Planning and Zoning Commission - July 13, 2026 - 2026-07-13 18:30:00
Okay, we will call this July 13th meeting of the planning and zoning commission to order. May we please have the roll
call. Here Scott Pullis here. Jeff Ron.
Here.
Brandy Eber?
Here.
Here. Megan Mills.
Here.
It is McKee. Here. Jared Gardner is excused. You have a quorum. Thank
you. Next is special order of business. Are there any disclosures? Commissioner Krishna.
Yes, thank you. I'm not sure if Ms. McGartle, who's sitting in the audience, is planning on testify today. Yes, maybe. But I just want to disclose to the commission that she serves as a non voting ex officio member of my board of directors. I have no financial or other interest in the case. And have not had any ex parte discussions about it. Thank
you. I don't believe I believe that you should participate. If anybody objects, feel free to make a motion otherwise. Moved by Commissioner McKee. Seconded by Commissioner Mills. Any objections. Hearing none, that motion passes. I'll now read the process by which the public may speak to the commission. After the staff presentation is completed on public hearing items, the chair will ask for public testimony on the issue. Persons who wish to testify will follow the time limits established in the commission rules of procedure. Petitioners, including his or her representatives, will receive 10 minutes. Part of this time may be reserved for rebuttal. Representatives of groups community council, PTAs, etcetera, five minutes. Individuals, three minutes. When your testimony is complete, you may be asked questions by the commission. You may only testify once on any issue unless questioned by the commission. Any party of interest wishing to appeal shall first file with the planning director within seven days of the commission's decision made on the record, a written notice of intent to appeal in accordance with AMC 21.03.050 a commission recommendations to the Anchorage Assembly are not appealable. Following approval of the written findings of fact and decision, any party of interest may within 20 days file an appeal by Filing a notice of appeal and paying the appeal fee and deposit in accordance with 2103005050. The notice of appeal must be filed with the planning director on a four prescribed by the municipality. If the appellate is not the applicant, the appellate's notice of appeal shall include proof of service of the applicant. May we please have staff presentation on case 2026-0080.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Since the sunset of the Urban Design Commission, the work and duties to the that commission were moved to the planning and zoning commission. And so this is the first sign variance that the commission has ever heard, in modern times at least. So this is a request for assigned variants from the location of a sign and the size of a building sign. The planning department in the staff report describes the sign, the issues, and finds that the nine approval criteria, eight approval criteria for a variance are met, and is recommending approval subject to conditions one and two on page four of your packet. In the audience, and I'd be happy to answer any questions that you might have.
Are there any questions for staff?
Commissioner Pullis. Just have one technical question. On page 22, DOT has a comment. Did anyone talk to DOT about
that? No. I didn't reach out to DOT about their comments. But it seemed a little funny because I mean obviously there are other signs on that street.
Page 22 at the bottom. It Alaska statute 19.25.105 prohibits outdoor advertising within 600 and 60 feet of the nearest edge of right away visible from the main travel way on interstate primary or secondary highways. Do you know what I'm saying? I'm not sure. I'm just I'll stop
in the question. Any further questions for staff. Seeing none.
Now it's on. Hi. My name's Kathleen McCartle. I'm the president CEO at the Anchorage Chamber of Commerce. I am representing the petitioner whose creative agency did the actual filing. Mish Madrano, I think, who's contracted by the Odum Corporation to help support this project. Adrian Velasquez here today is here to also answer any questions on this petition if they come up Thank you so much to this commission for hearing the application and the petition and considering the request. Thank you to the department for all the help that they did in answering questions. This is sort of a non-traditional request for our Anchorage, and we're excited to have the opportunity to present on it. The building, I've been president and CEO for almost three years. And I've been approached a handful of times over those years about wouldn't that be a great wall facing west of our building for a mural. And is the building owner interested? And I had preliminary asked questions about that, and he said he would be if certain conditions were met, making it easy for him and that the art was purposeful and meaningful. I was approached late last year by Adrian and representatives of the Odum Corporation. They're a member of the Anchorage Chamber of Commerce, the Coca-Cola bottler in Alaska, and Coca-Cola nationally has this initiative to paint the nation in honor of the America 250 year. So they have offered in every state in the United States to put up a substantial local culturally relevant local artist driven mural. And we were one of the first ones to get our preliminary agreement, and now we're a little bit behind the curve on getting the approval and installation. Some of them have already been complete, is my understanding, but what a great initiative to have this corporate sponsorship of amazing local art in our community. Beyond the beige has done so much to help with inspiring local art. But it is Cannot be the only mechanism, I believe, by which this is accomplished. To Rodica's point, I am an ex officio member on the board of the Anchorage Downtown Partnership. And also we co-serve on a coalition called Triple A or the Alliance to Anchor Activate Anchorage, in which our organizations along with Visit Anchorage and the Acquerage Economic Downtown Partnership discuss our correlated issues and how we can best align on resources. And that is unrelated to today's topic, but in the interest of full disclosure. So the Anchorage Chamber Board did actually approve the official support of this initiative. It's really inspiring to see the private support of art like this in our community. They're not without substantial costs. My understanding some of the other artistic endeavors are still seeking funding for what they need to be able to begin their process as well. Our building owners been entered into agreements where he's in full support of this. We have plans to intend to help with stakeholder outreach if approved to help with ahead of the project's installation, community engagement during, and as well as to celebrate its completion. But this is an incredible opportunity for a site specific design. I think you've seen in the packet. It was designed in collaboration with the local artist who was selected. There's a couple of designs, and this one really stood out to be impactful, draw the eye, and help with all of those lovely things we want to see in our downtown to help keep it vibrant and inspiring and energized. And I think that's all of my comments, but as we are co representative, I didn't know if Adrian wanted to say a few words with our 10 minutes.
Thank you, Cathleen. Oh, sorry about that. Cathlene said that very eloquently and when we got the opportunity. Please start with your name. I'm sorry, Adrian Velasquez, marketing manager for Coca-Cola Bali, Alaska. It's a subsidy subsidiary of the Odom Corporation.
Spell the last name, please. V is in Victor E L A
S Q U E Z. Thank you. Go ahead. As Kathleen stated earlier, she hit the nail on the head on everything that we wanted to accomplish when Koch gave us this initiative last year with the America 250 push, and to really it's a love letter to America and it's a way to express gratitude and patriotism and all the positive things. So when we were able to get identify the chamber building as a potential possibility and push it forward. It was exciting because these are the things that we want to see downtown. We want to see beautiful murals for tourists and for people who live here could take pictures and really take in downtown Anchorage. And I just I just can't see any other any other reason why we wouldn't want these things downtown. So yeah I'm if anybody has any questions or anything
questions for the petitioners question from Commissioner McKee.
I have a question for staff too, but so is the only way the mural could go forward is if it includes the Coca-Cola logo, just for clarification.
Yes, that was part of the criteria. I had to be a local artist and it had to have some form or variation of the Coca-Cola
logo. Thank you. And then my other question And I'm not sure whether I can ask for staff now or should I ask? Should I wait?
You just keep the petitioner standing there while you ask staff a question. You can always ask staff later. Okay. Okay, I see no further questions. You have four minutes and 34 seconds for rebuttal. We will open the public hearing now. Anybody from the public wishing to testify. Seeing none. I'll go ahead and do you have time do you have would you like to use your time for rebuttal? You don't need to yet. So well let's go with this. Now would be a good time to we'll just ask any questions of staff now before we close the public hearing Commissioner McKee.
So I kind of have a question. It pertains so there's an existing sign there already that's 144 square feet, which exceeds the hundred the 84 square feet allowance for an advertisement on the side of a building. Does is that signal waived, allowed
it to that sign predated our sign regulations. Thank you. Yeah.
Now do you want to use your four minutes and 34 seconds for rebuttal?
I'm not sure that I inherited the sign and I definitely predated the Anchorage Chamber sign on the side of that building. And to be fair, nobody sees it. So many people have been like oh there is a sign on your building after it's pointed out, but this I think would be I think it's tastefully integrated, and as well as the placement and positioning of the Coca-Cola branding as well, as much as it is included and mentioned, it is still fairly subtle and not too forward with a call to action. It really does celebrate Alaska and the wilderness and the midnight sunny
Thank you. Any further questions for the petitioner or staff? Go ahead, Commissioner Krishnan.
