Open Minutes is an early work in progress.Learn what that means

Planning and Zoning Commission - June 8, 2026 - 2026-06-08 18:30:00

Anchorage Planning and Zoning Commission — June 8, 2026 6:30 PM — 1h 2m

Okay we will call the June 8, 2026 planning and zoning commission meeting to order. May we have the roll call, please.

Anonymous Aardvark

Andre Spinelli.

Anonymous Aardvark

Gardner.

Here.

Anonymous Aardvark

Scott Pulice.

Here.

Anonymous Aardvark

Jeff Raun.

Here.

Anonymous Aardvark

Megan Mills.

Here.

Anonymous Aardvark

Edith McKee.

Here.

Anonymous Aardvark

Radhika Krishna and Brandy Eber are excused. You have a quorum. Thank you.

Next is special order of business. Are there any disclosures? Hearing seeing none, we'll move on to the public hearings. And I'll read the process by which the public may speak to the commission. After staff presentation is completed on public hearing items, the chair will ask for public testimony on the issue. Persons who wish to testify will follow the time limits established in the commission rules of procedure. Petitioners, including his or her representatives, will receive 10 minutes. Part of this time may be reserved for rebuttal. Representatives of groups community councils, PTAs, etc. five minutes. When your testimony is complete, you may be asked questions by the commission. You may only testify once on any issue unless questioned by the commission. Any party of interest wishing to appeal shall first file with the planning director within seven days of the commission decision made on the record a written notice of intent to appeal in accordance with the AMC 21.03.050A.4.a. Commission recommendations to the Anchorage Assembly are not appealable. Following approval of the written finding of fact. And decision. Any party of interest may within 20 days file an appeal by filing a notice of appeal and paying the appeal fee and deposit in accordance with section 21.03.050. The notice of appeal must be filed with the planning director on a form prescribed by the municipality. If the appellant is not the applicant, the appellant's notice of appeal shall include proof of service on the applicant. May we please have the staff presentation on case 2026-0063?

Anonymous Beaver

Thank you, Chair. This is a request initiated by the property owner to amend the zoning map for three parcels of land containing 1.63 acres. They want to rezone from Chugiak-Eagle River RO residential office with special limitations per assembly ordinance 85-198 to CE-R-3. That's a multifamily residential district. Those special limitations from 1985 are found on pages 15 and 16 of your packet. The department find that the three approval criteria for approval of a rezone are met, and is recommending approval of the rezone and a draft assembly ordinance is enclosed on page six of your packet. I'd be happy to answer any questions and the applicant's representative is here as well. Thank you.

Are there any questions for staff?

Good evening, Commissioners. I'm Jonathan Lang of Lang and Associates Professional Land Surveyors. I'm here as the representative of the petitioners, Shannon Amner Toms, and extreme heating and air. Thank you for considering this request. We agree with the staff's recommendation to approve this petition to remove the special limitations. These special limitations were enacted in 1985, and as you are well aware, title 21 has ch changed substantially since back then. Removing the SL will remove the primarily remove the requirement to install several hundred feet of landscaping along the north property line, which will be a pretty big expense. I'd like to reserve the remainder of my time for rebuttal if necessary. Thank you for your time, and I am available to answer any questions that you may have.

Thank you. You have nine minutes and 19 seconds. Are there any questions for the petitioner? I see no questions. Thank you. Now we will hear from the public. Anybody from the public wishing to testify on this matter. Please step forward. Going once. Going twice. Appears nobody from the public wishes to testify. Do you want to use your time? With that, we'll close the public hearing. What is the will of the body? Commissioner Raun, would you like to state your motion?

Thank you, Chair. I move in case 2026-0063 to recommend the Anchorage Assembly approval of the request to rezone three parcels of land from CEROSL, residential office space with special limitations to CE-R-3, multifamily residential district.

Is seconded by Commissioner Gardner. Commissioner Raun, would you like to speak to your motion?

Thank you Chair. I concur with staff's findings that all three criteria are met, A, B, and C on pages 3 and 4 of the staff packet. And we did not hear any public testimony in opposition to the proposed action tonight. Thanks I intend to support the motion.

