal year at the state level. This is really a cleanup item as well that that just changes some of the language. Also to note that it says the district is requesting in the original version, because this is an action of the assembly, it needs to be worded as coming from the assembly. And then lastly, I'll note this budget is ultimately a tax appropriation and authorization action. It doesn't address line items in the budget, it doesn't direct where the money should be spent or should not be spent, and it does not add policy directives, which are the purview of the school board. And that's all my comments for the time being. Thank

you. Mr. Conson. Thank you. I have a number of elements to discuss that will set the foundation for the conversation. As was previously discussed at our joint meeting last Friday. The assembly's role is for lack of a better term, ministerial in this process. We do have the responsibility for setting the tax levy and levying the taxes. That is where the nexus of the school district budget and the assembly come to play. So that the item before us now is the budget that was sent to us as approved by the school district. Our options according to the charter are very limited. The charter states the assembly shall approve the school district budget. That puts assembly members in a very difficult position because there are very few times when the command is to vote, and the command is not to vote no, but to vote either to increase, decrease, or approve. And I hope members look very carefully into the oath that they swore to uphold the charter. Because that's the first action that you took when the election was certified and you became a member. You swore an oath. And so I want to make sure that that isn't the underpinning of this conversation. Now we do not have the right to directly tell the school district you will spend in the following ways. There has been some suggestion that we should reduce the budget by some nominal amount that forces the budget back to the school district that would somehow stop the clock. That doesn't work that way. If we accept the budget with a reduced amount, it's a reduced amount, and that's what the school district then has to grapple with. It doesn't actually come back to us for action after that. It would just put a further cut into the school district's budget, which would then necessitate them having more very hard conversations with members of the community on because of the assembly's action, the reduction that they have to now make. It wouldn't move anything toward the achieving the very laudable goals of the parents and especially the children who came to testify before us today. So I want members to be very, very thought about the actions that they take tonight in the context of this budget. A symbolic no vote that fails the budget, the budget will pass. That symbolism, though, will have a cost in the community, and it will be painful and it's unprecedented. It hasn't happened because, again, the charter commands the assembly shall approve the school district budget. So there are some things that I've thought about that could be done. There are forms of non-binding intent language that could be amended in that sends a message to the school district. There obviously are members who will testify, who will probably ask questions. We're going to hear from the school district executive. And so all of that is part of tonight, but I want members to think really long and hard about the actions that they take tonight and the oath that they swore on the day that they became an assembly member, because it matters. So with that, I'll yield back the floor. I would ask that the school district superintendent, if you wish to come forward to provide any comments to begin our meaningful deliberations.

Good evening, members of the assembly, for the record, I'm Dr. Jarrett Bryant, the superintendent of the Anchorage School District, and I'm joined by the Chief Financial Officer of the School District, Mr. Andy Ratlift, and I'm also joined by our school board president, Carl Jacobs, and we're available to answer questions tonight. My comments will focus first on the budget. As members of the public and the assembly are well aware, ASD is facing a $90 million structural deficit for next school year. In practical terms, that means that if we don't make reductions to what we're spending on right now, we would be $9 million short. So we've had an unenviable task over the past six plus months of figuring out ways to move forward as a district, to still ensure that we fulfill our mission of educating all students for success in life, but with 90 million fewer dollars. How did this structural deficit come to be? There are a number of very complicated factors, but I'll boil them down to one, lower enrollment and the reasons why students student enrollment is lower, a number of reasons. One are changes in modality in learning. Many more students are opting for correspondent schools, for example. Many of them attend ASD correspondent schools, but because they're not in a brick or brick and mortar building, what we're beginning to see is that more and more school buildings are underutilized. In fact, over the past 15 years, ASD has lost more than 6,000 students. And to put that in perspective, a full elementary school serves about 350 to 450 students. So when you put that in the context of 6,000 students, that's the equivalent of about 14 to 16 full elementary schools. That's one of the challenges that we face. But the other challenge that the districts faces is that oftentimes revenue has been flat or unpredictable. And as we know, the cost of doing business for a school district, for a municipality, for an everyday household is going up and up and up. What I can assure the assembly is that 95 cents on the dollar of ASD's budget goes towards classroom instruction, student support services, and the cost to maintain and support our buildings. And it's frankly the latter that's probably growing at the most exponential rate compared to the others. I can control not hiring administrators, and certainly there have been freezes over the past several years, but what I can't control is the cost of fuel. Think about the price of gasoline as we pass by a gas station here in Anchorage, and you'll see that the cost of fuel is up by about a dollar from where it was a month ago. Why does it impact the school district? Think about the hundreds of school buses that traverse the municipality of Anchorage that spans about 2,000 square miles. Think about the costs that that means when it comes to next year. Think about the cost of fuel energy. Think about the costs of deferred maintenance, as I shared with the assembly at several previous joint assembly meetings, ASD's deferred maintenance is approaching $1.5 billion. And to put that in perspective, the average municipal bond from ASD specifically has averaged around 65 to 75 million over the past few years to chip away at that $1.5 billion. That would take decades. And that's time that our students don't have to spare when it comes to ensuring that their schools are safe places to be. So with all that context said as to where are we at, let's talk about how we approached balancing this structural deficit for next school year. One of the first things that we looked at was administration. So typically in ASD, we average about 5% of our budget goes towards district administrators like myself, our finance experts, our human resources department and what have you. And I will say that we've made the largest administrative reductions that we've seen in many years within the Anchorage School District. Just one example, our largest department is the Office of Academic Services. That department providical supports to all of our school buildings, whether it's through special education services, whether it's through supporting specific containeries and curriculum, supporting teachers, sometimes instructional coaching directly to schools, that department was reduced by 22%. And within the department of academic services, some departments were slashed by as much as 40, 50%. And in addition to academic services, we saw reductions across a number of areas administratively, including in communications, our development and grants division, our fine arts department, dozens of IT staff have been reduced from our workforce effective July 1, human resources, and a number of other areas. So that was step one. And as I mentioned, 95 cents on the dollars goes to everything but district administrators. So but that said, our commitment is to ensuring that as many resources as possible can directly go toward the classroom. We also wanted to be proactive, which is why the district implemented a hiring freeze in late November, early December to try to make sure that as vacancies came up, specifically outside the classroom, that we could hold those so we can prioritize every dollar for our classrooms. Even so, we had to go a step further. Again, we can't completely solve this deficit through administration. You could fire myself, take away every stipend from every school board member, fire everybody in the administration building, and we still would have had over $60 million to reduce from our deficit, but we did continue to pursue efficiencies. What does that look like? So we have over 90 school buildings in the Anchorage School District, and we've sought ways to do more with less, and we put forward in our budget proposal to the school board a number of things that in previous years we would have never recommended, but frankly, it was one of the only ways that we can ensure that as many critical dollars go as possible to our classroom educators. So one of the things that we had to look at was support and supplemental programs, some that have been funded for many, many years, including the popular Ignite program for our promising students, including consolidating the ways that we implement art and music in schools. These weren't things that we aspire to do. These were things that we had to look at critically. So again, we could protect as many classroom teachers as possible. We looked at ways to trim around the edges. So, for example, in middle school, for many years, if not decades, we've had a structure call the middle school model, which essentially gave our middle school educators valuable time to troubleshoot about their cohorts of students to help support their academic progress. We're unable to accommodate offering that extra class period, and we had to reduce the number of educators in our middle school. That was a very painful reduction that had been considered a number of times over the past five years. But when you're facing a $90 million deficit and there's no evidence that a structural revenue reform is coming from Juno, these are the types of structural decisions that we're faced with. And I could go on for hours and hours about all the different things that are not included in this budget, but I'll fast forward to the fact that even after going through everything that I've just described and much more, we still had to increase the pupil to teacher ratio by four students in the Anchorage School District. Again, that was essentially our last resort. And we were still forced to consider that painful decision in order to balance our budget. So what I can say is that this budget did not come with a good decision versus a bad decision. It was a matter of a terrible decision versus another terrible decision. And collectively, as a school board and myself, we had to figure out the best way to move forward as a district. Let me tell you a little bit about where I stand as the chief administrator for the district, is that one of the things that we can do for our community is to brought provide a sense of clarity. As many educators tell me, clarity is kindness. And for too many years, we've been holding on to programs and offerings and buildings because we want to hold on to hope that one day the legislature will come through, will figure out a fiscal plan, and we'll be able to offer the same things that we were able to offer in a very different time in Anchorage's history. I think that time is running out. And I will say, as terrible as this budget is, it does implement a number of structural changes that are going to help us manage much smaller deficits in future years to come. I don't want my district to go through this experience of a $90 million reduction ever again. But even though all of these reductions before you that that you're reviewing tonight. We still are having to face a $40-plus million deficit for next year. So it may be tempting for a school board member or a member of the public to wonder if more funding were to come in, can we add back X or Y program. Frankly, my direction to the school board will be to consider preserving as many dollars as we can just to maintain the levels of service that we'll have in next school year for the school year after that. So again, our challenge is not trying to figure out ways to save all of the programs that are currently in place right now. Wonderful programs, I might add, but it's a matter of how do we lessen the impact and reduce harm for our students two years from now, when again, we're facing a $40 million deficit and a projected $30-plus million deficit after that. So the district is in urgent need of making structural changes, and we do our very best to bring the community along with us. And I will say I'm sure that there'll be some extended conversation around the school consolidation portion of this budget. And I certainly have immense compassion for everyone who testified on the impact that that's had emotionally on the lives of our impacted communities again, that was not a difficult that was not an easy decision to make either, and to be completely transparent with the body. I did not propose school consolidations in the initial budget because in November the school board had actually rejected a proposal for school consolidations and I respected the will of the board, but I was asked to put forward a school consolidation proposal for them. Early in March, and I complied with that directive. But with that said, even though my school my budget did not include school consolidations, it did include other terrible choices that the school board had to grapple with. For example, one of the proposals in the budget was to dramatically reduce the number of health care professionals in our schools. So the original budget proposal would have reduced our nursing rings by over a dozen nurses, which would have had its own set of consequences for our students. And it also included large reductions to athletics and activities for our students, which again were very upsetting to the community at the time and provided a sense of relief when the school board had to make a very difficult trade-off between managing a school consolidation proposal, albeit on a very compressed timeline, and the prospect of offering as many activities and health care professionals in our schools as possible. It's an agonizing trade off, I can only imagine as someone who didn't have to vote on it, but had to be there to watch that process. It was not easy for anyone involved. And I'm happy to speak more towards the process, but I think as we zoom out here, what I'd like for the body to understand is that there are no easy choices forward. We can certainly make reverses in one area, and we'd have to make additional reductions in other areas. And again, we could rest we could contemplate hypotheticals about how to restore services. This for this upcoming school year that look like this school year. But my focus is on that $40 million deficit for FY28. And I hope that as you consider the things that you'd like more information on, I hope that you'll empathize with the agonizing tasks of the school board, not just this year, but in the years to come. And my ask to our community is to come along with me in this conversation because there's no easy path forward, but collectively, we can figure out a way to chart a path that is going to be sustainable within the realities that I know are true. And as of today, again, there are bills being put forward, but one of the complicating factors of school finance at the state level is that we oftentimes don't know what our revenue reality is until well into the summer, well after teachers have made their commitments or have perhaps left the municipality to teach in other places. There are a number of things that happen. In fact, you'll probably remember right along with me that the historic BSA increase that took place this summer was just that historic, but it also happened just a couple of weeks before school. You can imagine how destabilizing that is, not just for ASD, but for districts across the state. And with that said, we're looking ahead to next school year, and we see the same revenue picture. While that BSA increase was historic, it represented a $20 increase from the year before. And ASD is equip is operating under the equivalent of about a $1,400 BSA, because we've invested $700 of BSA worth of fund balance. Why did that happen? Because this time last year, parents, community members, maybe even some people in this room were pleading with the district to please preserve these programs, give the legislature time, give our community time. I'm afraid that time is running out and at this time. My ask of our community is to please come along in this conversation. It is not too late to enter it. But I owe it's my duty to ensure that the public is aware of how grave the situation is and the fact that there aren't any easy fixes or easy answers. Anything that comes back will result in something that would have to be taken away from students. And I hate that we're in this reality, but it would not be fair to the community to provide hope as the strategy. The strategy here is to get ASD's expenditures more in line with the revenue. And right now, for reasons outside of our control that large largely that rest largely in Juno, they're not matching. So I'm trying to get ASD much closer to fiscal sustainability than we've ever been. And that is where we're at today, this incredibly painful, agonizing process for all involved. So I thank you for listening to my initial comments and my team and I look forward to answering the questions you have about the ASD budget.