I just want to get at the bigger issue, and I think I've encountered this one other time in my career, which is that the reason we're here for a variance is because of the branding elements, right? That's what takes this from being a public artwork to having the entire surface of the entire dimension of the mural being considered to be a part of a sign rather than a piece of art. That's correct, right? That's correct. Is there has there been contemplation of updating our code so that just you know more specifically logo or branding related items constitute the part that triggers sign code review? No, thank you. Yeah,
any further questions for anybody from anybody. Seeing that you now have three minutes and 54 seconds for a bottle. If you'd like to use it, feel free. Otherwise, we'll yield it and close the public hearing. Okay, the public hearing is closed. What is the will of the body. Commissioner Key, would you like to state your motion? I
move in case 20260080 to approve variances from AMC 21.47.030 B, determining building frontage and building unit and AMC 21.47.060A. Basic standards for building signs to allow a 3,500 square foot mural and signage on the west facade of an office building as shown in the sign elevation plan, subject to the conditions shown on page four of the staff report.
That's second in my commissioner Baza. Commissioner McKee, would you like to speak to your motion?
Please. I intend to support the motions. The various criteria that were are included in the packet are all met. The proposed sign is a painted mural on the west side of an office building. This mural would face vehicles traveling eastbound on West Sixth Avenue. The mural achieves the intent of the subject design standard. Criteria two is met. The location size of the proposed mural will be the building with a fun Alaska themed scene. The commercial element of the mural is very small, and advertising is not the main impact of the sign. Criteria three is met, the mural will be the building, and this section of sixth Avenue. Criteria four is met. The proposed sign does not adversely affect the use of the adjacent property to the west. Criteria five is also met. The mural will not change the character of the zoning district. In addition. Sig are allowed in the B-2B district, so the variance is not related to a prohibited use of the property. The component of the mural that is an advertisement is approximately 29 square feet, which would normally fall under the allowed threshold of 84 square feet. Additionally, I think that the logo was incorporated in a really aesthetically appealing way, and that the mural is is beautiful and is a definite improvement to the to the side of the building.
Thank you. Anybody else wishing to speak to the motion. Seeing none, we'll call for the vote. Ms. Eber, how do you vote? Yeah. That motion passes. Next item is may we here have a motion to combine cases 2026-0085 and 2026-0086. Okay, we have a motion. Commissioner Pullis has m made the motion.
I move to combine cases 2026-0085 and 2026-0086.
And that was seconded by somebody previously that disappeared. Seconded by Commissioner Baza. Any discussion. Any opposed to the motion passes. The allotted time for testimony will be doubled. May we please have the staff presentation on cases 2026-0085 and 0086?
Thank you, Chair. These are requests initiated by the owner to amend the comprehensive land use plan map and the zoning map for one parcel. Case 2026-0085 amends the land use designation for the parcel from compact mixed residential medium to town center. Case 226-0086 amends the zoning map for the same parcel from R five, low density residential district to B three, general business district. The planning and zoning commission will provide a recommendation to the assembly for these requests through resolution. The assembly is the decision making body for rezonings and comprehensive plan map amendments. The department received no public comments against the rezoning and the comprehensive plan map amendment? The department received no reviewing agency comments in opposition either. The Abitloop Committee Council received notice and did not comment. The department finds the rezon request and the comprehensive plan map amendment request meet all approval criteria. And therefore recommends the planning and zoning commission provide an approval recommendation for the comprehensive plan map amendment to town center and the rezone request to be three to the assembly. I am available for questions of staff, and the owner and his representative are here tonight to speak on the presenter's behalf. Thank you.
I saw in the application that the current use of the site is residential. And I see that single family residential is not a permitted use in B three. So I'm just wondering if that if there is a single family resonance on that lot and if that poses any complications to this
case. Given the circumstances of the nearby corridor, it made sense to support the rezone two the B three district and I think there's been some internal discussions in the department as well to I think there have been some international discussions in the department as well to think about approving single family residential in B three. So I think Daniel is trying to speak to that. I'm not sure. But I do want to speak through my mic?
Daniel McConfas for long range planning. Yeah, we have looked at this because as you know, this commission has seen a number of rezones and land use plan changes in this area. And we've really been looking at it, and it does seem to be that when the land use plan was done, it didn't really maybe consider Abbott as a corridor in the way that people make land use decisions based on the road design alongside it. We talked about this a little bit last month, I think, when we talked about the work session for B-3. And people do make decisions based on the design of a road, the expected carrying capacity of a road. And since we've seen so much interest and a lot of conversions to B-3 in this area, to us, you know, if you have a one off, maybe it's a one-time problem, but if you see it a couple times, it's a trend, and then the trend probably should be addressed with some higher level policy guidance. So we're looking at talking a bit more with Abbot Loop about what they foresee for this area or maybe with that community council. But again, if the community council, at least from our perspective, the community council didn't express any concern about this, I think they maybe kind of see that too. And in long range, we did meet with a few representatives from Abbott Loop a month or so ago. And they were kind of asking, you know, what's going on down here? And we had a long a really good long discussion about it. So from our perspective, yeah, it does look like something's changing there, and maybe what the reality of what's happening in the ground is different from what the plan, I imagine, in 2040. So that's why we didn't see a reason to object to this. And some of the others in that area have also been approved. So it could just be that, you know, the way that the quarter-long Abbott is going to be a little bit different than people expected in 2017 and the 2040 Land use
plan. And through the chair to Commissioner Krishna, if you don't mind me jumping in as well. To answer your question, it does create a situation in which that residents becomes a legal nonconforming use on the site. So there would be complications if they wanted to expand on the building. But since the property owner requesting this rezone. We did not see any reason to object.
Thank you. Any other questions for staff? Seeing none, invite the petitioner up for their presentation.
Hello, I'm the partitioners representative, Kate Sove, S A U V E. Thank you for your time. Staff did a great job on this. This is supported by staff. There's no objections by any of the agencies. I think this is pretty straightforward, and I'm just here for any questions that you might have.
Any questions for the petitioner? I see none. You have 19 minutes and 49 seconds. It's like a new record. Thank you. Anyone from the public wishing to testify, please step forward. Hearing none, we'll go back to the petition. Hearing none. Would you like to use your time for rebuttal? Yielded the time for rebuttal. Close the public hearing. What is the will of the body?
My move in case 2026-0085 to recommended anchorage assembly approval of a comprehensive plan amendment. To change the land use designation in the Anchorage 2040 land use plan from compact mixed residential medium to town center.
You that's seconded by Commissioner Ron. Commissioner Pullis, would you like to speak to your motion?
Yeah, I intend to support the motion. I know the area pretty well. The site is an appropriate distance from Abbott Road to be considered a buffer to what is becoming a denser residential and mixed use area. It meets the seven approval criteria for the comp plan amendments as noted in the packet. We also heard no public or agency opposition to the amendments. Thank you. Anybody else wishing
to speak to the motion. Hearing none, we'll call for the vote. Ms. Eber, how do you vote? Yeah. Thank you. That motion passes. Now we'll be looking for a second motion for case 2026-86.
Commissioner Pullis, would you like to state your motion? Yeah, I move in case 226-0086 to recommend to the anchorage assembly approval of the rezone of one parcel of land from R five district to B-3 district.
That's seconded by Commissioner Mills. Commissioner Pullis, would you like to speak to your motion?
Yeah, I intend to support the motion for basically the same reasons I supported the comp plan amendment. The site is appropriate distance from Abbott Road to be considered a buffer to what is becoming a denser residential and mixed use area. It meets the nine approval criteria for the rezone as noted in the findings, and we heard no public or agency opposition to the amendment.
