HYBRID Community and Economic Development Committee Meeting
And with that, I'll call this meeting of the community and economic development committee for Thursday, July 9 to order. It is 9:01 a.m. And we'll begin with member introductions. I'm George Martinez. Johnson. Yeah, member Parks. Yeah, that's fine. Thank you. Any other members on the line at this time. Seeing none, and we'll wait for any to join the room. That's our start. And then today we'll begin with our regular reports, just to give a note on the agenda. During unfinished business. I'll also give a quick update on a resolution circulating through the National Association of Counties that I mentioned at the general meeting this week. And then also just a conversation of we'll follow up on any of the things that come up on new business unfinished business. But with that, we'll start off with planning development and public works, and I'll turn it over to our director of economic
community development, Mr. Chair. Thank you for the opportunity to present before this committee today. Ken Coleis is on leave today. We can blame the rain on him and We're just gonna try a different format where I'll be presenting for all the different departments today. First I'm gonna do a quick overview that I think is important in terms of looking at economic development in municipality of Anchorage. We've been working with J Bear to translate their growth plans into Anchorage opportunities. Basically, next year the president's budget calls for a $2 billion that's with a B budget for military construction on J Bear itself. If you look thought in the next five years, that amount goes to about 8 billion with a B going out. So those numbers are big. What's it mean? And working with the where this is an ongoing iteration with the base, but we know immediately what that means is they're forecasting about 600 and 60 new and junior enlisted members who will live on base. That will drive two barracks or dormitories. It's barracks if it's army, it's dormitory if it's air force, it's the same thing for junior enlisted members to live on base. Those will be large commercial projects available to Anchorage developers. What's more interesting, though, is there is an influx of about 2,000 additional service members total coming to J Bear over that time. And housing right now, J bear projects a housing shortfall where they cannot house these families of about 2,538 homes with the status quo, but with that growth, they're projecting that actual shortage is about 3,500 homes that they're going to be looking to the local economy, or a thousand more than the current base population would be driving, that were optimistic our builders can step up with me. So it is a huge ad. And just a reminder, this is just the army and the air force. There are other large projects going on the base that are also gonna be positive economic projects. Another federal agency that's a tenant has funded or has in the budget million-dollar expansion for next year going forward. So a lot big stuff happening there going forward. And just a quick update on the just within the CD side for or geographic data and information center working on two new products that we think will increase the effectiveness of the municipality of Anchorage. These are both internal and short testing right now. One is a short term rental app to show where the short term rental properties are in town. Again, this is still the science project stage. The second one being a living unit summary dashboard to provide a baseline to show the number of living units per type in each community council area. And again, that's in internal testing right it's another means to understand the different sort of density we have in different parts. Just a note the zoning and future land use maps should be up to date. Staff were able to incorporate the large number of changes made in AO 2026-47 and 48 going into that. So that's just some over big overview stuff. Showing down to development services as of yesterday we are permitted more dwelling units 289 this year than in all of 22 in all of 2020. Permit valuations are currently running 124% of last year, meaning we're about $100 million ahead want to touch upon some permits of interest this month, at least to me the West Park reconstruction came in for 22 million. And this is just permit value the actual cost is higher because certain things don't require a permit or Captain Captain Cook Hotel continues its renovations to the tune of 8.4 million this year going forward. The Touchmark Senior Livering Center at O'Malley in Lake Otis. That the phase one that we're looking at now is 120 units of senior citizen living. Call the project, there will be about 27 total. And what's really exciting about this, it provides that continuum of care from independent living all the way into the most intensive skilled nursing assistance someone could need on the same site. So you can just move there. That will also frankly free up some housing that senior citizens are now occupying because they do not have that option in Anchorage going forward. Closer to downtown again, the new Koyana House facility at 225 Eagle is underway to expand. Well this is a South Central Foundation project that will expand that model of the pub house and types of care management for providing services, and that is all there's nothing there's no residential outside. Everyone's busted that in the morning and bust from that in the afternoon, but it they've been a large steady great partner that location just coming in this week, native village of a Clutna gathering place, kind of a tribal administrative services building up in our northern communities permit came in for about 2.7 million. There's three new single family housing projects that came in this week, which was exciting to me because I watched these is all three of them were in the mid 500 range. Typically these have been running at the low end of 600 to over a million. So seeing these lower end ones shows maybe some hope for making housing more affordable. And coming next month is kind of an interesting one. The Alaska Native Tribal Health Consortium emergency department permit is coming under MOA jurisdiction. Currently, this project is underway. On federal land, the federal land is converting to be owned by A and T H C at that point, it becomes under the municipal process. We're working with them for this make sure it's seamless that their construction efforts can continue. This project in the out years is in the hundreds of millions of dollars of valuation. More importantly, though, it's gonna really increase the services available through A and T H C and on that campus over there. So it's kind of exciting. Permit review times are under control, but it's a challenge. Reviewers now indicate when applications are eligible for partial approvals to reduce tech workload and allow builders to get going where they can up to certain phases. Lan reviewers, the engineers in back are cross-training with permit techs to improve quality of reviews and ensure backup capacity during the busy season. You come up to the desk now, and the building official isn't there actually running the counter the executive secretary is doing shifts manning the counter. Plan reviewers are usually manning one station. These are the engineers at back, and they're really great when somebody comes in with an earlier question as to the type or flavor or how to proceed on a permit, and that they understand the technical requirements of how or how that can be done. And we have filled the final permit tech vacancy that we currently have, and we're in the process of creating a new position for an additional permit tech. Now we talked about those increases in revenue, those increases of permit. This is our second year over year increase, and they're at capacity two years ago. So we're not where we want, but we're going forward in terms of improving performance in these areas. And since it is also in the development service in this realm, the nuisance properties. We're aggressively working 907 East 11th, which caught again last weekend and we're pretty we're we've been initiated the invitation to bid where we'll demo it and just lean on it at this point. The 4400 block of old Steward Highway. We also have an ITB out that's probably a couple weeks out. That's a large removal of junk vehicles. 326 East 68th Avenue is exciting. A builder bought it out from under us, so we don't have to deal with it because he has a plan to pre-development going forward. We're looking at our Thompson Avenue project being demoed the week of July 20. And then once the demo cost will go to the minimum bid when we sell that property, which was turned over to us. This one like big timber slowed down on us a little bit because EPA changed some of their requirements for evaluating the testing data. Whenever we demo a building, the contractor has to turn and has just materials testing information to make sure that what is taken out of it is properly disposed of. We still think we're on track for the big timber demo, which will be at owner's expense with the lean in late July. 1306 Chi Chugch way, we also have an ITP out to get cleaned up by the Muni at owners' expense, i.e. a lean. And looks like next week, according to the notes I got from Greg on that, which is exciting. So we have many projects going forward there. Just some notes on tweaking some of the code around this area. We're looking at moving some dangerous going to be proposing moving some dangerous buildings until 15 to 23. Right now the everyone's jumping back and forth between the two. It's confusing for the owners. It's frustrating for the inspectors, and we think it'll provide a better, more transparent and equitable process for everyone involved because anytime you have to jump back and forth between two sections, particularly the public who doesn't live in that area. It really is the challenge. Pause you for a second.