All right, thank you. I probably won't go too far. We have a number of people in the queue, and I'm guessing a number of them will have questions for you. I do have one before I hand off the mic, though. That if the assembly sent it back, which I don't imagine that universe comes, but if there was a intent language that said try to find a way to keep this school, then you what I heard you say is that it would cost other schools or other students. And so would you engage in a process if such language was there. Obviously not a mandate. We can't do that to you.

I would say I think it would depend on the context. A couple of scenarios have been put forth. One would be more of a symbolic adjustment to the total cap, and others would be more substantive. So for example, if the assembly did reduce the ASD budget. That's not what I'm talking

about. I don't believe the assembly should or I do not advise, and I think if there was an action to reduce the budget to tell you to do something, I think that would be in violation of the charter, too. Because the charter says we shall approve and you guys get to decide how you spend but if we attach nonbinding intent language, that said, will you reconsider this and look closely at various other variables? Would you engage in that

process? I believe that would ultimately be a board decision to come back and revisit that budget at that point.

Right. But putting in a whereas somewhere that we request the school district to look closely at this question again after we approve the budget.

Thank you for that clarification, Mr. Chair. Again, it really depends on what we're talking about, what the whereas is, the whereas may involve an expenditure that's millions of dollars, in which case the the things that the school board would have to consider to make up that difference would be very difficult, very challenging, and ultimately their decision, so I can only

speculate.

Thank you. I know that school systems across the state and across the country, including ASD, have had to make painful cuts that are not in the best interest of our kids. Because of chronic underfunding. That has resulted from us as a society choosing not to invest in public education and in our youth. Imagine a government that invests in increases to the Department of Corrections budget of 55% and invests in increases to the governor's budget by 30%, but will only concede to a 12% increase to the public education budget, and that not even until after 10 years of begging, while school buildings fall apart, class sizes increase to ridiculous levels, and educators flee. Well, we don't have to imagine it, because this is where we are at now. My fourth grader started school this year in a classroom of 36 students, and we're being told that we're increasing the student ratio by four students. It's shameful. I place full responsibility for our current situation on the governor and on legislative majorities who have vetoed and kicked the can down the road on funding our kids. That being said, I am also deeply disappointed by some of the decisions made by the Anchorage School District within this budget. Specifically, I'm concerned with how this administration and school board have chosen to target STEM education with their last minute decision to close the only STEM elementary in Alaska, as well as delay Oceans Academy, which would have offered a public STEM high school, and was the first public charter school in Anchorage that would have offered public transportation, opening up opportunities to even more public school kids to grow and learn in a STEM educational setting. STEM education provides an opportunity for many kids to thrive, including kids who are on the autism spectrum and who struggle in more traditional education system settings. A recent meta analysis published in July 2025, which I've added to the record. Shows that establishing diversified education models is crucial to ensuring educational equity in special education, and that STEM education plays an important role not only in providing an educational opportunity for students on the autism spectrum to thrive, but that STEM learning has also expanded future employment opportunities later in life for students on the autism spectrum. For a school board and administration that has acted as champions of diversity and equity, I am deeply disturbed by these last-minute decisions to close the only STEM Elementary School and defer the opening of Oceans Academy, which would have provided a public STEM charter school for high school students. By cutting STEM out of our district, we will be leaving more children to fall through the cracks. We will be failing more kids. We will be removing the opportunity for more kids to thrive, learn, and grow. As a reminder, Oceans Academy would have been the first public charter school to offer public transportation, which is a model that there has long been advocacy for. While I understand and emphasize with the need to make hard decisions and hard cuts, these last minute decisions made by the Anchorage School District in this budget feel short sighted, and I believe will result in the loss of opportunity and in harmful outcomes to students who need diversified educational models to grow, learn, and thrive. I urge the Anchorage School District to take more time, thought, and care with these decisions. And as a district which prioritizes diversity and equity to support diversified educational models, including STEM and public charter programs, so as to ensure educational equity for special education needs, as well as students who don't have the means to look beyond publicly funded education for the opportunity that STEM and charter schools provide. That's all I have for now. I might come back later with some questions. Thank you.

Yeah, thank you, Mr. Chair. First, if I can just ask school board president Carl Jacobs to please come up. So first some folks during their testimony talked about please give us some more time and for a split second, I had a glimmer of hope, but I think as has as has often happened during this process, I ask the attorneys a question and my hope is crushed. This is no offense to the attorneys. Can I just get get a sort of a head nod from the attorneys that it's my understanding that s sort of April 1 per Alaska State statute for municipal code per municipal charter is the timeline that we're working off of. A decision must be made. Like there is there's no more leeway that we have. Okay, so just for the record, the attorneys aren't adding their head, both the municipal attorney and assembly council. Questions that I have for first question I would really like school board president Carl Jacobs to respond to. I'm also happy to hear from the superintendent if he would like to respond. But I'm asking you because this is a decision that the school board made, particularly regarding the right sizing, consolidating decision. You also spoke to this a little bit in Anchorage Daily Daily News article. What would it take from your perspective for the school board to reverse its decision? Specifically regarding Campbell's

time. Sure. Thank you, Member Rivera. Carl Jacobs for your record, AST school board president. I've thought long and hard about it. And it involves a bit of dreaming because the dysfunction and unproductivity that our capital and leaders in our capital, by and large, have demonstrated has been persistent and something that succeeded well over a decade. We need state leaders to implement a sustainable long-term fiscal plan. Our over reliance on the volatility of oil and the permanent fund earnings was never intended to be sustainable, is not sustainable, and is causing core services across state government to break. Public education is certainly one of those items. Due to the ease of increasing other department light items like our prison system. Certain State Departments have seen less trouble immediately, but our public school system requires bipartisan cooperation to increase a formula and a government bring stakeholders together to make those changes. We haven't seen that bipartisan effort and leadership in on a consistent basis in quite some time. My hopefully is a very The state leaders could come together, adopt a sustainable long term fiscal plan, implement new revenue measures, which would provide some sort of long-term sustainable picture for how the state of Alaska will choose to fund core services. At that point, a permanent based in allocation increase would be viable, as would a host of other fixes. It's not a topic of this agenda item, but I know that members of this body know that caseloads with the Office of Children's Services are skyrocketing again. Adult Protective Services case workers are overloaded. State retention rates are a challenge. So much in our State right now is struggling. And if our State were to get its fiscal house in order, we would see school districts like Anchorage and Matsue not have deficits that exceed tens of millions of dollars and have a sustainable fiscal picture, which in turn would allow us to invest in programs that matter to our communities and not have to move away from the neighborhood school model, which I personally value. That leadership hasn't demonstrated itself yet. That doesn't mean that our board won't continue advocating for the appropriate leadership necessary for that fiscal picture to be implemented, and we'll join your body in advocating for those reasonable priorities, because it's the truly the only way out of the constant the constant challenge we're seeing every cycle in Juneau, which is of structural at the state level, and a legislative session that's spent predominantly speaking about how we fund our operating budget versus other productive legislation.

Thank you for that response. And I'll dream right along with you and work to make that a reality. Second question. So I just have three and then some comments. So I won't I promise I won't take up too much time. Second question is could be a quick yes or no response from both the superintendent and from President Jacobs. So I imagine that after this meeting and after this vote, that my consistents are still gonna have questions. And this really isn't it. Conducive dial space literally by design to have dialogue. We don't have a lot of back and forth with members of the public who come to testify here. So I'm gonna ask a question that actually my colleague from Midtown Member Baldwin Day asked at the meeting last Friday. Should there still be questions for my constituents regarding the Campbell stem closure? Can you commit to coming to a separate public venue and responding and having dialogue with my constituents on that issue? Yes, I can commit to that.

Yeah, Member Rivera, this is something I've actually connected with member Baldwin day about. I think that we should engage in community dialogue, not just about the Campbell STEM issue, but also really raising awareness for the FY28 and FY29 deficits Dr. Bryant spoke about. I don't think there's enough widespread knowledge about those items, and I think our community deserves to know those, as well as letting both the local and state leaders understand exactly what school districts are up against. So I agree that would be a reasonable and prudent step forward.

Great. Thank you. My third question is sort of along the similar veins, asking for a specific commitment. Right sizing of the Anchor School District continue into the future. Can you commit to ensuring what I would Describe as abundant community notice.

Yes. In fact, the school board in the resolution that I referenced earlier tonight had three directives. One or the two we've already spoken about, but the third was actually to work with the community on a long range process to engage the community and ensure that moving forward that school consolidation proposals are thoughtful and grounded in community input and some of the realities that perhaps the community doesn't know, and we should inform them of them. Thank

you. Those are my questions. Now to my comments. They're not very long, because I know we have folks in the queue. So for me, when I think about this, two things can be true at the same time. First thing in my opinion, this was a bad process that resulted in a fractured community. Sure. The timeline was legally sufficient, but was the timeline right in the way that we define what is right. I think that's a much harder thing to argue. I think there are still questions that my constituent my constituents have regarding criteria. And so many more unanswered questions. That I think unfortunately has been broken. Thing two can also be true, which is that we are in a crisis of the state's making. This has to be number one, two, and three on their list. So That gets to how am I gonna vote on this budget. I like to think of myself as a very pro education assembly member. I have supported every single Anchorage School District budget that has come before me. I've supported every single measure. I have gone to the legislature and spoke to their joint education committees for year after year about why they need to increase funding for schools. Actually the last person who testified used the term save our schools that actually made me think back, I think it was in my first campaign in 2016, or maybe another campaign where I actually hosted just right out here on the corner of Denali in 36th, I hosted a rally, and I actually was holding a sign, save our schools. This is something that has been an issue and dear to my heart for years. I will be honest with my constituents. When I came in here today, I was fully prepared to vote yes on this budget, because I am fully support of our school district and think that the solutions here aren't necessarily tied to voting yes or no on this particular item. I will want to thank my constituents, though, who came here and testified, because as often happens with me, when I sit here and listen and truly listen to my constituents, I it expands my perspective, my field of view, and starts making me think maybe I should vote a different way. I can't commit one way or another on how I may vote. I'm gonna listen to the rest of this testimony. But that was really compelling testimony, and thank you. Someone asked at the end for options, what are our options? I will list three. One. And I've said this in in meetings, so my consistent heard this. And I'll keep repeating it. You have to continue to advocate to the state legislature. And I know many of you have, and I commend you for doing that. I want to encourage folks to continue to do that. Second is even though it seems that this decision has been made and there may be some opportunities to reverse the decision, depending on sort of if dreams come true, which I hope they do. I really want to encourage folks to demand transparency because right sizing, I believe, is something that will continue. And so I hope that you can really make sure that no other schools have to deal with what you have had to deal with. And then the third thing that I actually mentioned in a in a meeting was intent language. There's a sort of possibility of including some type of intent language. I made it clear in that meeting though that intent language is pretty weak. It doesn't force anything. I did not come here prepared with intent language, but certainly if someone did have intent language, I would be more than open to supporting it. That's it. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. President.

Thank

you. I'll keep this short because my colleagues, I think shared many of the same feelings and comments that I have. I first want to thank the folks that came out to testify tonight. That was very compelling. Thank you for coming and thank you for being here and thank you for your advocacy. And having having served on the school board for a number of years, having children in our schools cur currently. I a huge supporter of our school the district and our schools. And it just it sadens me that we're in the position we're in. I want to thank the superintendent and the school board for president and the whole team for being here today. And thank you for the explanation. Thank you for your clarity. Thank you for sharing the whole story. I think it's really important that we do begin to tell the whole story and make sure that folks know that this isn't a one year challenge that we face, but it's a multi-year challenge. I also just want to continue to encourage folks to advocate to the state and to and to continue to put the pressure on. I am I am going to vote yes tonight because it's our responsibility as a body to approve the upper limit of this, not to dictate how how the money is spent. I have a lot of faith in the school district, and in the in the superintendent and his team and the and the board to make these very difficult decisions. I don't like the decisions that are being made. I they I don't like schools being being closed. That's that's all I have to say. I'm really sad that this is this is happening. And but I intend to vote yes and I intend to continue the fight to increase funding and to and to see if there's alternatives to cloth closing schools, because I think it's not in the best interest of our of our community. But if it means downsizing in order to ensure quality of education for all kids in our district, then I'm willing to be be a part of that as well. So th thank you for being here. Thank you for time.