Thank you. Anybody else wishing to speak to the motion. Call for the vote. Ms. Eber, how do you vote? Yeah. Thank you. That motion passes. Now we will move on to unfinished business the public hearing in cases 2026-0034 and 2026-0035 are still open. Those who testified during the April 13th meeting may testify again.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Daniel McKenna Foster long range planning. These are the B-3 cases. We've been talking about them a bit over the past few months, and they've been in items discussion at the assembly since last summer. So I'll just give a quick overview. I don't think we made any changes since we last spoke. And I'll do I'll provide this presentation is pretty much about both of them. And I do include a summary of what I gleaned from the discussion during the work session. So please correct me if I'm wrong on that. And in my recollection, the last time the commission talked about this, there was some talk about maybe bringing some amendments forward or some proposals for changes. So we're glad to talk about that. So we have again PC case 2026-34 review and amendments to AO 2025-63, which was introduced by the assembly last summer. This is the stick and PCC case 2026-0035 expanded uses in B-3 and simplifying the definition of mixed use. This is the carrot, more specifically, case 34 changes the purpose statement of B-3, limits self-storage, storage yard and large parking lots to conditional rather than permitted uses. And that's only as a standalone use, that's not as an accessory use. So if you're building something and you're putting parking on site, that's not restricted in this way. And case 2026-35 is expanding uses in B-3, simplifying the definition of mixed use, allow all forms of housing in B-3. This was sort of trying to aim for the shop house concept. Clean up the definition of mixed use and eliminate lot size and restrictions on the number of structures in B-3. So what problems were these proposals trying to solve? Discourage car centered uses in B-3. There's been a lot of talk about that, and how B-3 is an urban zone and urban areas, we want you know, more stuff like human centered uses. Encourage more housing, more flexibility in housing in B-3, maintain a balance of zoning that supports light industrial commercial uses or businesses, and meeting the intent of the sponsors. So as everybody here recalls, and maybe people in the audience remember, there's a lot of discussion about what we're looking for in this, and there've been a lot of pieces to it. So that's why it's a pretty all encompassing set of ordinances. So timeline again, just for reference. In spring 2025, the assembly introduced 2025-63. In the summer of 2025, the assembly referred that AO to the planning zoning commission. In autumn of 2025, there were more discussions with the sponsors, and we're trying to, you know, understand what people were looking for. April 13 at the PCC meeting, this commission had discussion and referred to a work session. And then we had a work session on June 1, 2026, and then today's planning zone commission meeting on July 13. In April, the questions were about potential potential effects, qu questions about parking on separate lots, business development, data on how many properties this would affect, and uses for conditional as well as locations. On the June work session discussion, there was a lot more. So forgive me, it's a wall of text here. But the commission talked about how much of B-3 is currently being used for vehicle storage or parking lots, B-3 zoning and how to protect what makes it an attractive zone. I think it was something like let's not kill the golden goose or let's not ruin the things that have made this successful. The role of street design and road planning and Jason land use, especially in town center areas. Sort of contrast of road design versus how adjacent land is zoned, how certain areas of B-3 seem appropriate for vehicle centered uses, like old Seward, for example. Well, other places zone B-3 seem more appropriate for more urban uses, like Sponard Road, for example. And we talked about affecting this through changes to a B-3 overall. You could do a specific overlay, you could do a new type of B-3, you could do Use specific standards, own specific standards. I don't think we got anywhere in particular in that, but it was a good discussion. And then parking lots versus parking garages as an accessory and primary use and desire to avoid removing the parts of B-3 that make successful tract for businesses. This one is if you recall, there's some sort of cleanup pieces we need to do in the code that would distinguish between a parking lot or a parking structure in some places. We also got a comment, too, that recommended separating it out by the number of spaces. These are ideas we're interested in, and I think we're gonna try to address them maybe through the omnibus ordinance. We just didn't want to get it too much into this because it would be a bit too complicated. Once we start changing the use table, so you know, say right now we have parking lot or structure as a use. Once we start saying parking lot or structure zero to 10, 10 to 25, then it changes the entire use table. It changes all sorts of zoning. And although it wouldn't be a huge change, it would just sort of be a little bit bigger than what this the it would get a little off topic from what the B-3 was. So that was a great comment. And in the comment the discussions we had here, we were taking that under advisement. I think we're gonna try and do that through the omnibus too or something like that. All the points are really good. It would help clarify things. There was some talk last time about where travel behavior is heading, you know, some observations that it seems that most people want to drive, and then other observations that a lot of people want an alternative. And then the link between housing infrastructure, the budget, long term sustainability, financial sustainability, and then the potential for additional amendments at this next meet PCC meeting tonight, when this case returns. So we'll be happy to hear about that. So this again, we saw this before. It was just sort of looking at
where
different types of existing uses would become conditional, whereas now they're permitted. So this is just showing in the I-1, B-3, I-2 districts how many lots there are with that designation, at least according to the assessor data. This is parking lots, 50 spaces surface 50 more or more spaces. And just show where many of them are. So this is would also be a conditional use. Again, if the code change if you have an existing use then if it's illegal when it was built it has nonconforming rights. And then I believe this was parking lots 50 plus spaces as a structure and most of them they're all downtown. So these are in the B-2 zones and the B three again B-2 zones are only downtown and what this these ordinances are looking at or these proposals are looking at are B-2. Excuse me, are B-3, not B-2A and sorry this there's one at the airport in the TR zone So again just an old slide just remembering how we got here years ago there was a lot of talk about car washes and then about garage condos. And so I think that's just sort of where a lot of this came from so comments general supporter no objection one comment stating making larger parking lots condition used could affect development. And then after the last meeting comment about splitting out types of parking lots in the use table. This is where most of the B-3 zoning is now so if there was a change, these are the areas that would be affected. And with that, I'll leave it open for any questions or comments or anything else
questions for staff
Commissioner Ricky. So if it were a conditional use permit and let's say a developer had multiple parcels and they were building buildings and one of their parcels they're using for parking how much time would go a conditional use permitting process add to them? being able to develop multiple parcels
through the chair I think a conditional use permit takes what about six months maybe is that generally because you apply and then it takes a couple months to get it on PCC and conditional use has to be approved by the planning zoning commission if I'm not mistaken not the assembly probably I would say three to six months to do that
commissioner Pullis on page 14 when we're rewriting the purpose it's like the second sentence and it says these uses are intended to be located on primary transportation corridors and we got rid of arterials is there a definition of primary transportation corridors are we trying to be kind of general in that description
through the chair I think that language came from vice chair voland if I'm not mistaken I think it came from the assembly in particular in terms of do we have a definition of primary transportation corridors? I don't think we do maybe it's something we could look at in the upcoming official streets and highways plan but I don't I think that was more of a descriptive description rather than a technical description but that is language that we got from assembly members. Okay?
So I heard you say that this memorandum would not change existing properties or existing buildings. It would just impact future development and my question is what type of project or work on a existing property would
Through the chair. Do you mean like in in what case might this make things a little bit more complicated
or I understood you saying that the site would is like legal nonconforming in the event that this passes. What type of construction or work at a property would risk the property losing that status?
Through the chair and I hope the director will help me on this, because we did just make some changes to the nonconformities code. But traditionally it was that if you had a nonconforming use, as long as you didn't expand the use significantly, you could keep operating. So if you had to do basic sort of changes.
Seeing none We'll continue the public testimony. Anybody from the public wishing to testify, please step forward. Seeing none of it We'll go to the staff rebuttal. No, Chair, thank you. But I do have another I think I have another question.
We're glad for more questions. We're glad for recommendations or proposals to make changes. I think as we'll saw the chair of the assembly was here last time explaining that they really are interested in anybody's insights.
Commissioner Mills.
I wanted to ask about the B-3 zoning. Just the definition of the B-3 zoning kind of link back to auto-oriented uses, and it specifically says meeting the needs of auto-related and other auto-related uses. And then it also comes back to say that it accommodates personal mobility and other forms. And I guess just a little bit of clarity.
Thank you. Yeah, I think you've you've identified which is a pretty big, you know, most of the time we're focused on dimensional standards and the specifics of what might get built, but that change the purpose statement, I think is pretty significant. And that was policy direction we got. And it is different from what it traditionally has been. From from what I understand looking back through, you know, the years of the files is B three was always sort of understand stood to be a along big roads. And then the piece about you know facilitating mobility in other forms was maybe a sort of compromise or was added in when they were working on the new Title 21. And that's always maybe sort of been a bit of a just a compromise that didn't do that much. And with this change change of this purpose statement, it really would be taking a new direction different from what the municipality has taken. That's why from our per, you know, that language came from the assembly. And from our perspective, we were still thinking, well, there are places where B three, like an old seward, is pretty auto-centered and is gonna stay auto-centered, and it's very useful for that. There are other places it's not, like at Spinard. So I think you've identified what's a major policy change, significant policy change. In terms of how that actually changes things, that kind of comes down to questions of uncertainty. If it's you can go one way or the other, yeah, in the future it could be that if this commission had to make a decision of maybe approving a conditional use or something else, that purpose statement then could weigh into that. So really I think the big question here is Anchorage urbanizing or is Anchorage becoming maybe a place with slightly different travel patterns or not. And if it's not, I mean, that's okay too, but this is also a purpose statement that's saying that's what the intent the municipality is changing, sort of the idea of B three could be something different in the future than it's been the past. So just again, it's a it's a big policy question and a departure from probably the last 10, 20
years. I just kind of have a comment or I'm not sure if it's a question, but Keeping arterials is like it's that's like a defined roadway classification. We're saying primary transportation quarters is up to interpretation. Like keeping something that's actually a defined classification that you can look up and see what that is, I think is better than something that is up for interpretation, like maybe put a vehicle per day classification on it, if we're wanting to have flexibility across different types of roadway classifications. But as a person who has to go to these to look that up, like that leaves it up to somebody's personal interpretation on whether or not it's a primary transportation corridor or not versus arterials, or saying, you know, X number of vehicles per day to X number of vehicles per day is something like that you can definitively look up.