Anybody else wishing to speak to the motion hearing seeing none we'll call for the vote that motion passes moving on next item may we please have the staff presentation for case 2026-0064

Anonymous Crocodile

Thank you Chair this is a request from a design variance from to allowed an accessory garage to seed the cross the gross floor area of the principal single family residential residence 21507 Twin Peaks Drive and Chugiak. The 1426 square foot detached garage is exceeds the gross floor area of the principal residents by 235 feet, an average of 19.7%. The proper is zone CE-R-12 SL low density residential alpine slope and is 4.6 acres in size. The building permit for the living area was submitted in 2019, followed by the garage permit in 2023. Which design is a designated as a child permit on the dem permit. A total of seven of nine public hearing notice were mailed in accordance with the procedures in Title 21. Neighbors of lot 5 and 8 provided formal letter of support for the variance. The reviewing agents express no objections, and the Chugiak Eagle River Advisory Board and Chugiak Community Council Council provide no comments regarding this case. The department found the criteria A and C are partially met, and the criteria B and D through H are met. Therefore, the department recommends denial of the design variance. The two criteria found to be only partially met are A. The proposed alternative achieves the intent of the subject design standards to the same or better degree than the subject standards. And C, the proposed alternative results in benefits for the community that are equivalent or to or better than compliance with the subject standards. If after the public hearing, the board finds that all eight standards are substantially met, including criteria A and C the department request approval subject to the conditions outlined in the staff report. Thank you.

Are there any questions for staff? Commissioner Gardner.

Thank you. I guess a general question about the context of this application. I don't have a good sense of what it means to I'm looking for the language, to kinda close the open building permit. And I don't know if the R19 designation for the permit suggests that that was from 2019. Can you give me a sense of the timeline and what closing it out means in practice now seven years after the fact.

Anonymous Crocodile

So when when he applied for the permit in 2019, so that was only for the house. I the petitioner can explain when actually the garage was built, is uncertain, but in 2023, he applied for the for the garage. So I don't know between 2023 and 2019 when the garage was built. And so that's why we called it 2023 like a child permit, because it is under the main permit. So for him to close the permit, he need actually be these variants need to be approved for him to permit that the garage so he can close the permit. The original one from 2019 did I explain.

Yeah, I have another question unrelated, much more specific and technical. I saw in the application that it said that the lot was seven or sorry, not 70. And I was trying to get a sense of how it did compare to the minimum lot size. I didn't see anything that looked like it would be 45 times, but I was wondering if you know what the number is or if that's correct.

Anonymous Crocodile

You're looking right now on the computer. We're just gonna tell you the minimum size. And we're looking right now for the

So the commissioner Gardner through the chair. So this is in the CE-R-10, so that's Chugiak Eagle River R-10 zoning district. The R-10 is the low density residential alpine slope district. So the minimum lot size requirement for that zoning district varies based upon the slope. I can look that up very quickly. There's just one other reference where there's like a short little table that tells you the minimum lot size based upon the slope. If I'm trying to recall from memory, I think it's like it ranges between one and four acres, I wanna say. Don't don't quote me without me looking at the text citation, but that that's about it.

I think I saw the table I wasn't sure it was in the right spot. But I see 1.25 is the smallest, and it goes up to 7.5 and what looks like a pretty extreme slope.

Yes, that that's sounds correct to me. Yeah. I guess the only other thing I'll note to answer to probably try to answer your question is the petitioner, I believe was in the application, and we noted in the staff report was that this is a very large lot and the So the overage might not be as noticeable because it's such a large lot.

The lot also appears to be very flat in the pictures. Any more questions for staff? Seeing none, we will invite the petitioner. You gotta first turn the mic on until you see a green light. There should be a button somewhere. There you go. There we go.

Good evening, everyone.

Please state your name.