Thank you, Mr. Volant. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I have a question for assembly council and then also for our municipal attorney, and I would like them both to answer it. Just because I want my colleagues to have some surety going into the vote. I believe it was implied in this conversation that perhaps there's risk of us not doing our duty uphold the charter. I don't know exactly what the scenario is there. So first I would like to ask would an individual assembly member's no vote be a failure to uphold the charter? And then my second question is, should the majority of this body vote no what happens and would that be a failure to uphold the charter

Through the Chair. Thank you for the question, Member Boland. The charter does contain language in section 605 C that says the assembly shall approve a budget of the school district as amended in appropriate necessary funds at least 60 days prior to the end of the fiscal year of the school district. And that timeline of 60 days is actually further constricted by state law on the subsequent change to the municipal code, which is how we have the April 1st deadline that we're up against right now. In my opinion, I don't that language saying the assembly shall approve a budget does not remove the freedom of the individual assembly member to vote as they see appropriate on an item before the body. There's very similar language used also in charter regarding taking action on the municipal budget budget, and that language is also echoed in in Anchorage Municipal Code as well. Yeah, the section 1305 says the assembly shall approve a budget of the municipality as amended in appropriate funds at least 21 days prior to the end of the fiscal of the municipality. That language is not aware of a tradition of that language being viewed as requiring a yes vote on whatever municipal budget eventually gets moved for approval in front of the body. know that it's ever been interpreted to require yes vote. So I would apply that same logic to this language. I don't think each individual member is required to do an individual to do an individual yes vote. In answer to your second question, if this body fails to approve by majority vote the budget that's before you now right now you have the yes version in front of you. If the majority does not vote in the affirmative and pass this budget and no version of it gets passed by the body here tonight, then on April 1 the version that was passed by the Anchorage School Board, so the original would automatically go into effect by operation of law and the money would be automatically appropriated per code and charter

Thank you. And then maybe if we could hear from the municipal attorney as

well my office is in agreement with that

interpretation I guess just from my part, I think a read of the charter to say that either an individual member or the entire body essentially voting no would not be a failure to uphold the charter That being said I'm going to They are advising us though. But they're advising us though. Right. Thanks. And you aren't either so that being said, I am likely going to be a yes vote on this for many of the reasons that my colleagues have outlined and also because a no vote while that might message certain things to certain people is going to result in an approved budget regardless I do have a question for Dr. Bryant Dr. Bryant What So can Campbell STEM elementary being a STEM school. What is the process look like for being a designated or accredited accredited STEM school

Sure. So that process goes through our accreditor cognia, and there's a process specifically for STEM credentialing, and that's a process that could be implemented again. In fact, it's something that I'm excited to do once we move forward with consolidating our footprint so that it's smaller, but can sustain incredible STEM programs for the foreseeable future. So if Campbell STEM were closed and there weren't some sort of reversal that were to happen in the future, that would be something that I would utilize to recertify a school. With that said, it is not an easy or simple process. It requires the buy-in of teachers, school leader to champion it, and a lot of commitment to the principles espoused by Cognia, but it is a process that can and will be done when the situation is appropriate.

Is that a like a multi-year process? And do you have any idea of what the cost would look like?

In terms of the cost, I believe it's several thousand dollars, just a few thousand, several thousand. Not an extraordinarily large cost. I will say having gone through the district accreditation process, so now every single anchorage school is accredited through Cognia. It does take a couple of years and then continuous monitoring and oversight from Cognia, the accreditation board, but again, having just gone through a district wide accreditation for all schools, we certainly have the infrastructure to pursue additional STEM accreditations for one or more schools in the future.

Thank you. I appreciate that. I think for me, I will just say that that is the toughest part of this whole thing is losing the only STEM school in Alaska and knowing that it would be I think quite a process to bring something like that back in the future. So that you know it has made my decision making in this entire process difficult. You mentioned in your comments, Dr. Bryant, that clarity is kindness. And I understand that what you're hoping to do is set realistic expectations for the future. I think you're in a very hard spot. I think our school board is in a very hard spot. But I would respectfully submit that 11 days does not create clarity, nor is it kind. So going forward, I do hope, as other members have stated, we can have a more robust public process when school closures are being considered. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Mr. Johnson.

Yeah, thank you, Chair. So this is this is truly a heartbreaking position to be in. And the testimony we've heard tonight from from the parents and then the students at from the teachers at Campbell has been really difficult to listen to. I will tell you also it is not the first time we've heard heartbroken parents and educators and kids come before us. It has been year after year from different schools that have been on the chopping block. Or advocating for programs that are incredibly near and dear to students' hearts that have been facing cuts or sports programs that are important to them. This is sadly a regular exercise for this body. And it is incredibly hard to watch. But I will say for what it's worth, I believe we hear you. This body in the time I've been on it has consistently pushed for increases in funding the base student allocation, both through our adopted municipal programs and through specific resolutions calling for that. I know myself and others on this body have traveled to Juno to try and bring that message directly to the legislature. We have pushed back when we've seen the school board of education try to take emergency action to reduce the funding formula in a way that would strip millions of dollars out of our budget. And the majority of this body this year supported putting the special levy phrase defunding on the ballot I think when you look at the body of the work, we have been consistent that we believe our schools are worth investing in but I'll tell you I we're here today because the state isn't listening. The governor isn't listening either or they're listening and they just don't care. We knew we were going to be here. We knew that with continue year after year declining investment in education that this board and all of us were going to be facing these impossible choices. There's no getting away from it and we knew that I mean I'll tell you from from having sat through these joint meetings with the school board and listened to the presentations and taken a very sober look at our finances I came into this year knowing that there was no solution that was not going to result in a group of heartbroken students and parents and teachers coming before us. And I'm sorry it happened to Campbell, but it was going to be somebody some some group was going to suffer as a consequence of the situation we're in. And it is it is awful. And sadly I believe until such time as our state just fundamentally changes its attitude towards investment in education, we are going to continue to have this exercise year after year of terrible choices and heartbroken families. And it is just it is awful to watch. So I will continue for my part on this body for as long as I'm here to continue to advocate in education and dream of a brighter day when maybe we don't have to go through this exercise. But for now this is this is where we are

Mr. Girker Thank you, Mr. Chair. I would just like to echo some of the comments that some of my colleagues have made, thanking parents and students for coming and testifying. In this position, in this role, I have heard some truly heartbreaking testimony. But I think tonight was maybe the hardest for me to hear. Thank you for showing up. Thank you for staying engaged and being a part of this process. I do have a couple questions for you, Dr. Bryant. I heard what you said. I understand I understand the circumstances and the context and how we found ourselves in this position. I would quibble on a couple points, but it's neither here nor there. But in all of your talking, I did not actually hear the points of data to decide why Campbell's STEM was selected foreclosure. Can you can you what what was the what was the data points for this? Quantify this for me. Help me understand. This doesn't make any sense.

Sure, Member Gerker, great question. So this process of consolidating schools or right sizing schools has been taking place not just this year, but frankly for the past four years, and it's taken place in different modalities each time. Sometimes there were improvements, and I would say in this most recent iteration, a lot of setbacks due to the crisis that we face. But with that said, back in, I believe 2023, we actually took an entire year off from closing schools, but we didn't take a year off from discussing consolidation because we spent about six months working with the board and collecting input from the community on some sort of framework for how one would pursue a very agonizing task of selecting from You know, over 94 schools, a list to move forward to a school board to select for consolidation. And through that process, we received some good feedback, and some of the metrics that the school board adopted that particular year that have set a framework for subsequent conversations are a number of things, one of which would be utilization within an area. So one of the things that we see within Anchorage is we have a number of schools. Again, we've lost 6,000 students, the equivalent to let's say 14 plus full elementary schools, but oftentimes what you see is that they're clustered within a five mile, sometimes fewer radius. There are some situations where one elementary school is just a couple of streets away from another elementary school. And one of the reasons is actually very positive. It's because back when we were developing these schools many decades ago, the idea was to create neighborhood schools. And I think that's a very valuable, very aspirational idea that worked for many, many years. But fast forward to the popularity of correspondence education, lower birth rates, and a number of other factors beyond the scope of this conversation, we see a number of schools within a small geographic region that are underenrolled. And at a high level, that is not a good thing for students because when a school is underutilized or within an underutilized area of town, you're more likely to share services, you're more likely to have combination classrooms, you're more likely to share a PE teacher or a music teacher, or what have you. These combinations manifest in different ways. So that's one piece. And of course, When you have schools that are very close to one another that are all underutilized, the next thing is is it feasible? Is it financially sustainable to institute transportation services? So that's another factor. Mr. Bryant.

I'd like to we've reached the end of the hour for debate, so could we move to extend debate by 30 minutes?

So move. Is there any objection to the motion? No objection will be extended for 30 minutes. Go ahead, Mr. Bryant. Thank

you. So transportation service is is another thing that that's considered. Another thing that was on our criteria that we developed that particular year was on community growth because we did receive feedback that there are certain neighborhoods where perhaps there are developments that are going to be put in place that would result in not necessarily new residents to Alaska, but perhaps the migration of residents from one area of Anchorage to another. That's another common thing that comes up that would preclude an area from being considered development is something that's factored. A big piece is facility condition. And I think that's the one that played a prominent role in this situation because we're trying to manage a number of very difficult things at once. One, we have a $.5 billion tally in deferred maintenance, and it would take us 20 years in school bonds alone to reduce that number. And that's assuming that there's no growth in additional deferred maintenance. So one of the most significant ways that you can reduce that deferred maintenance number is to reduce the number of schools that you maintain in your portfolio. So one of the things that's being considered, for example, with Avot Loop Elementary would be to declare that facility as excess, and just for clarity to the public, that's a term that that's a legal term meaning that the school declares the building as being additional to its needs, providing it to the municipality. It does not mean that a school is excess to remission. And in fact, oftentimes the schools that are selected for closure are incredible. And Campbell STEM is no exception. It's an incredible school that adds a lot of value to hundreds of people in this community. But with that said, a common thread across all these schools is that there's a large amount of deferred maintenance. And we can talk about, you know, this school is on this bond or this school is going to be on this future bond, but when you look at the big picture, I think our path to ensuring that our schools can endure for future generations is frankly to have either fewer schools or many, many more children to fill those schools. And one thing that does make Campbell stand out are a couple of things. It was mentioned that there are fungible dollars that are through the school bond debt reimbursement program that are affixed to Campbell STEM. That is something that was taken into consideration as the directive from the school board was to find efficiencies that could generate short term dollars. And that's the second thing that the school board has to grapple with. The first one was around large deferred maintenance needs. The second one would be around how do we in this crisis moment try to Bring back as many fungible dollars to the district as possible so that we can move services forward for an additional school year. And I will say to the school board, they were making a very difficult decision between adopting budget that dramatically reduced the number of healthcare service providers in the school, specifically nurses, and then also athletics, and to consider that with a building that's in need of many repairs, with Campbell specifically, again, a wonderful program, but I think we have to separate the program from the facility. So Campbell is the, I believe, the only school that I can recall this year that was closed more than one time due to severe winter conditions. There was a sewer line that was frozen and something that doesn't get often talked about in these technical conversations is that specific issue with the facility was not a common that was not incorporated in the bond that we're talking about for Campbell STEM. And then there's additional work that needs to be done in the school. So even though there was a recent roof project in my most recent visit to Campbell, you know, well before the school consolidation conversation happened, I did notice that there was a bucket to collect water droplets at the very front of the school. So when I look at Campbell STEM, I see a school that perhaps deserves millions of dollars in investment, but when you zoom out and you look at the financial crisis that the district and city and state is in, we have to have the difficult conversation of figuring out how do we sink our footprint so that we can make every dollar that we may or may not get from the taxpayer through bonds to make sure that our schools can endure for generations. So myself, I had to make the very difficult I had to decomp decomparementalize in some ways the incredible program which we can rebuild and put in other locations from the facility that, yes. Could we tactically repair this building? Yes. But are there other needs that have also resulted in that $1.5 billion in deferred maintenance, I would also say yes. So it was and then in addition to facility condition, there are a number of other different metrics like alternative use. So there are a number of different things you can do with the a consolidated school. One way that's slightly less drastic, but is also more cost effective is to repurpose a building for another use, such as being filled by a let's say a charter school that has a much larger enrollment. A good example of that would be when we move the Alaska Native Cultural Charter School to the Lake Hood facility. Lakehood, the year that it was closed was approaching about 50% utilized, meaning that it was more susceptible to combination classes and a number of other things, sharing specialists, et cetera, et cetera. But fast forward to today, the Alaska Native Cultural Charter School is housed there. And as a charter school, they're able to use their dollars to maintain the minor maintenance on that facility. But I would say in the bigger picture, I'm also seeing a school that's at its highest enrollment that it's ever been. So now we have nearly 400 students that are in that building, whereas before it was approaching under 200 within the next couple of years. So that specific community, that specific building was transformed by alternative use. And that's another thing that was considered. And that's why in this proposal you'll see a number of different combinations. In the case of Campbell STEM, the proposals to declare it as excess because of the very intense needs that it would need to repair it for generations to come. But the alternative would be to repurpose a vacant facility for a charter school, one, so that you can have an independently funded charter school to pay for the minor maintenance and utilities costs, but two, ensure that that building has a greater utilization than it has before. And I would say in all the situations where that where that's happened, it's been better for students. It was better for students when we were able to fill the Lake Hood facility with one of our highest performing Title I charter schools. And it also was a huge win for the Baxter community when a school was closed on the east side, but those students were rezoned to Baxter, so now it's at the highest enrollment that it's been in for about 10 years. And as a result, it was less likely to have combination classrooms. It was less likely to have a number of these different vulnerabilities that happen when you have the same number of buildings that you had 30 years ago when you had almost 10,000 more students. So it's extremely complicated. And I don't blame the public for desiring some sort of strier that spits out the school that's the number one best candidate for consolidation. That's never the case. And there was never a school that was easy to close. There was never a school where there were arms racing, please close my school. We haven't heard from a single family from the Fire Lake and Lake Otis communities tonight, and those are fantastic schools as well. And I had the honor of hearing from hundreds of families that told me very compelling compelling reasons why those schools should be open as well. This is not easy work. But at the end of the day, I have to offer some lens of objectivity to the board that when I say that there are 6,000 fewer students in the same number of buildings that we had 20 years ago, that it's ultimately a disservice to those students when they're more vulnerable to the impacts of underutilization, such as everything that I previously described. So at a high level, those are just some of the criteria that we looked at for about a year and have largely guided our decisions in the subsequent years.