Through the chair, if I could. Yeah, that that's could be tricky too, because in some of our zones we actually have a zone specific standard or locational requirement. Right. It says like R-4A, for example, says you can only be on this type of street or in this. In a purpose statement, if you wanted to make that requirement to say B-3 can only be on our arterials, for example. I would say that should probably go in a locational requirement. But here in the purpose statement, it's more, I think, of the sort of philosophical idea where it should be, but not specifically a technical piece. So if we were looking at a rezone and somebody said I want to go to B-3, I don't think we would look at this and say it could be on our arterial or couldn't. So if there was interest in requiring that, I would recommend putting it into locational criteria. In terms of this in particular, I think maybe you've highlighted a potential conflict of having it as arterials that then people might wonder, oh, is it intended to be a locational requirement? Just in the purpose statement. I can't speak for I guess the source of that, but I guess I would guess that the idea was that B three is gonna be in central areas where we have transportation corridors. I don't know if getting to the specifics of a functional classification would add to that or not. I don't know if anybody else has any comment on
that. I don't know if anybody else has question comments on that, but Commissioner Ron is in the queue with a question.
Thank you through the chair. I appreciate an earlier commissioner raising the topic of the purpose statement. My question is on that topic as well. My interest is in the recommended changes to the latter portion of it specifically. The sentence that reads it is also the municipal municipality's intent that the B three district change will encourage replacing also shall provide for safe and convenient personal mobility in all striking other forms. Can you help me understand the context of that proposed change? Should I read that as the municipality admitting defeat, in this instance. To me it just feels like moving in a direction that I think we want to understand the intention of, given the importance of this purpose statement driving policy and application of B three development going forward. Through the chair, that's a tough one. So yeah, for anybody following along, I think we're looking at page or line 25 and 26 of page 14 of 64, and it says it is also the municipality's intent that the B-3 district will encourage, and it used to say also shall provide for safe and convenient personal mobility in all forms. I don't know if I could speak to the intent of that change. I could say that we could take a step back and think about how a district encourages types of travel behavior versus how different types of right-of-way improvements or public investments encourage different types of travel behavior. One thing I may guess this is maybe my opinion, personal opinion as a planner, sometimes purpose statements, they're it's sort of the floweryest part of the zoning. And so it's really trying to get to the ideals. But as when you drill down to it, it's sort of unclear like what does this actually mean. So I don't know if I have a good answer. I might kick it back to the director to see I when I read that, I it doesn't seem like there's an abdication of some sort of interest in doing that. But I would say at the same time, many of the other discussions we're having in the municipality, we're focusing on addressing the needs of all sorts of users, but doing it more through the OSH and P. So like the actual road designs in the DCM. And so this is a maybe a bit of a shift away from let's try to change travel behavior through zoning, which occurs in land use, to let's try to, you know, provide options for travel behavior in the right of way, which we do through changing this design criteria manual and the official streets and highways plan. But I maybe you have additional insight on that.
Through the chair to Commissioner Ron. That's actually a really interesting question because I kind of read it the opposite way. In that providing for other modes of transportation has just provided a five foot Sidewalk on the edge, right on the edge of major arterials, right? So we've provided for that other mode of transportation, but we haven't encouraged it. So my reading was that this would take that a step further and encourage other modes of transportation in these areas. But I think it's worth clarifying if that is actually the intent and I don't know if that was our language. I think it was probably from Dr. Voland, but we will ask and maybe see if there's a way that we can try to clarify that that was indeed the intent and maybe provide alternative language to support that idea, if that was what he intended.
I had a quick follow up question on that question. Was the shell provide in any way related to some of the issues where sidewalks later in the code are the code states that you shall install sidewalks on any B-3 adjacent to any road or right away, even in some instances when the sidewalks don't make sense. And moved to encourage it.
Through the sorry, chair spinelli. I don't think that and again I don't want to speak for the sponsor, but I doubt that that was on Dr. Voland's mind when he was drafting this up, but that is a also a very interesting question because that is a code requirement. And I have seen cases where it just does not make any sense to provide that sidewalk in those in that context.
I don't know another another question to bring
to the So I'm looking at the email we got from Dr. Voland and he did say maybe something like this that is the municipality's intent that the B three district also shall provide or shall provide safe and convenient person mobility in all forms. Playing design shall accommodate pedestrian spice with and use it of public transit. That was an early draft. So I wonder if it is that having shall in a purpose statement does create a weird situation because how shall it do it? So that that does make sense. And I don't think that came from the assembly member. It is probably something because we're we do try to be careful about where we use shall and where we use other stuff. And in a purpose statement, I think it's probably better to use the positive language of like aspirational language rather than the restrictive language. Commissioner McKee
I guess I'll I'm just kind of also thinking along those lines that shall means it's a lot stronger language, but it also guarantees that it happens. So I would think we would always want to guarantee that we're providing safe and convenient personal mobility in all forms for all roadway users, whereas encourage is really soft language versus shell, which is definitive, but I mean for me as a transportation person, the purpose statement carries a ton of weight. It's the purpose and the need together that define what we do for a project. So I think having the stronger language because like the planning director mentioned, I mean, you could have a five foot shoulder, or you could have a 10 foot one, that kind of flexibility happens in design, but I would think you would always want to provide. For all users. Whereas the encouraged might potentially allow you to not let's say include ADA compliant bicycle ped and transit
facilities. We have found more and more recently that there are multiple there are many situations where it actually does not make sense to provide structurally, you know, physically provide a separate facility for each mode of transportation. Often there are situations where the different modes can can share space. Or it might, for instance, it might not be appropriate to put a bike lane for example, on every single road in in Anchorage. So I think if we are going to include the show in there, we have to be very careful about what exactly it is that we are requiring. If that makes sense,
yeah.
I'll just read a few just some other examples of what purpose statements in sort of similarly envisioned areas. So in R three, for example. It says the commercial aspects of this mixed use district are intended to serve local neighborhood needs and promote pedestrian access to support local shopping. Others like R-4, I think it says something slightly different. Its development is intended to be oriented to sidewalk and windows to provide strong pedestrian connection stand by services. So I think statement is a little different. I do agree. I think the shell and the purpose statement might make things a little bit complicated. And it's really just intended to g to be sort of a last minute sort of vibe check on which way something is going. If there the specifics of requiring something for the zone should probably go into the aspects of the zone itself, either dimensional standards or use specific standards or you know locational standards. But I would also encourage anybody to just to look at some of the other ones and you'll see there's kind of a wide range in R 4.A it says this district is intended to implement the landing plan to meet housing needs for the community and establish a pedestrian oriented environment. So sometimes we say promote pedestrian activity, establish a pedestrian oriented environment, encourage pedestrian uses that sort of thing so I really I think it's there are many ways to do it. And I would agree I think shell should probably any shell language should probably be below in the specifics of the zone
Commissioner Pullis. Just a quick comment I mean I have some personal experience with some of the stuff on some design projects where, you know, there's probably some B-3 districts that are smaller than arterial corridors and stuff like that and tight right away. And quite often everyone demands you know you have to have everything in here, but when you get to it it's six foot right away you put everything in there it's 75 feet wide it goes at condemnation, the whole project falls apart and you can't do anything. So you know I'm not saying I'm not for shell or the other I'm just saying I have personal experience where you sometimes you just can't fit everything and that this seems like a situation where that could apply to
Commissioner McEy. Yeah I can see as long as we are defining in other locations where pedestrian bike and other types of facilities are required so that the encourage doesn't give the leeway for that not to happen in other locations where it really should be accommodated. That's my kind of concern with taking that language out and having softer language. But if enforcement type shall language is included in other places where it's really appropriate and drives the design to the con to the desired outcome, then
going to through the chair language is
good. I think we're also sensitive to that as well. We hear a lot of desire for that. And that's something that we're trying to write into the official streets and highways plan update and the complete streets typology, which is the movement is kind of thinking about you should have conte context based streets. So an arterial in one place might look like this and our trial in other place might look something different. So ideally if we do that sort of context of the street typology whatever they are, it's putting that walkability in the places where that makes the most sense but in the places where the walkability could function on a s a quieter, smaller road with a narrower right away, or it might not make sense at all because the way the road is designed so we are I think that's another piece of this too that isn't quite in the zoning is that we're trying to get to that through the right-of-way stuff so and there definitely is a big interest in there's a lot of policy support for
that. Sorry if you want to
say I agree. That is a very good goal. Because we do need corridors that are for moving vehicles and freight and whatnot and we definitely need more corridors that provide connectivity for bikes, beds, and transit. So I would love to see that happening
Director Babb I was just going to jump in and say that you I think you missed the entire site access saga because you weren't on PCC at the time, but that is one of the main questions that we addressed during that rewrite of that section of code is when is it appropriate to include a sidewalk in the development and when is it appropriate to maybe leave it out. And so there is some very strong language in code right now that speaks to like what are the thresholds at which a sidewalk should be required and where like have the traffic volumes, the adjacencies to schools and parks and things like that. So we do I feel that we do have that covered in code now, but we are like Daniel was saying, we are addressing that with those projects that he mentioned, and then also the DCM rewrite is happening at the moment. So PME is also currently working on this question. So
I have a question. We've spent a lot of time on the purpose statement. Section E, table of allowed uses. Some of the presentation showed self storage and car washes were the spur of the issue. Does this have any effect on car washes. If
I'm not mistaken, car wash in the code is actually minor vehicle repair. And this doesn't touch the minor vehicle repair use. But to change that, you could either separate out car washes at his own use, and then you have to go through the whole discussion of where where's it appropriate, where isn't it. Or you potentially take out all the minor vehicle repair, which might you know might fit somewhere else. So that is another interesting quirk of the c code that we don't have car wash separated out as an individual use.
