(unnamed)
Meetings
Okay. You guys are one of the more efficient meetings that I've attended, so I appreciate that. So I was asked to come and present and do a little bit of basically an overview on how we got to the SPU ranking for Girdwood in within the CWPP. Is that in alignment with what you guys were expecting? I just want to make sure I'm not going off the rails here.
Okay. I'll open it up to some questions, and at the end, if people got questions about the flyers, I'm happy to feel those. But okay, so as it relates to the CWPP and the hazard ranking, so a couple of things. We through the CWPP process, we did an evaluation of the entire municipality, and then ranked those comparatively against each other within within the municipality. There were some areas that didn't receive a ranking because they didn't have basically enough qualification factors of fuel or whatever else in order to actually assess a rating for them. But want to talk about some of the variables that kind of go into place, and then we can kind of explain why where we and how we landed at high so we do an assessment across the whole municipality, measuring like about 13 different variables. And what we're really trying to figure out is is one, how likely is a fire to occur, how bad will it be if it does actually occur. And a lot of that's centered around fuel or forest availability. And then how hard would it be to respond to protect the values within that geography. So one of the primary drivers is is really fire behavior and burn probability. And you know, we use a couple of different models to actually rate that so different computer models and we take potential rate of spread, flame length, crown fire potential, and then kind of combine all of that together for a burn probability. Now that is if we're in burns. So that's how some of those variables get in inputted. Fuel really is what matters most, and that's trees and vegetation, right? And in some cases, homes, but fuel really does matter the most. If we don't have that, and then we don't have a fire. In in Girdwood, obviously we have an abundance of fuel. And so that that weighs pretty pretty heavily. Coniferous trees are pretty substantial fuel when it comes to wildland fire carries a fair amount of fire activity. Then you know some beetle kill variable gets kind of played in there a little bit, but the continuity of that fuel across the landscape and the geography is a pretty big driver. So when it's continuous and heavy fuels, it starts to elevate the ranking process. In addition to that, suppression capability is a critical factor, and that's that's not whether you have a capable fire department or not. It it's basically the abundance of response that we can get there, and can they actually make it with their apparatus or like apparatus to potential area where we would have a fire. So you know, response times from the fire station within Girdwood, what the water supply access would be for that response, road system limitations for that response, dead ends, steep grades, sharp curves, single egress, that kind of stuff, all matters pretty heavily in that evaluation. So you know, kind of just leading to even moderate fire behavior or relatively you know slower moving fire becomes pretty higher risk if it's hard to access and actually get to do something with it. You you're obviously gonna have ability for that fire to continue to grow. The values, homes, infrastructure, stuff like that, drive a lot of the consequence for this rating. So basically structure density with relation to fuel, property value concentration, and then higher density, obviously we get more exposure to amber amber driven ignition and a higher potential for loss too, if it's kind of nestled within that forested area. Social vulnerability is an evaluation factor for us as well. So basically age of residence disability, lack transportation, be able to actually get egressed out of there. It's not weighted as high, but it is a it is a factor in going into our consideration. Ignition patterns and ignition patterns matter. We look at where filers have historically started and have potential to start. Areas with higher ignition frequency will usually get a higher rating. And obviously you know, where we have repeat repeated incidents, so any type of wildland ignition starts to go in as a variable as a for consideration on what the ignition potential is for that area. And so we take those 19 different variables and score them on a one to five scale. Like I said, the social vulnerability has a little bit lower weight, but they're really grouped into categories of fire behavior, fuels, suppression, vulnerability, and values at risk, and fuels, fire behavior and response capability carry the most rate. And then we mash all of that together and get our average and then basically throw that in and then get our ranking out of it. So. Like I said, it's relative to other areas in Anchorage, like it's compared against the rest of the municipality, in our ranking areas. So like when you see something that's a similar type of geography, sometimes you'll see similar rankings, especially with the housing density and the potential fuel loading within that area. But really, this is a prioritization tool for us, not a prediction of loss type of tool. So I guess I want to really make for sure that we emphasize that. It's it helps us drive where we do fuels reduction projects, access improvement, ass access improvements, response capability improvements, or maybe you know, maybe some project allocation or road improvements or whatever else to try and get connections through so we have better access and egress for an area. So those are some of the like I said, the 19 variables that go into it. And really, as we're looking at at Girdwood as a whole, it's on the low end of high, I guess if that makes sense on our scale there's a couple of variables that are outside of our control with hazardous fuels mapping and stuff like that. As we were doing the assessment across the entirety of the municipality, we did see some discrepancies within some of the the most recent hazard fuel data that was used and so we're you know we're actively working on updating some of that information this is something that every five years we go through and we do another assessment we do an amendment or a rewrite of the CWP and update to it so depending on new products that come out and mitigations that take place and some of the development that could take place may potentially lower the hazard rating in the in the future as well. So that's kind of like a pretty quick overview of some of the things you guys are are well aware that you know there's a fair amount of topography there's limited access and egress not an abundance of water sources a lot of things that really type of kind of go into the assessment within the for the area of Girdwood so I think that was about four four five minutes any questions on any of that stuff that people have I figure we might need a little bit of time for some of those Mike go ahead
It's actually the reason you're in the low end of high. You did sorry, just to clarify.