Just announce member Baldwin Day joined us at 9:06 a.m. And they also have their hand raised. Do you have a question at this point now, or do you want to wait, Member Baldwin Day?
Oh, I I'll wait till Director Bells done. Thank you.
Okay, cool. Great. Well, since director or since member of Baldwin Day joined us, I want to call out and appreciate her and member Johnson's efforts to better align the tenant relocation assistance program with its intent with the AO they're proposing and say we're full on board with it. Thank you all for leading forward. We're also going to be looking at cleaning up some notice requirements again to make it easier and more predictable for the public in terms of how we're going forward. I was going to jump over to planning, unless next plan zoning review times right now are looking at five days for residential and 20 days for commercial. On the permit side, zoning and land use view is our greatest challenge, and we're taking to address it. The planning director over there has issued a policy to allow builders to request at-risk permits for residential permits when review times exceed 10 days. And the residential or it's much easier to identify your big areas with wetlands and all sorts of area that lends itself to it. We're also taking an all hands on deck approach, similar to what you heard with development services. A new Zoning reviewer just started. We recently brought back a very experienced zoning and land use and reviewer is back on contract who retired after literally decades of experience. The current planning section is backstopping zoning and land use reviews stepping into that area to assist with some of the reviews and long range planning is backstopping current planning with some of the rezons and stuff they do to better align our efforts across the department to meet the needs of the public during the height of building season. We're also the mayor is approved creating an additional zoning and land use reviewer position. And my request for the public in this area, we really need a couple more planning board members that we know a real detail oriented folks who want to get on board with the community development and economic opportunities for Anchorage. We'd urge them to look at the planning board to apply. The wetlands plan update is forthcoming. The plan has significant challenges that we need to update the map. PCC has approved a short term fix to allow development services to review wetland permits rather than a long rather than long range planning. We think this will help move things along. And just a reminder, the assembly has introduced two B-3 ordinances that will be considered by planning zoning committee next Monday. PCC had a work session on these June 1 that you can watch. The link is on planning's excellent title 21 update page. Just like Ring the notes fed to me there. So but that aside, the B-3 is a very important district, and this is a very important area. So I do urge just engaging in that area going forward. During the maintenance and operations, the downtown library construction is approved by the assembly on Tuesday. We're finalizing documents to get out of that. There's ongoing construction at the Alaska Center for Treatment. Paving alleys across the city is underway. We're in the process of creating the seven new heavy equipment operator positions for snow season that was just authorized by the assembly. Long term superintendent for street maintenance retired yesterday after 25 years with the Mini. We recognize his decades of service and great posture in which he left us in this for this area going forward. Turn to PM and E. Well no attorneys waving at me sure. Eric I believe is his last name. But just somebody who was passionate about it and just real incredible for motivating folks to go out, give it their 110%. I just want to make sure that every person who served that much time for the municipality always gets their due credit in their promise. I'm sorry, Eric just said that. Well there may be something coming your way to more officially recognize appreciate it. But we've been a little bit scrambling, at least since I saw the email. Flipping over to PME, 42nd Avenue is a local road upgrade project. Just over that way, a little bit worth seeing. It's being coordinated with the Awood water main replacement. The water main work is complete now, and we'll be closing Piper Road shortly to finish it up. But it's an exciting project for proving the street and pedestrian amenities along there. The Bergoth Street corridor safety improvement contract with HDL was executed. Survey work is beginning the summer. This is a high priority priority project for the MOA since AMAT's identified Berg Austreet on its high entry road network. This will receive 25 million from FHWA funds through its safe streets and roads for all funding programs. This is off East Dowling Road to Askalin Road. Construction is now in progress. They successfully relocated the 12 inch diameter steel high pressure gas main to accommodate the new storm grain system. That sounds kind of daunting, does it construction's anticipated to be completed this fall. And just a reminder, feedback is requested on the fireweed lane rehabilitation coming up. It's really important to get the public's input in terms of how they envision they want fireweed lane to work. Jumping over to traffic, 10 speed feedback signs have been installed. There'll be seven more next week. We're coordinating with dot puffs. Similar effort if you came in on two probably saw their signs coming this way. They're also leading pedestrian interval pilot continues. They're looking at two intersections to update as far as ADA project. Northern lights slash uaaa and 40th slash lake Otis. And there's some other upcoming changes going to. And yes, it's summer. We've had plows out all winter. So watch out for those folks that are restriping and don't drive out wet lines. It really is frustrating. Going forward. The let's see, that's five six here. Moving to real estate. The we had the tax foreclosure sale June 24. Five properties were sold, including three nuisance properties. These don't go now go back on the rolls and can be rehabilitated by owners. Also, it recovered $102,645 and 22 cents for the code abatement fund for recorded liens that were on these projects going forward. So that's kind of excited. And last but not least, our public for public art artist Rose Hendrickson's project at the port of Anchorage, for the railing of the administrative building. Its installation is imminent probably next month. Standing by for the questions of committee. Thank
you, Mr. Dole. Member Baldwin Day
Yeah, thank you. And thank you, Dr. Dole, for that very comprehensive report. I'm curious that there is a place where we're sort of warehousing the information around code enforcement activities and you know what the what the current status is. I'm starting to feel a little sheepish about harassing staff to ask them for updates. And so I'm wondering if there's a place that that that sort of lives in a in a living document kind of way that members could potentially access
to the chair. Thank you, Baldwin Day, member Baldwin Day for that question. Just a reminder, the directors are always available, me and Greg in particular, to answer your questions in this area. It is a very dynamic evolving situation, which makes it challenging. We talked about one yesterday, you and I do text that is an example of that one. That was not on our screen until member Parks raised it Monday a day before that. So it is dynamic. There's some sensitivity about properties not the municipalities possession ownership in terms of they also highlight frankly what could be opportunities for those with the good intent once we make a public document. Graham and I'll would like an opportunity to work with you all at the clerk's office to see what we can do though to provide a better more visible means to do that.
Yeah, that would be really wonderful. And you know even I recognize the sensitivity of some of these situations. If there's a way for you to share I couldn't I couldn't take notes quite fast enough to keep up with your report today. If that's something that you could you know potentially share with members just so that we have that to reference I know I have several several different groups of constituents who would love to hear the updates about the properties that are adjacent to them, even if it's in sort of a high level way not with specifics necessarily I think that would be it would be really wonderful to have that if you don't mind sharing.
Yeah I will after this I'll ask Graham to send out to this group the talking points I had they came into being about 10 minutes before this started we finalized the last points but we will share those for those of you who may not been writing as fast as I was talking.
No that would be lovely. Thank you very much.
Did you remember Bulls? Yeah thank you director and so much good news when when we look at J bear and all the construction's gonna be happening there should we have any reason to be concerned that there's going to be enough builders tied up and that work that it's gonna create a capacity issue for you know private builders in the community, right? Is that going to have some sort of downstream effect for people who are trying to move projects forward, you know, outside of the military space. The chair I think that is a significant concern. We Jaber already doesn't believe there are enough people in the trades to address their needs. I would note that a lot of the builders who work on commercial projects do not work on some of our residential projects, at least a single family to triplex. So I think there's some space there, but frankly, I envision we've been sharing this information. I passed the last calculations out with with AHBA last week. We've reached out to AGC at Boma also to tell them, hey, this is coming. We still expect they will have to look heavily at frankly importing labor for this, which is an incredible downside. I'd like to get the multiple economic multiplier locally who could do this. Yeah, for sure.