My second question W What would happen if the Commission really liked the purpose statement but not the table and decided to only adopt the purpose statement
The Commission can make whatever recommendations that they like to the assembly and the assembly makes a final decision
I see nobody else in the queue. The public hearing is still open. There was no testimony. Anyone want to testify nobody wants to testify? Does staff have any rebuttal the next item before I close the public testimony. No? And then we'll close the public hearing. And look for a motion from the commission. Commissioner Pullis, would you like to state your motion?
Yes, I move in case 2026-0034 to recommend to the anchorage assembly approval of the review of AO 2025-63 allowing self-storage as a conditional use in the B three zoning district.
That is seconded by Commissioner Ron. Commissioner Pullis, would you like to speak to your motion?
Yeah While a little murky, I agree the revision of the B three description removes some extra language that's mostly covered elsewhere in title 21 and emphasizes all forms of mobility. The conditional use process for 50 plus parking structure uses is an appropriate opportunity for municipality review the context of large parking facilities and more industrial type uses in the B three district. We heard no agency opposition and public support for an amendment for the amendments.
Anybody else wishing to speak to the motion. Commissioner Ron
Thank you, Chair. I intend to support the motion as well. I concur with the findings of the previous commissioner and don't have any specific findings to add. My commissioner comments are as follows. I appreciate the responses provided by staff regarding my questions on the purpose statement. And appreciates the additional look into those elements with the originators of the AO and amendment at the assembly level secondly, I acknowledge the intent of this as an improvement to hold space for housing in the B three district, noting that an overwhelming body of evidence has shown B three district as apparently ideal for residential development in our community. And the competing uses and potential for uses at play here I think are balanced by not disallowing something that has existed, but changing the way in which it could be allowed in the future.
I intend to support the motion. Thanks. Commissioner Mills, thank you. I appreciate the support of all uses being included in this memorandum. Particularly the discussion about not keeping rigid requirements in there. But try to support all different forms of transportation. However, I have concerns about the 50 plus parking spaces being conditional. My concern being just hurting existing businesses, prohibit development or hurting future businesses that we would like to welcome to the area.
Commissioner Krishna. Maybe I'll just start by saying that amendments can be proposed right now. I speaking not to any potential amendments, but just to this ordinance as written. I am struggling with it a little bit, but I think I intend to support it. I have two comments. One is that I generally support and like the purpose that has been drafted and agree with previous comments on it, but I and maybe just struggling with the fact that I don't think that this purpose or this project is sufficient to achieve the intent of the zoning district. If we have a recommendation I would like to ask the assembly to propose a project to find out what it would take to achieve such density. Because I don't think languits such as that we're contemplating now get us that far down that road, which we want to be down. And then my second very minor thing is is only that I would ask that this be retitled because I think we've spent an equal amount of time talking about parking lots of self storage. Thank you.
Commissioner McCee I also intend to support the motion, but also have a couple of concerns that were brought up about if somebody who is you know legally allowed but wants to change the development on their lot could be triggered, but that it has to be a 50% above seems like a pretty high threshold. So I feel like that's okay. The other part is that they can there is a conditional use permit process that they can follow. I'm a little concerned that delaying somebody's development process by six months in Alaska where we have limited construction season could be a little bit inconvenient, but there is a path forward. So I do also intend to support the
motion. Nobody else in the queue. I do not intend to support the motion as written. I'm happy with all the work in the purpose statement. I like it. I don't like conditional use situations. I think they prevent development. They prevent people from purchasing the land to get to the point where they would apply for the commit conditional use. They stop projects in their tracks before they're started, even though there is a way forward. Often landowners don't want to wait six months while a proposed developer figures out if conditional use can be approved. So with that I do not intend to support. Commissioner Krishna
I think since we're talking about it, I would like to go ahead and propose an amendment to omit the parking lot or structure conditional use requirement.
Okay that's a motion to amend which will need a second Krishna, does that look right? Yes. Seconded by Commissioner Mills. Commissioner Krishna, would you like to speak to your motion?
Yes, I thought I would propose it since multiple commissioners have talked about it. I do think I intend to support this. This has been my biggest concern with this is just the scale of the uncertainty and that we might be that this might result in for retail businesses who I think firmly fit in with the intent of B-3. I welcome any further comments.
Anybody else wishing to speak to the motion to amend hearing none we'll call for the vote Ms Eber, how do you vote? Yes, thank you That motion passes. Okay back to the main motion. Anybody wishing to speak to the main motion as amended.
I just have a quick question since I'm not there. Go ahead. Did the self storage stuff get taken off as a conditional use as well? Or is that was that just the parking garages?
That was just the parking lot structures, self storage facilities and storage yards are still conditional use.
Okay. I think as amended I support the well I would further like to add on I don't support it without the storage units being on there. I think as you said or you stated that it prohibits developers from wanting to develop, so I shouldn't think it should be included. So as even as amended, I still don't intend to support
it. Did you say you do intend to support it, or you don't intend to support
it? Do not if the self storage stuff was included, then I would support it. However, since it was not included, I do not intend to support it.
Well you could offer an amendment to do the same change that Commissioner Krishna just amended, but for the other uses if you chose.
I would propose a motion to include self storage. I guess I don't know how to word it. And I'm not there.
I think Lori knows what to do. Did you want to include the self-storage and the storage yard and change them to permitted similar to the last
amendment? Yeah, essentially any of the conditional uses.
Okay, Commissioner Eber, the motion we have is to amend to include self-stored and storage as permitted uses. Is there a second? Seconded by Commissioner Mills. Commissioner Eber, would you like to speak to your motion?
I just believe that if we I don't well, I guess essentially I don't believe in putting conditional uses in areas and making zones more restrictive. If we want to see development, we need to make them less restrictive. We've done that in other things in the past. So I just don't approve the conditional uses.
Anybody else wishing to speak to the motion?
Commissioner Ron I do not intend to support the motion. While I can appreciate the comments from previous commissioners and the reasoning behind putting forward the motion. I go back to what problems the proposal's trying to solve. Clearly the will of the commission with respect to discouraging car centered uses was already spoken to. This element of encouraging more housing and more flexibility, I stand firm on and believe that conversion from permitted use to conditional use, again, does not take the use off the table. If the development makes sense, there's a pathway for it to move forward. Commissioner Pullis.
Yeah, I'll speak up this time. I don't intend to support the motion either. I think existing grandfather rights basically protects most of what's out there unless they go and spend what 50% of their site replacement value is. So at that point they're required to move towards conformance. If it's a brand new situation, I think it should be evaluated, and that's why I don't intend to support the motion.
Commissioner Krishna. I don't intend to support this motion either. Maybe it's just been m the self-storage facilities and storage yards I've encountered in Anchorage, but I don't see them as being primarily street frontage and uses that are oriented towards the street and offer pedestrians direct access or I see them as being potentially more appropriate for more industrial types of land. And so I do think that I do agree with the general intent of the B-3 district as we have drafted in this ordinance and don't think I'll support this one. Commissioner Mills.
One comment I guess I just want to share about why I intend to support this motion is just the shortage of industrial land types available to develop in Anchorage. You know, the beauty of B-3 has always been that it's very versatile in going towards you know more multifamily or towards you know these light industrial, you know, storage type uses. Is that it allows, you know, both types.
I'll just add I intend to support because I stand firm against conditional uses, making things hard in code, making things cost more money and take more time. That's why we are not getting our 200 and fiftyth anniversary mural on time. As we heard tonight, that it was one of the first selected, but one of the last to get painted because it came to the planning and zoning commission. Nobody else in the queue will call for the vote. Miss Eber, how do you vote? Yeah. Thank you. That motion fails. Back to the main motion as amended. Anybody wishing to speak to the main motion as amended? Before I call for the vote. Hearing none will call for the vote.
Miss Eber, how do you vote? No. Thank you.
That motion passes. Now we move to the carrot. Maybe please can I start with a motion to reopen the public hearing. Oh wait, nope, never mind.
Chair, before we get started, I think the Commissioner is in the queue.