I appreciate that, Dr. Bryan. And I and I beg indulgence for my colleagues. I have a couple more questions that that did generate. What is considered underutilized? Like what's the percentage threshold there?

Sure. So utilization, you can define it in a couple of different ways. The state actually has an index for defining utilization. They look at it in terms of square footage. It's a very sterile process. In ASD, we've created a somewhat more school friendly way of calculating capacity. So that's incorporating factors such as, you know, perhaps we must house a special education program that requires just a handful of students being in a large room. So in which case having a small number of students in a large space is actually utilizing the building to its full extent because some of our high need special education programs actually do need a lot of space. So it's very nuanced. I wish I could just tell you if it's 50 and below, you're on the list. If it's 50 or more, you're not. But it's more complicated than that because, again, to my previous point, sometimes you'll have as many to as four to five schools within a five mile radius. So even if one school may be utilized, if that school were to be consolidated into the others, they'll be much better utilized. So when I'm what we're

hearing you say, Dr. Bryan, is that utilization isn't necessarily enrollment. Is that is that correct?

So utilization, it student enrollment is a large driver of it, but I think it's important to keep the nuance of special programs like special education.

And I guess my Guess my comment there then is that you know Campbell Sem, I think was at 72% enrollment. That doesn't seem underutilized to me, and I know that you you mentioned infrastructure, you know, some of the capital projects needed at the school, but it there's bonds in the most recent years for it, and that's actually we're taking that money. Now we're moving it towards other projects, and that's what you said was actually one of the driving factors for it. I think to parents who supported the bond, thinking it's gonna go to their school to support their kids' education, that's probably a very frustrating thing to hear. That's yeah that's that's really frustrating. How would you say that it's weighted? You know, you you listed utilization, transportation, community growth, facility condition. How are those weighted amongst themselves?

It depends on the context, and that actually reminds me of the last point that I wanted to make, but I think when we developed that initial criteria several years ago, each one was a fixed a point system. I would need I'm happy to give that to the assembly and others. It's on our website, but just for clarity, I'm happy to provide that, but I don't want to misspeak on what got what number of points. But the other piece that I'll leave you with on the topic of school consolidations is that oftentimes people assume that there's some sort of short list and my ex school wasn't on the previous list that I saw last year or this year, so why is it on the list now? And I will offer some nuance to that because this would be the third proposal that's gone before this set of school board members. And each time there have been amendments or adjustments made to the original proposal. And when those changes are made, it causes a cascade, a domino effect. So, for example, Baxter was one that I mentioned earlier. It was actually initially slated for closure. Why was it not on the list again? Because the school board did close another school on the east side that same year. We rebounded that school into Baxter. So it now is at a very high level of utilization. There are other examples too, like Tudor Elementary was previously on a list, but after it was not consolidated by the school board, program changes were made, and preschool classrooms were moved into that particular building. And there are countless other nuances of when a school is removed from a list or not consolidated or the list is adjusted, there's a series of other changes that happened that could impact utilization. Most recently, the school board was faced with a proposal on consolidation, right sizing rather, in November. And while they did decline to consolidate schools at that time, they did approve the administration to move forward with commercial child care in underutilized buildings. So, for example, Fairview Elementary, which was which is historically a school with low utilization, will now house the headquarters for one of the childcare providers as a spinning kind service or a some sort of joint collaboration. We've also been able to utilize funds from municipal grants to put that work forward. But again, not to get too in the weeds, but again, every time that there are changes made to a consolidation proposal, it creates a ripple effect that changes the nature of the criteria by which these schools were initially assessed.

Appreciate that I asked at the work or the joint meeting last week how many of the some nearly 500 positions that were being eliminated through this budget were vacant PCNs and how many of those were actually filled positions at the time you didn't know. Do you have an idea now?

Yeah. So I went and check those numbers today. We currently have 371 FTE that are vacant within our general and transportation funds. As that relates to potential layoffs though, I mean that's across all funds so if we have 27 FTE and custodial vacancies but we need to lay off more teachers than that, then not necessarily kind of one to one. And that's all even the teachers are going to depend on their content area, what their certifications in, and if they have any openings in those. A good example is like we have some vacancies in psychologists. So we've cut a few psychologists out of our budget but we're not going to have to lay anybody off because we have those vacancies in there. But conversely we can't have like a nonpsychologist even certified education move into that position. Right. I

appreciate that. No that's that's good to hear and one of one of the things I would say that it would be nice to see when the district is pushing out information about positions being eliminated is how many are actually filled positions and how many are vacant positions. Eliminating 371 FTEs that are vacant FTs. That's a completely different situation for parents to grapple with than eliminating 371 teachers. That matters and I think you know that. Look this whole process I think it it's underlined to me how desperately we need some reform in this process. I think that there needs to be more oversight, frankly, of the school board from the assembly. This is a huge part of our budget, part of our taxes, and I think that we need to see more oversight, 100%. I've also seen, you know, conversations, Dr. Bryant, you've raised a good point. The funding timeline with the state is a mess. It's an absolute mess as far as when do you guys know when the funds are going to be available. What is it, and you have to pretend you've got ideal for your budget before you actually have the money. And that that creates this huge situation where you're sending out pink slips, you're telling these teachers, hey, sorry, hit the road, Jack, and then a couple months later going, just kidding, come on back. And that's that's terrible for teacher retention. I think one of the things we need to look at is reforming the timeline a bit. Like how do we get ourselves on a timeline where we're not screwing around with people's livelihoods like that. That's such a knee-jerk reaction to do, and that's not fair for the teachers. Simply simple as that. Yes, I think we need some reforms. I appreciate the conversation. And respectfully, finally, no vote I do not believe is violating my oath of office. I do intend to vote no. I do not believe that my oath requires me to rubber stamp bad decisions. Thank you, I yield back. Mr. McCormick. Thank you.

Yeah. Both my parents were career long ASD teachers, and in fact my grandparents were career long ASD teachers. My dad spent 25 years teaching at Campbell in the same exact classroom for 25 years. I spent dozens of in-service days in there helping him tear it down, set it up. So this is an abstract to me, though I didn't go to Campbell, I spent plenty of time there. But what I see here today is that ASD has a trust problem with the public. You can hear it in the testimony over and over again. People are talking about process, transparency, decision making. And then I hear from from out front and then from members in the diocese as well, a lot of fingerpoint this is the governor's fault, this is the state legislature's fault, this is the oil prices' fault. Anything but the personal responsibility. Why why is it so hard? Why are we sitting here talking about this still? Why can't you get funding? And it's decisions like this one here. You've lost the public's confidence. That is your failure. Voting this budget down is not anti-educ, it is pro-accountability. And while I understand that the charter, a no vote will still allow this budget to pass by default, it can do it without my support. So per my oath, I will faithfully perform the duties of an assembly member to the best of my abilities, and I'll be voting

no. Thank you, Chair. To the families and to the youngest testifies that came today, thank you. I heard you, I think everyone here has heard you. What they heard may be different, though. So I do appreciate that. And I also wanted to share in solidarity to the members of the of the East Anchorage community, we were a part of the first lists. The year year one and year two and I appreciate working with the administration, the superintendent, the school board, and the members of our East Anchorage community because the Baxter Nunaka stream academy model. I mean, so many moving parts. It was hard to kind of track it all, but as a parent in the community, we were tracking things that tried to make the most sense for the neighborhood. And I found I found that we were able to get there. We did have time. I do want to I do want to call out the legal time requirement was met, but the ability to have thoughtful, deep informative conversations with the community wasn't happen didn't happen. And so they're righteously uptight about that? And on the other hand, Chair, I do I do want to raise a point that from my vantage point is the oversight question that I want to land on today. And maybe someone from the administration and maybe the municipal attorney, maybe our attorneys. But I do want to land on a on a fundamental question around trust and voter intent. And the question I have is how do we, as the municipality, get out of using bonds when voters appropriate voted on bonds for a particular reason? What is our back door to get out of a bond, or do we have those? So if the voters say, for example, we approve this amount of money for example the education levy. Presumably we will now use that for the education purposes, or we did a voter approved bond for police equipment. And we added additional you know, of to what extent do we have the ability to say the calculus is changed and we will no longer spend those dollars there. We will use them in a different category. I just want to get a sense of that part of the oversight to the trust mechanism. And or how difficult is it? Just for those who are keeping tabs in the background don't know who they are conferring and figuring out who is going to answer one of the legal folks. Member

Martinez, I think it would be unfair for me to go first, since I went first last time. So I'm going to defer to my colleagues.

Mr. Hurt, I don't disagree with

you. While they are conferring, I'm trying to pull up the most recent school bond ordinance, so that I might quote chapter and verse from you. But I will defer to the municipal attorney, if you're right to speak.

Thank you for the question. Through the chair, this is something that we need to discuss with bond council, so that's a specialized area of law that we need to confer on. We have outside counsel for bond purposes.

Right on. And I appreciate that. While that's not the answer that I hope for. And to the school district is you all have a pretty easy way forward. And I don't need to see bond council pretty much, or I don't I don't think I need to see the It's pretty self-evident that as is identified today, the school district has the ability to null and void and a bond that was passed by the voters through an administrative process of a closing of a school. So once the administrative process of a school closure happens, the dollars associated with a bond are now available as just a process without any valuation or judgments to that. That seems like what was described to us. That's a m will you want to say what you just shook your head to on the microphone,

please? Sure. My understanding is in the bond language we have something to the effect of I don't know the exact language that if the project is no longer practical, then that money can be distributed to other projects on that bond. So long as those other projects on those bonds come in under budget after several years later, probably once they're all done, then it can go through other capital projects. But first it has to go through the bond the projects that were explicitly on that bond that the voters voted for first. Once those are all closed out and under budget, then it could be potentially reappropriate later down the road.

So you don't just have loose access to if you close the school here, there was money appropriated from a bond for repairs. You don't just have loose access to say that those dollars are going to go to anywhere else in the school district. You do still have to follow a formula.

Yeah, and there's within that. Project, there was two different funding sources. One was the bond, which was, I think a little over $9 million, and then there was the $2.2 million that Dr. Bryant referenced to the bond debt reimbursement program, which is separate funding that was fungible and kind of free and clear.