All right, thank you. If you can just a follow-up question for myself. First of all, yay to the good news. You started off the report with a lot of what I call the my development love language. How much how many more developments units are coming online, the evaluation of those units, and there are some really positive indicators into that space. Just for clarification, you mentioned one of the terms that I'm interested in better understanding and it may not necessarily be an answer to me, but just to put a pen in it. Wetland permits. What does that mean? What are we talking about when we say wetland permits and development?
Through the chair of director wants to address that now, I think it is something that probably lends itself for a more thorough description. Rather than request the opportunity to provide a response to this. There's complex overlaying issues of what the core considers a wetland, we consider a wetland.
Cool. So it's for a high level. Is this essentially where we identified developmental challenges through the language of wetlands. Like these are where the water is, and so maybe it's more difficult to build there. Is there some relationship between that and building, or is it much more complex than
that? I'd say that it's more complicated. The water may not be there, but an older map shows it is there. So there's issues with the dating of the map, where it really is and then how we address those issues, the army core determinations, our determinations. It's more complicated than that. Just to put a final and hopeful, hopefully
in the last point. Complicated to being able to affect development patterns.
Essentially is it about how we grow and where we can. Yes, it's about how we affect development patterns, but I think it's also about our obligation to protect the environment as we're going forward, and not create some of the problems like where for instance where COT has filled in a lot of wetlands around Ted Stevens and National Airport. We ought now have the long lake on a growth pattern in terms of rising levels threatening existing development. But beyond that basic obligation to protect future generations.
I appreciate the complexity of that conversation, and I just wanted to highlight I think we've also thrown additional complexity from this body into a larger conversation around essentially the opposite. If we're talking about wetlands, the concern that this body has had is also around the wildland interface. Essentially there is a development pattern relationship between all of these. Environmental features that we have asked the administration to study with respect to the Wowland interface, which is approximately 80% of our so it seems like there's a relationship between those worlds, and I want to make sure that we're talking about them more regularly in town.
Mr. Chair, we're we've taken that discussion to heart and we recognize these systems are all interrelated. Thank you. Appreciate that very much. And
on that note. Any additional questions for any other departments that we're gonna review for. Great. We have also in the room some of our community partners, and I see Mr. Robbins is here. So ACDA would you like to say hello to us. Can I step up to the more than welcome to come forward, sir? I
I only I have 22 slides. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Sorry. Just in case somebody takes a picture. Thank you. So we were asked last month to come and sort of give a general update about what ACDA is working on. And so I just prepared a few quick slides. And in the in the in the world of ACDA is in most of the municipal departments, I think, right here, but in a lot of the departments. We're moving in a lot of different directions to try to affect the 10,000 homes in 10 years, and to figure out how to eliminate barriers to development. My hat's off to the planning department and everybody on at the Elmore facilities. All I hear from developers now is that things are easier than they used to be. And I think that's a testament to the work that the assembly has done, the administration has done, and the leadership over at the Curmit Center. And that's something that I didn't hear five years ago when I got here. So I just wanted to say that. Up front. So I'm just gonna provide you with what I what I guess we consider our hot plate projects. The ones that are that are the hottest right now that we're working on. If I could wait is could that be could you expand that so that you can see the whole slide or is that not is it too big or opened in your browser instead of in PowerPoint, I think. Oh, you're sharing, maybe that's why. Never mind. Okay. Go to the next slide. The first project I just want to update you on is the fireweight flats project. That's a with a tax foreclosure project or a property that we bought from the municipality almost two years ago now. We issued an RFP in the summer. It we issued an addendum on June 10, just last month, because we discovered that there were some additional environmental issues that we're working through. This is a targeted unit development, 80 to 120% AMI. We've had to suspend. We were planning to award the RFP in the first part of July, but due to the additional EPA requirements, we're waiting for a determination from the EPA that should be coming in, we're hoping Tuesday or Wednesday of next week. And this project is is is moving we hope to move it forward still this year. We had 10 respondents to the RFP, so there was plenty of interest in the project and building and on doing the development. So this is probably the most the quickest, the closest we are to get any doors in the ground, right? This minute because if we can get the positive thumbs up from the EPA guys next week, then we'll go ahead and let the RFP and get started. Next project that everybody's been asking about if we go to the next slide is third in Ingram. As you know, we proposed an RV resort on that site. We were given a lease via your ordinance. You gave us a 20 year lease on the property. We've been managing the site. If anybody's driven by it, you'll notice you being in mode. We even threw flowers out last fall, so they would grow in the spring. So you might see some flowers start to pop up. But we've been basically keeping it clean for the neighborhood because that was a big concern. We did receive one response to our to the RFQ we put out last year. However, that response indicated some cost concerns. And so we've been working with that respondent to try to come to either an alternate proposal or something that we can represent to both the HLB and to you guys, because there were some specific requirements in the AO that we had to complete when we did this project. And so we're working through that. Unfortunately, they're a tourism vendor and they're in the middle of their tourism season. They're out of Juneau. And so we're talking, but it's not going as fast as we'd like, but we are working on that currently. And I know that there's a move afoot right now, too, to try to activate that on a temporary basis for the rest of this summer and possibly the through the winter and into the fall next year, that'll make good use of it for some downtown construction projects. JC Pennies is the next slide. Boy, you guys anybody who's been around the municipality for more than a day has heard this project talked about for a very long time. ACDA pursued this for I don't know, five to seven years before I got here. And we are now in the final stages of document drawing to present to our board of directors next month for approval for the purchase and be to begin the redevelopment process of that garage, that garage is. It's served our downtown core very well. But it's passed, I think. I think it's met its mission and it's time to retire it. So our plan is to purchase, you know, complete the purchase of the garage, take it down, redevelop it. And that's something that is we probably couldn't stop it if we wanted to at this point. So it's happening. So next slide. So the D Street, of course, everybody's very interested in this and understanding what's happening here. I want to thank you guys for your confidence for transfering the property to ACDA to give us a chance to get the redevelopment started. We did conduct some due diligence once we took the property over. And we needed to understand what was up inside the building. It's been vaguely for 10 years. We finished that, had seemens go through it, so we understand most likely this will sit another winter before anything happens to it. So it's really important to us to understand what does that mean from a management perspective, because again, the systems were all just basically turned off when they left town. So we've got a handle on that now, installed cameras and monitoring, and we're making sure that there won't be any surprises come this winter as we move into the redevelopment phase. And we're working right now with the other tenant in common who owns a small one of those lots that are underneath the building to purchase that share so that we can combine and own the entire building and redevelop it and be the lead on that and make that begin to happen next fall. Umchorage, next slide, please. Anchorage workforce housing initiative or system. A CDA's been working for about six months to come up with a duplicatable system that we can pair developers and investors with landowners. And I won't go into a lot of extreme detail on this metric. However, we've received very positive response for the structure of the program. We're working now on the finance and the how