No, what I'm saying is is it's we use the weather for the anchorage bowl, and we had a variance for Girdwood as well. At least to my recollection of it, and Jen may correct me if she's I don't know if she's on the call or whatever, but we had a variance for Girdwood where it was definitely a discussion point with consideration and to my recollection is what brought it to the low end of high. Again, the fuels when we're evaluating the fuels, we're assessing them with the expectation of burn probability with them, right? So we're not we're not doing an assessment and looking at it as is it a day that it's raining. We're looking at fuel availability and what the potential is for basically continued ignitions if we have a start.
The argument would be it would be higher than what it's at, yes. And unfortunately, like I said, it's a sliding scale. I can't remember if it's like five or seven points within the range, basically, of each element, and it was on the like I said, the lower end of high.
The the evaluation tools used, some of it is I'm trying to figure out how to answer this properly. Some of them are models that are a national standard, and some of them are like selected by the municipality or the borough or whoever else is conducting them. So like the fuel models like empty disc and different type of ignition models are a national standard. But the variables that were selected for making this assessment, and you know, inclusive of like social vulnerability and things like that, those were selected by the body. Most that that was a part of this working group. Now most of those are pretty standardized, but there is not like a cut and paste, like a different contractor could choose to use different things for their hazard assessment rating. And I don't mean to be vague, but this is sometimes you'll have a group of non firefighters that are conducting a CWP Assessment and they don't necessarily use the same tools. Now we took our fire chiefs, our suppression jurisdiction, state of Alaska Division of Forestry, their fuels people, their fire management officers, and also Dr. Jen Schmidt and some others as well, and put a working group together to select all of the variables that were used in deriving this model and tried to standardized it off of what the state of Alaska Division of Forestry has used and other CWPPs that that they've done across the state. So I hope that's a clear answer for you, but we used our suppression jurisdiction as one of the main resources for defining this, and then smarter people than me, and then experienced people like me to be able to select all the variables that went into this.
So I I'm happy to actually speak to a little bit of that. I'm a part of a working group that was that picked the people AWFCG, the Alaska Wildfire Coordination Group selected members from you know different various organizations and agencies to be a part of this working group to assess some of that potential with respect to naming different products that agencies are pushing out and trying to make for sure that we don't bump into any type of misinterpretation of a product or a tool used for assessing basically where we're gonna prioritize mitigation work or you know how we're gonna conduct response or something like that. What we have found, and like I said, this is people smarter than me and in a group much larger than just Anchor's fire department, within the state of Alaska, we don't have any evidence of someone's rates being increased due to an SPU hazard rating or a CWPP or anything like that. What is often confused is in areas like Oregon and some areas in the Pacific Northwest where they actually have wooey code for their counties, municipalities or boroughs where there's a lack of compliance with that mute Muni code or that wooy code, they're seeing rate increases. We don't we don't have a WUI code in here, so we don't have a lack of compliance for it. So we haven't seen any any rate increases due to rating or a product that was produced. I cannot speak to whether insurers are increasing rates because of massive fires like La Hina or LA or things like that, and it just a general scope of rate increase. But we have not nobody has provided us any actual evidence of a rate being increased due to any type of rating or assessment that was done within any of our suppression agencies within the state. Thank you.
Absolutely. So I appreciate you bringing up the question, Mike. So it within the CWPP, you see a fair amount of hazard fuel mitigation recommendations for Girdwood. Those are what you know the working group and the contractor assessed as needs for that area. I don't think they're necessarily wrong in any way, shape, or form. I think a lot of them are very, very good. But as far as like implementation, our process within Acridge Fire Department is we work directly with the board of supervisors, the community councils, the public that's involved. And we work to try and find at least a the right kind of medium for actually implementate implementing the fuels work on the ground. So you know, we have a pretty substantial cut up on the anchorage hill side off of Heights Hill. It's a clear cut for a single egress. You know, do I think anybody wants that in Girdwood? No, I do not think anybody wants that in Girdwood. I don't think it would go over too well. So when we get to the phase of actually implement implementing these fuel breaks, we want to take a real good look at what is actually needed, what you know what the breadth of that is, what the impact of that will be, what the true spec will be, and just what you read within the CWPP is not the finalization of what's going to be conducted on your geography and to that point the location either. The intent is what's written in the what's written in the plan and what we implement should try and model as closely to that as we can, but we definitely work with all of the people involved and try and make for sure that that we make a product that everybody's happy with that will still serve the purpose that we're driving for, which is a reduction in fuel or fire behavior or protection of a single egress or something along those lines.
All right. I appreciate it. Please don't hesitate to reach out if you guys have more questions and happy to present. Thank you.