I'm Derek Lampert. I'm the owner and the builder. So if about two years ago when I submitted, or excuse me, three years ago, I applied for the permit for the garage. It was an amendment to the original permit for the house. I didn't build a garage prior to that. So I went through the proper channels and got the garage design approved. Unfortunately, during the building process, I made a couple of layout choices that compounded and resulted into this 235 square foot overage. So that's what I'm here seeking a divine design variance for. I had no ill intent. It was simply a mistake that compounded. If I mean to be frank, if you can look at the pictures, my house is barely visible from the road. The lot is four and a half acres in size. And if you were to approach the house, no one would ever be able to tell. So in my estimate, I mean I will admit that I am in violation of the code, but I think in the spirit of the code, which is in my estimation to maintain the aesthetic of our city and the neighborhood, I don't think I'm in violation, at least in that regard. So I guess I'll reserve the rest of my time. Thank you for your time, I appreciate it.

There are any questions for the petitioner. Commissioner Raun has a question.

Thank you through the chair. I appreciate how you have approached your presentation tonight and talking us through how it came to be. I'm curious, if this specific limitation were not in place, would you have built a larger garage on your property?

To be frank, I wish I built a bigger house in the first place. My intent was to match the size of the house. U I looking back, I had to kind of recreate what happened after the design was approved, I had chosen then to what how I was going to build it, and I decided to use ICF. Nudura brand ICFs. Well those are extremely thick. They're about 16 inches in width by the time you get all the finishes on then in a mistake I built on the exterior of the layout line instead of the interior of the layout line. And when you do the math that comes out to almost exactly 235 square feet. So that is I think what happened looking back. I was not aware that I was in violation until I went to close the permit last summer.

Commissioner McKee.

Thank you. I have a question. One of the conditions if the variants were approved with to construct a driveway that's compliant for fire turnaround. Do you have any concerns about being able to meet that condition if the variants were granted?

No. And when I went to close the permit last year, I spoke with the fire department representative, and they have already approved what I've done. Thank you. On the as-built. Thank you.

I see no further questions. We will now invite members of the public to test up to testify. Anybody from the public wishing to testify on this matter. All righty. We're gonna close the public hearing We have staff in the queue. Do you have something to address it?

Anonymous Crocodile

Yes.

Okay, go ahead.

Anonymous Crocodile

Sorry about that. Thank you, Chair. So he mentioned that he already got the approval from the fire department. I just he needed to go back and talk to the fire department because like this design has been shown to the fire department and these comments is from last week from the fire department. So it is a condition of approved for these if it in case you approved. So he needs to get an approval from the fire department Okay, just want to let the end though.

Thank you. Very good. I W I we'll see what the commission decides to do. Commissioner McKee.

I had a follow-up question for staff. Is it okay for me to ask it now or should I wait?

Yes, okay.

In the packet it kind of it says that if we don't grant the variants, then the expectation would be they would have to demolish part of the garage

Anonymous Crocodile

Yes. Demolish a portion to get the his permit approv the project approved, yes. Thank you.

Anonymous Dolphin

Another option would be to expand the size of the house. That was my other question? Yes,

and I had one other point of information if that's okay, Chair. It was just because there's a the question on the minimum lot size, and then there's also a question of the petitioner about the special limitation. So I just I pulled up the ordinance 86-43, so that's the special limitation. So there the special limitations do actually include a minimum lot area. It's still a larger lot size. But the role point was just the special limitations did not affect the size of this garage, basically. So it's more just the regular rule in in code that is affecting the need for this variance because because the garage exceeds the size of the single family dwell unit. That's all just because I know we've been talking about special limitations a lot lately. Thank you.

I'll just follow up with one quick question. If the garage was not garage space, but considered I don't know, gym, home gym, some type of living space, would would we still exceed the code allowed size? Is the code because it's a an accessory use, or isn't it because it's an accessory structure?

Chair Spinelli. It if this was say it so a gym in that but it was still like in it was still in a accessory garage, then then yes it would still be in violation. So it doesn't doesn't really matter how he's using the accessory garage. It's more that the structure of the accessory garage is larger than the than the living area of the residents. I suppose if we're if you're talking about like square footage of oh, what if we're counting the like living area above the garage? I suppose maybe that's a different question, but it's really the structure, not the use. That's the issue.

Yeah, I guess that was my question. Is the code that prohibits the size of this garage directly related to accessory structure versus accessory use?

Chair Spinelli accessory structure.