to arrange the financing for the developers and the workforce housing consumers. We know there's a demand. We've already done a an informal demand study, but we're preparing to do a formal evaluation, if you will. And we've already got project sites selected for the first three projects that we'd like to do. So this is a system that's unlike anything that we're currently is being used to solve the workforce housing challenges in Anchorage. And we will be talking to you more about this as time goes on, but this is something that we're working on pretty continually and pretty hot right now. We've also got this the Alaska housing accelerator fund this is a program that we've been working on with the state of Alaska and with Ada has been endorsed by both the administration in Anchorage and by the governor. And this is a program that's designed to appreciate for example the AO that the chair and member Baldwin Day have for the missing middle. And when when ACDA sat down and tried to look at how we could help solve the housing problem in Anchorage. We don't own land we don't have a bank we don't have $100 million to do financing for people. So what we did is we looked around and we said how could we how can we try to help builders build it more effectively and efficiently and that's this fund. It pairs ADA with local banks we've got a commitment from the local banks of up to $50 million to match Ada spending and what it would do is it would lower the cost of construction loans to the developer and more importantly lower the equity requirement that the developer has to bring to the table. And then once the construction is complete, offer an construction or a takeout loan that's on a 40 year amortization. And so anybody who's ever developed a property understands going from a 20 year to a 40 year amortization how substantially that affects the project being able to pencil. And we haven't talked a lot about this because we felt like we were not close enough to the finish line, but we're gonna have either a go or a no go, I think here in the next couple of weeks. So we're pretty confident that this is this is gonna get to conclusion. So we've also been working, which there is no slide really about this one, but we've been working with the state of Alaska on as some of the you may have heard some of the rumblings, but the DNR has been working with other communities around the state to try to transfer DNR property to the local community so that they can do development. We've spent painstaking amounts of hours going through the DNR database here in Anchorage. And it's given me a newfound respect for our GIS map folks and how thorough they are when I look at the state system. And we have identified some parcels, we've made a request to DNR, we have parcels that we believe that were very hopeful are gonna be at mid their mid town parcels, there's east anchorage parcels. And one of the things I didn't mention is we're about to sign some land leases or development with some private owners. And there's five leases we're about to sign. And then we'll take those RFP them for developing to workforce housing as a part of the A WIP program that we're doing. And those properties are in downtown, mid town, so it's all over the it's the entire city. So we're working on a lot of different things and sometimes People look at ACDA and they say, Well, what is ACDA really gonna do? What could you guys really do to help with these problems? And I did and I want to just call your attention to what our mission is. And our mission is really to serve as a catalyst for development. Because we don't have a land bank, because we don't have a we know we're not funded, we don't get $100 million to make loans to do things like that. What we have to do is look for creative ways to try to make make the wheel turn. And sometimes that involves, I'm sure from the outside, people will look at us and say, Well, yeah, but what are you really gonna do? And so that's why we come up with some of these ideas and we work through them and we spend time and effort and energy to try to make these things happen. And they seem like a little bit outside the box, but it's important for us, and that's the way we try to think about things. And we're looking forward to the AO that's been proposed by member Day and by yourself. We have been talking about that since the emails that we exchanged, and we're gonna be on the phone call that's coming up, and I think there's a work session. Is there a work session schedule too? And we're hoping to come to the work session because I think we're gonna have some ideas on how we could help with that program once it wins and if it passes, so that we can help you execute that. So that's just a quick update from ACDA. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Robinson.
Any questions from members for ACDA? Boldwind, is that a new hand or is the old hand?
That's a new hand.
And you're not clapping? No, I'm just kidding.
You you you did not actually hear me clapping, but yes, I was. Thank you very much, Mr. Robbins for that report. A couple of follow-up questions. So the demand study that you mentioned in the earlier part of your presentation. Can you share a little bit more about what the what the parameters of that study will be
So the demand study that I was talking about through the chair. da days the demand study that that I was talking about was in regards to the appetite for there's a there's a group of large workforce housing consumers in the marketplace and the demand study is to formalize that demand and understand exactly how many units they could use in this a wip program how many units would they be willing to invest in for us to create this workforce housing program so that we can for folks out of hotels and put them into apartments and get them into how into regular housing so that we could sort of it'll create kind of a spill over effect on a lot of the housing issues that are happening so the parameters of that will basically be that that will be targeted at specifically workforce housing consumers and what their need is and then what their appetite for this kind of a program is we are also by me just as a follow up no you didn't ask about it but we have contracted with McKinley research and you may have noticed as of late if you haven't I think we sent out we published I think now two sort of portions of a real estate market study that go into sort of understanding the real estate market and the housing market in Anchorage and we are about to update our housing study that we did two years ago with Bakinley research and that'll be sort of a full market housing study and I can't give you the exact parameters for that other to tell you that it's a be a complete study they're gonna include available inventory they're gonna do demand they're gonna be able to focus on identify the demand in the differ pricing categories so we know how many homes do we need between 150 and 250,000 it's gonna be a sort of a complete look at the marketplace. And those previous those studies that we just published were part of that process. So
Fantastic. I really appreciate that follow up. So one question when when you say workforce housing, are you are you using that term as it pertains to the type of housing itself or the price point of the housing.
So in relationship to your see that you're member date. In relationship to your question, workforce housing means primarily companies who provide housing for their employees. So we look at that look at workforce housing sort of in two separate ways. Then there's the other program that we're working on, the Alaska Housing Accelerator or the Fireweed Project, those are workforce housing projects targeted at the income level of like 80 to 120. And those are for permanent people who live in Anchorage, if you will.
Okay, got it. So yeah, so that's that's helpful. So Yeah, I'm I wonder if we could come up with like different language to think about just to distinguish between workforce housing in terms of like the in the income definition, that 80 to 100% or 120% AMI versus housing that's provided by an employer. I think that using the same phrase for both of those sort of disparate things, I think might become confusing for the community at some point. And so I don't I don't know exactly what the solution is there, but that that's just a flag, something that might need to be workshopped a little bit so that we can sort of keep our vocabulary consistent for the public. So just an a comment there. And then I think with the follow up question on the housing accelerator fund. So the capital that's been put up by by local financial institutions did I hear you correctly that that capital is intended to match ACDA spending, or does that capital exist irrespective of ACDA spending?
I wish it was ACDA. It's ADA. So
Okay, got it. So A will match A, so there's the there's a match coming from A. Got it. I miss her. Okay. And we'll know you you said it like in the next couple of weeks whether or not that accelerator is gonna materialize. And what are there any have any sort of restrictions been discussed as to how that capital could be used, or is it is it is the only parameter that it is for multifamily development?
Multifamily development of eight units or more is our target.
Got it.
Okay for the tax abatement. I'm sorry,
got it. Okay. And is that and that would be specifically new construction, not necessarily rehabilitation of existing structures? Yes. Okay. Awesome. All right, thank you very much. I think that is all my questions. Thank you, Chair.
