Joe Busa
Deputy municipal attorney who answered Assembly questions on the public records ordinance (AO 2026-19) in February 2026.
Meetings
Through the chair to member Martinez, AMC 25.35.060C. This is ADC ACDA's own section of code says that they're not subject to Title III unless otherwise provided in that section of code. So my understanding that's been true since ACDA was established. So my understanding is that currently ACDA is not subject to Chapter 3.90, our public records law. And so this AO would not change that status quo. And then as to proprietary software, that was copied wholesale from the longstanding Alaska Public Records Act, and the administration of that act in this context is very well established. I don't think there should be any ambiguity as to the meaning of proprietary software in that definition.
You can always seek to amend a piece of legislation if the body wills it. I don't think it is necessary. I think the definition from state law that we're drawing on, that's been the definition for a long time is clear enough.
Through the chair to Member Martinez. The section of code I'm looking at actually says that ACDA is exempt from titles three, six, and seven. And I think the intent there is to make ACDA leaner meaner and able to engage in sort of commercial activities that a typical government organization would not be.
I think it would depend on the legislative will that you're trying to effectuate. No, I think that there is a longstanding definition in Alaska statute that says that look, if we produce our own proprietary software, then that software is not a record subject to disclosure. I think that's pretty clear. I think if you think it needs additional clarity, you are, of course, free to offer amendment. I just don't see the ambiguity to be resolved.
Correct. If there's a report that's generated using proprietary software, the report itself is a record under the plain meaning of the definition of record.
Thank you. So I think that it is fair what member Silvers said that it is difficult to estimate the actual amount of extra revenue that would be forgone by ratcheting down that $10 filing fee to the $6 level. If you look at 2024 numbers, my best understanding is that there might have been 9,000 give or take public records requests across the municipality. If every single one of those people had been charged a minimum filing fee of $10, we would get a certain amount of revenue. If you ratchet that down to $6, then it's a potential loss of up to $36,000. But as member silvers mentioned, there's a h inherent uncertainty in that estimate, right, for any number of different reasons. I'm sorry.
It's a potential decrease of the amount we would have gained otherwise, right from going down from 10 to 6.
And the other thing just to point out is that APD has, as a matter of practice, been charging at least $6 to process any public records request for quite some time. So the $6 level would track current practice at the agency that receives by far the lion's share of all public records requests.
Sorry, through the chair to member Johnson. I was just walking back up to the podium. I apologize. The administration doesn't object to the amendment.