Thank you. And then Elizabeth, are you in the queue still?

Oh no. I okay I I'm removed now. Thank you.

All right. With that. We will close the public hearing. The petitioner, you still have time for rebuttal before I close the public hearing. Would you like to use your time for rebuttal? All right. The petitioner yields the rebuttal time. We'll close the public hearing. What's the will of the body? Commissioner McKee.

I move in case 2026-0064 to approve the request for design variants from AMC 21.05.070D.9. To allow an accessory garage to exceed the gross floor area of the principal residents subject to the conditions shown on page four of the staff report.

That is seconded by Commissioner Gardner. Commissioner McKee, would you like to speak to your motion?

Please. I intend to support the design variance. The conditions are met. I think criteria A, that the proposed alternative T is the intent of the subject design standards to the same or better degree than the subject standard. I think due to the significant size of the lot, that the accessory, the garage does not dominate the residential lot. I also think it's consistent with the rural lifestyle of the district and does not visually dominate the property. The other criterion criterion C that says the proposed alternative results and a benefit to the community that are equivalent to or better than compliance with the subject standard. I feel that this criterion is significantly met, and that having an enclosed garage structure so that your recreational equipment vehicles and other things that we all like to store in our garages is in an enclosed structure versus open to public view. I think that that is a it is a betterment and in compliance with the standard. Thank you.

Thank you, Commissioner Mc anybody else? Commissioner Gardner

Oh sorry, thanks. I intend to support the motion as well. I'll just note in addition we didn't receive any public testimony this evening, but there were two letters included with the application from I take to be neighbors supporting the requested variants. And as well that there are photos that I think further emphasize both how the property, including the garage, is offset, not easily visible or at all visible, maybe from the road, and that when facing both structures, the garage looks much smaller than the house the way that they're oriented.

Thank you. Anybody else wishing to speak to the motion. Call for the vote. That motion passes. Next item on the agenda case 2026-0065. May we please have the staff presentation.

Anonymous Elephant

Thank you, Chair. This is a rezone request initiated by the owner to amend the zoning map for one lot from CE-B-3 SL General Business District. With special limitations to CE-B-3 general business district. Without a special limitation. The special limitations are outlined in AO 2002-129 in pages 15 through 18 of your packet. The department received two public comments against the rezone. The department received no review review agency comments in opposition. The Eagle River Community Council received notice and did not comment. The department finds the rezone request meets all three approval criteria for an abbreviated rezone, and therefore recommends the planning and zoning commission provide an approval recommendation for the rezone to CE-B-3 to the assembly. I am available for questions of staff, and the owner and his representative, I believe, are here to speak to on the petition's behalf. Thank you.

Are there any questions for staff? Hearing seeing none, we'll invite the petitioner up for their presentation.

Good evening again. I'm still Jonathan Lang from Lang Associates Professional Land Surveyors. I am here as the representative of the petitioners, Mr. Dale Wahberg and Blythe LLC, who have owned and operated Mile 5.2 greenhouse on the property for more than 2 years. The special limitations require a minimum of 13 dwelling units be constructed on the property. It's 12 dwelling units per acre, and the property is just big enough that it would require 13 at a minimum. Removing the special limitations will allow a lower density residential development to proceed on the property. Thank you for considering this request. We agree with staff's recommendation of approving the petition to remove the special limitations, and I would like to reserve the remainder of my time for rebuttal if necessary. Thank you for your time. I am available to answer questions if you have any.

Are there any questions? I see none. Oh no. Commissioner Gardner.

All right, thanks. One of your comments got to a question I was curious about, so I figured I would just ask it since it fit well. You mentioned that removing the special limitations would allow building a lower density than would otherwise be required. Were there other special limitations that you were aware of? Sorry, not lowered. Well, lower kind of density. Were there other special limitations that would limit the intended new use of the property?

So if you look at the special limitations, I believe it is right on page we jump ahead to page 15 here. I don't know that I have marked it.

I think they're I assume accurately on pages 2 and 3 of the packet we received as well. I don't know if that is what you are looking at or your application.

Anonymous Elephant

Yeah. If I could interject it's page 15 of your packet, 15 through 18? The special limitations are listed under section two.