Thank you, Barbara. Well, no additional questions. I just want to say on the record, thank you for the presentation. Your presentation today is do not put too much attention on our GIS team. The state does not need to poach our people. You have a very good team. They already know and the Vest of our folks. So very good GIST. And I wanted to give them shout outs, but stay stay away from our good people. And on that note, we'll continue. Thank you. And just to know other of other community partners also often come through. And so I see Mr. Bittner here. Thank you for being with us today. Did a presentation last meeting as well. And we'll move on to unfinished business at this time. Also just to check the room if there are any members of the public who expect to or want to speak at the end. I don't see any at this time. We'll hold space for that. Unfinished business before we get new presentations. I just wanted to and I mentioned earlier. I'm really excited that the language of missing middle housing seem to at least be a little more palatable and understandable than the previous language around the areas where they were, and we call those areas the transit supportive development corridors, and that seem to have a lot of different connotations in real time versus the historic perspective. But when we target what we mean by housing options in even transit supportive development corridors, we're landing on the language of the missing middle options. And I mentioned at our assembly meeting, and I wanted to just pause that again because reflection on the record, that member Baldwin Day and myself had an opportunity to meet with community members round the missing middle work that we're doing. And one of the community members mentioned why can't we look at other cities and learn from other places of what they're doing. And I mentioned that we are a member of the National Association of Counties, and in the National Association of Counties, we are also a member of the Western region group, and we're also a member of the large urban county caucus. Now we are sneak into the large urban county caucus because generally speaking that's communities of 500,000. But they let us in as the big city in our state into that particular cost. So various places, small counties, big counties, people are having the same conversation of housing shortages, affordability, and then who can do the building, the work that it takes to do that. Last week, the NACO or this week it'll be voted on at the national convention. But last week, one of the subcommittees that I'm a vice chair of the housing subcommittee proposed a resolution on expanding housing affordability through focusing on dwelling units as part of their missing bit of housing strategy, but I wanted to just read the proposed policy so that we also know here how we are working and aligned. And I know Mr. Robbins has a person on his team with national insights, but the proposed policy from the National Association of Counties works to support federal policies that expand housing supply and affordability by incentivizing voluntary accessory dwelling units and missing middle housing development through flexibing, financial tools, tax incentives, and technical assistance that strengthen locally driven housing strategies while preserving full county land use authority. And ACO has recognized that challenges through its housing task force and counties for housing solutions initiative, which supports counties in advance in advancing locally driven strategies to expand housing supplies, ADUs and missing middle housing, including duplexes, triplexes, fourplexes, cottage style developments, offer scalable community oriented solutions that increase housing options while preserving neighborhood character. Federal incentives, technical assistance, and financing tools can help counties expand these approach and strengthen local housing markets while not undermining local control. The work we're doing here locally is aligned to what National Association of Counties is advancing on the national level for federal policy. And it's better to be in front of federal policy from my vantage point. And so moving in this direction with our community partners sharing this language across our community makes us more ready when the federal government opens the doors for increasing support for this type of work. So that's good news, and I wanted to flag that for all of our members. Great. Now with that continuing with good news because downtown is the heartbeat of Anchorage, as they say. And this really the next presentation, I hope overlaps with part of my presentation, but we'll go into and thank the downtown partnership for being with us today. And I'll turn it over to Radica from the Dowtown Partnership for their presentation.
Yeah, thank you so much for inviting me to speak here today. I've got a few slides to share with you. And I was here presenting to this committee last fall, and last fall I spent more time on us as an organization. We're in the unique position, I think, of being the only managing the only business improvement district in the state of Alaska. So under that, we are in it. We're a nonprofit organization and we provide supplemental public services in downtown. So for those in the room or on the screen who may not be familiar with that, you know, we talk to Eric Hodgtson every single day that it snows. We do the sidewalk snow downtown, those public trash cans that you see downtown or use downtown, we service those. We do daily litter pickup. And then we also run free community events like our city's New Year's Eve celebration and fireworks. So we're very honored to play the role that we do in our city. But today, since you've already heard a lot of that, I wanted to just give you a broad overview of everything that's happening in downtown, the projects, both public and private that are underway. And before I start on that, I just want to show you this map that I believe Mr. Shudy put together many years ago. And what this shows is the red shaded areas are the downtown district. They're the properties within the downtown district that are owned by the municipality of Anchorage, state of Alaska or the federal government. And I was just looking at these numbers yesterday, and I just want to share that the city of Anchorage owns directly about one third of downtown properties by assessed value. So I'd point that out to say to give you a little bit of context as we go into the rest of this presentation about the city's both overall interest in economic development downtown, but also the municipality specific interest in downtown because you are the majority landowner within downtown. And so all of the downtown visions and plans that we have are just simply not possible without the city's direct investment in your own roads and public facilities and parks and all of the other properties that you have ownership and management of. So moving on, I just want to highlight a couple of the public projects, and I'm sure there are many folks in the room who probably could give you the same update as well that are happening downtown right now. You've probably seen Townsquare Park has been fenced off, and there's really a tremendous amount of construction going on there right now. That's expected to continue in full force for about 90 days, but then the park will remain closed for longer than that while lighting is ordered and installed. And then Peratrovish Park, which is the park adjacent to Historic City Hall on Fourth Avenue. That is starting the most recent date that I've heard is July 22. Some of you may have already seen the downtown way finding signs. There are five of them that have been installed on Fourth Avenue and Second Avenue this year. And that's the culmination of something that we have put into our plans and have asked for decades. I don't mean as the partnership, I mean us as precedents of Anchorage. And so that project is fully funded, and the remainder of the signs, which is I think 30, 40, 50 more signs, it are going in next May. So I it's something that almost every other city in Alaska that has any population already has and has had for a long time. And so we're really pleased to see it come to fruition here. You may have seen that the Ship Creek to Coastal Trail connection broke ground earlier this spring. And then finally, I just want to say that the downtown library, a new municipal facility, that truly the new municipal the first new municipal facility in downtown in decades, I think it'd be fair to say, is starting construction later this fall with a goal of opening, I think this winter or spring. So lots there. And I will say those are only a small portion of the projects that are plan for the next few years. This is a map that's on the Munis website. There are projects at the PAC, projects at City Hall, signals and lighting upgrade projects that are happening. Of course, ACEA's work. A lot more to come. I think the neighborhood greenways are getting installed later this fall. You know, I think there are as also mentioned several other hotel projects that have been recently completed and are also starting this year, but last year in 2025, we had major remodels at the Hilton at a new property called Assaulted Root Space Camp, which is an extension of existing Alaska brand. And then of course at the Hotel Captain Cook last year was Tower Two remodel, I believe this year the tower three remodel is starting. And then of course you've seen the Fourth Avenue Marketplace that's come before the assembly. I just want to say construction has begun. And the 15 residential units on the second floor are exciting to see. You know, I think they probably represent a model that we're gonna want to continue into the future of you know, taking some of these large commercial properties and finding ways to have fixed use in them. And then of course you're also familiar with block 41. This one is really significant as the first major new construction project in downtown in several years. A lot of the other ones you've seen have been remodels of existing buildings, but this truly is you know, a brand new construction also very much underway right now. And then this one has gone a little bit under the radar, but I think most of them know about it. These are the 3 residential units on the north edge of downtown, a little bit north of Second Avenue, through a partnership with between the railroad and development group. And that just had a ribbon cutting in May of this year. Again, new residential is exciting to see here in downtown. And then I just want to You know, not to steal Mr. Dol's time, but I just wanted to kind of talk a little bit about some of the other projects that are happening right now that you know including of course the Westmark renovation, there's a project that's a commercial to residential conversion, which is exciting to see, and then several other major hotel remodels and brand openings have either happened this spring or are are underway. Then I just have two more slides that I'm going to go through pretty quickly, and I see Ms. Member Ball and Day has a question after that. But the last thing I wanted to mention was just our events. The graphic on the left is the from the Meet Me Downtown campaign that ACDA has is running and it's a great new tool to promote arts and culture downtown and all the things happening. So you can see there's a whole bunch of major events that have happened last month in downtown. And then the park closures, a number of the recurring events that we run live after five. And then we are partnering on the summer night market. Both of those have moved to F Street this year. Jazz on the lawn is again that we run in partnership with the Alaska Jazz Workshop that's moved to the museum lawn this year because it was in Craterwich Park. And the museum has expanded their lunch on the lawn program from from one day to two days a week. It's really lovely if you haven't seen it.