Tracking. So when a school closed the bonded reimbursement didn't have to go there, there is a little more flexibility with that cash, 2.4, but the 9 million, what happens to

it? That way we do have to wait and see the other projects on the bond and see when they come into budget. So they have to be finished before we can reallocate that bond money?

But it will be reallocated because of this closure.

Yes.

Okay. So cool. And so essentially that was a very very quick direct answer to how a process could essentially deviate from the voter intent of a bond.

Right. My understanding of the process.

Right. No, and I think that is fair. And these are not gotcha questions. I just want it for clarity for myself and for the public. But I do want to put this challenge out there. Because if we're talking about long range processes, and we're talking about the difference between 11 days, well, we need to map these timelines much more effectively. Because we're projecting outward now based on population decline, based on maintenance, based on dollars not here, what we will not be able to do, but we still have a wish list of the things we want to do, and we're bringing that to the public at the same time. And so I have a problem that when we bring things to the public within a within a short time period, we can roll those back. And I don't the answer is not here tonight. It is highlighting this challenge, for example, but if a bond is approved, I think that it's a real challenge within the same bond cycle that has been changed to a different purpose. And it's all above board. I think from the vantage point of long term planning and trust building, voter intent really does matter. And we really don't want people voting on stuff that we are in the back room predicting is gonna be obsolete tomorrow anyway. Because then that really creates a trust problem at that particular Nexus point. Does that make sense? I appreciate you all. Thank you. That's my comments, Chair. Thank

you. Vice Chair Thank you. I would like to move to extend debate again by another 20 minutes.

There's a motion to extend debate.

Unknown

Second.

Moved by Ms. Brawley, seconded by Ms. Baldunday. Sir Objection. Thank you. Seeing hearing no objection will be on this debate until the top of the hour or sooner. Now, Ms. Gardner. Garner. Eva, go

ahead. Thank you. I just wanted to draw a distinction and do one point of clarification. There are two items on the ballot. One is the bond for capital expenditures and capital improvements. One is the levy. And the levy is a separate one, and that one is strictly required to be used only for classroom, you know, teacher operational expenses to keep class sizes down. So that one is specifically on the ballot. That one could not be repurposed for any anything other than keeping class sizes down.

All right. I'm next in the queue, but Ms. Baldunday, you can jump me if you want. Okay. So I have myself in the queue. I'm gonna explore more the assertions that were made by my friends, the municipal attorneys and assembly council. I have a few questions. I also would like to hear from Kate Vogel and Mr. Gates on the question of the duty to vote on the budget. So that's one thing. I wanna keep separate though the question of the municipal budget and the school district budget because they are two processes. Even though one says the assembly shall approve the both do one of them the assembly budget, what it commands if we don't pass the budget by a point in time is that we meet every single day until it is passed. There is no option. You must pass the budget. And so you can vote no and go around, but you are gonna be in a room together with these people until it is passed. It's a different matter than what the school district budget says, even though they both contain the language of shell. So I do want to hear both from Ms Vogel, deputy attorney, and Mr. Gates on the question. Because I believe that it was much too comfortably asserted to the members that the language of the charter it's defensible that you just vote no. I wanna hear other opinions and then I have some to add to that after that. Either Mr. Gates or Ms. Vogeling

Well thank you, Mr. Constantine. That's certainly not an easy question. I hadn't contrast it actually between the two they both do have that an issue sent instead the assembly shall approve budget and school district or the assembly or the municipality and that's the pre from direct vote to the body. So it's incumbent on the body to come out, I guess. And that's probably not easier to formulate to do in terms of the municipality's overall budget. 'Cause without passing if without funding to the end of the year of the you don't have a functioning government to provide essential services and so forth. With the school district it's is a little different without Mend to do it within 30 days or automatically approved. Again, though it's a duty of the body to do it and so it doesn't speak to a duty for each individual member to vote. So I kind of struggle with like I mean there's a grounds recall to do that. But the ground's recall among them is there's three and one is fail to perform prescribed duties. So it's prescribed duty of the body to approve a budget if it fails, but I guess votes. There's possible grounds recall and actually can't we I have not seen case law in that specific scenario. I'm not exactly sure how that would turn out. And in some discussions here, it feels like looking or we need some clues about how that might turn out. So I wish I could be give you a better response to that. But it's a very uncertain and difficult question to answer. I appreciate that answer.

I appreciate that answer much better than no, it's not a problem. Miss Vogel

Are you there, Kate? Can you hear me now?

Yes.

Okay, great. Kate Mogle here. So I concur with Dean that this is a very close call and a difficult decision for a judge. The state versus we call them lead case. Involve the court rejecting an impactfulness attack to the recall ground. Where the court said the failure to act. If that's the ground. Failure to do a prescribed duty, if that's the ground that recalls being thought on, the court is going to decline to subject that to specific test of impactfulness, which is what the state had been advocating for in that instance. And there the issue that was the subject of recall was the governor's failure to appoint a judge within 45 days. And the state was making the argument that the judge was eventually a judge was eventually appointed to the 45 day measure, you know, didn't really matter. Here there is a statement in charter that has a mandate. Now there's also a statement in charter that shows that if that mandate is not fulfilled by the body as a whole, it has no impact because because the budget will be passed automatically. But what a court does with those two things, the fact that there's this mandate, and if the body as a whole does not pass the school board budget, then that mandate has not been fulfilled. I think that's a very close question in a real in a recall case

case. So one last question for all the attorneys. What is the general kind of approach of the courts to questions of recall of elected officials? Who do they generally find is the judge of the

question? Truth here, I mean, they're certainly generally giving it back to the voters.

They're giving it to the voters. Right. That's I think everyone will nod their heads to that question. They'll generally agree that the voters are the judge to the question. Right. And so Mr. Rivera has lived through that painful experience. And so To me, that's the kind of logic model or the kind of crosswalk that I take when I think about it, because I have seen the courts consistently say, we're not the judge. The people are. This is a political question. And so for me, I think members ought to really read that section of the charter because the charter is pretty clear. I see Mr. Hurd is in the

cue. Mr. Chair, I just want to clarify. I wasn't flippantly saying it's not a problem to vote no. I'm sorry. I just want to clarify the distinction I was drawing is that there is an element of discretion that it the assembly explicitly has, both in the municipal budget process and in the school budgetary process. You have the right to amend the total value of the budget for the school up or down. So it's not a ministerial function. That was the distinction I was drawing between a discretionary function of this body where reasonable disagreements can occur, and you know, unanimity is not required in a ministerial function that is just simply you have to do this, do this. So that was the distinction I was drawing. Fair

enough. I again I apologize for speaking to that that plainly about what wasn't necessarily clear, but the bottom line of that question is really generally speaking, the courts defer to the voters on political questions. And this the language is clear the assembly shall approve if it doesn't. So I have a couple more thoughts, and then I'll yield back the floor. It was asserted by a member that we need more oversight of the school board. You don't have oversight of the school board. If you want oversight of the school board, you need to run for the school board. They are a separate body with separate powers. They are elected to do that job, period, and full stop. So if you want that job, get that job. It offends the separation of powers. When a member asserts that it is our role to oversee. The functions of that school board. Our job in the process is the budget and the budget only. And it's the amount of the budget up or down or approved. It is not to tell them they need to do it this way or they need to do it that way. I don't agree. It should be whatever. And we can all say we agree it can be more transparent. There can be more time. But it is an offense to the separation of powers to assert a right to oversee and tell the school board what to do. They are an independent elected body with all of the rights and authorities granted them under the charter. The charter does not grant you the authority to provide oversight, not offense. This is a night of attorneying dangerously. There's a lot underpinning this conversation. I'm gonna get out of the way. There are a lot of people still in the queue. I think probably the attorneys can take themselves out. No, Eva, you still need to go. Go ahead.

Thank you. I just want to add one more comment on the recall issue, which is that the duty and charter is put on the assembly. The assembly shall pass. It does not say individual members must vote yes. And so I think that if the assembly as a whole were to vote it down, then there would be more, you know, of a I think space for debate between attorneys over it what exactly that means. And if there is no effect to the action, is that something that would be the basis for a recall? Looking at the case law not comprehensively, but it does seem I'm not seeing cases where there has been absolutely zero effect, right, where the action that has been voted down, goes into effect anyway, as is the case with the school district budget. So I think that an individual member voting, no with the body still voting, yes, to me is not a close question, but there are often differences of opinion between attorneys.

I actually agree with that. Ms. Baldwin Day.

Thank you, Chair. One additional question for council. Since it w it was suggested by a couple of folks testifying that a no vote or a budget reduction would somehow send this budget back to the district for reconsideration. And I just want to clarify with council that that is not in fact the case. That is not in fact what happens.

Yes, that is correct. That is not what happens.

Okay, thank you. Couple of questions back to the ASD administration, and thank you, gentlemen, for being here tonight, especially for sticking with us so late. So it there was a question asked earlier regarding what it would take for the Campbell STEM closure decision to be reversed. And I think what I what I heard in summary was that it would take money. Is is that an a fair characterization of the situation.

Member Baldwin Day. Mr. Jacobs, would you pull that microphone real close? Sure Member Baldwin Day, I think that's a summary that that might be just a bit too brief. I think our state needs to provide a framework for adequately funding core services, which would then allow them to adequately invest in public education. Right now the state can't meet its constitutional mandate, which is one of the reasons why it's being sued.

Indeed. So I guess my follow on question to that would be what would that I appreciate that that there a stable fiscal is prerequisite for a stable education system. However, I think in this case I'm curious what what the dollar figure is that is attached to the Campbell STEM closure. What does that represent to the district in terms of the total funding that is saved or reallocated? I I've heard 2.2 million in fungible dollars, I've heard 9 million in a bond that would be reallocated elsewhere for capital improvements. Obviously, I think according to the budget book, it's something like 2.4 million in operating costs. Are we talking about the sum total of all of those things together would be what is required to essentially replace the Campbell STEM closure and the savings that are derived from it in in the ASD budget at this time?

Sure. I think the chair to member Baldwin, there's It was about 3 million, 3.1 million ish that was saved from the closure of Campbell STEM specifically in the budget, you know, you see it and that's based on the 2.2 million in the school bond reimbursement coming into our general fund. And then about $900,000 in operational savings generally tied to utilities, principal, counselor, office staff, BPO, custodial.