So again, as you're well aware, Title 21 has gone through a lot of changes since this was rezoned in 2000, and a lot of what's here is kind of redundant or does not apply in the current zoning. So part of this is cleaning that up, but the major concern was again the density because it is a minimum requirement based on the LSL, whereas rezoning will open that up.

Okay, thank you.

Thank you.

I see no further questions So we will open the public hearing. Anybody from the public wishing to testify, please step forward.

Good evening, Commissioners. My name is Jeiner Leon. I am the Northeast resident of the name. The property here.

Pardon me. Can you spell your name for the record?

J E I N E R. First name, last name, Leon L E O N. And I would like to say that I already did some comments, and those are on the ones that I provided on page 21. So I'm not sure if it's okay and you guys had a chance to read those comments, otherwise I can just read them for you out here.

Go ahead.

So I have concerns about removing special limitations. Grading, leveling, compacting, and paving to hold a multifamily structure with parking space will reduce the permeability of the soil and increase the runoff and load on the already compromised storm drain system. Just this past winter groundwater overflow on the corner on Santa Maria Drive the Old Glenn Highway, resulting in very icy conditions. Actually the ice conditions extended to the sidewalk. And the Santa Maria drive lane lane and the old lane right lane. So driver driving over these areas requires street and slows down during the inversion temperatures basically turns into a very slippery road and sidewalk. Also adding any larger structure in this property will increase the vehicular load of an already busy intersection. We're already seeing this happening now, so adding any other structural see just increasing the already strong vehicular loads of the case. Reducing or removing the 20-foot vegetable easement on the northeast lot lines will result in loss of private privacy for the residential properties. That's one of my pro that's where my house hit starts, basically and the high restriction of zoning designation will basically allow for a very tall structure that will result in a structure of structural views from the properties and deprive them of sunlight, especially during the winter months. Class A improvement area reports require sidewalks. Santa Maria Drive is a narrow residential road with a steep grade and no sidewalk as of now. Added vehicular load traffic from commercial activities pauses and increases the risk of pedestrians and residents. So yep, that's all I got. Thank you for your time. Thank you.

I see no questions. Anybody else wishing to testify, please step forward.

Good afternoon. My name is Ginnette Navas. I am the owner of the resident that is the North East on this lot area.

I'm sorry. Can you spell your name for the record also?

Ginnette G I N N E T T E

Navas.

N A V A S and Nancy, Amy, Victor, Amy, Sam.

Thank you. Please continue.

Okay. So keeping the special limitations in place works is reasonable and important because the 20-foot setback from the northeast and east lot lines covered in bush and mature trees is a natural movement corridor for terrestrial wildlife. Moose use this pathway year round to feed and have safe travel along the neighborhood of Santa Maria Drive. This buffer landscape is a windbreaker barrier, hides the electrical power lines and serves as a physical, visual and noise barrier to the traffic from coming from the old Glenn Highway. Chickadees, nuthatches, magpies and Steller's jays and forest in this buffer landscape. Protecting these areas preserve this their natural breeding and wintering ranges. This property sits on a steep slope. Limiting the structural height to 30 feet that it is right now will continue to allow views and son exposure to the other properties, especially during during the long winter months. This property is limited to one drive access. Maintaining the current traffic flow from Tran Santa Maria Drive into the intersection of will with old Glenn Highway preserves a dynamic vehicle flow that helps all the users get in and out smoothly during peak hours. Especially during the winter time when driving conditions are more challenging. And it also helps emergency vehicles get into the street rapidly.

Thank you. I see no questions. Anybody else wishing to testify, please step forward.