Alright, thank you. I actually went to lunch on the lawn this week. It was wonderful. It was such a nice little like interlude in the day to walk over from City Hall, grab some food at the senior moose food truck, which was out there and enjoy some music in the sunshine. So shameless plug for lunch on the lawn. It was great. And then I think my second question, or I guess this is the question, not a comment. I'm curious about the commercial conversion to hotel and residential. Are you at liberty, Director Krishna to tell us what that pro where that project is and who is spearheading it.
I'm not really comfortable kind of talking about a private developer by name in this room. And frankly I don't know anything more than the permit, you know, the permits that have come through, but we can certainly connect offline and I think that the property owner would be pretty happy to connect.
Okay, yeah, I would appreciate that. I'm particularly interested in the in, you know, how folks are are making the commercial to residential or to hotel process work. So I would really appreciate the connect offline. Thank
you. Absolutely, and I'll just maybe add like a sentence of commentary, which is to say that I am too. I think that's where a lot of the opportunity lies in the next couple of years is figuring out how to make those work. And I know there are multiple folks at the meeting working on
that. Thank you, Chair. No further questions from me. And yeah, really appreciate your report.
Excellent. Thank you. Just one question for me, at least to start. Self-interested question is Are we still doing art with the school district on trash cans?
That was part of a grant, and I think that grant has ended. If someone gives me trash cans and paint and school district contact, I think I'd be interested in doing more of those.
excellent. Right, I don't know how we've been hanging on that. And but this is a great if there are no other questions for for the downtown partnership, I'll move into the next part of the presentation where we talk about the 18 hour economy, but the overlap is Mr. Dole, I don't you have to hang out for a few more minutes. Part of this committee has been successful in breaking silos on long-term conversations that don't necessarily click to one-to-one in a more in in a particular time. So for example, this committee has talked about looking at the creative economy as one of the economic pillars of our city and really better understanding that. We've had that conversation for several years at this body, and we've brought research back accordingly. So today when we talk about activation and we talk about these things in the room to have the downtown kind of our big heavy economic development players in the community. I want us to move these conversations of some things that like when we talk about activation downtown and arts and culture, we have thought of those things outside of economic development or as kind of ornamental. And today we're gonna I hope that we move that conversation a little forward. So I ask everybody to hang out a little further. But I also want to start off by saying all parts of community development, community economic development, don't always start off with formal businesses. Most of the time, from my vantage point, we point to regular people having an idea, rolling their sleeves up, and starting something new. And that'll be my starting point for at least the connection to the downtown through the trash cans, which is a few years back, a group of artists got together, and we thought that creating public art with just paint and opportunity were a powerful thing to bring to downtown. And as a result of a group of artists getting together with no formal structure, we created a partnership with the downtown partnership at that time to activate an empty storefront space at the bottom of at that time was the key bank building right next to the center. The entire first floor was activated into an art gallery for almost two years. From that art gallery, the down the community of Anchorage wanted to change the baskets, the downtown basket garbage cans to bearproof cans. The reason wasn't necessarily for bears. The reason had to do with folks in the community wanting to stop people from going into garbage cans. They gave them to the downtown partnership. The group of artists who were activating this space downtown thought that was some ugly features to our to our downtown. And we started painting on those canvases. And the partnership put those canvases out onto the street. Some of those canvases are still there from a decade about. And some of them have taken a beaten from cars because they slid in the wintertime onto the curbs and they get hit. But then the school district picked up that partnership. And then the municipality picked up that partnership. And I don't know where it all is, but today I can go through Russian Jack Park, come through Nunaka Valley, go through Russian Jack Park, and the very first trash can I see on the road there is an art trash can that some youth did in our community. And I remember the very first trash can that Parks and Rick picked up was at Takishna Park, and they work with the community to do a competition, a selection of what youth art should go onto this trash can. So I wanted to just recognize that we have a lot of folks in the room who have very strong institutional capacity. But the secret sauce to all of this is igniting the imagination of the public and giving the public the opportunity to feel an invitation to create in our city. And that's the starting point, at least for where I'd like to move us into this conversation of the 18 hour economy. And so good evening, good afternoon, everyone. Today I want to share some observations that have emerged through this committee's ongoing work looking at economic development, specifically bringing back some ideas from two conferences that I had the opportunity to attend, the social bull cities, social city summit, and the Americans for the arts conference. The central theme is straightforward. Successful communities increasingly view creative economy, the night time economy, and the social economy as interconnected components of economic development, infrastructure, rather than discretionary cultural amenities. Communities that are attracting residents, retain talent, increasing tourism, and improving public safety are making intentional investments in arts, culture, public spaces, and evening activity because they recognize these investments are drivers as drivers of local resilience, community identity, and long term growth. For Anchorage, this presents an opportunity to broaden our understanding of economic development and to recognize the role that artists, cultural organizations, entertainment venues, festivals, public gathering spaces, and creative entrepreneurs play in building a more vibrant and economically competitive city. I don't have fancy slots as the downtown partnership, but I have the memo and I'll just walk through a couple of the key observations. And I do have one graph at the end that was AI AI assistant in his generation. And so pardon any typos, but we'll look at that as well. Key observation one, and this is what I mentioned, that the creative economy is economic infrastructure. The first observation is perhaps the most significant. One of the strongest themes that emerge throughout all of these various discussions at a national level is that arts and community cultural are not simply organizations that provide programming. They are community infrastructure. They create trust, they build relationships, they activate neighborhoods, they contribute to civic life. And this is the part that is most important for me today. And I'll continue to live for it. And during times of disruption, whether economic or environmental, they often become the trusted gathering spaces that strengthen community resilience for local government, this represents an important shift in perspective. Instead of asking, how do we support the arts, maybe a more strategic question is, how do the arts support Anchorage's economic development goals? And then working it from that perspective. The