Yeah, we'll take a five minute break. Okay. Now may we please have a staff presentation in case 2026-0035 AKA the carrot.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Dana McCunfoster again, long range planning. This case was built on the back of the other case, or you know, thinking about how can we make it easier to do some other things instead of just doing the restrictive pieces. So Basically it allows all forms of housing in B three. It simplifies some of the dimensional standards, and it cleans up the definition of mixed use development. So the mixed use development isn't totally about B three, but it just makes it a little bit simpler. So it if you wanted to have one dwelling unit and one commercial activity, it'd be okay. The way it was worded previously was a little bit confusing.
Are there any questions for staff?
May I jump in really quick? Director Babb. This is the proposal that would make single family residential a permitted use in B three. So I know we were discussing that earlier. This would also address that issue. And also just jumping in on the relationship between the two AOs when the sponsors brought the original the stick AO to the planning department. Our response was similar in some ways to your response as a body in that we did not see the direct correlation between restricting uses and promoting housing in B three, in that AO. And so this was our an AO that we worked with member Prawley on in order to actually take it a little bit further and create an AO in B three that would actually promote the development of more residential in that zoning district
Are there any other questions for staff? I have one Commissioner Mills.
I just have one question. What is the background or reasoning behind why wouldn't you just rezone a lot to the applicable residential use oppos to trying to accommodate like a single family in B-3.
Through the chair. To Commissioner Mills. That the rezon process is dependent upon our future land use map. And there are many areas in town where a single family exists in B-3, but a rezone to a residential district would not necessarily be supported
in that area
by the plan because that area is envisioned as a commercial district. I don't know if long range planning wants to jump in with any more information on that point.
Yeah, Daniel can have asked a long age planning through the chair. This was originally thinking about if people are doing garage condo and they're living in garage condos, which may or may not be happening. There's some anecdotal data or not. And so maybe there's a type of living that's desirable to do that. And then we didn't really have a category for garage condo, so that's how we came all the way around to sort of think about Well, what if you could just permit it as a single family house with a large garage, and then you could do a bunch of small lot, like narrow lot, single family with a large garage. So that was the intent to get to the shop house concept and make it so it's we can use what already exists rather than create a new use for like a garage condo. Yeah, also there are many places where the land is B-3, but the land use plan wouldn't support going to like an R three or something else, then you have to change the landing's plan. So it was really just kind of opening up the flexibility and allowing if people can be creative for there's a lot, you know, fewer restrictions on the size of a garage in B three, then maybe they could do something comparable what to what people have been trying to do in R three or other places. Or doing as garage condos and maybe there is residential activity happening there or not. So that's kind of how we got to this.
And to add on that just a little bit too, in most of our residential districts, they are very restrictive about the size of the garage, compared to the size of the dwell unit. So this was a way for us to provide a avenue towards building something that seems to be popular in other parts of the US that we don't have a lot of land available for here in the poll at the moment. Commissioner Krishna.
Could you speak a little bit to the overall thinking on relocatable dwelling units and relocatable dwelling unit communities? And I'm guessing that that's a synonym for what's called on page 20 in our table a manufactured home community.
Through the chair, yeah, I think the table I feel I believe you're referring to the really small font table. Is that right? Yeah, so the manufacturer dwelling units, manufacturing community, that those are renamed with a recent ordinance. I think maybe this might have started before that renaming happen. So that table just didn't get updated. Or it might have been done from
That's correct. This actually started before that AO passed. And one I think one recommendation that the planning department might make to the assembly and Daniel jump in if I'm getting this wrong, but I think we had suggested to the sponsor that if we didn't discuss it here that we would suggest updating this AO, to match the more recent relocatable dwelling unit AO. And allow relocatables in B three as a permitted use. So this that would be an amendment, I think, to what you actually have in front of you. And that would be in
our packet it says this it would be permitted.
Okay, then never mind.
I guess I'm asking if you could speak a little bit more about w the reasoning behind that
behind allowing it in in this Yeah, it's been
district. You know, we've seen it come up in multiple ordinances over the last few years. I guess I'm looking for the larger trend towards it sounds like it's part of this larger effort to allow every single type of housing that's allowable in the municipality in within B three specifically.
Is that correct? Yes. Yes, that's correct. Yeah,
and if I could build on that through the chair. So the Muni has been doing a lot of work on thinking about modular housing and manufacturing housing. And there's a lot of work across the state actually, looking at that when a couple years ago we applied for the HUD Home Pro or Housing Pro grant and our project was we wanted to figure out if we could figure out a way to value engineer modular homes and then make it a lot easier to cite them. And so throughout those processes often the municipalities come up with sites like well, there's a good site, and somebody has a B three site, they want to try it. So yeah, it really is sort of looking for the places trying to make as allow as many opportunities as possible where it might make sense. Yeah, because these days I think the modular home or the manufacturer home or the relocatable doing in the future will probably look a little bit different, I think, from what we've seen in the past with the sort of HUD standard from 1976. Thank you. Okay. Mr. Chair if I could make a quick comment Sure. Sorry to interrupt. I so I'm looking in let's see, I'm looking in the draft and I'm looking at the use table in section three, excuse me, the dimension standards table in section three. And I think there might be an error in here, because I'm also looking at the existing code. And if I could I'll bring that up and so I wanted to bring that to the attention of the commission. So you can make a decision about it. So this is the existing code. Okay. Let me just check the date on this April 15, 2026. Yeah. So the existing code, it doesn't have the max number of principal structures in a lot. And the side setback requirements are a little bit different. So I'm wondering if some pieces of the deleted text might have gotten removed from this. So I guess and I'm sorry for making it more complicated, but I would bring it to your attention just to be aware of what This code says now and what's shown as deleted or not deleted is slightly different in this. I think the intent is still, at least from what we brought forward, is to remove restrictions. But the code itself may be slightly different, and I don't know if this AO shows those deletions. For example, side setback in B-3 general business. Currently it says five plus one foot for each five feet in height exceeding 35 feet in height. On this and this page, we don't see that. It just says five. So that's our omission and our error. And then the other piece about max number principal structures on a lot. As you see here on the official version, there is no column. I think that column from max number of principal structures is only on up to the residential zones, the R zones, and then you get down into the Bs and the ROs and MCs, and it I don't think it has those. So I don't know if Lori, if there's a procedural piece there or if you want to address those, or if you have any questions I could answer.
My question is I think you need to clarify for the commission what staff intends for us to vote on. What you would like us to would you like us to make a motion to amend section three table. I think that's the table we're talking about.
Yeah, our so our proposal, and this again is on page 10 of 40 of this packet, section three, it's sort of starting at line 10. Our proposal would be to make the amendment so it appears as in this table, even though and then also include the deleted text that should be deleted. No, you don't have to take that if you don't want, but so the change there would be saying this current version is not showing that this side making all of the uses and residential uses to a five foot setback. That would be a change from existing code. So I guess I can zoom in here. So as you see here, it'd be basically Putting this in brackets. So the motion might be to use the dimensional standards as shown in this table, if you like them. And then correct the ordinance to show the proposed deleted text. And then I think this column here of on here that says max number of principal structures per lot. I don't see that in the existing, and I'm assuming this is the correct title 21 online. So
just to clarify, staff's recommendation would be to amend the current section three in our packet to match the current code setbacks. Correct? It would
be to add in the text that we've proposed to be deleted, but sort of omitted. Showing that.
Yes. So staff's proposal is for us to change section three to match current code setbacks.
Right? To change section three to match current code and then make the amendments that would make the dimensional standards look like they do in the packet as it is. So instead of, for example, a long way with saying instead of residential household living uses just being five side setback, we would propose deleting five plus one foot for each five feet in height exceeding 35 feet and setting it to five. Or we could come back and
whatever's easiest for you, honestly. The easiest thing would be for me to open public testimony and somebody from staff write that down really fast and give it to Lori. Okay, let's hear from the public. Anyone wish to testify, please step forward. Hearing thing none staff rebuttal.
I'd like to make a suggestion about the edit that we just discussed. Sure. I would suggest that the commission just address the proposed change, which would be the proposal to delete the extra requirement for five feet in height exceeding 35 feet. And just address whether or not you support that in your findings or your comments for this particular vote. And then also direct staff to correct the table in the AO so that it matches
current code. That work that might that would be easier.
And I can show you on the screen so everybody can see what it should look like in about 90 seconds.
Okay, we have a motion.
Sheron, would you like to state your motion? I move in case 2026-0035 to recommend the Anchorage Assembly approval of an ordinance amending title 21 to permit shop houses in the Anchorage Bowl.
Seconded by Commissioner Baza. Commissioner Ron, would you like to state speak to your motion?