Last name, Moore M O R E. First name Jim. I am a resident. Actually I'm their neighbors. So I live in visual distance of the greenhouse. I've lived in that property for probably about 10 years and the greenhouses is a location that I can look out in my bard and I can see the greenhouse, and that's beautiful. I am concerned if there is no greenhouse there and there's a multi-unit living arrangement. It would take away the views, especially in the wintertime when the foliage is not blooming and there's leaves blocking the trees and whatnot. But It is a bad traffic area currently, trying to get out onto the Glenn Highway from that that hill is pretty bad as it is. So my concern is traffic is the plan for someone to put stop lights in, make some type of arrangements for the extended traffic that's gonna come from the housing. And there is water issues already. So what the plan would be for that is a concern. Because I am one of the citizens that did call the city to come out and fix the ice this winter. So I do hope that that that to me there seems like there's a lot of things that need to be resolved before there's a multi-unit complex built in our neighborhood. And if it happens, it happens. I have seen rumors and reports that it could be up to five stories. They just built a new one behind the L house. It's three stories, and I thought that was a monster. So I can't even fathom a five-story apartment unit in my back yard. So questions and concerns for what the plan is if it's approved to build this, because I think there's a lot of things that need to be done to make it successful. Because right now it's kind of not. And you haven't built anything yet. So that's that's all I have.

Thank you. I see no questions. Anybody else to testify, please step forward. If that is it, would the petitioner like to use your time for rebuttal?

Yes, thank you. First thanks to the neighbors for coming and for bringing your concerns. Most of those were brought up in the online comments, and I appreciated that. As I said in my presentation, Mile 5.2 greenhouse has been on the property for more than 20 years. Loss of the vegetation is an understandable concern. The owners intend to develop the property and retain ownership. So they're not going to build it and sell it. And as owners of a greenhouse, they understand understand landscaping and the importance of natural spaces. It is their intention to landscape the property and to keep it as green as possible, creating a beautiful space to live. The petitioners intend to develop the property with duplex and triplex residences. So the rumor of a five-story building is pretty pretty incredible. But no, the intention of the developers is duplexes and triplexes. It's unlikely that these structures would exceed 30 feet in height. This morning I spoke with Anthony Anthony Winsor, deputy officer with the Chugiak Birchwood Eagle River Road service area about the glaciation at the intersection of Santa Maria Drive and Old Glenn Highway. He said the issue was with a frozen storm drain in the right of way of Old Glenn Highway, and the problem was resolved immediately when state DOT came and thawed the drain. Mr. Winsor verified the problem was not caused by the greenhouse property. Looking at the development of this property, stormwater runoff from the site onto Santa Maria Drive will be addressed when the proposed residential development is submitted for approval. Again, thank you for considering this request, and I'm available to answer any questions that you might have.

It seems the residents I guess it's understandable that they don't like the idea of a multifamily in their backyard. There's a currently a 20-foot easement. Do you happen to know what code would require as a landscape separation between a proposed multifamily project and the neighboring properties?

Yeah, the zone the property next door, their property is zoned ROI. Which is residential office. I believe staff can correct me on this. I believe the landscaping is just screening.

Anonymous Elephant

In addition to the landscaping, they'd also have a 10 foot setback site setback that have they have to maintain. So that's not really affected by the special limitation? So there's instead of 20 feet of separation, there's probably gonna be just 10 feet. That's pretty much it.

Did I hear that correctly? Are you saying they're 20 feet or just the 10 foot side yard with the landscaping in the 10 foot?

Anonymous Elephant

So the separation if you look at the special limitations, it speaks to a separation as well as screening easement. So I'm talking about just the width of the separation, it's gonna go from 20 to 10 feet as a as a prescription? Because in the special limitation it says 20 feet, but if you look at Title 21, and based on uses adjacency use adjacencies and current zoning district and dimensional standards, they'd have to maintain a 10 foot side setback?

Yes. Okay, and then the landscaping is also 10 feet? But within the 10 foot side yard setback. I guess the question was what's the landscaping requirement?

Anonymous Elephant

There would be no landscaping requirement as per Title 21.

No landscaping requirement as for Title 21. Okay, thank you. Question from Commissioner McKee.

I think my question is for staff. Is that okay to ask at this time?

Yes.

So in the special limitations it says that the building height is limited to 30 feet if it's rezoned. To commercial what is there a building height restriction?

Anonymous Elephant

So the chair could you give us just a second to take a look at that?

B-3, the maximum height is 45. Also the adjacent property is 20 feet higher than than where the pad currently is on the greenhouse property.

Are there any more questions for the petitioner before I close the public hearing? We will still be able to ask questions of staff. Commissioner McKee.