observation number two. A sociable city is built on strong creative economy. Second observation is that vibrant cities don't become vibrant by accident. Communiti with thriving daytime and evening economies intentionally cultivate the conditions that bring people together. Live music, arts programming, festivals, public performances, cultural districts. These active activities are not simply amenities. They create experiences that encourage residents and visitors to spend time in public spaces and support local businesses. Anchorage already has many of these assets. Local musicians, indigenous artists, forming arts organizations, some degree of museum, space, festivals. Coordination of these activities intentionally through an economic development strategy is part of the goal, I hope that we're amplifying today. We have, in my mind, had the more often seen things happen and celebrate them, but from the economic development perspective, we are usually opportunistic to promoting the season of the activity as opposed to the long-term understanding of what these things mean and then how we amplify and sell them. And I hope that our tourism partners are listening to this as well. Key observation three. A lot of cities across the country are talking about how to make your city a 24 hour city. The nightlife that it goes into the evening, the morning activities. Anchorage is not a 24 hour city yet. I'm not sure if we're an 18-hour city yet, but maybe that's the aspiration. And an 18 hour city essentially extends the traditional activity beyond the traditional work day of the economic activity, having people recognize that the work day doesn't end, and a lot of times in anchorage people go back home or they go out, but we want to activate essentially the idea from 6 a.m. to 12 midnight. Anchorage is activated, open for business. And that means a lot when we think of what does it mean in the evening time? What do the nighttime activity or economy mean here? And how do we recognize how we could be better supportive of that initiative that work in that direction? Key observation four public safety improves when places are active. A decade ago, Town Square Park as then renovated today, had a lot of problems when Ethan Berkwitz was first elected as mayor, and people didn't want to go into the Town Square Park, and downtown had lots of people stressed out by things that still persist today, but were more acute at that time. And I remember people talking about do we have enough police? And that was an important conversation. And what can downtown partnership do more with their ambassadors? Can they engage more? And do we have more service services provided? And then it was Pokemon Go. And if people and if people remember that, while we were focusing in intentional resources to address the acute challenges of some of the social issues that were happening on the streets, the key point of this observation is that public safety improves when places are active, even if the activity is independent of the institutional why. Pokemon Go was not coordinating with the municipality of Anchorage to put special treats of the invisible kind on the app, downtown Anchorage. That had no impact. It was not coordinated with APD, with fire chief, with no one. It was just what happens in that place of online gaming. And you saw people downtown with their phones chasing whatever they chase in that game. And don't play it, don't throw it. I'm dating myself. But it was intergenerational, too. And as people were walking around downtown with their phones, it created movement in a way that if you were if people found themselves comfortable doing unsightly things, and they felt like no one was watching them, that changed when they felt like people were walking past them more often. And it had a measurable impact. I know that that's true because everywhere we've had community murals to address vandalism. Similarly, we've seen a positive impact where the mural has lasted, but people in the community have seen the work to come together, and it's created a new moment of activation that needs public safety opportunity. So recognizing that the concept is often described as creating eyes on the streets. It's not that it diminishes the importance of law enforcement, but it recognized that through thoughtful urban design and community activation, we can complement traditional public safety strategies. And then we'll get right into opening for any discussion that folks had, especially the last slide. Community centered development produces better outcomes. Another consistent lesson was that successful economic development is collaborative. Communities that achieve lasting results bring together artists, business owners, nonprofit organizations, neighborhood leaders, educational institutions, tourism organizations, and government. Government economic development becomes something that is done with communities rather than to communities. Those partnerships and help help us to ensure investments reflect community priorities while remaining sustainable over the long term. I want to just flag the way finding signs downtown. Like that's an example of we should have had that a long time ago. The resources in the in the environment to make that happen were true, but were those resources adequately aligned to a need that we knew we had, a need that other cities were already moving on. And where were those conversations from the variety of the various community organizations and economic development partners leaning toward? And a lot of those conversations were at planning, but did they hit implementation? And those are the questions that I hope we can continue to look at. Lastly, the key observation is resilience is culturally. Music, art, culture help those spaces. So with that, I'll pause. I wanted to just highlight this last chart because we have a few last minutes of a conversation with one of our businesses in the community that has a license coming up, and I just wanted to give them a chance to come to the forest. But lastly, for folks here. This building a more sociable anchorage lessons worksheet essentially highlights some of the things we I mentioned today. It also gives what I wanted us to look at for consideration is a scorecard. Other cities are beginning to utilize a scorecard to rate its social ability. Social ability. For example, we have a handful of bars. And we've had challenges with bar break security. And nighttime security. One of the conversations that I will take from specifically the the Nashville example is they use their bid essentially to fund over time for the police dedicated for the nighttime operations. So there is dedicated funding for the police, recognizing that that funding comes from the businesses and the activity from that they generate because. Corridor needs the extra presence. The police will do that, but it's a community partnership to pay for the overtime. It's not necessarily more staffing. Staffing challenges are there, but it's the overtime question. And we have that same challenge here. Who pays for the additional police? And how come we haven't been able to mobilize the economic sector toward those type of private partnerships that happen in other cities. That's one thing that I would flag that was a major lesson to hear from another city and how they pay for that work. If there are no questions on the flo da, I encourage you all to send them to me. I would love to hear your thoughts, your feedback, because I expect that there will be some resolutions coming from this work to support increase the lack of it. And with that, I'll turn over thank you, Mr. Dole, for that conversation and for my community development partners for hearing the I think pointing but probably long winded economic development conversation of how we continue to grow the creative economy as a fundamental pillar of our community. And with that, we will have a group conversation with make sure I get this right. Marijuana retail license. Application review as special limitation's
permit.
Land use permit.
Yeah, Slurp.
Is what it's described as Sensame number M thirty five four ninety. And I'll turn it over to presenters from the licensee.