Thank you, Chair. I intend to support the motion and would direct staff to correct the table in section three as discussed this evening. A few findings as we are tonight, this is a companion ordinance intended to incentivize development in the B-3 district in a way that is more flexible to help achieve Anchorage's housing goals. We did not hear tonight any public testimony in opposition to the proposed ordinance. We received one comment from a member of the public included in the staff packet, highly supportive of the proposed changes.
With that I intend to support the motion. Anybody else wish to speak to the motion. Commissioner Krishna.
I have one clarifying question that may potentially lead to an amendment if you'll allow me to ask a question to staff. Ask away. So if I'm understanding the intent of this correctly, it's the shop house. Allow falls under mixed use, and that's why we're amending the definition of mixed use development. That's correct. Okay. So what just to clarify before I make my motion, removing making a making an amendment to remove single family detached dwellings as permitted uses within B-3 would not be contrary to the intent of expanding the uses of shop houses in this district.
Through the chair, I think that would run contrary to the intent of allowing for the shop house. The thinking was that at first it was kind of attached, single family, and then detached sort of became part of that, but I think it was also allowing for small lot. Development of single family. So
that need not include commercial use.
Sorry, that did not include in commercial use?
Yes. So a single family home that has shop on the same lot falls under mixed use development, not under single family.
Well, so I think the way we put it was that a single family with a large garage is just a single family with a large garage. And other in other districts, there's specific standards about garages where you can't have such large garages. So the thing was if people really want a single family with a huge garage, they could maybe do it in B three and figure out a way to do it. I guess that
wouldn't be considered a mixed use. It would not be a mixed
use. Yeah. Just the shop houses. That was that was the alternative is do we create a new use type for shop house? And then the more we talked through it, we thought, you know, a shop house is really just a single family with a big garage. So that was the other way to do it, create a new use and then have it p figure out which zones it should go in or shouldn't go in. Then we looked like and B three doesn't have those restrictions on garages already. And so it was just a matter of connecting that big garage to a living unit.
All right, I think I understand now. And
through the chair to Commissioner Krishna, if I can add one more thing. The I think the intent of this AO also evolved a little bit since it was originally titled. The sponsor member probably started with the idea of promoting a specific type of dwelling unit in B three, but then through discussions with her, and internal to staff, we decided to proposed other changes to the AO that supported all kinds of housing in P three. So it doesn't quite match the title anymore. But that was the intent behind that particular change.
Thank you. Not able to make any motions, but I would just throw it out there, we can rename it the carrot. Okay, anybody else wishing to speak to the motion. Hearing thing none, we'll call for the vote.
Ms. Heber, how do you vote? Yeah. Thank you.
That motion passes. Okay. Can I please have a motion to reopen the public hearing on case 2026-0036? That's moved by Commissioner Krishna, seconded by Commissioner Pullis. Any discussion? Any objection? Hearing none. Motion passes. May we please have the staff presentation on case 2026-0036.
Hello everyone, Daniel Kanafoster Long Reach Planning. This is PCC case 2026-0036. Updating the wetlands management plan. This is phase one. It's kind of phase 1.5 at this point. So this is about the wetlands that the Anchorage municipality has jurisdiction to manage and regulate. I creates a lot of wetlands is as both federal wetlands and local wetlands. This we through the zoning power have power to regulate the local wetlands, even if the federal says they're not. And so this is a discussion on on the plan that is both the policy guidance and the regulatory tool to manage those. So what problems are we trying to solve? Wetlands permitting is not clear in Anchorage. Regulatory landscape has changed. There was the loss of the municipality's general permit in 2021, and then the SACAT decision at federal Supreme Court in 2023. The Anchorage Wetlands Management Plan is very specific about who can implement and really only says that we in long range can implement, and there are other sections of the municipality that have more expertise on this than we do. The Anchorage the wetlands management plan is set up to be both policy guidance and regulatory, and they should be separated out. And the wetlands plan is out of date, the mapping is out of date, and map changes require assembly review and approval. So that's kind of the main thing that changed since we went through the work session is just allowing the municipality to make updates to its wetlands map without going through the much longer process. Let's see, this is a lot of sort of historical context, but basically the wetlands plan was adopted in 2014. The 2014 plan built on plans that came from before that. In 2021, the municipality did not get their general permit review. The general permit allowed us to issue permits for C class wetlands if they were federal wetlands. So then it put everybody in this weird situation where if it was a wetland, you always had to go to the core and determine the court didn't have as much staff. And so we sort of hit a bit of a backlog. And then in 2023, Supreme Court decision sacked for EPA narrowed which wetlands are protected under the Clean Water Act. So it used to be you could have a pond or something, and if the federal government says a wetland is probably wetland. The second decision really said that you have to be connected to the waters of the United States. So maybe a stream or something, and that gets sort of legislated a little or adjudicated a little bit. But so it meant that if you have a wetland and it's not connected to an ocean, basically, it may not be a wetland for the federal government. But again, the federal government still makes the juris jurisdiction about what is their federal government federal wetland or not. The plan overview, the plan is sort of policy guidance and enforceable policies and specific actions for wetlands. So right now we have these sort of general ideas of how we're supposed to deal with wetlands in Anchorage, but then also very specific guidance and rules about what can or can't happen there. So if you come into the municipality and you say, I'd like to build here, we say, Well, that's mapped as a wetland on our mapping tool. And it's map number, or it's wetland number 164, then we go into the wetlands plan and it says for 164, you need to do A, B and C. Sometimes it's really specific, sometimes really broad. So this is something else we'd like to update in the future. Here's some specifics. Maybe you can't see on the screen, but basically you you find the wetland unit, 60 south, and it and it tells you development of the parcel may consider directing surface water runoff to clap bog or other measures. And so it gives some specifics, but not really. So as regulators and also sort of implementers, it's really difficult to do this. So long term we are looking to update the way we manage wetlands, so we can manage them safely, we can manage them effectively, we can use them because they do provide a great benefit to our community, but we can also provide certainty to people who are building in in the urbanized area. So issues with the existing plan, the framework relies on the MOA still holding the USA, the Army Corps general permit, the plan is both regulatory and policy, plan specific about which divisions of the MOA can enforce and the regulatory maps are out of date. Timeline, we had initial discussion of the May 11th meeting, PCC meeting. We had a work session on June 8. We discussed this last week at the July 8th, 2026 watershed and natural resources commission meeting. And Michael, if you want to jump in, how did they receive that? I think they were pretty favorable about this. They're pretty excited about it. They love the flow chart that Paul of France put together. And then we have a second discussion today for decision. So proposal for this case, make needed functional changes, change the language to allow MOA staff to update the new wetlands map, excuse me, update the wetlands map without assembly approval. So that doesn't mean we just change the map when we're we want, but it would be as verified and approved and information becomes available. So if somebody comes in and they're, you know, a like a certified and we haven't I don't think quite figured out what certification would be engineering firm or engineering water professional firm, and they say, Yeah, we've done this delineation, it makes sense, and it meets the core standards, then we can go through the process and just update the map. And then establish an in-house flow chart for reference, mostly for the public. With that, be glad to answer any questions anybody may have.
The questions on page 35 of 51 from Paul of France. Can you just kind of quickly go through those and note whether you guys think you address those or not? I don't need a lot of detail, just yes, no, that kind of thing. Let us know if there's any hanging out you couldn't deal with
it. Sorry, did you say 25 of 51?
35 of 51. Paul's final kind of comments. Did we address all those the best we could
Yeah? Through the chair. We've worked really closely with Paul and Steve and CJ and Greg Soule. So I believe we've hit all these. We did talk to Paul this afternoon. And I think everybody is on the same page with that. Michael, can you confirm that? Paul's seen all this and we've gone through it. This I think is from April 17, and so we've had a lot of meetings with them since.
Yes. We developed this particular case working closely with development services. Lily Dalf also will be enjoying us at the commission to follow it very closely.
Yeah, so if anybody has any questions about that, too, recommend watching the July 8th Watershed Natural Resource Commission. Paul was there, and I think CJ was there as well. So we're this has really been a pretty collaborative project. They were a little surprised at first. They didn't quite know what was going on. We had a couple of sit downs and everybody felt a lot better.
Can I ask one more quick question? Who's the phone number now?
The phone number still remains
Commissioner Rodrígues. Thank you to the Chair. Staff, I'm interested in on page eight of 51 of the staff packet's exemption to wetlands map amendment section A. Line 15. I'll give everybody a minute to flip there again, page eight. Proposed language when wetland delination prepared by a qualified professional. Not more than five years ago. Can you help me understand the basis of the five years statement? Is it scientifically founded in wetland science or is it arbitrarily selected or other? Michael, do you I'm thinking that we probably just picked five years. I mean we have something sometimes in we require an as built that's no more than two years. Michael, is that do we have any more specifics on that
number? We chose five years to make what the core of engineer uses. So every delay shill according to the core of engineers is valid for five years. And so we said that as the standard for this amendment.