So you just brought up a something that brought up a question for me. So drainage is currently coming from the It's kind of it's flowing down Santa Maria Drive towards the old Glenn Highway?

The road drainage is, yes.

So if this parcel had vegetation removed, it's not going to contribute runoff towards the properties up the hill. It would add drainage to the old Glenn Highway.

Correct. And all of that would need to be addressed. Site drainage is addressed in the building permit process. Thank you.

And do you know what the properties the adjacent neighboring properties are zoned?

I believe that's in the staff report. On page eight. So immediately to the or north C E R O and immediately to the south C E R O and then CE-R-1A to the east

Anonymous Elephant

Just to interject immediately to the south it's CE-B-3. We just checked the online maps. All right. The heavy line. Thank you.

Are you done? I see no questions. Close the public hearing. What is the will of the body. Commissioner Gardner, would you like to state your motion?

Yes, thank you. I move in case 2026-0065 to recommend to the anchorage assembly approval of the request to rezone a tract of land from CE-B-3 SL, General Business with special limitations to CE-B-3 General Business District.

That's seconded by Commissioner Abaza. Commissioner Gardner, would you like to speak to your motion?

Yes I intend to support the motion. I think it meets the rev review criteria as set forth in the staff packet including for the fact that this is an implementing zoning district from for the land use designation under the Chugiak Eagle River Comprehensive Plan update from 2006 that was put in place after the ordinance that added the special limitations to this property. We received some testimony neighbors in opposition to the rezone, which seemed to go primarily to concerns about adding some multi-district housing to this property. I think a lot of the concerns can and should be addressed through the building permit process. Not something that really plays into the criteria for the rezone directly. And I also will just note that one of the implications from this rezone with respect to some of the concerns that we heard is that this actually removes an existing minimum requirement for housing density and will allow potentially lower densities on the property than currently required.

Thank you. Anybody else wishing to speak to the motion? I will just say that I also intend to support the motion. My main reasons for doing so is that the motion will allow lower density, as commissioner Gardner stated, and that a lot of the drainage plan requirements will be required by the building permit. We'll call for the vote. That motion passes. Next, are we good to keep going or does anybody need a break? Keep it going. Next up, case 2026-0062. May we please have the staff presentation.

Yes, thank you, Chair. This is an a draft assembly ordinance. So this would be a recommendation for the assembly decision on text amendment to title 21. It would clarify the review process for parkmaster plans in the Turnagain Arm area. This area does include Girdwood. This came to light because there is a draft Girdwood Parks plan. It has not yet come before the planning and zoning commission for a public hearing. It has been I know the consultant working on that project has held public hearings and has spoken with the planning department about it. And so that's how we discovered this confusing piece of code where it basically directs that plan and other plans of that type to go through a site plan review process. And so it asks questions that are very specific to the site, and it doesn't make sense for a planning document such as a parkmaster plan or the forthcoming draft Girdwood Parks Plan. I'll note that we received no objections from state and municipal reviewing agencies. And while not included in the packet, I do actually now have documentation formally from the parks and recreation department, the municipal parks and recreation department, that they have no objection to this change. And then I also do have a resolution from GBOS or the Girdwood Board of Supervisors. So unfortunately I was not able to get those prior to this meeting tonight, but I wanted to note that I do have that documentation on file with the department now, and I will include it in the packet that goes forward to the assembly. Thank you, and I'm here for any questions.

Any questions for staff. I'm seeing none of the sure I do have at least one. Commissioner Raun.

Thank you. Through the chair. Question staff in the proposed ordinance language. Item B one, it looks like in brackets some proposed added language such that the new ordinance would would read all master plans and any development projects costing more than $1 million and then in subsection two also see that mention of $1 million or less. And then jumping down to proposed added language in subsection four, items B and C are acreage based. You help me understand the bridge between the two, the relationship. Is there a conflict? Is there not? Thanks.