I'm putting myself in the in the shoes of the parents and the teachers who are sitting in this room right now who have heard conversation about charter schools assuming responsibility for buildings. And outside grants that have been secured to maintain programs and child care operations entering buildings as a way of maximizing the utilization. And as I imagine parents and teachers hearing all of this and hearing that when you factor in the increased cost of student transportation, the overall cost savings of the school closure is rather minimal. And in the end, it's that $.2 million of fungible money that makes the juice worth the squeeze. And that has to be an awful thing to hear when you've put eight years into building a program that, if we're being honest, is not simply going to be duplicated or replicated at the three receiving schools that are currently slated for these students to attend that that work isn't going to regenerate biosmosis in these new spaces. And I think what I'm what I'm struggling with here is that we're it seems we're making a really significant long term decision for $2.2 million in one time funding. And I understand very, very clearly this document, this thing right here spells it out with really terrifying clarity the financial situation that we find ourselves in with respect to public education in this town. And I want you to hear that I do I do not hold The current current administration administration responsible for the $90 million structural deficit. That that's not what I'm saying. I'm just really concerned that we are mortgaging an entire program for one-time cost savings. And we're not gonna get that back. And when I look at the map of Midtown, when I look at the map of my district, and I see what happens when you take Campbell away, when you remove that little blue dot from the Google map, it leaves a massive hole in Midtown. And that troubles me. That troubles me as a legislator, that troubles me as a resident of Anchorage, that troubles me as someone who put my own children through public school. And I recognize that we are all doing our dead level best in an astonishingly awful environment. Like, don't get me wrong. I cannot, I cannot in good conscience support a budget that does what we're doing here. Not because I don't support public education and educators and teachers and administrators who do the thinkless work that you have done of cutting $90 million, 15% of last year's fiscal operating budget. That is an that is a feat that you have accomplished here. And I can get behind pretty much everything that's in this book. And I'm really struggling with the decision to mortgage an extraordinarily well built program for 2.2 million in one time funding. And again, this is not a referendum on the work that you have done. This is not a referendum on my colleagues at the school board and the extraordinarily awful decisions that they have been asked to make, that all of you have been asked to make. There was no way that we all were coming out of this unscathed. There's no possible way. Somebody somewhere was going to be angry and upset. And so I want you to hear that. I appreciate your leadership. I appreciate that you have made extraordinarily difficult decisions. And I'm aware that you were asked to make those decisions on a really, really tight timeline. And that a lot of the ire that you have received tonight and in other public meetings should not be directed at you. We are experiencing the result of a failure of leadership in 2011 to inflation proof the BSA. That is what we are experiencing now. The chickens have come home to roost, and it frickin' hurts. So I will be a no vote tonight. I will be risking potentially not meeting my obligations in charter, but I think that it's worth it sometimes to say that the c the trade that we are making is wrong. And I believe that. I believe that the trade that we are being asked to make in this budget is wrong. On a grander scale, I believe that everything about this budget and the fact that we've been asked to cut $90 million from public education in this town is fundamentally backasswards. But I mean, any budget that asserts that 30 students starting in a second grade classroom is okay, that that is that's fundamentally unacceptable to me. But my no vote is is more than that. I think it is an acknowledgement. I want it to be heard, I want it to be understood very plainly as an acknowledgement that the process that was taken to close Campbell's STEM is not commensurate with the process that was undertaken for every other school closure that we've experienced here. This group of parents and students and administrators and teachers did not have the opportunity to develop a charter school proposal. They did not have an opportunity to try to save themselves because they did not have the days that they were re that would be required to do that work. I have no doubt that given the time, that is work that would have been done because any group of parents and administrators and teachers that will band together over the course of eight years to create a program top to bottom would bend over backwards to create a charter school to make sure that that program stayed intact. So I want to my constituents, I want you to hear this. I hear you. I hear you. I agree with you that this process was not what it should have been. It's not because you have. Leadership that thinks STEM education doesn't matter, or that what you've built is disposable. That is not what is happening here. I'm going to continue to ask for what I ask for at our joint meeting on Friday. I'm going to continue to advocate for a town hall at Campbell STEM that offers some of the clarity that we've started to get to tonight, and I appreciate that deeply that we have started to get at the why, at what happened at the criteria, at how these decisions were made and how the math worked out. But the broader community needs to hear that. I believe that you all deserve that. You deserve to hear how these choices came about. Even if the rationale is not great, the truth is still worth it. I will continue to advocate that somehow we figure out how to preserve the program that you've built because it's worth it, and it's exactly the kind of thing that we want to see in Anchorage. It is not the kind of thing we want to cut the knees out from under. I am not an expert in these matters. But I will hold on to hope that there is a way to preserve what you have built. And then I will continue to ask for the reconsideration of this closure decision, should there be funds available to do so. I do not want a hole in Midtown. I do not want to see the closure of a neighborhood school. And I believe that my colleagues on the school board feel the same way. I don't know a single person on the school board or in the ASD administration that relishes the idea of closing neighborhood schools, not a single one. And I'm going to ask for another thing tonight, which I really appreciate that the superintendent alluded to the need for a longer term decision making framework. Because this is not the end of the school closure conversation. We are going to be here again next year. And the year after that, and the year after that, until the state has its house in order. And the fourth request I'm going to ask is that we develop some sort of public engagement, whether that is a right-sizing commission that is made up of members of the public who help to weigh in and to make more public and more transparent this process, these very painful, awful, horrendous processes that affect our neighborhoods, and partnership with the community somehow. In spreading the load of these brutal decisions, because the administration is correct, there is not a neighborhood one that is going to put up their hand and say, you know what, we want we want our neighborhood school to close. Not a single school is gonna put up their hand and volunteer for that, but I firmly believe that if we involve the public in some of these conversations, we involve the public in the calculus, that we might get somewhere better. And we might not be doing it on 11 day timelines. I am so sorry that this is how this process has unfolded. I

have to interrupt. Can I ask for a motion to extend by just two or three minutes? The motion to extend by three minutes. By Ms. Brawley's or second. Thank you, I'll wrap up quickly. Is there a second?

Unknown

Second.

There's a second by it, Mr. Johnson. Is there any objection? Officially. Okay, no official objection. So we're extended for three minutes. There is someone else who wants to speak, Ms. Ms. Day.

Thank you. In conclusion. This is not where any of us wanted to be. None of us. But I think that there's more conversation to be had. And I think that there is a public accounting that can still happen. And I hope that my colleagues on the school board and in the administration will join me in doing that work. Thank

you. Thank you. And appreciate the members. The first time I spoke I was providing information about the S version. Now I'd like to provide just very, very brief personal comments. And also I will incorporate the wishes of my friend from Eagle River and incorporate his his comments as well by ending this by the time so this is a hard vote. I think a lot has been said already. I will say that I do intend to vote yes on this budget for a simple reason that I believe that is in this community's best interest that we support we support our public school, and that includes passing the budget. I understand all of the complexity. I understand very much understand the request from the community to do otherwise, but I think we need to think about what is the actual outcome of that and would it change the outcome. So for my part, I will also say this is one of the hardest votes that I remember taking up here. And unfortunately I don't think it's gonna be the hardest vote that we're gonna take. Possibly not by the end of April, but certainly for the folks who will be up here, we are gonna have hard votes like this because our state has a problem, our community has a problem, and that is we need to make changes to actually sustain ourselves in the long term. And others have spoken very well to that, so I won't elaborate further. But just to say I think this is not the last time it is certainly going to be a pattern that we are going to have to take up hard decisions with people who are angry at us, and until we make structural changes, none of this will change and this pain will continue. And I don't relish saying that, but it is true, and we have to look truth in the face. So I look forward to voting I should say I don't look forward to voting yes on this, but I look forward to moving this to the next step of the process. Thank you.

See no one else in the queue members may proceed to vote. Mr. Chair. Oh, Mr. Myers. I was in the queue. Oh, you're gonna speak. I do. I

was gonna ask the question, but since we're done with time, I'm not gonna ask the question. I am not worried about a recall, so I intend to vote now.

Fair enough. Thank you. With that, then I've got broken cue issues going on here. Members may proceed to vote. On a vote of seven to five. I think that's the closest I've ever seen the budget Yeah, we'll take five minutes right

now. So fresh one from palm trees ready made good. Don't stop burning the leaves in the background. So I was in a brief seconds from the least tree to breathe freedom. Some selfish Time I need for Give me true to what I know Give me bruise Wait all you fall across to get no bridge third No man could reach I pray three times a night Okay I'm nearing heart's I trend He's a feel And since nobody else can hear me Heart strings were following the tie Never was a sign To a line to the ceiling on the moon my strike Low G's low weight low everything cheap These lights These streaks my guy Too bright can't be my lenses Blue ball in the sky Keep turning on and on and on and on scared to breathe From my beliefs Freedom Me scared to see Too scared to be my own you see I know I just need some selfish time I need my give me true to what I know Give me bruise please Nothing's better than being home with your loved ones, you won't be alone When it's cold out you be in warm in your own bed from the storm Home is calling when you feel a drift It'll always be there and never miss Life has got you all around You never feel you got your feet on the ground Home sweet home Home sweet home A place to find some ease You know wants to come But you never know until it's all said and done You can stay home all night and day Rest in your mind keeping all bad thoughts away Home sweet home is where I wanna be Home sweet home sk Home sweet home be Home sweet home place to find some be Nothing's better than being home with your luck once you won't be alone When it's cold out you'll be in one stone Skip this pain the work you judge makes you a kid It's the like you're sustained It keeps you open And keep them talking about always You life on it with empty faces She'll never see again version of you you like Won't you did it Why don't you start me Why don't you Why don't you Why don't you Why don't you start me I need a little substance I sure is headed but I know it's going somewhere cabinet on the back to all the side Nowin Stay going on a pressure I'm flying over the key under these old cupboards Now I'm back in the bed Stay going on a cushion Sit back and watch the paint track Take time and watch the dough pressure wise I've controlled the buttons do the things that does on my time People in it Slowly fit On

behalf of Mr. Martinez. Social hours over Thank you, Mr. Martinez. Next on the agenda we have item 14.B, 14.B AO 2026-13 ordinance to Anchorage municipal assembly amending Anchorage Municipal Code Section 4.60.090 and 27.30.080, 27.30.085 to establish a review and comment procedure by an advisory commission for capital improvement projects within the Jug State Park Access Service Area. Public hearing is now open. Member Brawley.

Move to continue the public hearing to the meeting of April 14.

Motion to continue to April 14 by Ms. Brawley, seconded by Ms. Silvers. Any discussion? Any objection to the motion? Seeing hearing no objection, this item will be back for us on the 14th. Next we have item 14.C, AO 2026-24. An ordinance of the municipality of Anchorage authorizing withdrawal transfer of real property legally described as lots 235 block 72, original town site of Anchorage PID 002-112-62. 002-112-61. 002-112-60, 002-112-69. From real estate services inventory to Anchorage Community Development Authority Inventory. Public hearing is now

open.

We set 13 after 14.E. Oh. Yeah. So public hearing is now open. Anyone wish to be heard? No at all. Seeing hearing none. Public hearing is now closed. What's well the body? Second. Moved by Miss Baldwin Day. Seconded by Ms. Brawley. Any discussion. So I think that's Just briefly speak to it. Mr. Conson. So I support it. It's tricky project, but I do really on my last vote, probably on matters of the community development authority, have to reiterate, you guys need to start doing some things, not just collecting property. I haven't found any action on any of these parcels or properties that have been delivered to you that have resulted in a building being built, a housing unit being stocked up, or really meaningfully seeing people get into housing. And so I pray, I beg, I ask for you to deliver some projects with all of these amazing properties that you have acquired in the last two years. So I do support this. I just have concerns that it's continuing to grow as a property holding company and not as a project delivering company. So I do support it. Anyone else. Second. Move by Mr. Johnson, seconded by Ms. Brawley. Mr. Johnson.

Great event last year. She'll be great again this year. All right. Ms.

Bradley. If you look at the memo, the intent of this is that it's valid for a five year period, provided there's not substantial changes to the safety plan. And that is because the there is a public hearing required for discharge of a bow within a municipal park. But this is really within the scope of a safe event, well well planned event. And so unless something goes terribly wrong, then it wouldn't be back before us for a few years. Thank you.

So anyone else? Seeing hearing none members may proceed to vote. On a vote of 12 to 0, AM 144-2026 is passed the body. Next we have resolution AR 2026-55. Resolution of the Anchorage Municipal Assembly approving the 2026 tourism improvement projects tips and reappropriating amount not to exceed $1 million 600,000 from the Convention Center Operating Reserves 1 202020. 2026 Tourism Budget Office Chief Administrative Officer is $750,000 to the airway general fund. Office of the CIO for Alaska Center for Performing Arts Management costs $650,000 to the Anchorage Metropolitan Police Service Area Fund 15100 and Anchor Police Department for overtime to fund foot patrols and high tourism areas. $10,000 within the office of the CO to support for Honeybu and other tourism and 100,000 to the Anchorage Parks and Recreation Service Area Capital Improvement Project Fund 461800 for mobile restroom facilities. Public hearing is now open. Anyone wish to be heard on this item anyone at all seeing hearing none. Public hearing is now closed with swallow the body.

Move to approve.

Second move by Ms. Brawley, second by Mr. Martinez, Ms.

Brawley.

Okay, move by Mr. Brawley, second by Silvers.

Thanks. This is just correcting a couple fun strings.

Any discussion on the motion to amend? I would like to ask unanimous consent. Any objection to the motion? Seeing hearing no objection, the amendment is made. Ms. Silvers. Oh go

ahead. Sorry, just one more brief comment. Just to note Actually no, I'll come back afterwards. Okay,

Ms. Silvers.

Unknown

Second.

Is your microphone not working? There you go. So Ms. Silvers has moved Silver's amendment one, and we have a second by Ms. Brawley, Ms. Soris.

Yeah. So the purpose of this amendment isn't really to change the purpose or the focus of this funding. What it's meant to do is give more flexibility for APD to choose to address a problem spot in another area that sees tourist use. For example, if there's an area of frequent purse snatching on the coastal trail, I would like APD to have the flexibility to address that with a patrol. So I tried to make the language carefully so that it's the focus and the purpose is still foot patrols in downtown, but it adds a little level of flexibility for APD to address another problem spot in a high tourist area if they needed to. I ask for your support for this amendment, please. Thank

you. Any further discussion on the amendments. Any objection to the amendment? Seeing hearing no objection, the amendment is adopted. You do. Okay, Mr. Bond. Then we'll go ahead and take a vote. Or do you want to speak to it? Okay, members may proceed to vote. So it's already preloaded, but you can change it however you want. Everyone ready for the vote to be recorded. Okay. Members. We're vote 011 to one. The amendment has passed. We're back on the main motion as amended, Ms. Brawley.