Sure. Janel Dean, thank you for the invitation to come. You asked us to come. Usually the marijuana license applications don't come through here anymore. They used to at the beginning, used to a route all of them through here, and that was pretty good process. So I'm guessing our invitation is probably due to I would say community engagement that we've had and
tell you quickly just
I invited the group here primarily thank you for coming. This is not an inquisition moment, this is not a hard line moment, this is more of a moment to utilize this community to have at least the public space to recognize that a license that the North East Community Council had heard about in the past had some challenges and it's coming back before us, and it doesn't have to go through all the same processes, and but I wanted to give it space here, at least so folks can hear about it and get it on record
sure yeah and I'll like to talk about our community engagement because our community community engagement was lengthy so we had five community council meetings and two additional community meetings so the first community meeting was September 21 of 2023 and then we had another one October 19 of 2023 and then November 16 of 2023 the September 2021 or September 21 one there was no vote and then the October 19th in 2023 there was a straw vote of the community council which resulted in 31 people in support of the application and 13 people opposed so that was the first true vote and then we came back with an MOU to the community council November 16 of 2023 and that was approved 45 in favor nine opposed but that MOU included an a management agreement basically a different licensee was gonna manage the shop because Bowstar has never run a marijuana shop so an entity call good out of Fairbanks they also do lots of products in the state was going to manage the shop well good had other opportunities that came up for them that they felt for better use of their time in other parts of the state and so they didn't feel that it had the manpower to manage the store. So then on February 20 2025 2025? Yes 2025 we resubmitted an MOU to the community council and said hey you know good is not going to be involved anymore Bowsitar is going to run his own shop so we had this very robust meeting which you were at and there was about 70 people there and in person they started to do a new type of way to vote that has never been done to our knowledge in the community council. And essentially in the room they were checking IDs. A gale like didn't have the same address that she that of her business on her ID. So they said, well you let her bring a lease in. She didn't have a lease. So she wasn't allowed to vote, that kind of stuff. So it was fine. In the in the room there was 34 people in favor and 34 people opposed. And so the tiebreaker came to the Zoom votes, which was very interesting because the Zoom votes they didn't actually get any IDs checked. They didn't have to prove anything. They were allowed to vote and that tipped it, tipped it over and tipped it over in the negative. So unfortunately there were about I think four folks that voted for it online in the Zoom and Well they told us that it was approved. Oh yeah, well there's that but first they said first they announced the vote and said that that it had passed. And then they called me over and said actually we kind of vote the vote it didn't pass because the Zoom votes tipped it the other way. So that's what happened. And so after that weird kind of community meeting that we had We kind of waited because Balzatar had to do a plating action to change some configurations of his property because he's gonna use the back half of his property for something different. So there's a plotting action. And so when we came back to resubmit, I think it was our said, hey, you know, it's been a while since you've engaged with the community. Go ahead and have another community meeting. Well, we did we hosted our own at the facility and via Zoom. I think about 15 folks showed up. And there were you know concerns of too many pot shops. I guess it's really detailed in our report. Worried about the park that Ch Chaniska Park I'm gonna say that wrong. Someone should say that better. Do you know what park I'm talking about? Yeah, Chatsu. Thank you. Park, which in our application pac, we actually had that park surveyed by Far Point Land Server surveyors. And it'll show you it's way more than 200 feet from property line property line, but also it's 733 feet pedestrian route. So it meets the code. And we've talked to Elizabeth, actually Balzatar came and talked to Miss Appleby. Nice to see you. About this when we first started the application and she kind of, you know, verified the distance was met. And then we also talked to Ryan Yell about this back, I think in 2021. That the property distance is met. So really the main concern I think is from this weird and key engagement process, which they seem to kind of have, I don't want to say they have a tough time with marijuana applicants, but we did kind of like pull the record and look back in 2022 when baby bull, which is kind of bliss, right? Applied and went through the community council process and they approved the MOU, but then like for some reason wouldn't send it to the applicant. And so the applicant Punning smit try to get the MOU that was approved. It's all in the summary of community community council reports, community council meetings in that application, which I brought copies of. They had to re-host their own community meeting again. So we've kind of at this thing with community council where I think kind of the leadership is not super marijuana friendly, which is fine. But we've kind of gone above and beyond to address the community, engage with the community, and you have like a 20 page community engagement report because you know it's like seven meetings. So
and just some photo, I'm gonna ask my members for the indulgence of five additional minutes. Cool. Thank you, Member Johnson. Shook his head, yes, and member Balling Day doesn't seem to be a good
thing. I do have a I do have another meeting I need to jump to. I'm so sorry. Yeah,
it's fine. You're full feel free to jump to your meeting, but we'll take additional just five minutes to close this. Appreciate you being here. And I wanted to get on the record for us because it is in it is coming back, and similar to I am aware of every meeting, and pretty much attended every meeting except for one that was individually held. Right since 2023, when I was the president of the community council at that time. Prior to getting elected in the first term. So this has been before the Northeast Community Council for some time. This is I wanted to be clear from my perspective as this committee that I think everything is in order at this time. And then I and I always refer to staff, like where are the applications are the have they met their requirements? Do they have to go back and talk to the community? So from my understanding, this current application is in. process followed the right pathway and this was a voluntary come to this committee. You didn't have to come busy. But you voluntarily came because my request was to just hear it all so that folks can get a sense where they may hear wait we don't want another one or they may you may hear voices coming out of like sometimes left field. Essentially this has been a few years in the making. I have pushed back on them and I haven't always been a champion of the idea because I wanted to hold them accountable this particular vendor this particular folk accountable to the community interests. And I think they've met those interests from my vantage point. So I just wanted to also be clear about that on the record but Jenna you mentioned something about the community council in the North has also had some kind of consternation around the amount of marijuana shops. Yeah. And they talked about that they feel inundated essentially can you express a little bit more on that if you can or
I mean I don't want to speak for that community council but I think I think Anchor as a whole, right, is feeling a little bit saturated with the number of marijuana shops. But you can't pick winners and losers, right? So like if the Anchorage Assembly wants to it can adopt just like LaCilla or like Fairbanks has done and other communities, Castabu, Barrow other communities have done and set a limit, right? And say, hey, we're not gonna have any more than X amount of marijuana shops. But we haven't done that, right? So folks are relying on the code, and if they meet the code, they bring it forward. I think from the North East Community Council's position, they actually have I would say probably the least amount of marijuana shops out of the Anchorage Bowl. So they're really other than Eagle River. Which not in the Anchorage Bowl, but other than Eagle River, which is part of the municipality, which has zero. But Northeast Community Council really doesn't have a huge amount like Midtown does and downtown does. But they're really feeling that they want to have less in their community. And I think that's their obligation to bring that forward in some kind of resolution to the assembly and see if the assembly wants to address that. But from what we heard, they just feel like they just don't want more marijuana shops in their area. But practically speaking, they literally have the least out of Calist and Catalyst and bliss, but it's Anables, yeah.
is I've asked staff to also provide me we're not gonna put it up to date but we'll make it available through the page and then we'll bring it to our next meeting as well. But I've asked to have to give me the GI GIS map of where all of our licenses are so we can see it visually as well. Because I think the equity question is important. And so there are parts of town that are over saturated probably and I don't know if it's a limitation question in terms of restricting or if it's an equity question that other places have been restricted. And so because of the restrictions in other places it's created a disproportionate amount of burden in some parts of the community that Would be open to some businesses, but not maybe the amount of those businesses. And I think those are fair questions. You raised the Eagle River question, and I'm not too well versed in that, but I think you just mentioned there are no.
Yeah. There are no, there's no marijuana shops there because the their use code, which they have a separate special use code for them, says that you can't have marijuana in B-3, which totally mixes a lot of the area, and only in I one. And additionally adds all these different sensitive uses like residential and parks and all these additional like
that are different than the bowls.
That are different than the bowls. So it effectively creates a total zone out. There is no property that you could do a marijuana shop without getting like four different layers of variances.
I think you've interesting question. I'm not again I'm not well versed in the and the reason of that why, but it seems like it's an interesting question when we think about equity question across the community, where things are, and then the communities who are getting some of these businesses their feedback of saying how much they want and that limitation. I think these are fair questions. Thank you for bringing them. If there are no additional questions for our guest today, I just appreciate you coming. And with that, we I opened it earlier. There are no folks for public testimony, and we'll stand adjourned at 1036. Thank you everyone.