Any other questions for staff. So were any other amendments made since the original introduction. Or
any? The middle amendment will be section four of the package, which is on eight page eight of 51. I think the consensus from the first meeting was about the substance of the AO draft itself. So we thought putting in section four would really give the some substance.
Seeing no more questions for staff, we will ask for public testimony since we have reopened the public hearing. Seeing none ask for staff if you have any rebuttal. Seeing none of the closed the public hearing. What is the will of the body. There is still time for questions for staff if you're not ready to make the motion. Commissioner Pullis, would you like to state your motion?
Yes, I move in case 2026-0036 to recommend to the anchorage assembly approval of the Anchorage Wetlands Management Plan update phase one. That's seconded by
Commissioner Krishner. Commissioner Pullis, would you like to state your motion?
Yes, I intend to support the motion. The proposed revisions reflect responses to comments received from municipal regulatory staff who will enforce it. The revisions clarify who at the municipality is responsible to complete wetland regulatory review process. Having a method in place to modify wetland boundaries is an important development process that needs to be managed by qualified individuals. We also heard no public opposition to the wetland management plan revisions.
Anyone else wishing to speak to the motion hearing none we'll call for the vote. Ms. Eber, how do you vote? Yeah. Thank you. Okay. Title Twin Discussion. How is the commission feeling about hearing from the department on their work plan? Would we like to do that this evening? Or would we like to not do that? I'm hearing that the next meeting has eight cases. It was not in our packet.
It only has three cases, but you have some cases in August. We have a number of cases in August.
If let's just say we said yes, we wanted to hear it. How long would it
take? Okay. Distribute what have we got.
Commissioner Ron, what are you thinking?
I'm thinking I'm here in five minutes. I'd like to learn about the work plan.
All right, let's let's have the work plan. I'll just add that the last meeting was over in 30 minutes.
Okay. Damn kind of follows our long range planning. We'll do this very quickly. This is just sort of the second half of 2026 looking at some things we've all accomplished together. And the things we have coming up. You see the July cases. In August, you you're probably gonna have a number of current planning cases. You'll have unit lots subdivision, which we were supposed to look at this month, but got postponed. So it looks like you have at least three current cases in August, on August 3, and then you've got maybe three more on August 10. Oh, four more in August 10. And then in September we have some changes to the parks and recreation zoning category, just like allowing Parks and Rec to do some of the stuff they're already doing, like selling tree plugs and maybe it's something like school activities or something like that. We might have the CSS process, the context sensitive solution street review updates potentially, and then looking at the toja tract land use plan designation. That is a case. So we looked at the future land use designation of that a couple months ago with the case that just went through the assembly. And we're gonna look at that again. In October, we might be looking at some R-2M edits. We're looking at another omnibus. And we're also trying to get rid of old Title 21. So you all just did we did that legacy rezone, getting rid of TR and B four and D two, but there's still a few pieces of title 21 that say you have to go back and if you do a project in certain areas, you have to follow the code as it was in 2014. And we're trying to just make it so if you have an industrial district, but it has to go back to 2014, it just allows us to implement or to use the 2026 industrial district. So we're still working out how to do that. Michael, it might have some district neighborhood plan hazard mitigation stuff incorporation. That's just sort of looking at what different areas can do for hazard mitigation. That's a one of our state grants. We'll be looking at some capital improvements project stuff, including with the school district. And then the recreational trails plan may be coming in November if it if they decide to make it a component of the comprehensive plan. And then maybe some child care uses in November. So that's pretty exciting. Midtown plan, it's gonna come back eventually, hopefully, child change the to child care. I think November. South edition has been working on a plan for about 10 years, and we're waiting for them to bring it forward. So we can if they want to incorporate that into the conference of plan. Some other stuff we've been working with other divisions about, you know, the school district and site designs and how kids get to school. Official and highways plan major update. We're almost getting that RFP out. Wetlands plan management plan major update. So we just looked at phase one, phase two will be coming in the next six months, hopefully or at least we'll start talking about it. We're trying to update all PCC materials to get to be searchable PDFs. That's something we're really excited about. Probably gonna see more abbreviated rezones. I think we have 18 so far. We're expecting more. So we're looking at that and we're looking at where especially with R five. So R five is a zone that's actually not even called out in 2040, Landy's plan. Wasn't expected to implement anything. I think it was expected to kind of go away. So we're looking at going out to the community councils where they have the most R five and just explaining if they see more abbreviated rezons, what it looks like, why, you know, because a lot of these it was always expected that R five was gonna change, and so we want to just sort of help people understand how that process works. Yeah targeted comprehensive plan update. We're looking at a sort of third party review of our process to make sure that somebody with some fresh eyes who also knows Alaska can look at that. And then the design criteria manual updates depends on PM and E, but that will be coming. So we're collaborating a lot with PME on that. So that's pretty much it. Glad to answer any questions, or if you have any questions, we can bring them back for next time. Thank
you. Any questions? See no questions. Thank you for the work plan. Any commissioner comments.
Commissioner Ron. Thank you, Chair. Reflecting on a comment that staff made in a case tonight about the respective role of the streets and highways plan and management of land use with respect to access, using that as a tool relative to the role that management of zoning plays in that space. And trying to put words to this. I guess I have concern based on the way that I interpreted the comment that there may be a deflection of responsibility away from zoning in that space and fully to transportation planning. I guess I would caution raise caution if in fact that's the movement that's being taken. I could provide some background, or I could just take that under advisement. A quick response if you have one ready. Yeah, thank you. That's that's a big question that we've been talking about for many years. I think the thing you know, one of the first case I worked on was R-4A, the R for A zone. And R four was really trying to figure out how to use zoning to create great spaces and great public places. And every developer we talked to who wanted to do the kind of walkable mixed use density, that kind of stuff, they bristled at sort of every single requirement we did about like don't put parking between the street and the building. Or we want nicer facades against the building. And so that really got us thinking more about if you if you want a walkable environment or a different transportation environment, you have to focus on where that activity exists, or at least that's gonna be more effective. Really, you have to do them both together, right? So and then I think also we saw with site access. If you remember site access that came through in 2022, a lot of that was trying to control how people traveled based on what happened where the in all the places they weren't traveling. And that became really complicated and problematic. They do have to work together, right? It's like the width of a driveway affects how you interact with a building, how much parking you have in front of a building, but then we have the practical realities like we saw tonight of the way transportation behavior is right now. And so we we're sort of a lot of us went to this NACTO conference was the National Association of Transportation officials or something, and they were from PME, from Capital Improvements, and we came back kind of energized to look at how we can think about using the, you know, treating the right of way as a public asset and really achieving the goals of the municipality also in the right of way, also in zoning. So some of that is like in zoning, we need maybe need to let up a little bit because the site access project was not very successful, I think we can say. I mean, it took a year, it was immediately very unpopular with the municipality or the assembly put a moratorium on it. That approach didn't seem to work, but we still have problems on the road. So we're really trying to get to let's work closer together with the way we design the road. So on that's on the DCM and also on the way we plan the roads, which is those H and P. And that's a m a component of the comprehensive plan. So that's an interesting piece that in OSHP comes through planning, DCM goes through P M and E. We're hoping we can be working on both those things together. So Yeah, I absolutely it's a it's a difficult question and it's gonna take sort of some creativity for anchorage and anchorage sort of growing up a little bit, the department's growing and learning together. But it is something. It's not that we're trying to move away from that responsibility or give that up as a priority because if you look in our land long range transportation strategy, the first three few pages are people, you know, the community, the public have been talking about a different transportation environment for decades. And that still seems to ring true. And I think we see that even I was reading the state transportation plan. People are asking for something different. So that's on our mind, and now we're just really trying to get to whatever works, right? Well with one final thing is something that came out of site access was moving away from requiring sidewalks everywhere, which looks like a big, you know, flashing siren moving away from walkability. But what we got to was that we might actually at first these smaller streets, it's pretty expensive to put in a sidewalk. Maybe we just treat that street truly as a place where you multiple users really do have a right to be there and gonna and that's a bit of a philosophy shift, too. So there are a lot of these discussions going on, and I'm thinking when you see the OSH and P information come out, you'll see it's really looking at things a little bit differently. But I think in the past we spent too much time maybe looking at zoning as a way to control travel behavior. And that produced some bad impacts. And now maybe we'll focus a little bit on a more balanced approach, you might say. Thank you.
Any other questions or commissioner comments. Hearing and seeing none Director Babb.
I just wanted to thank the commission for hearing the wetland plan proposal again. I know that it was a little bit rocky to start with, and I appreciate the time that you spent in the work session and in allowing us to come back with this proposal. to the commission. So thank you very much for that.
And with that, I'll entertain a motion to adjourn. Moved and seconded, any objection here, number.