Thank you. I just want to put some brief intent on the record. I really appreciate this funding and this new proposed tips or tourist improvement projects program and thanks to Visit Anchorage and the municipality for negotiating that. But like with many or really all of our funding, it should not be expected that this funding is utilized for the same purposes forever. And I know that is also the intent of Visit Anchorage, as you there was a letter from Ms. Sape in our inboxes earlier today. So I appreciate this. It isn't that these aren't important, but I think we have already run into issues where there's expectations that the same funding continues forever. And we should not be planning on that, especially in this challenging funding environment. So glad to see these move forward, and I also expect that in the future this funding allocation would

change. Thank you. Ms. Baldon Day. Just wanted to note that there are more hotel rooms in Midtown than there are in downtown. And so as I'm very excited to support this particular package of tourism improvement projects. I as member Brawley alluded to, look forward to Midtown getting some of that love in the next iteration of tourism improvement. Thank

you. Thank you, Ms. Sorris.

So I'm thankful for this funding and I support it. I'll definitely be a yes vote. I do just want to say, though, that it it's difficult for me to see and to tell my constituents in East Anchorage that we will prioritize and fund these patrols in tourist areas, but not in our neighborhoods. Our schools are in our neighborhood parks where problems arise. I have constituents in Unaka Valley who have been dealing with drug use and illegal activity in public areas around their homes for many months now. We've attended many public safety meetings, listening sessions and we found no solutions for them. It's difficult for me because I hear it said that we don't have the funds or the manpower to send out patrols for a time to curtail frequent illegal drug activity in known locations. I understand the reality of different funding baskets and how this is funded, and that you know this is coming from funds that are set aside for tourism uses. I would like to ask the administration to work towards finding the means to provide our neighborhoods and our residents with the same level of public safety by trying to find a way to provide for patrols to curtail hot spots of illegal activity Muniwide and not just in tourism areas. Thank you.

I have myself in the queue briefly. Mr. Considering Thank you. And I co-sign that, and the reality is with the fact that we're finally running full academies and getting close to what would be considered a full police force for the tax cap budget that we have, even though it's definitely not enough relative to other communities of our size across the country. When we get to those full staffs, we do get specialized patrols, specialized units, and we do get back to where the promise of what 2019, I think it was, where we had food patrols in certain neighborhoods that were out of the general funds. And so I look forward to that day as we get closer to having full complement of APD. These funds, as you noted, are directed from tourism related activities in the charter to tourism related activities. And I want to thank Mr. Falsey over there for doing the hard work of navigating this question with me to get these funds available to us at this point, because it wasn't easy, and I was really hard on a lot of people to kind of move the ball, but you carried us over the line and I'm really grateful. I think that you know our tourism dollars spending it on APD, hopefully we get our full compliment and APD can just do APD work and we can use tourism funds for other things in the future. So I really co-sign as well what Ms. Brawley said. These are not annual permanent operating dollars for these programs. It's these are one time funds. And maybe they're one time again a couple times. But please use your judgment wisely in making sure that the tourism dollars don't just become programmatic funding for one department or another. But this is exciting. Thanks again, Bill, for doing that hard work. I recognize how much of a challenge this was, and this is the positive day when it turns into something better. So thank you everybody. Anyone else? So you hear none members may proceed to vote. vote of 12 to 0 AR 2026-55 as amended. Let's pass the body, which takes us back to 13.A. 13.A is AO 2026-22 and omnibus ordinance of the Anchorage Municipal Assembly amending Anchorage Municipal Code section 1.15.150 and title two to update provisions regarding legislative branch organization rules of procedure and functions and amending AMC section 3.30.172 to update position classifications. Anyone wish to be heard on this item anyone at all seeing hearing none public hearing is now closed what's swallowed the body

move to approve the yes move by

Ms. second by Ms. Baldwin Day Ms. Bale

yeah I'm going to actually turn it to Mr Consent to run an amendment

so Ms. Baldwin Day you suggested you might have an amendment

Yes Chair I would likely make that a verbal amendment to unify the language of legislative branch staff versus assembly staff in a couple of places which I could identify for the clerk if that would be helpful

so the motion to amend is to clarify that wherever it says assembly branch it should say legislative branch I'll second moved by Ms. Baldon Day seconded by Ms. Brawley you want to speak to that's it self-evited just unify the language into one any discussion on the amendment any objection to the amendment I think on the main right Mr. Johnson you're not in on the amendment yet okay so I don't hear any objection to the amendment so consider the amendment has been adopted So I do have a second amendment

Mr. Chair I'll move constant amendment one.

Motion by Ms. Brawley seconded by

point of information, Mr. Chair. I apologize for the interruption. I didn't just have a constituent reach out and say that the stream, our live stream is down. Is that is that true.

Okay I am just hearing about that. And the good news is we have a secondary recorder going, so we won't lose any of the proceedings as we move forward, but the clerk says that she's working on it, and there's not much he can do right now. As you've noticed, we've had a few glitches tonight. And so but thank you for the point of order, and we're working on it. And we have a backup.

There you go. Why do we have to go to back up again?

Because if we don't, you're gonna get something We want to have a back up So Ms. Brawley made an amendment or proposed an amendment on behalf of me. I got a move by Ms. Brawley's second by Mr Wall. I can speak to it if you want.

Yeah, go ahead, Ms. Cost.

So this just speaks to the powers of joint resolutions at the joint meetings, the joint conferences of the assembly and the school district. And it makes it clear that we can act jointly, but each vote has to be taken separately, and for items to be passed, they need to be on the agenda. So essentially the same rules of a special meeting. This I believe only. Isn't Mr. Hurt is this only in the section on the school district, or is this in joint conferences as a whole?

It's only on there there is only a section on joint conferences, so this would apply to joint conferences. Thank you,

Mr. Vallins. Yes, it would also apply to a cleaner. What it doesn't do so there had been some conversation about narrowly constructing it so that only items on the agenda could be discussed. But what we decided to do with this amendment was we could add discussion items. You just can't add action items unless there were notice the public has a right to understand what we're doing. And so action items, meaning we resolve to do the following things. But if we wanted to hear from the CFO or the police department or whatever, we could just add that to the agenda. It doesn't prescribe to that level, only to the level of action. So any further discussion on the amendments seeing hearing none. Is there any objection to the amendments? I'm not seeing or hearing objection to the amendment. We'll consider the amendment has passed. Back on the main motion as amended So I will speak briefly. Oh we're meeting manager is broken again. Just raise your hand if you want to get in the queue, I think, Mr. Rivera? No. Okay. So or maybe we're back. So the gist of this is just a series of cleanups for the legislative branch rules of procedure and organization. I don't have a line by line kind of breakdown to go through it. I don't know, Mr. Hurt, if you wanted to add any kind of broad and kind of overarching elements. But this project was in the queue and being worked on methodically by multiple leaderships. It's kind of a two to three year project, actually. Ms. Broy.

I was just pointing out Mr. Johnson's in the queue as well.

Okay. So Mr. Johnson. No, I I'm pretty good. I don't I don't have the line by line detain in my head.

Okay, thank you. I'll say having read the breadth for this and especially the original version. Most of these changes feel fairly intuitive to me, but I was wondering if the sponsor could briefly speak to you in the S version the changes to section nine and the problem we're trying to fix

there. So let's see. I don't know that I have it. Can you read this section?

I'll read it from the AM. It says new section clarify the assembly's authority to delegate to the chair the ability to transfer unencumbered funds between categories within an appropriation to the legislative branch.

S version additional language. So there is some discussion about the way that the charter is written. It authorizes the mayor to act on budget transfers. And the legislative branch is a separate branch of government, so there's no section of the code that makes it clear that the assembly can move transfers within the budget. So the assembly can authorized by resolution that the chair has the authority to tell our friends at OMB move these dollars on expenses within our budget only. So it's narrowly constructed only on our budget.

That's the gist. Okay, but as I'm reading this as I understand it right now, that authority to move money within the branch

is

inherent to the done with the approval of the assembly, but this would be a change to delegate that to the chair instead of the body?

The assembly could delegate it to the chair, essentially. And so because our friends at OMB need somebody to do something, the assembly doesn't have the authority. That's at least how I understand it. Mr. Hurt?

Yeah. If Mr. Farina was here, he could probably Thank you, Chair. If Mr. Farina is here, he could probably clarify this more. As it is right now, the language in charter says that the mayor is the authority for transferring within an appropriation. And the way that that's read then is that if we want to transfer something within an appropriation to the assembly branch. We don't have the authority to do that. The mayor has to do it. So essentially if we need to move some money from the clerk's office over to the assembly council's office for some reason, or vice versa, the chair doesn't have that explicit authority in code. So the options are we can just have the mayor use her inherent authority to transfer money within an appropriation, and that's currently what OMB says has to happen. We have to go to the other branch, essentially to ask to move money entirely within our own branch. Or we could bring a resolution to the assembly to reappropriate the money with more specificity within the assembly branch and keep it all within our house, but that's obviously a much more procedurally lengthy process.

Then the Chairman. wouldn't have the authority even if the assembly did it unless the assembly specifically authorized so this just puts it in the code that the assembly can do that can make direction to the chair the OMB folks need a person to say like I sign the chair signs leave request the chair signs any number of administrative documents for the branch but in this case the way it's set up only the mayor can until this is authorized

Okay that that explanation is satisfactory for me just one thing I'll point out and I think this probably qualifies as a scribbiner's just to make sure that's on the record on page 19 there are three paragraphs seven, eight and nine and I believe in each of these paragraphs there is meant to be a reference to protested by owners however in paragraph eight on line 16 it says protected by owners I'm pretty confident that's just a typo but since protected could be interpreted a particular way I just want to make sure that in fact protest is one is meant there. I mean it doesn't sound like we would need an amendment but I just want to make sure that that's caught and fixed if that's good catch how it's supposed to be good

catch. I think we're all in agreement it should be protested are we correct Mr.

Hurt yes and just from a pure vanity point of view I just want to say that that's already in code I didn't write that.

So we'll well if that's the case then probably it's not a scribiners error we should make an amendment

We can go ahead and make an amendment now or we could contact the I think

it's better to make an amendment if it's old code because

then I'll ask for an amendment.

Ms. Brawley, would you or Mr. Wall? Mr. Johnson.

Yeah, I'll just say I would like to make a verbal amendment on page 19 line 16 to change the word protected to protested. Second.

Motion to amend by Mr. Johnson, seconded by Ms. Brawley. The clerk has the notes. Any objection? Seeing hearing no objection, the amendment is adopted. Any further discussion. Yeah, a lot of people have worked on this over a lot of time Okay. Hearing and seeing none then members may proceed to vote on the final item. Oh wait, you're on Were you did you have anything further? Okay. Members may proceed to vote. A vote of 12 to zero. 2026-22 as amended has 2026-22 S as amended has passed the body. And we're still experiencing some weirdness with the system. It's going in and out. And so it's possible that we may revert to some old school assembling and doing verbal votes with the clerk recording the votes. So but that's okay. We're gonna move on next to 13b, which is AO 2026-27. An ordinance the anchorage assembly amending, anchorage municipal code, chapter 21.05, 21.40, old code, and 21.50, old code, and sections 21.09, 050, 21.10, 050, and 21.35.020. Old code to clarify the land use review process for data centers. Similar energy intense facilities request in the planning department development. There's also an S version. Public hearing is now open. Welcome. Please take your name apart of Tony from the Oh, you already testified on

this. Fair enough. Yeah, man. So it's just brief. So Jamie Lopez D Sankers. So the one thing that I noticed in here, and mostly the entire document's good, but on page nine, that's something I briefly spoke to before. It's designating between a small and a large data center based on the number of servers. And so it is section municipal code 21.35.020 definitions and rules of construction. And you skip to page nine, and it's item B. A facility with less than 2000 servers shall be considered a small data center, or facility with 2,000 or more servers shall be considered a large data center. The main issue with this is you have no way to figure this out. It's gonna be whatever somebody's gonna tell you. Are these virtualized servers are they actual, you know, actual hardware bare metal. It's just better just to take it out and sort of look at you know the power requirements, wastewater requirements, noise, size of facility, things pertaining to right to light, you know, and noise pollution, just things that impact that you can monitor. Because somebody can just make it up and you'll never know. So that's pretty much it. Otherwise, great job. It's good good document.