Yes, Commissioner Raun through the chair. So the first item so B one the so the brackets show a deletion. So that's so it says right now Any master plans and development projects more than $1 million have to go through a major site plan review process. So those brackets delete the reference to master plans. So that it's as clear that a master plan wouldn't have to go through that process. The rest is existing code. It that matches anchorage language for the $1 million threshold as as to whether or not there's a public hearing review for a parks project, basically. And then the underlined language that is the addition for for park master plan proposals. It matches some similar language in in Anchorage. So I suppose let's see. I see what you're saying. So it's saying Master Plancer Parks classified okay. If it's saying if the plan covers a park that has a classification in the Anchorage Park Green Belt and Recreation Facility plan, if it's classified as community use area, special use area, or if it's any other area that's that's not classified in that that plan. If it's over 30 acres, then it has to go to the planning and zoning commission. And if it's 30 acres or fewer and it's not classified in that plan, then it can be approved by the director. So basically if it still has that park classification in the plan, it would come to PZC. But if it's just like some other natural area that is getting some kind of parks plan, it would only come to PZC if it's over 30 acres. D does that make sense? Okay.

I'll just add that $1 million in 2014 is $1.4 million in 2026.

I do have one brief follow up, if I may.

Go ahead.

Thank you, through the chair. In item four A, first section of proposed new language, the wording is for all park master plan proposals. The parks and rec commission shall hold a public meeting. And I just want to make sure I understand the intent of the wording as it's phrased and would seek to avoid any confusion. Are we talking about the master plan in total or individual proposals within a master plan? Just curious if some cleaner language might be helpful there.

Commissioner Raun through the chair. Let me just pull up the existing code for Anchorage because I think I pulled that because it was the same language used for the Anchorage Bowl, but I can double check really quick just to make sure we're not adding any confusion. Okay, yes, I did find the language for the Anchorage Bowl, and I basically copied the language that is in the Anchorage bowl, so it's just applying it to the entire municipality. So that is why it is worded that way. I suppose I would suggest if we're taking out the word proposals in this, then we should also do it for the Anchorage bowl. I could note it as like a future we sometimes do the like cleanup ordinances or like scriveners errors. I can note it for that because it should be done for both the Bowl and Turnagain Arm if we take that out is my suggestion.

I see no further questions for staff. We will go to the public hearing anybody from the public wishing to testify. Please step forward. Seeing none, we will close the there's nobody testifying. Well close the public hearing. What is the will of the body? Commissioner Gardner, would you like to state your motion?

I move in case 2026-0062 to recommend the Anchorage Assembly approval of a text amendment to title one. Title 21, excuse me, chapter 21.05.040G.2.b. With you specific standards for Turnagain Arm public or private parks to clarify the review process for park master plans.

Thank you. That's seconded by Commissioner Abaza. Commissioner Gardner, would you like to speak to your motion?

Just briefly, I intend to support the motion. I think it's a straightforward clarification that tracks the process that occurs in the Anchorage Bowl that's necessary to remove some ambiguity in the code and I think it meets the approval criteria as set forth on page one in the staff packet.

Anyone else wishing to speak to the motion Hearing seeing none we'll call for the vote. That motion passes. Moving on, any committee reports to be made. Seeing none. Title 21 discussion. Oh, Miss Appleby.

Yes. I just wanted to note that tonight was the first design variance case that the planning and zoning commission heard. Those previously went to the urban design commission. The Urban Design Commission is a officially sunset and is is totally totally done now. So you will be seeing those types of cases in in the future and other other types of cases that previously had gone to the Urban Design Commission. I wanted to just note that and then I suppose there are some other items going to the assembly that could affect Title 21 in the future, but I to be honest, I don't really prepare to speak on that because I was focused on this other case tonight and just noting the urban design commission, but most of those items are for introduction at the meeting tomorrow night and then we'll be set for a public hearing in the future. I suppose that that's about all I have for now, unless anyone has questions.

I just have one comment that maybe we should the department should consider changes to Title 21 that would prevent the need for the design variance case we saw for the accessory structure. And then thank you to Commissioner McKee for your leadership stepping up on your urban design skills. We needed that and any commissioner comments? All right, last item move to adjourn. Move by Commissioner Mills, seconded by Commissioner Pulice. Any objections? I'm sure there's none. We are adjourned.

0:00
−1:01:59