Thank you. Anyone else wish to be heard? No one at all. Sing hearing none. Public hearing is no closed. What's called the body? Move to approve.

Unknown

Second.

Move to approve by Mr. Brawley. Second by Mr. Wall. Ms.

Prowley. Thank you. So anyway we haven't had a discussion about this. We did have a work session a few weeks ago. I'll briefly just comment that the S version of the U.S. Point of order, Mr.

Chair. My apologies. Yeah, there we go. A disclosure. Thank you, Mr. Chair. So I think as folks know for my day job, I honestly don't think I have a conflict, but rule is always declare. So for my day job, I work at the Alaska Center. The Alaska Center has not taken a stance on this ordinance, but this ordinance has been discussed by my organization, and I have been in some of those meetings where this ordinance has been discussed and provided process clarifications. I also understand that one of my colleagues did discuss this ordinance with one of the sponsors. I just wanted to declare that to the body and to the chair. Thank

you. Do you have any financial interest in a data center? No. Right. And then it's hard for me to get there. If your organization that you work for has an interest in resisting or shaping the policies, whatever that's pretty attenuated. And so I can't kind of draw a line mentally. Is your organization funded directly to do advocacy on data centers?

None of the grants that the Alaska Center has received are specific to data centers. Or opposition to data centers.

And is it in your job description description at the organization to be working on policies related to job description data centers. It is not. Okay. So with all of those things as a whole, I think decide that you don't have a conflict. Again, that the code says you will vote unless there is a substantial enough personal or financial interest. The interest is not substantial here. Okay. All right. So we'll move on. Thank you. So Ms. Brawley.

Thank you. I'll be very brief. The S version makes some changes to one of the well, the testifier mentioned instead of referring to servers to designate a small or large facility, it changes to a certain number of square feet, 12,000 square feet. And also says that even a smaller facility, if it requires at least three megawatts of electrical demand or greater, that it would be considered a large facility. So I can mention these numbers could change in the future with more experience, but that's really what it does. And then just a few other technical changes regarding what's considered a noise sensitive use. These were after referring or after conferring with planning staff. We also incorporated Ms. Baldwin Day's amendment, it's on page six that that she offered in the prior meeting. And then I believe That's all of it. And then I do have one technical amendment, and I'll just preview it by saying that in this particular ordinance we are amending old code because there are certain zones, including some types of industrial zones that would make sense for potentially would make sense for a facility like this. So making sure that those are included. So I will move Brawley Amendment

one. Second motion to amend by Ms. Brawley. Second of Mr. Molland.

And again, this is just amending old code, it's putting the exact same changes in what's considered new code now. And it was just left off of the original S version. So it's not changing the policy, it's just mirroring what was already there. Thank you.

Mr. Johnson.

Unknown

No.

Mr. Mare on the amendment. Anyone on the amendment? Any objection to the amendment? Ms. Brawley. Is that it? All right. Now Mr. Johnson.

Yeah, thank you, Mr. Chair. I think this would probably be a question for council. Perhaps. But I do see that in here this changes the table of allowed uses for Girdwood, the assembly. Thankfully. Recently, any change that required Girdwood Board of Supervisors to have an advisory role on changes to Title 21 in the Valley. So I am just wondering if we are procedurally correct in including this in here. Not to say I mean I my inclination is to believe that Girdwood would probably support what's in here, but I just want to make sure that we're following

code. Isn't there like a maximum number of questions that can be asked? We're actually gonna need amendment to check the effective date of the ordinance.

So I think the action probably you can do that while we contemplate a motion to amend out that section. So Gurdwood can become Anchorage's premier host for data

centers.

Yeah, I guess that is a good point. Mr. Johnson, so I appreciate you bringing that up. We the sponsors to my knowledge, at least I did not formally confer with GBOS on this. However, I would say that because of the situation that we didn't get to talk about really except in the work session, is that these aren't contemplated in our code currently. And so if a warehouse or an data processing facility or something like that is currently allowed in an industrial zone in Girdwood, I think they are at risk. And so the question would be in this particular case, do we want to we could amend it out and then have the full procedure. It's probably not likely that they're gonna build one in it in the next six months. But the alternative is to put this in code and then make additional changes per planning staff recommendations later. I

I guess since I agree with that, and frankly, I mean while I may be I'm getting ahead of myself theoretically, I do feel pretty confident that Gurdwood would support this. If we do take it out, I would certainly work with them to bring it back in. But you know that I tend to be a little particular about making sure that we are in fact falling code correctly. So I mean if the attorneys say that it is acceptable to keep it in here, then certainly I would not protest that decision.

Not quite ready to say whether it's appropriate and the question resolves around the effective date of the ordinance that created that power. It's interesting. This is very interesting.

Probably thank you. As we're waiting for the attorneys to review, I wonder if I could ask the planning director to come up for one specific question. This is also in this the consideration of Girdwood, so I'll let the attorneys figure out the procedural question. But my question is if we were if we made the intent to basically amend out the regulations for Girdwood, I know I'm looking at the last page of the ordinance. There's the use table. It's table 2902 specific for Gerdwood, and then it's industrial industrial zones. So would there be other changes needed, or would it just be removing this use table from the ordinance to make it not apply to Girdwood

Through the chair to member Brawley, if you would just give me one moment, please. Thank

you. Okay,

yeah, through the chair to member probably. I believe that that is the only change that would be required.

Thank you. So I think then pending the decision by the attorneys, then the consequences if we did want to do that, we would delete this table. And if we were procedurally unable to do that, then we would leave it in

the good time to make a motion to extend so we can tackle the remainder of our business.

So I'm gonna make the very unpopular motion to extend to midnight, and I can speak to the rationale.

Motion to extend has been made. Is there a second?

Unknown

Second.

Okay. Move by Mr. Riley. Second by Mr. Vaughan. Ms. Brawley.

Yeah, and members are welcome to object where we take a vote, but I will note that we have a number of items many of which I think will not take that long. There are number of rezons. And if we do not finish our agenda tonight, it doesn't go away. It rolls to another very stacked agenda. So I think if we spend an extra hour today, then we save some headaches down the line. That's the theory.

I would offer that I don't actually think it will take an hour, because it's eight items, and most of them are non-controversial. So I think that if it were an hour, that would be a very far outlier. Any further discussion? Members may proceed to vote. Motion to extend has failed. Okay, we'll be done in 10 minutes. I am going to direct the clerk, though, that the remaining items on the agenda, except for which one was the one you were working on? Which one the one you want to be participating in? We do have to take up the 15 tonight. Yeah, but which one is it? Is that what number? So all items except 14K and 15.A will be directed to the special meeting on the 22nd. And while we're waiting, we're gonna I'm gonna go go ahead and if there is no objection, take up item 15.A, which is a most pass item. Item 15.A is resolution AR 2026-56. Resolution of the Anchorage municipal assembly stating its conditional protest regarding the transfer of ownership location. Public hearing is now open. Anyone wish to be heard on this item. Anyone at all? Seeing hearing none public hearing is now closed with sold the body move to second. Move by Ms. Brawley, seconded by Ms. Baldon Day. Any discussion? Seeing hearing none, members may proceed to vote. 12 to zero AR 2026-56 has passed the body. Let's go back now to item 13.B. Entertain the motion to delete the file, delete the table.

Second.

Mr. Ballin has moved. Second seconded the deletion of the Gerdwood table. Is there any objection to that deletion? Seeing hearing none, Gerdwit is now deleted from the ordinance. We're now back on the main motion. Mr. Johnson. Ms. Brawley. Members may proceed to vote. Sorry, I'm making the clerk run a marathon now. On a vote of 10 to 2 AO 2026-27(S) as amended as passed the body. We'll now move to audience participation. Any member of the public wish to be heard of the Welcome, please state your name. I'm part of time you're from you'll have three

minutes. Okay Jamie Lopez East Anchorage formally collision. I'm gonna

interrupt Jamie. I'm sorry. We have to take up one action item first. Yep, don't go far I'm gonna read an ordinance a draft ordinance for introduction AO 2026 unnumbered an ordinance to the anchorage assembly repealing and reenacting Anchorage Municipal Code chapter 10.80 licensing regulation of the marijuana establishments to incorporate certain provisions of the applicable state law, future amendments to them for operation requirements and restricting update and clarify and restrictions, update and clarify municipal marijuana licensing regulations, amending AMC section 10.10.015 regarding records related to the municipal license applications and amending AMC section 14.60.030. Find schedule accordingly and find schedule accordingly and related matters. So moved. Introduced moved by Mr. Vaughn second by Mr. Brawley by Mr. Rare. Thank you. Now Ms. Jamie, go ahead. Welcome back to the Sorry about that. Come forward. No Jamie, you have the floor. Sorry about that interrupt. Oh, it's

fine. Jamie Lopes you think's formerly cool, which formerly on this. So unprepared remarks. Where do we go from here? So it's tough watching things play out in the city right now. People are being endlessly driven. I'm not trying to do the one trick pony stuff all the time, but I've seen different things this week. And so there was somebody who was hitting an age where they if they were not found within a matter of hours, they would lose an opportunity to get house because once they hit the magic number of 25, their opportunities diminish. And so they could not be found, but I was able to find them in 40 minutes. And so people are literally losing housing opportunities in this town, unless people like me find them. Yet nobody wants to pay for real outreach. And so this is the thing where you have to show up daily, get to know people within an area, supply them with things to build trust and relationships to the point where you know people realize you care and they're on your side. So aside from that, some other things that I saw this week, or ran into a lady at downtown on Sunday, and more or less, it was lady who was a cutty part. And she was in RV. And when I met her, I was like, How is this lady outside? Basically she had three dogs. She was in RV, and endless numbers of people, they have different issues, either mental illness, substance abuse, things like that. But no, this lady's crime was essentially not being able to find an apartment that would accept her pets. And so therefore her only recourse was to purchase an RV, and then she was at Cuddy, literally. And she lock her RV, go walk her dogs, come back, and you know, then National Archives stock got abated, and then she was at Fairbanks Street, and then that got abated, and then she was midtown. And so anyways, the short order of things. Sorry, once or twice in the period since and then Sunday, basically her R V was strip drummer. And similarly, there was another lady in Mount View, her R V was snowed in, and police literally showed up, gave her demand to move it, and that R V is not moving. And they've done this endless numbers of times over the past year, where they target people knowing that they can't move these things. Not necessarily because they're non functional, but because they're snowed in, and then they strip people of their personal possessions, and then you know, what do they have? They have nothing. They're left walking with no shelter. Something else I found out this week. So I found out that basically the leader of the Hope team is the battle captain 176 or excuse me, 176 military police battalion in Quantumobay. And so that opened my eyes. And it's like the end justifies the means for things that I've seen over the past year where it's not the humanity that we're looking at, it's results. And results seem to be doing everything. People are being failed. Please try to find other people lead the efforts.

Thank you. Welcome, sir. Please state your name on part of Town or we just have a minute left. So We'll have a minute. The microphone's off. Yeah, sorry, so I'm talking

about it. No worries. I just wanted to reiterate like a point of clarification that I said before you guys today as the founder, president, and chairman of Living Ultraviolet Inc., and not as the federal litigate. That you guys are seeing in court. I just wanted you guys to look at the colors of this room. You guys are to vessel, your people are to wine, and hopefully I'm the fired I will turn both the most radical economic experiment in the northern hemisphere's ever seen. I've been here since December 1. I'm not going anywhere. My federal case secures my right to speak, but my love secures your city future. The post has begun and will not stop until every heart and anchorage beats in the rhythm of absolute unmitigated sovereignty. Thanks.

There won't be time for assembly member comments for now adjourned. Thank you everybody.

It's so fresh where I'm from Palm trees ready made good fine Cause you was on your own time coming Don't stop running Burning the leaves in the back yard songs flowers and a breeze keep warning me the priest keep warning me Seconds from the least heart tree Too scared to breathe from I believe the land freedom the land for me Too scared to sick Too scared to be my own seal I know I just need some selfish time I need for face Give me truth to what I know Give me rules Way S great Changes But a while you fall across together No bridge stood No man could reach I pray three times a night Okay I'm nearing Hights I dreamt of High Snobody else can hear me Heart strings were following the tide

0:00
−6:10:55